CAMBODIA-Vietnam relations have always been enveloped by the shadows of a bloody past. This past refers to the Cambodian-Vietnamese War which was an armed conflict between then Democratic Kampuchea and the Socialist Republic of Vietnam. From 1975 to 1977, isolated clashes along the land and maritime borders proved to be a hallmark of this bloodbath, sporadically resulting in division-sized military formations. On 25 December 1978, Vietnam conquered Kampuchea, subsequently occupying the country after removing the government of the Khmer Rouge from power.
In its modern guise (from 1996 onwards), tensions between both ASEAN countries relate to an omnipresent border issue that encompasses both land and sea. Still relevant to this day, the land border imbroglio relates to contested locations along the common routes and to the demarcation of the border line, which Vietnam deems to be arbitrary. On the other hand, the maritime dispute encapsulates water and continental shelf areas in the Gulf of Thailand to the southeast of Cambodia and to the southwest of Vietnam. To add fuel to the fire, Cambodia rejected Vietnam's proposal to build four formal checkpoints with the former only accepting one. In retaliation, Vietnam blocked off four heavily travelled, informal crossings. The primary contention as brought forth by San Chey, the country director of the Affiliated Network for Social Accountability is that Vietnam may want more efficient routes to smuggle illegal timber into Cambodia.
As such, sentiments of an anti-Vietnam flavour are widespread in Cambodia and has often been used as a tool by opponents of Prime Minister Hun Sen, who took over the helm during Vietnam's occupation of Cambodia after it defeated the genocidal Khmer Rouge regime in 1979.
Vannarith Chheang, Chairman of the Cambodian Institute for Strategic Studies (CISS), points out that the strong nationalist ideology within the country has diminished any hopes of attaining a semblance of peace with its much-maligned neighbour. In 2009, a nascent Vietnamese threat gained momentum when then opposition leader, Sam Rainsy supposedly encouraged villagers to uproot border markers on the Cambodia-Vietnam boundary in the Svay Rieng province. With this in mind, the intensification of the border disputes came about after lawmakers from the opposition Cambodia National Rescue Party (CNRP) led activists to the to-be-demarcated border region in the north eastern provinces, leading to bloody clashes in June of that year.
In early 2018, Kirth Chantharith, a spokesman for the National Police of Cambodia, pointed out that Ratankkiri provincial authorities are hard at work trying to resolve the dispute, urging Vietnam to reopen the four blocked crossings that were shut in response to a denied building of formal barriers.
In August two years prior, a closed-door negotiation about the aforesaid border between the two countries ended in a stalemate, with neither party wanting to budge from their positions.
Va Kim Hong, head of the Cambodian Border Committee, pointed out that his country observes the boundary with Vietnam as set in 1983, with reference to maps of Indochina, the former French colonial territory that is now comprised of Vietnam, Cambodia, and Lao PDR. He is of the opinion that Phnom Penh should use "the map that the colonial power left for us when we gained independence in 1953" as an unwavering guide.
Border contentions will persist as long as the Cambodian political narrative revolves around a nationalism that is skewered towards hate and distrust. Transparency and public engagement are urgently required in the border negotiations and demarcation process between not only Cambodia and Vietnam, but other neighbours as well, including Lao PDR. The hoi polloi will remain susceptible to political manipulation in the absence of the aforementioned checks. What could be done potentially, with regards to the mitigation of conflict is to minimise anti-Vietnam sentiment so as to have a more impartial or objective view of the situation as it is. Both sides should not be swayed by preconceived notions and biases. This is of course easier said than done.
* Arief Subhan is a Research Assistant for the Political Futures Experts Group (PFEG) based at the International Institute of Islamic Thought and Civilisation (ISTAC)
**The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
Arief Subhan
Wed Feb 05 2020
Cambodia's Prime Minister Hun Sen embraces his Vietnamese counterpart Nguyen Xuan Phuc after their meeting at the Government Office in Hanoi, Vietnam October 4, 2019. REUTERS/File
Kerajaan Jawa Timur bincang kerjasama dengan Universiti Al-Azhar
Sejak 2019, setiap tahun Kerajaan Wilayah Jawa Timur hantar 30 pelajar melanjutkan pengajian peringkat sarjana muda di Universiti Al-Azhar.
Sultan Selangor, Raja Permaisuri zahir ucapan Maulidur Rasul
Sultan Sharafuddin turut menyeru seluruh umat Islam agar terus menguatkan kecintaan kepada Rasulullah SAW dengan mengamalkan sunah-sunah baginda.
NAFAS perkenal Kit Pertanian Bandar, galak lebih ramai tanam sayur di rumah
NAFAS harap Kit Pertanian Bandar akan dapat memudahkan lebih banyak keluarga di kawasan bandar untuk mula menanam sayur di rumah masing-masing.
Labuan sasar empat emas pada Para SUKMA Sarawak
Pingat emas disasarkan menerusi tiga atlet iaitu Risabel Rozell Parinus, Labo Taulim dan Avirinda Anis.
Perkhidmatan kereta api Poland-Czech digantung kerana banjir
Perjalanan kereta api yang datang dari Republik Czech ke Poland telah dibatalkan sehingga diberitahu kelak.
Sambutan Hari Malaysia di Bagas Zakariah imbau nostalgia zaman dahulu
Pengunjung yang hadir berbusana tahun 50-an dan 60-an disajikan dengan pertunjukan wayang pacak dan diberi peluang menyertai joget lambak.
Darah satria mendiang bapa mengalir dalam badan Indiran
Indiran juga berhasrat menyambung pengajian ke peringkat lebih tinggi untuk menjadi seorang pegawai tentera seperti bapanya.
PDRM, agensi penguat kuasa perlu tegas kenal pasti kegiatan penunggang agama
Ketegasan penting bagi memastikan gerakan subversif yang boleh memberikan ancaman terhadap akidah umat Islam di negara ini tidak berkembang.
Perbezaan pendapat perlu ditangani dengan adab terbaik - Ahmad Zahid
Ahmad Zahid berkata pada ketika menyambut Maulidur Rasul tahun ini, umat Islam diingatkan untuk menangani perbezaan pendapat dalam masyarakat dan organisasi dengan adab yang terbaik.
Umat Islam diseru perkukuh ukhwah, elak perselisihan
Ahmad Zahid berkata, ini kerana Malaysia sering dilihat sebagai contoh oleh dunia terutama dalam membawa suara Palestin.
Perkongsian strategik komprehensif pacu pertumbuhan perdagangan Malaysia-India
India yakin bahawa Perkongsian Strategik Komprehensif (CSP) yang baharu dipertingkatkan dengan Malaysia akan mendorong perdagangan dua hala ke tahap yang lebih tinggi.
‘Ribut geopolitik’ menghampiri, ASEAN harus perkuat kesepaduan - Mahbubani
Ketika ketegangan antara Amerika Syarikat dan China terus meningkat, diplomat terkenal Singapura dan ahli akademik Kishore Mahbubani menggesa anggota dan pemimpin ASEAN untuk mengukuhkan perpaduan.
Menteri luar ASEAN nyatakan solidariti dengan negara terjejas taufan
ASEAN menegaskan solidaritinya dengan kerajaan yang terjejas serta yakin negara-negara itu akan dapat mengatasinya dan pulih dengan segera.
Isu berkaitan Laut China Selatan perlu ditangani menerusi ASEAN - Mohamed Khaled
Sebarang isu berkaitan Laut China Selatan perlu ditangani secara berterusan menerusi ASEAN, kata Menteri Pertahanan Datuk Seri Mohamed Khaled Nordin.
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Antara pelbagai berita luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
Ringgit naik berbanding dolar AS, hampiri paras sokongan segera RM4.3259
Ringgit ditutup lebih tinggi berbanding dolar AS pada hari kedua berturut-turut untuk menghampiri paras sokongan segera RM4.3259, kata pakar ekonomi.
Negara ASEAN perlu bersatu suarakan isu perubahan iklim - Nik Nazmi
Katanya, jika negara anggota ASEAN bekerjasama dan memanfaatkan 670 juta penduduk dan kekuatan ekonomi rantau ini, suara mereka akan lebih dihormati.
Ringgit ditutup tinggi berbanding dolar AS menjelang laporan inflasi AS
Ringgit ditutup dengan mengukuh berbanding dolar AS hari ini, sejajar dengan mata wang serantau lain berikutan peserta pasaran menunggu laporan IHP AS yang akan dikeluarkan esok.
Malaysia sedang perhebat kemampuan dalam industri semikonduktor - Tengku Zafrul
Malaysia mempunyai kelebihan daya saing dalam sektor semikonduktor, termasuk sebagai pemain utama dalam industri elektrikal dan elektronik.
Pihak berkepentingan pelancongan diminta tingkatkan usaha jayakan VM2026
Pihak berkepentingan dalam industri pelancongan diminta untuk meningkatkan usaha menjayakan kempen Melawat Malaysia 2026 (VM2026), titah Pemangku Raja Perlis.