It comes as no surprise that suddenly the Trans Pacific Partnership Agreement (TPPA) supporters are coming out of the woodwork this week. This is a reaction to Tun Mahathir’s launching of a book by the Malay Economic Action Council (MTEM) last Friday, entitled ‘TPPA: Malaysia is not for sale”.
During the launch, the former prime minister himself said that free trade agreements such as the TPPA are another way to colonise a nation.
We would firstly add that nowhere in our statements throughout this rational and factual debate regarding this agreement have we ever referred to the United States as “the Great Satan”, something which the proponents and cheerleaders of this agreement has done just yesterday in a Malaysian daily.
Furthermore, proponents of the agreement have argued a few points that are constantly unproven. For one, Malaysia would “lose out without the TPPA”.
And yet, nobody bothers explaining why or how Malaysia would lose out. We as a coalition worry that premature judgments are being made without the completion of a cost-benefit analysis.
Is it because we won’t have American conglomerates setting up shop in Malaysia or cheap American products? Of course not, we can choose to let them in and at low tariffs, if we want, without signing the TPPA.
Is it because Malaysian exports will face high tariffs? Malaysia as a member of the World Trade Organization (WTO), already receives zero or low tariffs on its exports to all nations in the TPPA. In addition to this, Malaysia already has free trade agreements with all the countries involved in the TPPA except 4; USA, Canada, Mexico and Peru.
In these countries, the United States imposes on average a three per cent tariff, while Canada imposes an average of 6 per cent. This, of course, excludes the textile industry. However, the US insists on all its FTAs, including the TPPA, having the yarn forward rule. In other words, even with zero or low tariffs on Malaysian textiles, we won’t benefit because Malaysia would have to use expensive American thread to gain access to these lower tariffs, so it would still be uncompetitive.
In addition to this, we would like to remind everyone that Malaysia chose not to sign the Malaysia - US Free Trade Agreement in 2008, and still has an increasing goods trade surplus with the Americans.
So please, enlighten us naysayers just what exactly is this “losing out” that has been constantly mentioned and never explained?
Also, us naysayers here in Bantah TPPA have never said that trade was not important. In fact, we believe in free and fair trade. We believe, instead, that this agreement is the opposite of free trade, and as such should be opposed by those who believe in free market economics. We already have useful free trade agreements (which do not require all the problematic non-trade provisions the US insists on in its FTAs) that allow Malaysian companies to sell to billions already, including India, Pakistan and even China.
What we don’t believe in is when a trade agreement such as the TPPA spans 29 chapters, but only talks about trade for six chapters, while another 23 dictate non-trade requirements.
To put it simply; when trade is no longer about trade but setting up rules that limit only one party, then it is no longer free nor fair.
We would also wish to point out that it was Bantah TPPA which met up with US Trade Representative Michael Froman in April to discuss our concerns with the agreement, particularly our 75 Red Lines. It was during this meeting that the US agreed to have direct engagements with key stakeholders. Bantah TPPA through the Malay Economic Action Council (MTEM) also had a follow up meeting US chief negotiator for the TPPA Barbara Weisel on June 26.
Leaked text from the TPPA intellectual property (IP) chapter shows that the US is exporting its laws that suit it as a net IP exporter, which is contrary to the needs of Malaysia as a developing country which is a net IP importer and needs affordable access to technology, medicines and textbooks.
Furthermore, the United States Congress insists on imposing on us in the form of disciplines and penalties as a ‘currency manipulator’ that it will not be subject to, despite its quantitative easing.
As for our part, we have mentioned that this agreement benefits American corporations instead of their people, and it does not benefit Malaysians as a whole since it will affect their lives in the form of high medicine and textbook prices for longer all the way up to the undermining preferential treatment to local SMEs and even state owned enterprises.
And since we want to keep things rational in order to make an educated decision, we would need a cost benefit analysis (CBA) report to decide whether or not this agreement benefits us.
Proponents of the TPPA, who are academicians and corporate leaders alike still insist on saying that this deal is good without any basis as the CBA or the Economic Impact Assessment (EIA) report for this agreement has not yet been released.
So we ask yet again, would you recommend a legally binding deal enforceable through trade sanctions and the leaked TPPA investment chapter which would allow unlimited monetary penalties and compound interest without knowing its contents, without scrutinising the fine print, without guaranteeing an equitable agreement?
Furthermore, given the leaked texts from the TPPA confirming Bantah’s fears regarding what the United States is demanding and what all countries involved including Malaysia have already agreed to, why has nobody brought this into consideration as part of their “support the TPPA” crusade?
This is what Bantah TPPA is doing by pushing forward our 75 Red Lines, including that there be no stronger intellectual property provisions limiting access to generic medicines, carving out tobacco control and the halal sector from the agreement and ensuring that the preferential treatment of local SMEs are not up for negotiations.
We further recommend that these TPPA cheerleaders would at least read our TPPA book, and see the factual depths of our analysis which “examines the evidence” because it is based on the actual leaked texts of the TPPA and the past USFTAs (which are all very similar due to the US insistence on its template) and their impacts before making any unjustified and unwarranted conclusions merely to be seen as a free trade ideology subscriber or out of fear of a superpower.
Mohd Nizam Mahshar
Thu Jul 17 2014
Mohd Nizam Mahshar
Nyawa tiada nilai, maruah pula dibuat main oleh Israel
Sudahlah kejam, jijik, tidak beradap pula. Tidak cukup dengan kekejamannya membunuh berpuluh ribu rakyat Palestin, nyawa manusia di bumi Gaza itu bagaikan tiada nilai buat mereka. Dalam beberapa video yang tular baru-baru ini, tentera Israel dengan bangganya memperolok maruah rakyat Palestin dengan bermain pakaian dalam wanita yang ditemui di rumah-rumah penduduk di situ.
Libya giat langkah kumpul derma untuk Gaza
Libya tampil dengan beberapa inisiatif mengumpul dana untuk dihantar ke Gaza.
Antara kempen bantuan yang diiktiarkan termasuk kempen yang bermatlamat untuk mengumpul 2,000 tan bantuan yang akan dimuatkan ke dalam kapal berlayar dari Misrata ke Pelabuhan Arish sebelum ianya dihantar ke Enklaf Gaza menerusi laluan Rafah.
Antara kempen bantuan yang diiktiarkan termasuk kempen yang bermatlamat untuk mengumpul 2,000 tan bantuan yang akan dimuatkan ke dalam kapal berlayar dari Misrata ke Pelabuhan Arish sebelum ianya dihantar ke Enklaf Gaza menerusi laluan Rafah.
Kisah bayi Leila Jeneid bukti Israel tidak berhati perut
Leila Jeneid, bayi yang berusia dua bulan belum lagi berkesempatan merasai nikmat hidup dan mendapat pelukan mesra keindahan dunia. Baru sahaja mencelik mata, dia sudah diuji dengan kesengsaraan kekurangan zat sehingga menyebabkannya berakhir di hospital.
TikTok perkenal pusat pilihan raya bagi tangani info palsu
TikTok merancang untuk melancarkan pusat pilihan raya dalam talian di platform itu sebagai sebahagian daripada usaha menyokong integriti pilihan raya sepanjang 2024.
Lebih daripada dua bilion orang dalam lebih 50 negara dijangka keluar mengundi tahun ini dan pusat pilihan raya itu akan digunakan untuk menunjukkan kepada orang ramai maklumat yang boleh dipercayai.
Lebih daripada dua bilion orang dalam lebih 50 negara dijangka keluar mengundi tahun ini dan pusat pilihan raya itu akan digunakan untuk menunjukkan kepada orang ramai maklumat yang boleh dipercayai.
Baki stok simpanan air di empat empangan pada paras kritikal - NADMA
Empat empangan air di Johor, Pulau Pinang dan Kedah menunjukkan penurunan paras simpanan sumber air mentah pada paras kritikal setakat 27 Mac susulan cuaca panas.
Puluhan wau 'warnai' langit malam Kampung Panchor
Cuaca panas yang melanda Kedah sejak kebelakangan ini dilihat sedikit sebanyak merubah rutin seharian penduduk setempat. Di Kampung Panchor, Pendang, sekumpulan anak muda telah memulakan satu aktiviti yang jarang dilihat di kawasan lain iaitu bermain wau pada waktu malam.
Dua jasad dari enam mangsa hilang ditemukan
Dua jasad daripada enam pekerja pembinaan yang hilang dalam insiden jambatan yang runtuh di Baltimore, Amerika Syarikat telah ditemukan pada Khamis.
6 kereta, tiga rumah terjejas dalam kejadian pokok tumbang di KL
Hujan lebat di sekitar kawasan Kuala Lumpur pada petang Khamis menyebabkan beberapa pokok tumbang dan menghempap kenderaan orang awam.
Jabatan Bomba dan Penyelamat Kuala Lumpur menerusi kenyataan berkata, pihaknya menerima lapan laporan pokok tumbang di beberapa kawasan termasuk di Bukit Jalil, Sri Petaling dan Taman Salak Selatan.
Jabatan Bomba dan Penyelamat Kuala Lumpur menerusi kenyataan berkata, pihaknya menerima lapan laporan pokok tumbang di beberapa kawasan termasuk di Bukit Jalil, Sri Petaling dan Taman Salak Selatan.
Tabung Pembangunan Ehsan Selangor-Gaza dilancar
Sultan Selangor Sultan Sharafuddin Idris Shah pada Khamis berkenan melancarkan Tabung Pembangunan Ehsan Selangor-Gaza, iaitu antara inisiatif kerajaan Selangor bagi membangunkan semula wilayah Gaza di Palestin.
Baginda menerusi kenyataan bertitah Pembangunan Ehsan Selangor-Gaza, yang dijalankan dengan kerjasama Majlis Perundingan Pertubuhan Islam Malaysia (MAPIM), melibatkan tiga projek pembangunan di atas tanah wakaf di Gaza, yang memerlukan dana berjumlah RM8.7 juta.
Baginda menerusi kenyataan bertitah Pembangunan Ehsan Selangor-Gaza, yang dijalankan dengan kerjasama Majlis Perundingan Pertubuhan Islam Malaysia (MAPIM), melibatkan tiga projek pembangunan di atas tanah wakaf di Gaza, yang memerlukan dana berjumlah RM8.7 juta.
Tol percuma pada 8 dan 9 April sempena Aidilfitri - Nanta
Kerajaan bersetuju memberikan kemudahan tol percuma selama dua hari pada 8 dan 9 April kepada semua pengguna lebuh raya bagi kenderaan kelas 1 (persendirian) yang akan pulang ke kampung halaman sempena Aidilfitri tahun ini.
#SayaMaisarah
Matanglah, Zahra. Tak ada orang yang mula membeli 'property' pertama meletakkan sasaran sekitar Kuala Lumpur.