IT IS a pity that some groups and individuals are urging palm oil importers in India to refrain from buying the commodity from Malaysia. The Solvent Extractors Association of India, India’s top vegetable oil trade body is one such outfit. Apparently, this boycott is a sort of “punishment” for Prime Minister Dr Mahathir Mohamad’s remarks on Kashmir at the United Nations General Assembly on 27th September 2019.
The Indian government has reportedly protested against Dr Mahathir’s criticism of Indian action in Kashmir. However so far it has not voiced support for the call to boycott Malaysian palm oil. There are also groups such as the Tamil Nadu Congress Committee that have come out against the reduction of Malaysian palm oil imports by India because of the possibility of retaliatory measures that could impact adversely upon workers from Tamil Nadu employed in the information technology sector and restaurant business in Malaysia.
This is one of the dangers of trade boycotts and the like in bilateral relations. They escalate quite easily doing irreparable damage to ties that have been cultivated over a long period of time. It is commendable that the two governments have displayed a degree of restraint. Vested interests, political parties and civil society groups in India and Malaysia should also demonstrate their maturity and approach the issue at hand in a balanced manner.
Since both countries are practising democracies, criticisms of certain aspects of the policies and practices of one another should be viewed as integral to their underlying value system. A democracy does not overact to a critical comment about its policy or practice. This is especially so if the state in question is also the world’s largest democracy.
Besides, one should examine the view expressed by Mahathir without any blinkers. Its main thrust was that the longstanding Kashmir conflict should be resolved “by peaceful means.” UN resolutions on Kashmir should not be disregarded. This is a position that a number of other governments have also expressed from various platforms.
At the crux and core of the UN’s stand on Kashmir is the solemn recognition that the wishes of the people of Jammu and Kashmir should be accorded primacy. This is why right from the outset the UN had urged all sides involved in the conflict to allow for a UN supervised plebiscite in Jammu and Kashmir which would decide the destiny of the people of that region. In other words, the people of Jammu and Kashmir should exercise their sacred right of self-determination.
In the early decades, self-determination was understood as the people of Jammu and Kashmir joining either India or Pakistan. In recent years, a new dimension has emerged. Self-determination in the real sense must also mean the people’s right to establish their own independent, sovereign state of Jammu and Kashmir which is part of neither Pakistan nor India.
Whatever the eventual goal, self-determination as a principle has not only been ignored but often suppressed. Uprisings by the people have been mercilessly crushed, the most infamous of which was the Jammu Massacre of 6th November 1947. It is alleged that Indian occupation forces alongside Dogra forces and RSS militants killed around half a million Kashmiri Muslims. Killings have continued in the last seven decades. It was this that Mahathir alluded to in his UN speech.
It is important to emphasise that these massacres have spawned the rise of militants and militancy in Kashmir. While militancy in Kashmir is largely home-grown and is intimately interwoven with the legitimate struggle for self-determination, it is quite conceivable that it receives material and moral support from elements in the Pakistani power stratum. This support and the militancy itself have now complicated the quest for a just solution to the conflict.
Sometimes political decisions made by New Delhi intensify --- perhaps unwittingly --- militancy among Kashmiris. The recent revocation of Kashmir’s special status through the abrogation of Article 370 in the Indian Constitution on the 5th of August 2019 is a case in point. A portion of Kashmiris will interpret the revocation and all that it implies in terms of ownership of land, the right of settlement and the alteration of ethnic and religious demographics as the wilful annexation of Indian occupied Kashmir into the Indian Union and therefore a clear repudiation of the desire of the Kashmiri people to determine their own future.
It appears that the abrogation of Article 370 will only perpetuate the violence and the bloodshed associated with one of the longest political conflicts in modern times.
* Dr Chandra Muzaffar is President of the International Movement for a Just World (JUST).
** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
Dr Chandra Muzaffar
Sat Oct 26 2019
FILEPIC: Indian security personnel stand guard along a deserted street during restrictions in Jammu, August 5, 2019. - REUTERS/Mukesh Gupta
Gempa kuat bermagnitud 6.3 landa Jepun - MetMalaysia
Satu gempa bumi kuat bermagnitud 6.3 dikesan di Shikoku, Jepun pada 10.14 malam tadi.
Thailand, New Zealand tingkat hubungan dua hala
Thailand dan New Zealand bersetuju meningkatkan hubungan dua hala mereka kepada perkongsian strategik menjelang 2026.
Ia sekaligus menandakan langkah penting ke hadapan dalam kerjasama kedua-dua negara yang telah lama terjalin.
Ia sekaligus menandakan langkah penting ke hadapan dalam kerjasama kedua-dua negara yang telah lama terjalin.
Penumpang HSR Jakarta-Bandung cecah 2.56 juta orang
Pada masa ini, perjalanan kereta api harian kereta api itu telah meningkat daripada 14 kepada 52 dan bilangan tempat duduk penumpang melonjak daripada 8,400 kepada lebih 31,000.
Antara pembangunan, pilihan manusia & kesihatan planet
Antara pembangunan, pilihan manusia, dan kesihatan planet.
dilema yang menjadi cabaran utama buat mana-mana negara untuk keluar dari kepompong kemunduran.
Hari kedua Sidang Kemuncak Kesihatan Planet (PHAM 2024) dan mesyuarat tahunan ke-6 antaranya mengangkat topik berkaitan kecerdasan buatan (AI) yang masih menjadi perdebatan kalangan pakar.
dilema yang menjadi cabaran utama buat mana-mana negara untuk keluar dari kepompong kemunduran.
Hari kedua Sidang Kemuncak Kesihatan Planet (PHAM 2024) dan mesyuarat tahunan ke-6 antaranya mengangkat topik berkaitan kecerdasan buatan (AI) yang masih menjadi perdebatan kalangan pakar.
KKR beri jaminan projek Kolam Selam Tempur siap Jun ini - Nanta
Kementerian Kerja Raya (KKR) akan memastikan projek pembinaan Kolam Selam Tempur di Kem Iskandar, Mersing, Johor yang mengalami kelewatan, siap sepenuhnya pada Jun ini.
Pemilihan MIC bermula 27 April ini
MIC akan mengadakan pemilihan parti bagi penggal 2024-2027 dari 4 Mei hingga 6 Julai dengan hari pencalonan ditetapkan mulai 27 April ini.
Kerajaan pandang serius pihak main sentimen rakyat
Mesyuarat sepakat agar kerajaan bertindak tegas menurut lunas-lunas perundangan dan tidak berkompromi dengan sebarang tindakan melampau yang boleh menjejaskan kestabilan negara ini.
Tumpuan Khamis - 18 April 2024
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan di Astro AWANI.
MCMC rakam percakapan Che'gubard, Salim lebih tiga jam
Salim dan Che’gubard yang ditemui di bangunan tersebut memberitahu mereka disiasat atas pertanyaan berkaitan kesihatan Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim dalam media sosial baru-baru ini.
Sabah kehilangan pemimpin berpengalaman, luar biasa - Hajiji
Ketua Menteri, Datuk Seri Hajiji Noor menyifatkan pemergian Tan Sri Joseph Kurup adalah satu kehilangan pemimpin berpengalaman dan luar biasa bagi negeri Sabah.
Kita mengecewakan Tun Razak - Chandra Muzaffar
Kejayaan dan keselesaan dimiliki negara membuatkan ramai pemimpin selepas Tun Abdul Razak tidak mempunyai semangat sepertinya.
Semua ini kerana nafsu politik beberapa individu yang tak dapat dibendung - Chandra Muzaffar
Chandra Muzaffar berpendapat, ada beberapa individu yang terlalu menginginkan jawatan Perdana Menteri.
Tak ada parti, pemimpin yang dominan gerakkan penyatuan - Penganalisis
Sejarah konfrontasi 1964 menunjukkan Perikatan dipimpin Tunku Abdul Rahman dapat menyatukan Malaysia berdepan krisis yang memberi impak kepada seluruh negara.
Perkukuh penyampaian maklumat peringkat akar umbi atasi persepsi negatif pengurusan pandemik
Mengambil contoh perolehan vaksin, Chandra berkata masalah utama yang dihadapi adalah kerana tindakan segelintir negara maju yang membolot vaksin.
Prestasi kerajaan tidak boleh diukur kepada angka jangkitan COVID-19 sahaja - Chandra Muzaffar
Peningakatan kes COVID-19 sejak kebelakangan ini antaranya kerana ujian saringan dan kewujudan varian-varian baharu.
Kejayaan PPN bergantung kepada sokongan rakyat - Chandra Muzaffar
Presiden Pergerakan Keadilan Dunia (JUST) itu berkata pengurusan pelaksanaan PPN tidak seharusnya diletakkan di bahu kerajaan semata-mata.
Parlimen buka semula tirai, ada perubahan? Agenda AWANI malam ini jam 8.30
Parlimen kembali membuka tirainya untuk memulakan Mesyuarat Khas Dewan Rakyat, menyaksikan Perdana Menteri membentangkan Pelan Pemulihan Negara sebelum dibahaskan oleh Ahli Parlimen yang hadir.
Perlu ada jawatankuasa yang disertai wakil kerajaan dan pembangkang untuk atasi krisis
Jawatankuasa bebas yang mengandungi semua wakil ini lebih berkesan ketika negara sedang berdepan krisis seperti mana yang sedang dihadapi sekarang.
Penubuhan Jawatankuasa Khas Bebas: Ini 5 tumpuan temu bual Dr Chandra Muzaffar
Berikut merupakan lima tumpuan dalam temu bual Agenda AWANI dengan Dr Chandra pada Selasa (12 Januari 2020).
Redakan suhu politik sementara waktu, ini rayuan rakyat - Dr Chandra
Rakyat telah merayu agar ahli politik lebih menfokuskan kepada isu penting yang lebih mendesak dan mencabar ketika ini.