KUALA LUMPUR: As the adage goes, “the enemy of my enemy is my friend”. But surely this doesn’t apply to Malaysia’s relations to China and the US, as we are heavily reliant on both for our economic and security well-being (in terms of regional stability) – one way or another.
China is a main foreign direct investment (FDI) player in Malaysia, having overtaken traditional investors that the US has been since 2016. Perhaps the most popularly known example of China’s FDI in Malaysia is in automotive where Geely is the 49.9% owner of Proton (with 50.1% owned by DRB-Hicom).
However, the trade war and reshoring by American multinational companies (MNCs) – and not least the debacle arising from the East Coast Rail Link (ECRL) renegotiation in the aftermath of the 2018 general election – may yet see a reversal taking place.
In 2019, US FDI jumped to RM11.5 billion as compared to the year before at RM3.2 billion for last year (representing a 259% spike).
By comparison, inflows from China were valued at only RM4.4 billion, which was actually below the quarterly average in 2019.
Hence, despite our increasing reliance on China for FDI as one of the means for economic growth and development, we have not weaned or decoupled ourselves from American MNCs. And just like the US through its MNCs, China (both state-owned/parastatal and private entities) is a very important partner for tech transfer. Of course, de-coupling is neither necessary nor desirable, especially given the complex of inter-dependent supply chain linkages in globalisation.
To state another truism, even China & US continue to be dependent on one another despite the latter’s containment policy applied to the tech sector that parallels China’s “dual circulation” strategy (see e.g., “The coming tech Cold War with China: Beijing is already countering Washington’s policy” by Adam Segal, Foreign Affairs, Sep’ 9, 2020).
The “dual circulation” strategy is intended to only reduce China’s own dependence on MNCs for its exports and hence global supply chain linkages with the US over time in an effort to spur the localisation of technological applications and innovations; and not least to boost domestic consumption.
How far this is a viable longer-term strategy and outlook remains to be seen.
Meanwhile, we should also be coming up with a strategy of our own, i.e., in terms of localising tech know-how and accelerating and increasing localisation of tech transfer mainly to our small-and-medium sized enterprises (SMEs) to reduce reliance on MNCs as driver of exports.
This will also help to reduce our balance of payments (BOP) deficit when it comes to imports of capital goods (heavy machinery, industrial/manufacturing equipment) for the purpose of producing consumer goods for exports which contributes to outflow of the ringgit only to be exchanged for the USD or renminbi, for example.
In this, it’s right that we haven’t taken sides in the tech “cold war” between the China and US.
We need both (and in fact have benefitted from the reshoring and supply chain reconfiguration) and so far, there’s no indication whatsoever that Huawei’s presence in Malaysia – which is critical for our advancement into the 5G era – is not conducive to or inimical to our national security.
On the South China Sea (SCS), while we need to stand firm against China’s “expansionism” and promote a multilateral approach to countering the threat to our territorial sovereignty (and that of our Asean neighbours), including continuing military cooperation with the US in the form of e.g., joint-exercises – the annual “Bersama Warrior”, there’s no need to enter into any Nato (North Atlantic Treaty Organisation) type arrangement(s) that’s overly and formally belligerent in nature.
And we shouldn’t be so over-dependent on China, economically, in the hope that perhaps the country would be more compromising on the SCS issue.
In other words, there’s no need for us to engage in what international relations (IR) scholars label as “bandwagoning” (allying with the country that’s considered threatening) or “counter-balancing” (allying with other against the threatening country).
Perhaps, the term “frenemy”, although sounds unpalatable, would be a better policy.
Malaysia should treat both China and US with a certain “cageyness” albeit in different contexts and ways.
Whilst we can’t accept China’s nine-dash line as intrusion into our Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) as well as contravening basic norms of international law and the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (Unclos), Malaysia mustn’t become an unwitting pawn in the geopolitical and geostrategic agenda of another, rightfully or wrongfully. This might eventually drag us into outright conflict – turning the South China Sea flashpoint into the grim reality of war.
China would respect our stance on what is in our national interests (territorial integrity and national sovereignty) and, by extension, of Asean as whole.
What China can’t accept is what it deems to be foreign interference in its own backyard, namely from the US.
This means that any outright military confrontation with China with direct US participation would only be the last resort (like an “after-thought”) – where all other options have been exhausted in the face of the unlikelihood of all-out aggression.
At the end of the day, China still wants the SCS issue to be resolved bilaterally set against the benchmark and framework of the regional Code of Conduct for the South China Sea (COC) that’s still being negotiated.
On our part, a multilateral strategy that complements the bilateral approach should be adequate to ensuring that the SCS issue is resolved amicably and definitively.
In short, Malaysia are friends with both China and the US – except when our own national interests are at stake.
Jason Loh Seong Wei is Head of Social, Law & Human Rights at EMIR Research, an independent think tank focussed on strategic policy recommendations based on rigorous research.
** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
Jason Loh Seong Wei
Thu Apr 22 2021
De-coupling is neither necessary nor desirable, especially given the complex of inter-dependent supply chain linkages in globalisation. Unsplashpic
“Saya tak benarkan Diana buat bariatrik” - Farid Kamil
Farid lebih yakin hanya cara semula jadi lebih selamat untuk menurunkan berat badan.
Pemandu bas kilang ditahan, rempuh penunggang motosikal sehingga maut
Mangsa meninggal dunia di tempat kejadian selepas mengalami kecederaan parah di kepala.
Gagal capai sasaran, kerajaan tak boleh pandang ringan
Kegagalan Kerajaan untuk mencapai sasaran 30 juta pendaftar menjelang hujung bulan 3 ini harus dijadikan sebagai satu isyarat bahawa masih ada segelintir yang skeptikal tentang sistem Pangkalan Data Utama (PADU).
Kerajaan harus ambil cakna tentang keraguan orang ramai tentang sistem PADU sebagai satu mesej.
Menurut Presiden Persatuan Pengguna Siber Malaysia, Siraj Jali, masalah ini tercetus akibat kurangnya komunikasi yang cermat dan akhirnya,ia tercetus sebuah pemahaman yang bersegmen dan kompleks.
Kerajaan harus ambil cakna tentang keraguan orang ramai tentang sistem PADU sebagai satu mesej.
Menurut Presiden Persatuan Pengguna Siber Malaysia, Siraj Jali, masalah ini tercetus akibat kurangnya komunikasi yang cermat dan akhirnya,ia tercetus sebuah pemahaman yang bersegmen dan kompleks.
Arab Saudi dipilih pengerusikan Suruhanjaya Status Wanita (CSW) ke-69
Arab Saudi dipilih sebulat suara pada Rabu untuk mempengerusikan badan wanita Pertubuhan Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu, Suruhanjaya Status Wanita (CSW).
Tokoh Wartawan Negara 2014, meninggal dunia
2014, Datuk Ahmad Rejal Arbee meninggal dunia di kediamannya 2 pagi Jumaat
ICJ arah Israel ambil tindakan atasi kebuluran di Gaza
ICJ berkata, rakyat Palestin di Gaza menghadapi keadaan hidup yang teruk, kelaparan dan kebuluran semakin meruncing.
Penipuan kewangan: Pengasas FTX, Sam Bankman-Fried dipenjara 25 tahun
Pengasas FTX, Sam Bankman-Fried dijatuhi hukuman penjara 25 tahun kerana penipuan mata wang kripto yang disifatkan sebagai salah satu penipuan kewangan terbesar dalam sejarah Amerika Syarikat.
OIC perlu tubuh pasukan pengaman
OIC perlu menubuhkan pasukan pengaman bagi menangani isu-isu berbangkit seperti penindasan ke atas rakyat Palestin.
Kekejaman zionis: PM Mustafa bentuk kabinet baharu Palestin
Perdana Menteri Palestin, Mohammad Mustafa membentuk kabinet baharu di mana beliau juga akan berkhidmat sebagai Menteri Luar.
Kekejaman zionis: ICJ arah Israel ambil tindakan atasi kebuluran di Gaza
Mahkamah Keadilan Antarabangsa (ICJ) sebulat suara mengarahkan Israel untuk mengambil semua tindakan yang perlu dan berkesan untuk memastikan bekalan makanan asas tiba tanpa berlengah-lengah kepada penduduk Palestin di Gaza.
InvestKL raih FDI tertinggi RM8.7 bilion pada 2023, lonjakan 300 peratus
InvestKL berjaya menarik pelaburan langsung asing (FDI) tertinggi berjumlah RM8.7 bilion pada 2023 yang merupakan lonjakan sebanyak 300 peratus daripada RM2.79 bilion pada 2022.
Ringgit lemah: FDI, DDI masih tertumpu kepada industri buruh tidak mahir - Penganalisis
Mata wang Pelaburan Langsung Asing (FDI) dan Pelaburan Langsung Tempatan (DDI) yang direkodkan ketika ini masih tertumpu kepada industri buruh tidak mahir.
Ekonomi Malaysia dijangka kekal kukuh pada 2024
Ekonomi Malaysia dijangka berkembang antara 4.0 peratus dan 5.0 peratus pada 2024, mendapat rangsangan daripada perbelanjaan domestik dan pelaburan langsung asing (FDI).
Malaysia harus tangani isu struktur untuk bawa masuk FDI - Ahli ekonomi
Malaysia harus tangani isu-isu struktur terutamanya untuk menambah baik modal insan, sumbangan kepada produktiviti dan pekerjaan untuk membawa masuk FDI ke dalam negara.
Pertumbuhan ekonomi Malaysia lebih baik sebanyak 4.5 peratus tahun ini - HLB
Pertumbuhan itu dijangka didorong peningkatan FDI, pelancongan yang berkembang dan perbelanjaan infrastruktur yang lebih tinggi.
CPTPP bantu Malaysia raih FDI RM14.9 bilion pada suku ketiga 2023 -- Tengku Zafrul
Tengku Zafrul berkata FDI dari Jepun meningkat sebanyak RM4 bilion manakala dari Australia naik sebanyak RM1 bilion berbanding 2022.
Dua misi ke Jepun bawa pulang hampir RM30 bilion - Tengku Zafrul
Tengku Zafrul berkata kedua-dua misi ke negara matahari terbit itu telah memperoleh potensi pelaburan berjumlah RM29.6 bilion dan RM2.8 bilion potensi eksport tahun ini.
Ringgit dijangka catat prestasi lebih baik berbanding dolar AS pada 2024
Mata wang serantau termasuk ringgit dijangka mencatat prestasi yang lebih baik berbanding dolar AS pada tahun akan datang.
FDI dari Jepun dijangka cecah lebih AS$30 bilion tahun ini - Tengku Zafrul
MITI menjangkakan FDI dari Jepun melebihi AS$30 bilion tahun ini, didorong oleh sokongan berterusan daripada syarikat Jepun.
MITI optimistik 2024 tahun lebih positif bagi FDI ke dalam Malaysia
MITI optimistik 2024 akan menjadi tahun yang lebih positif bagi pelaburan langsung asing (FDI) ke dalam Malaysia, memanfaatkan perancangan yang telah dirangka.