SEOUL: With U.S. policy toward North Korea in limbo as the new administration in Washington conducts a months-long policy review, former officials and experts are sparring over whether to shift focus from seeking the North's full denuclearisation.
The administration of President Joe Biden says its review of North Korea policy will be finished in coming months, before announcing its plans for handling a rolling crisis that has bedevilled generations of U.S. presidents.
In his first major speech outlining Biden's top foreign policy priorities, Secretary of State Antony Blinken on Wednesday focused on China, only mentioning North Korea as one of several countries that present "serious challenges".
The administration's interim national security strategic guidance released later that day said Biden would "empower our diplomats to work to reduce the threat posed by North Korea’s growing nuclear and missile programs" while standing shoulder to shoulder with allies like South Korea and Japan, but did not elaborate.
The strategy's talk of threat reduction is notable and potentially positive if the administration embraces that as a short-term focus while retaining denuclearisation as a longer-term aspirational goal, said Ankit Panda, a senior fellow at the U.S.-based Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
"Threat reduction suggests a realistic appraisal of the situation on the Korean Peninsula - namely, that North Korea’s nuclear and missile capabilities need to be addressed short of total disarmament," he said.
Regardless of the approach taken, analysts and former officials say it would be a mistake to wait for North Korea to make the first move, such as a long-range missile or nuclear test, and that Biden stands the best chance of making some progress by being proactive.
"One key lesson we’ve learned over time is the longer we kick this can down the road, the more limited our options become," the U.S.-based 38 North think tank said in a recent report.
Among the proposals being raised by experts are limited arms control arrangements in exchange for easing sanctions on Pyongyang, establishing better diplomatic ties, conducting exchanges, and declaring an official end to the state of war that has technically existed since the 1950-1953 Korean War.
Several former members of Donald Trump's administration, however, have called for Biden to double down on sanctions and the threat of military action to pressure North Korea into giving up its nuclear weapons, arguing that his "maximum pressure" campaign was never fully enforced or given time to work.
Many of these ideas were debated prominently when Trump's historic meetings with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un raised the prospect that relations between the two old enemies could change.
But no significant breakthroughs were made and a growing number of observers say it is time the United States tries something new.
ARMS CONTROL VS DENUCLEARISATION
Earlier this week, analysts at the James Martin Center for Nonproliferation Studies (CNS) said commercial satellite imagery showed North Korea recently built a structure over a pair of underground tunnels near Yongdoktong, where it is believed to store nuclear weapons, highlighting potential progress in expanding the North's arsenal.
Last month, Blinken told the United Nations-backed Conference on Disarmament the United States "remains focused on the denuclearisation of North Korea."
38 North argued smaller steps could help reduce tensions and risks of conflict. Measures could include arms control agreements, scaling back military exercises with South Korea, building diplomatic ties, and declaring an end to the Korean War, while also working closely with allies and strengthening deterrence.
"The goal of denuclearisation should be maintained but reframed in a more realistic way that seeks to secure achievable limits on North Korea’s nuclear and missile capabilities in the near term," the report concluded.
Trump’s former national security, John Bolton, blasted those ideas in a recent op-ed for Bloomberg Opinion, arguing the United States needs to keep military options on the table. He feared Biden would adopt "weak arms control and nonproliferation diplomacy".
Another of Trump's former national security advisors, H.R. McMaster, told a U.S. congressional committee on Tuesday Biden should not to accede to initial agreements and payoffs just to get to the negotiating table.
"Acknowledging North Korea as a limited nuclear power and pursuing a strategy of containment is not acceptable," he said.
A former adviser to South Korean President Moon Jae-in argued the goal of denuclearisation does not need to be dropped, but the United States needs to be more flexible in making initial deals with Pyongyang.
"There’s unlikely to be any progress if they adopt a cognitive frame of 'crime and punishment,' Moon Chung-in wrote in a op-ed for the Hankyoreh newspaper.
Reuters
Thu Mar 04 2021
Among the proposals being raised by experts are limited arms control arrangements in exchange for easing sanctions on Pyongyang. (Korean Central News Agency/Korea News Service via AP)
Keliling kampung, ketuk buluh kejut penduduk bersahur
Pasukan gerak sahur di Teluk Bahang di sini masih mengejutkan penduduk di kawasan itu untuk bangun bersahur walaupun sudah dua minggu umat Islam berpuasa.
PADU: Kerajaan perlu lebih fokus mengenai cara untuk mempertingkatkan keyakinan - Pakar
Kerajaan perlu lebih fokus mengenai cara untuk mempertingkatkan keyakinan pengguna untuk memastikan pendaftaran sistem PADU berjaya.
7,348 kes jenayah komersial direkod hingga Mac, kerugian lebih RM770 juta
Belum sampai tiga bulan, polis sudah merekodkan 7,348 kes jenayah komersial melibatkan kerugian lebih RM770 juta.
Pihak berkuasa pelabuhan Singapura siasat insiden jambatan di Baltimore runtuh
Penguasa Maritim dan Pelabuhan Singapura akan menjalankan siasatan susulan insiden Jambatan Francis Scott Key di Baltimore, Maryland runtuh.
Kahwini warga tempatan, jadi dalang sindiket pekerja asing
Dua warga asing yang mengahwini rakyat tempatan dan menjadi dalang sindiket pekerja asing terbongkar selepas dicekup di Jalan Duta, di sini, pada Rabu.
Raja Permaisuri Agong berkenan agih bubur lambuk di Kampong Bharu
Raja Permaisuri Agong Raja Zarith Sofiah hari ini berkenan berangkat ke Majlis Pengagihan Bubur Lambuk di Masjid Jamek Kampong Bharu.
Kemarau: Kerajaan Kelantan gali 100 telaga tiub bantu pesawah
Kerajaan Kelantan akan menggali 100 buah telaga tiub bagi mengatasi masalah kekurangan bekalan air yang menghantui pesawah di negeri ini akibat kemarau.
Lelaki Myanmar dan Bangladesh dalang sindiket pekerja asing
Dua lelaki dari Myanmar dan Bangladesh disyaki dalang utama sindiket pekerja asing ditahan Jabatan Imigresen menerusi operasi khas di ibu negara.
Fokus mempertingkatkan keyakinan dan kepercayaan pengguna
Pensyarah Pusat Pengajian Sains Komputer, Fakulti Inovasi & Teknologi, Taylor’s University, Prof.Madya Ts Datuk Dr. Husin Jazri berpendapat bahawa Kementerian Ekonomi Malaysia harus fokus cara untuk mempertingkatkan keyakinan dan kepercayaan penuh dikalangan pengguna untuk memastikan pendaftaran sistem Pangkalan Data Utama (Padu) ini berjaya.
Operasi pembenihan awan Sabah dimulakan pagi tadi - Hajiji
Operasi pembenihan awan bagi menghasilkan hujan di Sabah telah dimulakan pagi ini, kata Ketua Menteri Datuk Seri Hajiji Noor.