KUALA LUMPUR: Lawyers and constitutional experts can go on debating all they want, and as much as they think this public back and forth in this political crisis is intellectually impressive, the truth is that these arguments are of no practical value to most people and businesses. It is an exclusive, high-level correspondence that appears deaf and blind to the voices and needs of the Rakyat.
One of the reasons for this is disconnectedness. Politicians typically get a glimpse of what’s happening on the ground through secondary data analysis by their own respective offices, news media outlets, research institutes and think tanks.
Even if these bodies strive their very best to stifle any biases and ensure polls/surveys are as representative of the population as possible, unfortunately most people may still dismiss these results because of the same reasons. Not to mention how information may get refined and “massaged” by the time it reaches the intended ears.
What Parliamentarians and politicians need is perhaps a way to know exactly what the sentiment is on the ground in a direct, reliable, frequent, unbiased and transparent way.
Perhaps it’s time to consider a “MyRakyat” application (app), used for Parliamentarians to engage the people directly, just like how MySejahtera app is used nationwide to connect directly with the people for Covid-19 healthcare related purposes.
Through this national MyRakyat app, mechanisms such as online opt-in nationwide polls or surveys could and should be done to obtain opinions and sentiments of the people.
Such a tool would be particularly useful in times of political crisis (as what is happening now). While politicians play politics at the top and political alignments remain elusive, occasional doses of unfiltered truth may just be the “booster vaccines” needed to bring them back down back to realities of the earthly realm.
MP allegiances are anybody’s guess, but nationwide polls can shed some light on key perceptions of the people on questions such as: Do most people really think Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim is the next Prime Minister? Do most people really want Prime Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin to step down? Do most people think that the pandemic management has failed and that it can be done better if there is a new government?
We already know what proponents on each side are going to say about those questions. Let’s see what the people have to say.
The prerequisite for the success of such a platform like MyRakyat is that people need to trust the system. It has to be discreet, immutable, and secure. This is for system’s experts to work on but generally we know how it should be.
National Digital ID (NDID) should be tied to MyRakyat account holders to ensure these are truly Malaysian nationals. It is said that the NDID is developed with privacy and security by design, and that one of NDID’s function could be used in e-Voting. Therefore, the secure integration for such use should be seamless.
The body managing the app and its infrastructure can be made fully independent with its own funding, and report to a special committee in Parliament, consisting of a balanced composition of the opposition and ruling coalition.
The servers have to be located in a secure and neutral place where data must be stored in tamper-free systems that exist outside of any particular ministries or agencies, accessible to Parliamentary oversight, as well as independent oversight bodies such as the Royal Commission of Inquiry. This is no different than how the Electoral Commission should operate.
Just like how the vast data related to Covid-19 management are released to the public, raw data and results from MyRakyat app such as polls, questionnaires and surveys can be released to the public. Research houses and think tanks can do their part to scrutinise, analyse, interpret, and get creative with data presentations.
It’s fine to debate as long as everyone is looking at the same reliable set of data. It is said that the truth is like a lion – it just needs to be let out and it will know how to defend itself. Clearly, those who are averse to such ideas have put the protection of personal interests as priority, making them indifferent to the cries of the Rakyat.
Should MyRakyat app be as widespread as MySejahtera app, it should solve the issue of sample randomness and representativeness. The system can segregate this according to location, age group, race, education level, income level, and many other dimensions for further analysis and refinements.
Such data is, of course, a snapshot of public sentiment. It is no way a determinant of a ruling coalition’s level of MP support, nor a prediction of general election outcomes. Experience with nationwide polls in the US is proof of this.
National polls can be useful in obtaining the general “feel” of the people, identifying pain points and elucidating Malaysia’s preferred political candidates. If anything, it becomes a guide for strategizing towards General Elections and the results may greatly differ than what poll results initially projected.
If results from a certain locality indicate a strong support for a particular party/coalition/candidate, it would be unwise for politicians to make a contrarian move to those results. Therefore, it may even prevent frogging.
It provides guidance on what issues are to be addressed, and therefore, guides the development of strategies for politicians and policy makers. Getting the voices of the people heard directly means a much more democratic, data-driven strategy and policy-making for all.
The app is not limited to political polling. We know how online platforms such as Change.org have been used to exert significant public pressure on decision-makers. Similarly, the app should allow for a certain “motion” to be participated by the people. These “motions” can be started by MPs.
Therefore, it can also cut down on physical protests. With enough votes by Parliamentarians, polls, surveys, and other forms of public-government engagements can be triggered through the MyRakyat app.
Without this, lawmakers are shielded from the “pulse from the ground”, which may fuel delusions and reinforce false-perceptions on what’s really happening. After all, even if the facts are inconvenient and may be against personal interests, company executives have to listen to their shareholders.
Ameen Kamal is the Head of Science & Technology at EMIR Research, an independent think tank focused on strategic policy recommendations based on rigorous research.
** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
Ameen Kamal
Tue Aug 03 2021
What Parliamentarians and politicians need is perhaps a way to know exactly what the sentiment is on the ground in a direct, reliable, frequent, unbiased and transparent way, says Ameen Kamal of EMIR Research. - Pic via REUTERS
16 kereta, tiga rumah rosak ditimpa pokok akibat hujan lebat di KL
Dalam semua kejadian berkenaan tiada mangsa dilaporkan cedera.
Tragedi Easter: 45 maut, bas terbabas, terbakar
Kesemua yang meninggal dunia itu dilaporkan dalam perjalanan menuju perhimpunan Easter.
Pengasas FTX, Sam Bankman-Fried dipenjara 25 tahun
Bankman dituduh mencuri AS$8 bilion daripada pelanggan dan pelabur syarikat pertukaran mata wang kripto FTX yang kini telah muflis.
Melaka sasar nilai pelaburan RM10 bilion, fokus 10 sektor
Kerajaan negeri berada di landasan terbaik dengan sasaran nilai pelaburan RM10 bilion, apabila meletakkan 10 sektor industri sebagai fokus utama pada tahun ini.
Sabah akan pelbagaikan sumber ekonomi - Ketua Menteri
Sabah tidak boleh hanya bergantung kepada dagangan sumber sedia ada terutama kelapa sawit, minyak dan gas dalam membangunkan ekonomi negeri.
Sarawak perkasa industri hiliran untuk hasilkan produk kayu bernilai tinggi
Kerajaan Sarawak akan terus memperkasakan industri hiliran seperti penghasilan biojisim bagi meningkatkan lagi pengeluaran produk kayu nilai tambah tinggi.
Duta, Pesuruhjaya Tinggi Malaysia perlu mahir pelaburan, perdagangan
Menteri Luar Datuk Seri Mohamad Hasan mahu perwakilan ke luar negara iaitu Duta Besar dan Pesuruhjaya Tinggi Malaysia mahir dalam aspek perdagangan bagi membawa masuk pelaburan ke dalam negara.
Malaysia kekal komited usaha reformasi ekonomi, terima inovasi dan pembangunan mampan
Malaysia kekal komited dalam usaha mereformasi ekonomi dan pada masa sama, bersedia menerima inovasi serta pembangunan mampan, kata TPM Fadillah.
PSM adakan mesyuarat pascanilai padang SNBJ awal minggu depan
Perbadanan Stadium Malaysia bakal mengadakan mesyuarat pascanilai (post-mortem) berkenaan isu padang SNBJ pada awal minggu hadapan.
Nyawa tiada nilai, maruah pula dibuat main oleh Israel
Sudahlah kejam, jijik, tidak beradap pula. Tidak cukup dengan kekejamannya membunuh berpuluh ribu rakyat Palestin, nyawa manusia di bumi Gaza itu bagaikan tiada nilai buat mereka. Dalam beberapa video yang tular baru-baru ini, tentera Israel dengan bangganya memperolok maruah rakyat Palestin dengan bermain pakaian dalam wanita yang ditemui di rumah-rumah penduduk di situ.
Malaysia sekali lagi tewas 0-2 kepada Oman
Malaysia gagal membalas kekalahan kepada Oman di Muscat pada Jumaat lepas setelah sekali lagi tewas 0-2 dalam saingan Kumpulan D Kelayakan Piala Asia 2026.
Malaysia, Korea Selatan sambung semula perjanjian perdagangan bebas - MITI
Malaysia dan Korea Selatan menyambung semula Perjanjian Perdagangan Bebas Malaysia-Korea (MKFTA) yang dijangka dapat meningkatkan perdagangan dan pelaburan dua hala antara kedua-dua negara.
Gencatan senjata di Gaza: Malaysia sambut baik resolusi Majlis Keselamatan PBB
Malaysia sambut baik resolusi Majlis Keselamatan PBB berhubung gencatan senjata serta-merta di Gaza, pada Isnin.
Malaysia-Oman: Pan Gon tuntut janji padang dalam keadaan terbaik
Ketua Jurulatih Harimau Malaya Kim Pan Gon menuntut janji yang diberikan bahawa kualiti padang akan berada dalam keadaan terbaik.
Malaysia kecam serangan keganasan di Rusia
Malaysia menyertai masyarakat antarabangsa mengecam sekeras-kerasnya serangan keganasan di Moscow, Rusia.
Kelayakan Piala Dunia: Jurulatih Oman nak tengok dulu keadaan padang
Oman tidak melatah di sebalik desas-desus mengenai keadaan padang di Stadium Nasional Bukit Jalil (SNBJ) bagi perlawanan Selasa ini.
Malaysia terima 348 penilaian susulan pembentangan UPR Keempat di Geneva
Malaysia menerima sebanyak 348 penilaian daripada 130 negara susulan pembentangan laporan negara dalam sesi Penilaian Berkala Sejagat (UPR) Keempat, Januari lepas.
Malaysia mungkin salur bantuan kemanusiaan di Gaza melalui "air drop"
Malaysia tidak menolak kemungkinan untuk menyalurkan bantuan kemanusiaan bagi penduduk di Gaza secara 'air drop' atau digugurkan melalui ruang udara.
Astro catat keuntungan RM44 juta pada suku keempat 2024
Astro berkata, meskipun dibelenggu keadaan makroekonomi tidak menentuia telah mencatatkan hasil dapatan sebanyak RM820 juta, suku ke suku.
Inisiatif kod QR: ICA Singapura ingatkan pengembara berkereta bawa pasport
ICA berkata pengembara juga memerlukan pasport mereka untuk pengesahan identiti di pusat pemeriksaan Malaysia.