Two Pakatan Rakyat Member of Parliaments had claimed that the government is trying to revive the Emergency Ordinance (EO) and the Internal Security Act (ISA) through its suggestion to amend the Prevention of Crime Act 1959 (PCA).
In a joint statement by Steven Sim Chee Keong PKR-Bukit Mertajam and Zairil Khir Johari DAP-Bukit Bendera, the two claimed that the PCA violates civil liberties.
They said that the Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak has neglected his promise for transformation and had tarnished his own credibility.
"Many have pointed out the double standards of Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak, who began his term promising “transformation” and respect for human rights and civil liberties, but have now succumbed to business as usual by undoing his very own reforms, and his own credibility in the process," said Sim and Zairil.
They also said that the amendments to the PCA are problematic due to a few other reasons, including as an attempt to broaden the ambit for detention without trial.
Sim and Zairil argued that even without the amendments, the PCA already allows for remand of up to 28 days and then a further 28 days upon the approval of a magistrate.
They suggested that the police should focus on solving crime via the criminal justice system instead of taking the easy way out by using detention without trial.
"In other words, a person who has been accused of an offence can be detained without having been proven to have committed it.
"Does this not contradict the basis of criminal justice, whereby a person is innocent until proven guilty?" they asked.
Besides that, the two MPs also claimed that the arbitrary powers of the Home Minister that existed in the ISA has now been replaced with the arbitrary powers of a “Prevention of Crime Board.”
They said the Board will comprise three members, with a chairman who “shall be or have been, or be qualified to be, a judge of the Federal Court, the Court of Appeal or a High Court.”
"In addition to the chairman, there will be two other members. However, the bill provides no specification of any criteria whatsoever for the appointment of these two other members. This raises many questions – who will recommend them and on what basis would they be recommended?" questioned the two.
Sim and Zairil also claimed that the new amendment lacks independence and check and balance in decision-making as they say it prohibits legal redress by not allowing judicial review of the Board’s decisions.
"Thus, it is obvious that the proposed amendments to the PCA are a clear violation of civil liberties, and a return to a haunted past Malaysians believed to have been buried.
Although the two denied objecting the move to strengthen existing criminal laws to tackle crime, however that said that the current amendments are akin to the government reviving the oppressive EO and ISA through the backdoor via the PCA.
Haider Yutim
Fri Sep 27 2013
PADU: Keraguan pengguna patut menjadi satu mesej yang kerajaan kena faham - Pakar
Masalah itu tercetus akibat kurangnya komunikasi yang cermat dan akhirnya, ia membawa kepada pemahaman yang bersegmen dan kompleks.
Jumlah korban serangan di dewan konsert Rusia meningkat kepada 143
Jumaat lepas, sekumpulan lelaki bersenjata melepaskan tembakan rambang di Dewan Bandaraya Crocus, Krasnogorsk dalam Wilayah Moscow.
Kerjasama dua hala India-Malaysia bergantung kepada kepercayaan, kebolehpercayaan bersama - Menteri Luar
Memupuk kepercayaan dan kebolehpercayaan bersama sebagai asas untuk kerjasama dua hala antara India dan Malaysia adalah sangat penting, kata Menteri Luar India, Dr S. Jaishankar.
AWANI 7:45 [28/03/2024] - 75 peratus pemegang akaun keldai | Sakit mata, sakit hati | Bayar agihan pendapatan | Elak serbuan saat akhir
#AWANI745 malam ini bersama Essan Yahya;
1. Scammer! Dalam tiga bulan, lebih empat ribu ditahan
2. Hati jadi sakit, lambakan kereta terbiar depan rumah... Gempur745 siasat
3. PNB agih pendapatan RM0.67 bilion
4. Tambahan 300 kaunter PADU seluruh negara
1. Scammer! Dalam tiga bulan, lebih empat ribu ditahan
2. Hati jadi sakit, lambakan kereta terbiar depan rumah... Gempur745 siasat
3. PNB agih pendapatan RM0.67 bilion
4. Tambahan 300 kaunter PADU seluruh negara
AWANI Ringkas: Rusuhan di bazar Ramadan
AWANI Ringkas
PM Anwar beri bayangan tiada 'cuti tambahan' sempena sambutan Aidilfitri
Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim beri bayangan tiada cuti tambahan diberikan menjelang sambutan Hari Raya Aidilfitri yang dijadual pada 10 April depan.
UAE lancar kempen derma lebihan makanan sepanjang Ramadan
Emiriah Arab Bersatu (UAE) menerusi UAE Food Bank melancarkan kempen menderma lebihan makanan sepanjang ramadan kepada mereka yang memerlukan.
Pelapor Khas PBB terima ugutan
Pelapor Khas Pertubuhan Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu (PBB), Francesca Alabanese mendedahkan menerima ugutan ketika cuba mengumpulkan bukti genosid dilakukan Israel di genting Gaza.
Pentadbiran Biden arah semua agensi persekutuan AS lantik ketua pegawai AI
Pentadbiran Presiden Joe Biden telah mengarahkan semua agensi persekutuan negara itu melantik seorang ketua pegawai Kecerdasan Buatan (AI) untuk menyelia semua teknologi berkaitan.
Gempur: Masalah lambakan kereta usang membelenggu penduduk
Lambakan kereta tersadai di kawasan flat Sri Pantai menyebabkan penduduk berdepan masalah kekurangan parkir. Ada yang sudah berbulan malah ada yang bertahun tersadai sehingga menyebabkan kesesakan di kawasan parkir. Walaupun beberapa kali pihak berkuasa menunda kenderaan, tetapi masalah ini terus berulang.