MP for Serdang Dr. Ong Kian Ming wrote an excellent article about the worrying gender imbalance in Malaysian public universities.
MUST READ: Malaysian boys "missing" from our public universities
Our colleagues in the Penang Institute have shown that women greatly outnumbered men in major public universities.
In institutions such as Universiti Putra Malaysia, Universiti Malaysia Sarawak, Universiti Pendidikan Sultan Idris etc., female students constituted more than twice the number of male students.
Other top public varsities such as Universiti Malaya, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia scored between 1.5-1.99 in the Gender Parity Index (GPI), and are categorised as having “extreme disparity” with women outnumbering men.
Dr. Ong correctly pointed out that “the presence of a reverse gender gap in our public universities raises other concerns such as the career trajectory of the ‘missing’ boys and potential negative impacts on crime and other social indicators”.
The corollary situation
However, the corollary situation is also a matter of grave concern: the ‘missing’ girls and women in our job market.
Although women dominated our public tertiary institutions, they often go ‘missing’ after graduation.
I will borrow UNESCO’s Gender Parity Index used by Dr. Ong to measure the relative participation of women and men in the job market.
Similar to the UNESCO index, the GPI for this purpose is calculated by the quotient of the number of females by the number of males employed in a particular sector.
The purpose for this, other than its simplicity, is also to better demonstrate the corollary of Dr. Ong’s case by using similar measurement.
Using Dr. Ong’s UNESCO GPI of 0.97-1.03 as parity, while there is an over-representation of women in the clerical support workers sector (GPI 2.53), and in the professional sector (GPI 1.28), as well as parity in the service and sales sector (GPI 0.99), overall, women are still grossly underrepresented in the job market with a GPI of 0.62. (Source: Dept. of Statistics, Labour Force Survey 2015)
Dr. Ong pointed out that “45% of engineering undergraduates in Malaysia are female”. However, GPI for graduate engineers in the job market is 0.29 with women comprising only 22.7% in the sector in 2014.
While it is understandable that women are largely not in physically-demanding jobs such as plant and machine operators and assemblers (0.24), women are generally “missing” in decision-making and corporate leadership positions as well.
The GPI for managerial position is 0.29 suggesting a situation of “extreme disparity” against female workers.
The situation is as bad if not worse at the board level. According to data from the Commission of Companies, women made up only 16% of corporate board members, equivalent to a GPI of 0.19.
Government-linked companies are not faring any better. For companies under the Finance Ministry Incorporated, women made up only 17% of board members.
Women senior civil servants are also very few, about 33.7% holds Jawatan Utama Sektor Awam (JUSA) - GPI 0.51.
At the highest leadership level in the civil service, 7 out of 23 (30%) Chief Secretaries (Ketua Setiausaha) are women, while only 29 out of 151(19%) heads (Ketua Pengarah) of departments and statutory bodies are women.
Overall, from heads of departments onwards up to the Chief Secretary, the GPI is 0.26.
Where are the women whose numbers surpassed men in our public varsities?
A 2013 survey conducted by TalentCorp and ACCA on “Retaining Women in the Workforce” found that the top factors for women leaving the workforce are:
1) to raise a family
2) lack of work-life balance
3) to care for a family member
4) childcare is too expensive, and
5) lack of support facilities for women from employer
The comprehensive list of reasons given mostly have to do with a woman’s commitment to her family and workplace gender discrimination such as the gender wage gap, opportunities for promotion etc.
In today’s world, to choose between one’s family and one’s career are unfortunately a false dilemma posed to women. Often, it goes back to the culture of discrimination against women.
For women who took a career break to care for family, the same survey found that 93% of them wished to return to the work force, but 63% of them thought that there are major obstacles hindering them from doing so.
They cited “career obsolescence and employer bias” as key barriers for re-entry; again gender discriminatorion factors.
Economic consequences of our missing girls and women from the market place
While it should be clear that empowering women in all aspect including in the workforce is about fairness and human rights, closing the gender gap in the job market also brings real and measurable economic benefits.
Firstly, tax money spent on subsidising public varsities will not be maximised if a major segment of our student population goes “missing” from the job market after graduation, especially if it is not by choice and is due to circumstances which can be reversible.
Secondly, there is a real concern about the qualification of our workforce when our graduates are not “turning up for work” for whatever reasons. Only about 27% of all employed persons in Malaysia have tertiary education.
Thirdly, the World Economic Forum’s Global Gender Gap Report in 2014 confirmed “ a correlation between gender equality and GDP per capita, the level of competitiveness and human development...consistent with the theory and mounting evidence that empowering women means more efficient use of a nation’s human capital endowment and that reducing gender inequality enhances productivity and economic growth.”
McKinsey Global Institute reported that in a “full potential” scenario where women’s participation in the economy is identical to men’s, the annual global GDP in 2025 will increase upto 26% or USD28 trillion compared with a business-as-usual scenario.
This is equivalent to the economies of US and China combined today.
The report also projected an 8% increase in GDP for Southeast Asia by 2025 in such a scenario, translating to about RM110 billion in our own economy.
Dr. Ong is right to conclude that “just because female enrolment in IPTAs have far surpassed male enrolment does not mean that gender discrimination against females has disappeared.“
In fact, the missing girls and women from the job market should raise a red alert as much as the missing boys from public varsities.
While the missing boys phenomenon is relatively new, missing girls is an old problem, often highlighted but yet unresolved till today.
Steven Sim Chee Keong is the MP for Bukit Mertajam, and also Director of the Penang Institute and Penang Women’s Development Corporations
Views expressed are personally those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Astro AWANI.
Steven Sim
Thu Jun 09 2016
While women dominate public tertiary institutions in Malaysia, they often go missing after graduation.
Anwar jumpa ketua cabang selepas hari raya selesai kemelut PKR Sabah
Presiden PKR, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim akan mengadakan sesi konsultasi dengan semua ketua cabang di Sabah selepas hari raya nanti untuk mencari formula terbaik mengatasi pergolakan yang berlaku.
Pantau Agenda Reformasi: Bagaimana data PADU akan menambah baik penggubalan dasar?
Memahami keperluan untuk daftar PADU.
Dr. Hadhrami Bin Ab Ghani, Timbalan Dekan Fakulti Sains Data dan Komputeran UMK
Dr. Hadhrami Bin Ab Ghani, Timbalan Dekan Fakulti Sains Data dan Komputeran UMK
ICJ perintahkan Israel ambil tindakan tangani kebuluran di Gaza
Panel hakim di ICJ sebulat suara memerintahkan Israel untuk mengambil tindakan segera bagi menjamin penghantaran bekalan makanan asas kepada warga Palestin di Gaza.
Mungkin pegawai polis senior lindungi kegiatan haram
Pegawai kanan polis yang ditahan kerana menerima suapan bagi melindungi kegiatan
haram di ibu negara baru-baru ini berkemungkinan besar tidak menjalankan aktiviti itu secara solo.
Ketua Pesuruhjaya SPRM Tan Sri Azam Baki berkata pihaknya tidak menafikan pegawai itu tidak bergerak sendirian dalam menerima suapan dan melindungi kegiatan terbabit, selain disyaki wujud penglibatan pegawai polis yang lebih senior.
haram di ibu negara baru-baru ini berkemungkinan besar tidak menjalankan aktiviti itu secara solo.
Ketua Pesuruhjaya SPRM Tan Sri Azam Baki berkata pihaknya tidak menafikan pegawai itu tidak bergerak sendirian dalam menerima suapan dan melindungi kegiatan terbabit, selain disyaki wujud penglibatan pegawai polis yang lebih senior.
Jangan ambil tindakan sendiri, Malaysia ada undang-undang
Ketua Polis Negara, Tan Sri Razarudin Husain memberi amaran dan peringatan keras kepada orang ramai untuk tidak mengambil tindakan sendiri berhubung apa jua insiden yang berlaku di negara ini.
34 penjawat awam ditahan, sebabkan ketirisan RM2 bilion
Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) mendedahkan jumlah ketirisan akibat kegiatan sindiket penyeludupan babitkan beberapa anggota Jabatan Kastam Diraja Malaysia di Kargo Lapangan Terbang Antarabangsa Kuala Lumpur (KLIA), Sepang mencecah 2 bilion ringgit bagi tempoh tiga tahun lepas.
Konsert Ungu di Kuantan dianjak ke 4 Mei, Ella tampil sebagai artis undangan utama
Pesta Muzik Kuantan yang kini bertukar nama menjadi Konsert Ungu di Kuantan Bersama Artis Tanah Air 2024, akan dilangsungkan pada tarikh 4 Mei 2024.
[KOLUMNIS] Penyesuaian pesakit dengan stoma: 5 perkara yang perlu anda ketahui
STOMA merupakan bukaan usus di bahagian badan pesakit yang terhasil selepas pesakit menjalani pembedahan berkaitan usus.
Pasangan suami isteri, dua lelaki didakwa perdagang wanita Malaysia di Peru
Sepasang suami isteri dan dua lelaki yang dihadapkan ke Mahkamah Sesyen mengaku tidak bersalah atas pertuduhan memperdagang dua wanita Malaysia di Peru.
PM ucap selamat raikan Good Friday, Easter Sunday kepada penganut Kristian
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim mengucapkan selamat menyambut hari Good Friday dan Easter Sunday kepada seluruh penganut Kristian.