THE recent floods in eight Malaysian states (i.e., Kelantan, Terengganu, Pahang, Perak, Negeri Sembilan, Melaka, Kuala Lumpur and Selangor) have devastated homes, vehicles, livestock, farms, farming equipment, etc. and with that comes the financial losses and worries.
Against the backdrop of chaos (kelam kabut) and what has been a rather lacklustre attitude from the current administration that has slowed down the search and rescue mission, the quintessential Malaysian spirit of #kita jaga kita once again shone through the bleak and desperate situation when many Malaysians uncalculatingly lent their helping hands to assist flood victims.
On December 28, it was reported that at least 47 people died from the flooding and four people were still missing. Due to polluted water supply, affected residents faced difficulty cleaning up their homes.
A such, the residents who were left with flood-damaged houses, vehicles, furniture and electrical appliances had found it challenging to endure the double whammy of the on-going Covid-19 crisis affecting livelihoods and now the flood disaster.
Not only have they been struggling to put food on the table due to a reduction in income and savings arising from the scarring effects of the Covid-19 induced lockdowns, but the flood has exacerbated the situation by constraining their ability to go out to work as their vehicles were damaged by floodwater, among other calamities.
Notwithstanding, the federal and state governments have introduced numerous initiatives to help flood victims. However, folks like hawker Rohkiah Abdul Aziz from Kampung Kubu Gajah in Selangor complained to the New Straits Times that she did not receive any cash handout since applying more than a week before, as reported on December 20.
She also expressed frustration that some affected residents including herself could not have access to food and shelter at a temporary evacuation centre (PPS) as they were not residents of the area designated to the facility.
For Selangorians affected by the flood, each household is eligible to receive a total of RM2,000 one-off financial assistance – RM1,000 from the federal government via the Bantuan Wang Ihsan (BWI) and another RM1,000 from the Selangor state government.
Nevertheless, if we were to do a simple calculation (i.e., RM2,000 divided by 5 family members divided by 30 days), each family member merely has RM13.33 to survive per day. It would not be sufficient for a family to navigate through the flood crisis as they have to purchase basic necessities ranging from food (including milk and beverages) to toiletries, clothes, gadgets (e.g., handphones, charges, power banks) and pharmaceuticals (e.g., Panadol) to support and sustain their basic living.
Still, flood victims also could apply for the Bank Simpanan Nasional (BSN)’s interest-free personal loans of up to RM5,000 to buy replacements for household equipment and furniture destroyed in the floods with repayment starting after six months.
Even though the loan schemes would provide breathing space for the flood victims to purchase the required items to rebuild their homes, they still have to pay off accrued expenses after six months. If they cannot repay within the specific timeframe, they will fall deeper into poverty and debt.
There are some who are clamouring for their EPF savings to be withdrawn under an extension of the i-Citra scheme. According to Umno Youth Chief Asyraf Wajdi Dusuki, many flood victims in Kampung Bukit Changgang, Selangor, for example, have pleaded for another round of RM10,000 withdrawal from EPF as they do not have much cash in hand available to spend.
Notwithstanding, Prime Minister Dato’ Sri Ismail Sabri Yaakob and Finance Minister Tengku Zafrul Aziz are resisting such populist move by emphatically rejecting this option as impractical and unsustainable.
Tengku Zafrul’s timely article, “Further EPF withdrawals will burden younger generations in the future” (as published e.g., in the Malay Mail, December 31, 2021) articulated very clearly – in typical technocratic style – that further withdrawals is inimical to the sacred mandate of the EPF to safeguard the contributions of members, among others.
To this, we could also just add that if the populist call for i-Citra to be extended is heeded, the affected contributors or account holders will not be able to enjoy the compounding interest rate associated with their accumulated EPF savings account.
Instead, the Prime Minister has announced that flood victims would receive as much as RM61,000 so that this is precisely to ensure that they do not have to dip into their EPF savings as stated in his New Year message.
The criteria to withdraw EPF savings for “emergency” use should not be loosened – but in fact tightened over the medium to long-term to counter-balance the impact of the withdrawals.
In addition, there is also the Bantuan Banjir Keluarga Malaysia flood assistance five cash incentives amounting to RM10,000 for each head of household.
The RM61,000 will not necessarily be uniformly disbursed but includes a cash voucher of RM500 for the purchase of electrical appliances. There is also the RM1,000 voucher for repairs or purchases to replace vehicles that have suffered serious damage as well as cash aid of up to RM5,000 for house repairs.
Finally, for houses that have been totally destroyed, the government will help bear the cost up to RM56,000 for the construction of a new one.
To further assist the flood victims, EMIR Research would like to propose the following policy recommendations for the current administration to consider:
1. Increase the unconditional/automatic basic cash quantum of both federal and state government’s financial assistance to a minimum of RM5,000. The ratio of share between the federal and statement governments should be 60/40, i.e., RM3000 and RM2000, respectively.
For a household with five family members, each family member would have RM33 to spend per day (i.e., RM5,000 divided by five family members divided by 30 days).
2. Relocate the affected families to vacant properties under a temporary resettlement programme.
Temporary accommodation could also include converted or modified containers and long-houses as well as modular houses under Industrialised Building System (IBS) schemes.
The government could work with cooperatives and non-governmental organisations (NGOs) to provide some basic furniture (including beds) and accessories.
In addition, to prevent flooding on such a massive scale, flood management should be reconceptualised:
1. Flood mitigation and defence should be integrated and inter-connected rather than piece-meal.
Meaning – instead of disjointed or isolated flood management systems of sluice gates and pumping stations that are simply connected to the river without any overall strategic purpose – there should be an overall masterplan.
This masterplan ensures that the individual flood mitigation mechanisms support the overall flood management and water security policies, and not least climate change adaptation strategy.
As mentioned in EMIR Research article, “Flood management – please come up with a masterplan” (December 29, 2021), the construction of canals (this time around) should also “inter-lock” with one another and not just “parallel” with one another. That is, secondary canals should connect with primary canals (in turn connected to the underground water storage facilities).
And revolving around the concepts of absorption and storage.
Adopting and transplanting the impressive Dutch model of “Room for the River” is unfortunately impractical as the over-development precisely takes place on our floodplains themselves, including Kuala Lumpur city centre.
So, apart from the Tokyo (floodplain) model as alluded to in the article, there is also the Singapore’s Marina Barrage model, (alluded to in EMIR Research article, “East Coast flooding: Breaking the annual cycle”, November 10, 2020) i.e., urban water catchment that can be copied for Selangor as the most urbanised state in Malaysia.
The Marina Barrage is similar to the Thames Barrier – that formidable concrete series of 10 separate movable steel gates which stands at 20 meters tall and stretching 520 meters designed to protect the City of London from tidal flooding.
Stamford Diversion Canal is connected to Marina Bay or Reservoir (seen from the perspective of the role that the Barrage play in damming up freshwater). Like the Tokyo model, it’s a canal system that has an underground detention tank.
Our masterplan could have a similar barrage or barrier that protects against tidal and coastal flooding at the mouth of the Klang River – flanked by a series of mangrove swamps along the coast on both sides as eco-barrier to protect against coastal erosion (so as to maintain some land buffer as “second line of defence”).
Our underground tanks and other storage facilities should connect with waste water treatment plants (where possible). Otherwise, they can be converted into portable water for transportation to water treatment plants overland – by pipe or trucks. All in all, the tanks should be divided into two kinds – one for immediate collection and the other for diversion (i.e., to water treatment plants).
Natural water catchments should be identified (and gazetted) in the upstream – in addition to constructing deep and wide canals.
In conclusion, now is the time to rebuild the EPF as it must never be used any longer as a “last resort” withdrawal scheme. At the same time, we must also “rebuild” our flood defence system – for the future.
Jason Loh and Amanda Yeo are part of the research team of EMIR Research, an independent think tank focused on strategic policy recommendations based on rigorous research.
** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
Astro Awani
Fri Jan 07 2022
The recent floods in eight Malaysian states have devastated homes, vehicles, livestock, farms, farming equipment, etc. and with that comes the financial losses and worries. - Astro AWANI/Filepic
Pelepasan air terawat Fukushima digantung kerana terputus elektrik
Pelepasan air radioaktif terawat ke laut dari loji janakuasa nuklear Fukushima yang lumpuh digantung pada Rabu berikutan gangguan bekalan elektrik separa, kata pengendali loji itu.
Prabowo rasmi diisytihar Presiden Indonesia
Suruhanjaya Pilihan Raya Umum (KPU) secara rasmi akan mengisytiharkan Prabowo Subianto sebagai Presiden Indonesia dipilih, dalam satu majlis pada Rabu, seperti yang dijadualkan.
Jerman-UNRWA mungkin bekerjasama semula
Kerajaan Jerman merancang untuk menjalinkan kerjasama dengan agensi Pertubuhan Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu bagi pelarian Palestin (UNRWA). Ia susulan daripada kontroversi yang mendakwa anggota petugas UNRWA terlibat dalam serangan di Gaza yang berlaku pada 7 Oktober tahun lalu.
Ini panggilan daripada Allah SWT - Dr Sharifah Mazlina
Ketua Misi Ekspedisi Wanita Berkumpulan ke Antartika, Dr Sharifah Mazlina Syed Abdul Kadir yang merupakan salah seorang peserta dari Malaysia bagi misi Break The Siege of Gaza Freedom Flotilla menyifatkan penglibatannya dalam misi berkenaan sebagai satu panggilan yang ditentukan Allah.
Tujuh ditahan polis dalam serbuan 'keganasan' Australia
Polis Australia menahan tujuh individu yang menimbulkan risiko dan ancaman kepada orang ramai selepas melakukan serbuan antikeganasan membabitkan lebih 400 pegawainya, pada Rabu.
[TERKINI] UM diminta siasat, sedia laporan segera
Kementerian Pendidikan Tinggi (KPT) mengambil maklum dan memandang serius isu yang berlaku berhubung tindakan seorang penceramah warga asing mengeluarkan kenyataan yang dilihat mencetuskan kontroversi dan tidak menghormati sentimen masyarakat seperti tular di media sosial.
Astro AWANI dinobat adaptasi AI dalam pemberitaan terbaik di pentas Asia
Astro AWANI dinobat sebagai pemenang Anugerah Digital Media Awards 2024 bagi kategori adaptasi Teknologi Kecerdasan Buatan (AI) dalam pemberitaan terbaik di rantau Asia.
MITI optimis prestasi perdagangan lebih baik pada 2024
Tengku Zafrul menjelaskan, MITI juga memperbaharui fokusnya dengan berpaksikan kepada empat tunjang utama iaitu ekonomi, kelestarian, rakyat dan inovasi.
Pekebun durian musang king gagal dapat kebenaran semakan kehakiman
Mahkamah Tinggi tolak permohoan pekebun musang king untuk semakan kehakiman
Mahkamah Tinggi Kuantan menolak permohonan 186 pekebun durian musang king di sekitar Raub untuk mendapatkan kebenaran semakan kehakiman terhadap notis arahan pengosongan tanah dikeluarkan kerajaan negeri Pahang sebelum ini.
Mahkamah Tinggi Kuantan menolak permohonan 186 pekebun durian musang king di sekitar Raub untuk mendapatkan kebenaran semakan kehakiman terhadap notis arahan pengosongan tanah dikeluarkan kerajaan negeri Pahang sebelum ini.
Inspektor polis ditahan disyaki lakukan amang seksual fizikal
Seorang pegawai polis berpangkat inspektor ditahan bagi membantu siasatan berhubung dakwaan melakukan amang seksual fizikal
ke atas kanak-kanak perempuan berumur 16 tahun.
Ketua Polis Johor, Komisioner Polis M. Kumar berkata suspek yang bertugas di Ibu Pejabat Polis Daerah Pontian dikatakan melakukan kesalahan tersebut pada 22 April 2024 sekitar jam 6 petang di kawasan taman Johor Jaya.
ke atas kanak-kanak perempuan berumur 16 tahun.
Ketua Polis Johor, Komisioner Polis M. Kumar berkata suspek yang bertugas di Ibu Pejabat Polis Daerah Pontian dikatakan melakukan kesalahan tersebut pada 22 April 2024 sekitar jam 6 petang di kawasan taman Johor Jaya.
MARA siasat guru didakwa pedofil
MARA akan membuat siasatan menyeluruh terhadap seorang guru yang didakwa terlibat kes pedofilia ke atas murid di sebuah sekolah berasrama penuh.
Lebih 80 peratus tawaran ke MRSM buat pelajar B40
Pengambilan pelajar tingkatan satu dan empat dalam kalangan golongan berpendapatan rendah atau B40 ke Maktab Rendah Sains MARA (MRSM) bagi sesi 2024 adalah melebihi 80 peratus.
Konsep payung perlu dikembalikan - Asyraf Wajdi
Ia bagi membantu usahawan kecil untuk mempunyai kemahiran dalam menguruskan aliran wang tunai dalam perniagaan masing-masing.
PM luang masa tinjau perjalanan KEB 2024
Perdana Menteri meluangkan masa meninjau perjalanan Kongres Ekonomi Bumiputera 2024 yang bermula hari ini di Pusat Konvensyen Antarabangsa Putrajaya.
Pentakrifan kategori pendapatan B40, M40, T20 bukan gambaran realiti - Asyraf Wajdi
Asyraf Wajdi berkata isu ini sering dibangkitkan dalam sesi libat urus dan wajar diambil kira sama ada pentakrifan kategori ini masih lagi relevan ataupun tidak.
'Kongres Ekonomi Bumiputera tidak harus dipolemik' - Asyraf Wajdi
Kongres Ekonomi Bumiputera 2024 (KEB 2024) tidak harus dilihat sebagai salah satu langkah untuk menafikan hak bukan bumiputera.
Jawatankuasa Khas Gubal Undang-Undang Islam diharap perkasa Akta 355
Asyraf berkata, antara cadangan penting ialah untuk menaikkan had hukuman denda maksimum daripada RM5,000 kepada RM100,000.
Kampung Baru Cina: UMNO tolak cadangan Nga Kor Ming
Tegas Asyraf Wajdi, ia bertentangan dengan Perlembagaan Persekutuan yang mengiktiraf hanya bumiputera sebagai penduduk asal dengan hak keistimewaan tertentu.
25 peratus tawaran MRSM ditolak setiap tahun, kekosongan diisi calon simpanan
Asyraf Wajdi berkata, jumlah itu berdasarkan rekod yang dikenal pasti sebelum ini.
Tak perlu bukan Islam dalam jawatankuasa khas kaji bidang kuasa Mahkamah Syariah - Asyraf Wajdi
Asyraf Wajdi menegaskan tiada keperluan untuk pakar bukan Islam dilantik dalam jawatankuasa mengkaji bidang kuasa Mahkamah Syariah.