AMBASSADOR Bilahari Kausikan wrote in the Straits Times this week that demerger was Singapore's “happy mistake”.
In fact, perhaps he suggests that it has been its happiest mistake so far.
I have no quarrel with the credit he gives to Singapore's domestic leadership.
But his comments on the Singapore-Malaysia relationship were less charitable.
Ambassador Kausikan considers the demerger to have been due to irreconcilable differences between Singaporean “multiracial meritocracy” and Malayan “Ketuanan Melayu”.
To begin with, Ambassador Kausikan oversimplifies the Malayan political ideology of the period.
The question of leadership in a fledging post-colonial nation riven by dramatic urban-rural inequities and simmering ethnic tension as in the 1960s Federation of Malaya bears no easy answer.
Yet, for Ambassador Kausikan, Malaya's answer is reduced to the arid monolithic concept of "Ketuanan Melayu".
Even if we were to limit our perspective to that of the towering personalities of the period, it would be a disservice to consider then Prime Minister Tunku Abdul Rahman a proponent of this.
One only needs to read the Malayan founding documents such as the Constitution and Proclamation of Independence to find no mention at all of such a concept; only instead consistent references to the principles of liberty, justice and democracy as the fundamental foundations of the nation.
In fact, the very term was only first articulated in August 1986, over 20 years after demerger.
The late Tan Sri Abdullah Ahmad @ Dollah Kok Lanas controversially said to the Singapore Institute of International Affairs (SIIA), “The Malays must be politically dominant in Malaysia as the Chinese are politically dominant in Singapore,” leading to the translation (or mis-translation) that is “Ketuanan Melayu”.
Ambassador Kausikan’s ignorance of the fluidity of ideology naturally engenders his ignorance of the possibility of reverse causality.
As much as value differences caused the demerger, demerger made value differences inevitable.
Once detached, it can be argued that young Singapore had no choice but to align itself, values and all, with the Anglo-American liberal order.
However, most worrying of all is not Ambassador Kausikan’s interpretation of the past, but his suggestion that such purported value differences continue to essentialise the Singapore-Malaysia relationship.
By ignoring real change in Malaysia and other regional neighbours since demerger, he denies to us the same agency that he claims for Singapore.
To him, Singapore is the product of its decisive leadership bending the arc of its history forever.
Yet for the rest of us, history is destiny.
He assumes our future is fixed by the values of our past, glossing over the struggle of individuals like Anwar Ibrahim daring to dream of a Malaysia founded upon the principles of liberty and justice.
The Ketuanan Rakyat vision was one example of our attempts to redefine our ideals on our own terms, amidst challenging politics and inexorable demographic shifts.
All I claim is that sustainable change must be managed carefully and well.
Realists like Ambassador Kausikan should realize that, given our nations ever-greater interconnectedness, violent societal upheaval in one of us is to the benefit of none of us.
The natural consequence of Ambassador Kausikan’s reductionist and deterministic view of Singapore's neighbours is that of missed opportunities for foreign policy.
A new rationalisation of regional interaction may well be necessary considering the cold war between a declining United States and an ascendant China.
Though it may seem provincial besides Classical Greek Thucydides, the Minang proverb: ‘bagai aur dengan tebing' is apt.
If Ambassador Kausikan is right, Malaysia and Singapore are as different in nature as bamboo (aur) and the riverbank (tebing).
Yet, this proverb reveals that differences can be a source of strength, not strife.
As the bamboo's fine root structure protects the bank from erosion, the bank grounds and nourishes the bamboo.
It is precisely this synergy that allows both to survive the drought and the stream.
This spirit of symbiosis is muafakat, loosely and unsatisfactorily translated to being in accord with one another despite our distinct identities and cultures.
Regional muafakat within and amongst all countries in the region results in economic success in each.
Small Singapore and slightly-less-small Malaysia will suffer what they must.
But at least, they will suffer less as partners, not mere neighbours.
Ambassador Kausikan’s worldview thus interprets the relationship between our nations to be a contest of scanty political philosophies, sweeping under in a fell swoop the richness of our shared connections and values.
It is a static worldview, unable to accommodate for the fact that the times have changed.
It would be a great and saddening pity if Ambassador Kausikan's reductionism truly were the “driving force” underlying Singapore's foreign policy towards Malaysia.
As we correct the course set by our previous government, I can only recommend the same spirit of introspection to the good ambassador.
It might just change his mind and temper his judgements - as it has a good many of ours since our nations parted ways.
* Senator Yusmadi Yusoff is a Senator, Chairman of the Senate Caucus (Kaukus Dewan Negara), Parliament of Malaysia and Lee Kuan Yew Senior Fellow in Public Service at LKY School of Public Policy, NUS.
**The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
Yusmadi Yusoff
Fri Jan 24 2020
Ambassador Bilahari Kausikan comments on the Singapore-Malaysia relationship were less charitable.
Letusan Gunung Ruang: Malaysia Airlines, AirAsia batal penerbangan Kuala Lumpur ke Sabah, Sarawak
Malaysia Airlines umum pembatalan 11 penerbangan Sabah dan Kuala Lumpur serta lapan penerbangan laluan Sarawak dan Kuala Lumpur dibatalkan.
Reformasi ekonomi: Bukan sekadar umum, rakyat perlukan penjelasan - Penganalisis
Pelbagai platform dan kaedah penerangan perlu dilakukan lantaran tahap kefahaman rakyat terhadap sesuatu isu adalah berbeza.
Tarif air pengguna domestik Perak naik 5 sen mulai 1 Mei - Saarani
Saarani berkata, beliau yakin kenaikan itu tidak terlalu tinggi dan boleh diterima oleh rakyat.
Penang FC harap kehadiran satu lagi tonggak import
Bekas penyerang kebangsaan itu berkata kehadiran pemain import amat diperlukan pada posisi tengah menyerang.
Wanita Singapura hilang di Sepanyol ditemui mati dengan kesan tikaman: Laporan
Polis tempatan tahan seorang lelaki warga Singapura untuk dirakam keterangan.
Google tidak akan tuntut hak cipta atas kandungan dijana AI
Google tidak akan menuntut hak cipta output yang telah dijana dengan perkhidmatan AI generatif mereka.
Mangsa banjir di tiga negeri menurun - NADMA
Jumlah mangsa banjir menurun kepada 759 mangsa yang ditempatkan di enam pusat permindahan sementara setakat 6 pagi tadi.
KWSP tidak lagi jadi pemegang saham utama Affin Bank, buka laluan kepada Sarawak
Pelupusan saham Affin Bank oleh KWSP berlaku pada 12 April, namun tidak dinyatakan nilai urus niaga itu.
Niaga AWANI: Melengkapkan pekerja dengan kemahiran masa hadapan
Sertai perbincangan bersama Faizal Ridzuan, Perunding Sumber Manusia, mengenai risiko yang dihadapi oleh pekerja yang tidak mempunyai kemahiran masa depan yang diperlukan, termasuk aspek kecerdasan buatan (AI), serta impaknya terhadap keputusan pekerjaan dan keperluan pembangunan kemahiran.
#NiagaAWANI
#NiagaAWANI
Telegram sasar capai 1 bilion pengguna aktif bulanan tahun ini
Buat masa ini, perkhidmatan permesejan berkenaan mempunyai sekitar 900 juta pengguna aktif bulanan.