With the signing of the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) on Nov 15, the stage is set for Malaysia to tap into the world’s largest free trade area (FTA) of some 2.1 billion strong market, including China, and accounting for approximately 30% of the world’s GDP. Up next is the Comprehensive and Progressive Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP) – spanning the Asia-Pacific Rim countries and home to 95 million consumers as well as contributing around 13.5% of the global GDP worth a total of USD10.6 trillion.
The CPTPP is a gargantuan FTA in terms of the scope of provisions running into thousands of pages. Previously, it was known as the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) under the lead sponsorship of the US. Essentially, the TPP is perceived to be biased in favour of the rights and interests of multinational corporations, i.e. the foreign investors (based in the US), over governments as sovereign entities. Both the TPP and CPTPP excludes China.
Even with the withdrawal of the US from the TPP, the CPTPP or the new version of the TPP remains highly controversial. It’s good that Minister of International Trade & Industry Azmin Ali has reiterated Malaysia’s stand that there’s no timeline to ratify the CPTPP. And that ratification must be dependent on the CPTPP being about “fair” trade and, therefore, not just about “free” trade.
Such caution is to be welcomed because both the old TPP and new CPTPP are not a standard FTA.
And that the basic provisions of the TPP remains intact in the CPTPP.
Well-rehearsed arguments opposing the TPP include:
• the prospects of imported products threatening to swamp the local market and thus, threatening to put domestic producers and suppliers out of business as well as inflationary pressures; and
• the fear that the bumiputera agenda and government procurement policy in relation to bumiputera contractors as well as local small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) will be undermined in the name of “convergence”, “non-regression”, or “level playing field”.
Added to that is the issue of state aid, i.e. government or State intervention in the private sector targeted at nurturing and developing certain industries and sectors. Outside of Malaysia, South Korea with its chaebols and Japan with its zaibatsus are classic examples.
Under the CPTPP, state aid rules remain a major concern. As highlighted in a report by Khazanah Research Institute (KRI), Chapter 17 of the CPTPP specifically mandates “level playing field” between state-owned enterprises/SOEs (government-linked companies/GLCs) at the federal level and non-SOEs (read: foreign investors). This would definitively impact the advantages enjoyed by our GLCs from the government (institutional, regulatory, financial).
In addition, the TPP was also opposed within Malaysia on grounds revolving around investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) and intellectual property rights (IPR).
Firstly, on ISDS which basically means disputes between the government and foreign investors are to be arbitrated by a non-judicial tribunal outside of the country’s sovereign jurisdiction.
Given developments post-TPP which spills over into the current CPTPP context, the worry is that in the event our government chooses to cancel or renegotiate a contract with a foreign investor as was the case with the East Coast Rail Link (ECRL), just to give an example, will this expose us to ISDS proceedings? This on the basis that it constitutes a form of “indirect expropriation” and breach of investment obligation?
Secondly, on intellectual property rights (IPR), there’s the well-acknowledged and well-founded argument that the TPP would have resulted in the prices of drugs soaring, thus impacting access for the low income, due to patents enforcement and licensing requirement.
Now under the CPTPP, the suspension of longer patent periods for innovative medicines and shorter periods for copyright protection may be welcomed as good news for Malaysia. But will the inbuilt bias against data localisation work to the adverse disadvantage of new entrants into the CPTPP market, not least of all from Malaysia?
Data localisation means data collected be first approved by the host country before being transmitted across borders. Prohibiting data localisation benefits countries with strong patents applications and track record. New data from one country can be used as part of the subsequent newer patent submissions in another country, with all the ramifications on us including also loss of tax revenue due to ease of transfer pricing, for example.
Ironically, this undermines level playing field.
Thirdly, on electronic commerce.
Will our accession to the CPTPP render the digital service tax (DST) under the Service Tax Act (2018) susceptible to legal challenge as being incompatible with the provisions on electronic commerce as per Chapter 14 (of the CPTPP)?
The relevant provisions mention the prohibition of the “imposition of customs duties on electronic transmissions”. Will the DST be interpreted under the ISDS as constituting a violation of the government’s “investment obligation”, where the digital content providers that are the foreign service providers (FSPs) have operations in Malaysia, whether outsourced or through subsidiaries?
Furthermore, will the DST be deemed as a form of customs duties and, therefore, a form of protectionism? Bearing in mind, legal action can still be initiated by an interested party based in Malaysia with legal standing on the basis of judicial review. Thus, the relevant stakeholders who may be aggrieved needn’t go through the ISDS which of course has a much higher threshold, for example, requiring demonstration of loss of investments.
Last but not least, as we pause to consider ratification of the CPTPP, have we weighed the potential impact on intra-Asean cooperation and regionalisation? Will the CPTPP also simultaneously weaken Asean’s “centrality” as the “fulcrum” of the wider Asia-Pacific cooperation – which lies at the core of the RCEP?
The government is right to be now focussing and committed towards accelerating and intensifying intra-Asean cooperation and coordination by prioritising the RCEP. In doing so, we’re tapping into the vast potential of the Asean and wider RCEP market that’s also more supply-chain resilient while at the same time taking advantage and playing a part in shaping the reshoring and onshoring phenomenon of the supply chain reconfiguration.
Jason Loh Seong Wei is Head of Social, Law and Human Rights at EMIR Research, an independent think tank focused on strategic policy recommendations based on rigorous research.
** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
Jason Loh Seong Wei
Tue Nov 17 2020
Malaysia is tapping into the vast potential of the ASEAN and wider RCEP market that's also more supply-chain resilient. AWANIpic
Setiausaha Kerajaan Negeri Melaka meninggal dunia
Allahyarham Zaidi Johari yang berusia 54 tahun menghembuskan nafas terakhir akibat serangan jantung sekitar pukul 8.15 pagi ini.
Letupan terdengar di Isfahan, Iran - Laporan
Satu letupan kedengaran di barat laut bandar Isfahan di Iran, lapor agensi berita FARS yang memetik sumber tempatan.
Raffi Ahmad mengaku pernah minum air basuhan kaki ibu
"Benar, saya minum (air basuh kaki). Minggu hadapan semua pekerjaan yang hilang saya dapat balik." - Raffi Ahmad
Tiada lagi ulang tayang Piala FA
Semua video ulang tayang perlawanan Piala FA dari perlawanan pusingan pertama akan dibatalkan mulai musim depan.
Niaga SPOTLIGHT: Financial Inclusion via Innovative FinTech
12% of Malaysia ie; 7 million Malaysians, primarily from rural areas are unbanked - meaning they cannot access any financial services.
This is a dire need in Malaysia due to the country’s fast growth rate in mobile banking and e-money transactions, which quadrupled to RM800 billion in 2021.
Moreover, the existence of financial inclusion gaps among underserved communities such as women, gig workers, and lower-income earners requires significant attention.
Niaga Spotlight speaks with Nisa Ismail, CEO, Sedania As Salam Capital Sdn Bhd (SASC) about the latest in Financial Inclusion via FinTech to help close socioeconomic gaps, especially in rural areas.
#NiagaAWANI
#NiagaSPOTLIGHT
This is a dire need in Malaysia due to the country’s fast growth rate in mobile banking and e-money transactions, which quadrupled to RM800 billion in 2021.
Moreover, the existence of financial inclusion gaps among underserved communities such as women, gig workers, and lower-income earners requires significant attention.
Niaga Spotlight speaks with Nisa Ismail, CEO, Sedania As Salam Capital Sdn Bhd (SASC) about the latest in Financial Inclusion via FinTech to help close socioeconomic gaps, especially in rural areas.
#NiagaAWANI
#NiagaSPOTLIGHT
Niaga AWANI: Pendidikan AI sekolah rendah: Pembangunan masa depan digital
Di sekolah rendah di Malaysia, pelajar akan diperkenalkan kepada asas AI dalam mata pelajaran baharu yang dipanggil Teknologi dan Digital bermula dari 2027. Apakah persiapan yang diperlukan setiap sekolah untuk memastikan pelahar lebih muda dibawa masuk ke dunia penggunaan AI yang bertanggungjawab?
#NiagaAWANI
#NiagaAWANI
Niaga AWANI: MOSTI sasarkan penubuhan 900 pemula niaga menjelang 2026
Kementerian Sains, Teknologi dan Inovasi (MOSTI) menyasarkan untuk memudahkan penubuhan sehingga 900 pemula niaga kecerdasan buatan AI menjelang 2026 melalui program perintis AI Sandbox 2024.
#NiagaAWANI
#NiagaAWANI
Klopp terima kenyataan kurang ancaman punca Liverpool tewas
Mohamed Salah kurang menunjukkan prestasi terbaiknya sejak kembali dari kecederaan hamstring.
Niaga AWANI: Sinergi diperlukan bagi merealisasikan aspirasi mampan negara
Kenyataan itu juga mengatakan bahawa RHB telah mencapai kemajuan yang ketara ke arah operasi neutral karbon, mencapai pengurangan 43 peratus dalam pelepasan gas rumah hijau (GHG) operasi berbanding garis dasar 2016, merangkumi Skop 1, 2, dan 3 (Perjalanan Perniagaan melalui Jalan dan Udara.
#NiagaAWANI
#NiagaAWANI
AWANI Pagi: Raya Oh Raya: Alamak! Poket dah "kering" ni
Diskusi 8.30 pagi Jumaat bersama Dr Nur Lalua Rashidah Mohd Rahsiad, Pengurus, Perhubungan Korporat Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation (APU) mengenai pengurusan kewangan selepas berdepan perbelanjaan yang banyak dimulai sesi sekolah dibuka diikuti puasa dan hari raya. Ini termasuk bagaimana pengurusan yang baik boleh membantu membawa keluar keluar daripada pergelutan kewangan sementara menunggu gaji bulan seterusnya.
Malaysia perluas hubungan perdagangan: Pastikan pelaksanaan ACFTA, RCEP berjaya
Malaysia berazam untuk memperluas hubungan perdagangan negara dengan memastikan kejayaan pelaksanaan perjanjian ACFTA dan RCEP.
Banyak syarikat gagal manfaatkan pengurangan duti import CPTPP, RCEP - MITI
MITI menghadapi cabaran untuk meningkatkan kadar penggunaan atau pemanfaatan CPTPP dan RECEP oleh syarikat tempatan walaupun telah dikuatkuasakan sejak 2022.
Malaysia-Vietnam akan manfaatkan RCEP, CPTPP - Tengku Zafrul
Katanya, RCEP dan CPTPP akan mempertingkatkan usaha pemulihan ekonomi yang sedang dilaksanakan oleh kedua-dua negara, pascapandemik.
Perdagangan luar China lepasi RMB20 trilion
Jabatan Pentadbiran Am Kastam China (GACC) menyifatkan prestasi itu selaras dengan jangkaan selepas meraih pertumbuhan sebanyak 2.1 peratus.
Sri Lanka minta sokongan Indonesia untuk sertai RCEP
Menteri Luar Sri Lanka, Ali Sabry, bertemu dengan Menteri Kewangan Indonesia, Sri Mulyani Indrawati, di Jakarta pada Khamis.
RCEP dikuat kuasa secara menyeluruh babitkan semua 15 ahli
Perjanjian Perkongsian Ekonomi Komprehensif Serantau (RCEP) dikuat kuasa secara rasmi di Filipina pada Jumaat, menandakan kesemua 15 anggota meratifikasi perjanjian berkenaan, lapor Xinhua.
FMM akan bekerjasama dengan China dalam pelbagai bidang
FMM akan bekerjasama dengan CCPIT dan CCOIC untuk memperkukuh hubungan perniagaan serta kerjasama antara Malaysia dan China.
MYEG meterai perjanjian dengan China Customs bagi pemudahan perdagangan rentas sempadan
Sijil lain yang berkaitan dengan perdagangan rentas sempadan seperti jaminan makanan, kuarantin dan dokumen kargo juga boleh dikeluarkan di platform blockchain itu.
Malaysia bakal penerima manfaat terbesar RCEP dari kalangan negara ASEAN - Azmin
Memetik laporan UNCTAD, Azmin berkata, Malaysia diunjurkan mencatat nilai peningkatan eksport sehingga USD200 juta.
Malaysia alu-alukan Arab Saudi manfaatkan penyertaan negara dalam RCEP - MITI
Malaysia dan Arab Saudi mengesahkan komitmen masing-masing untuk mengukuhkan perdagangan dua hala ke tahap yang lebih tinggi.