The High Court on Monday struck out the suit by 102 taxi drivers against the Land Public Transport Commission (SPAD) over the Uber, Grabcar and Blacklane services as they had used the wrong avenue to institute legal action against SPAD.
Judge Datuk Su Geok Yiam said the plaintiffs also failed to produce a reasonable cause of action against SPAD as the defendant in the lawsuit.
The court made the decision after allowing the application by SPAD to strike out the suit filed by the group of taxi drivers who claimed that SPAD had failed to be proactive in banning the activities and operations of the online taxi service providers.
"The plaintiffs should have initiated their action through Rule 53 of the Rules of Court 2012, that is, by filing for a judicial review and not through a writ of summons and statement of claims.
"The plaintiffs' claims are clearly unsustainable as Uber, Grabcar and Blacklane were not named as defendants together with SPAD in the writ of summons although the plaintiffs had made a lot of allegations against them (Uber, Grabcar and Blacklane)," said the judge, who also ordered all the plaintiffs to pay RM5,000 in costs to the defendant.
Justice Su also said that the plaintiffs failed to show that they had a locus standi to pursue the suit against SPAD.
She said according to SPAD's statement of defence, it had taken appropriate actions including arresting and charging individuals who broke the law by allowing their cars to be used to provide services to the public illegally.
"The plaintiffs' failure to provide details of the defendant's (SPAD) negligence has caused shame and prejudice to SPAD and tarnished its reputation," the judge said after hearing the submissions by lawyer R. Kengadharan, representing all the 102 taxi drivers, and lawyer Ben Syazmin, acting for SPAD.
On Dec 30, 2015, the Klang Valley Taxi Drivers Action Committee chairman, Zailani Isausuludin, 51, and 101 taxi drivers filed the suit against SPAD.
They demanded, among others, a declaration order for SPAD to ban the Uber, Grabcar and Blacklane services obtainable via online, stating that such a service did not come under the Land Public Transport Act 2010.
They asked for an injunction for SPAD not to legitimise the activities and operations of the three online taxi service providers, and to issue a guideline and circular subject to agreement on the terms of banning their services and operations.
In their statement of claims, the taxi drivers alleged, among others, that the Uber, Grabcar and Blacklane operations had adversely affected the local taxi service industry due to the latter's lower fares charged than the fares of metered taxis.
Kengadharan, when met by reporters, said they would file an appeal to the Court of Appeal against the High Court's decision.
More than 100 taxi drivers attended the court proceeding yesterday. -- Bernama
Bernama
Mon Sep 26 2016
The court ruled that the taxi drivers had used the wrong avenue to institute legal action against SPAD.
RM30 juta untuk pembangunan semula sekolah daif SK Tamu Darat - Fadhlina
Kementerian Pendidikan (KPM) memperuntukkan RM30 juta untuk membangunkan semula Sekolah Kebangsaan (SK) Tamu Darat di sini yang merupakan antara sekolah daif di negeri ini.
AS mungkin tidak kena sekatan terhadap Iran, bimbang harga minyak mentah naik mendadak
Iran tidak akan lakukan serangan besar yang boleh melumpuhkan Israel dan Israel juga tidak akan berbuat demikian terhadap Iran.
AWANI Ringkas: Kes lelaki Israel miliki senjata api
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Saya masih setia dengan UMNO, kritikan hanya untuk bangkitkan semangat parti - Tengku Zafrul
Ahli Majlis Kerja Tertinggi (MKT) UMNO, Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Abdul Aziz menegaskan beliau masih lagi setia bersama parti itu walaupun pernah mengkritik kepemimpinan UMNO Selangor sebelum ini.
AWANI Tonight: How will Iran-Israel situation evolve after tit-for-tat attacks?
Iranian officials and media are playing down the Israeli attack on Isfahan, saying it was limited to three small drones. Analyst Jonathan Lord discusses the Iranian response as concerns grow over a possible war with Israel.
AWANI Tonight: India: voters head to polls in world's biggest election
India’s 2024 general election kicks of today with over 969 million eligible voters. Rahul Mishra from Jawaharlal Nehru University shares what to expect as voters head to polls in the world’s biggest election. India, election, Narendra Modi, Rahul Mishra
Ringgit terus meningkat berbanding dolar AS semasa ditutup
Pada 6 petang, ringgit mengukuh kepada 4.7810/7855 berbanding dolar AS daripada 4.7840/7870 semasa ditutup pada Khamis.
Tidak perlu terlalu terkesan dengan lawak perkauman - Belia
Wakil Malaysia Southeast Asia Youth Leadership Program, Amira Aliya Abd Aziz berkata tidak perlu ambil hati dengan jenaka bersifat perkauman selagi mana ia tidak melibatkan isu-isu yang sensitif. Jelasnya, masyarakat berhak untuk membuat pendirian tersendiri terhadap jenaka-jenaka yang dibuat tetapi tidak perlu sehingga dipanaskan secara keterlaluan. #DialogAnakMuda
Raikan perbezaan selagi tidak menggunakan kaum untuk meraih perhatian - Mahasiswa
Setiausaha Agung Demokrat Universiti Malaya, Krishan Renganathan berkata perbezaan pandangan dalam sebuah negara demokrasi adalah suatu yang lumrah. Jelasnya, batas dalam perbezaan itu adalah tidak menggunakan sensitiviti kaum untuk meraih perhatian dan memancing isu. #DialogAnakMuda
Pupuk sikap mendengar tanpa bersifat emosional, reaksi terburu-buru - Belia
Graduan undang-undang Taylor’s University Malaysia, Faith Ling berkata masyarakat perlu amalkan sikap mendengar dari semua pihak secara terbuka tanpa bersikap emosional dan memberi reaksi secara terburu-buru demi menyantuni perbezaan pendapat yang wujud. Jelasnya, isu seperti konflik Israel-Palestin adalah terlalu kompleks dan perlu diamati dengan berhati-hati demi menjaga keharmonian. #DialogAnakMuda