KUALA LUMPUR: The High Court today ruled that the prosecution in the case of Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah, who is charged with money laundering, failed to prove that the RM9.5 million received by the lawyer from Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak was proceeds from unlawful activities.
Judge Datuk Muhammad Jamil Hussin, in his summary judgment, said that based on the testimony of the prosecution witnesses, there was no evidence of predicate action (illegal activity) involved and also where the money was obtained from.
"On the other hand, the testimony of the 8th prosecution witness (SP8), Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) investigating officer Mohd Farid Jabbar, confirmed during cross-examination that there was no illegal activity involved in the accused receiving the money through cheques and that the money was not proceeds from unlawful activities," said the judge.
He said since there was no predicate offence nor proceeds from unlawful activities involved, the (alleged) predicate offences could not be proven.
Following which, judge Muhammad Jamil acquitted Muhammad Shafee, 70, on charges of money laundering involving RM9.5 million allegedly received from the former prime minister and making false declarations to the Inland Revenue Board (IRB).
On the first and second charge made against Muhammad Shafee, namely for allegedly receiving proceeds from illegal activities amounting to RM9.5 million through two cheques from Najib, judge Muhammad Jamil said there was no evidence of unlawful act committed either by Najib or any other persons who could contaminate the money.
"In my opinion, the date at the time of receipt is important to determine that the money in question is from unlawful activities.
"The conduct of a predicate offence must be before or on the date of receipt of proceeds from unlawful activities as in the charge. The dates of receipt of proceeds from unlawful activities that were stated in the first and second charge were Sept 13, 2013, and Feb 17, 2014," he said.
However, he said, the prosecution failed to show that an act of predicate offence was committed before or on the date of receipt of the money.
In relation to the third and fourth charges, for engaging in transactions resulting from illegal activities by submitting incorrect tax returns to IRB, judge Muhammad Jamil said that both charges could not be proven because there were no transactions involving proceeds from illegal activities that took place on March 3, 2015 and June 29, 2015 as stated in the charge.
"The act by the accused is more of an offence under Section 112 and Section 113 of the Income Tax Act and not an offence of money laundering under the Anti-Money Laundering, Anti-Terrorism Financing and Proceeds of Unlawful Activities Act 2001," he said.
He said the court found that the prosecution failed to establish a prima facie case against the accused for all the charges made against him.
"From all the evidence adduced, it is not safe for me to call the accused to defend himself on the four charges. I am also not prepared to convict the accused if the defence is called and the accused chooses to remain silent.
"Therefore, the accused is acquitted and discharged of the four charges without being called to enter his defence. The RM1 million bail is to be returned to the surety and the passport to be returned to the accused," he added.
Meanwhile, deputy public prosecutor Afzainizam Abdul Aziz, when contacted after the proceeding, said the prosecution would get instructions from the Attorne -General on whether to appeal against today's decision.
Muhammad Shafee, when met by reporters, thanked his legal team, comprising lawyers Harvinderjit Singh, Farhan Read and Muhammad Farhan Muhammad Shafee.
He also hoped that the case would just end at the High Court today and not continue with the appeal stage.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Fri Oct 28 2022
The court found that the prosecution failed to establish a prima facie case against the accused for all the charges made against Shafee. - Astro AWANI/SHAHIR OMAR
UMNO aktifkan 'war room' bantu calon Kerajaan Perpaduan - Ahmad
Ahmad berkata UMNO juga akan melaksanakan kempen bagi membantu calon berkenaan dengan bersungguh-sungguh.
Pelepasan air terawat Fukushima digantung kerana terputus elektrik
Pelepasan air radioaktif terawat ke laut dari loji janakuasa nuklear Fukushima yang lumpuh digantung pada Rabu berikutan gangguan bekalan elektrik separa, kata pengendali loji itu.
Prabowo rasmi diisytihar Presiden Indonesia
Suruhanjaya Pilihan Raya Umum (KPU) secara rasmi akan mengisytiharkan Prabowo Subianto sebagai Presiden Indonesia dipilih, dalam satu majlis pada Rabu, seperti yang dijadualkan.
Jerman-UNRWA mungkin bekerjasama semula
Kerajaan Jerman merancang untuk menjalinkan kerjasama dengan agensi Pertubuhan Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu bagi pelarian Palestin (UNRWA). Ia susulan daripada kontroversi yang mendakwa anggota petugas UNRWA terlibat dalam serangan di Gaza yang berlaku pada 7 Oktober tahun lalu.
Ini panggilan daripada Allah SWT - Dr Sharifah Mazlina
Ketua Misi Ekspedisi Wanita Berkumpulan ke Antartika, Dr Sharifah Mazlina Syed Abdul Kadir yang merupakan salah seorang peserta dari Malaysia bagi misi Break The Siege of Gaza Freedom Flotilla menyifatkan penglibatannya dalam misi berkenaan sebagai satu panggilan yang ditentukan Allah.
Tujuh ditahan polis dalam serbuan 'keganasan' Australia
Polis Australia menahan tujuh individu yang menimbulkan risiko dan ancaman kepada orang ramai selepas melakukan serbuan antikeganasan membabitkan lebih 400 pegawainya, pada Rabu.
[TERKINI] UM diminta siasat, sedia laporan segera
Kementerian Pendidikan Tinggi (KPT) mengambil maklum dan memandang serius isu yang berlaku berhubung tindakan seorang penceramah warga asing mengeluarkan kenyataan yang dilihat mencetuskan kontroversi dan tidak menghormati sentimen masyarakat seperti tular di media sosial.
Astro AWANI dinobat adaptasi AI dalam pemberitaan terbaik di pentas Asia
Astro AWANI dinobat sebagai pemenang Anugerah Digital Media Awards 2024 bagi kategori adaptasi Teknologi Kecerdasan Buatan (AI) dalam pemberitaan terbaik di rantau Asia.
MITI optimis prestasi perdagangan lebih baik pada 2024
Tengku Zafrul menjelaskan, MITI juga memperbaharui fokusnya dengan berpaksikan kepada empat tunjang utama iaitu ekonomi, kelestarian, rakyat dan inovasi.
Pekebun durian musang king gagal dapat kebenaran semakan kehakiman
Mahkamah Tinggi tolak permohoan pekebun musang king untuk semakan kehakiman
Mahkamah Tinggi Kuantan menolak permohonan 186 pekebun durian musang king di sekitar Raub untuk mendapatkan kebenaran semakan kehakiman terhadap notis arahan pengosongan tanah dikeluarkan kerajaan negeri Pahang sebelum ini.
Mahkamah Tinggi Kuantan menolak permohonan 186 pekebun durian musang king di sekitar Raub untuk mendapatkan kebenaran semakan kehakiman terhadap notis arahan pengosongan tanah dikeluarkan kerajaan negeri Pahang sebelum ini.
1MDB: Muhammad Shafee ditegur hakim kerana bersikap 'keterlaluan'
Ketua peguam bela yang mewakili Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak ditegur apabila dilihat menyerang kredibiliti pengawai penyiasat Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) ketika perbicaraan.
Keputusan permohonan Najib mulakan semakan kehakiman cabar kewujudan Titah Adendum 5 Jun
Mahkamah Tinggi Kuala Lumpur menetapkan 5 Jun untuk memutuskan permohonan kebenaran semakan kehakiman difailkan Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak bagi mencabar kewujudan perintah tambahan beliau.
Ada seorang saksi penting dijangka sokong permohonan Najib untuk tahanan di rumah - Shafee
Seorang saksi penting dijangka memfailkan afidavit bagi menyokong permohonan kebenaran Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak untuk memulakan semakan kehakiman.
Shafee alami palpitasi, perbicaraan kes 1MDB Najib tangguh
Perbicaraan Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak berhubung kes penyelewengan RM2.3 bilion dana 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB) di Mahkamah Tinggi ditangguhkan hari ini.
Najib akan mohon pengampunan kali kedua - Shafee
Peguamnya Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah memaklumkan permohonan itu dibuat disebabkan anak guamnya tidak mendapat keadilan ketika perbicaraan dan proses Lembaga Pengampunan.
Tunggakan cukai: Muhammad Shafee perlu bayar RM5.5 juta kepada LHDN
Peguam Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah diperintahkan oleh Mahkamah Tinggi supaya membayar tunggakan cukai pendapatan lebih RM5.5 juta kepada Lembaga Hasil Dalam Negeri (LHDN).
LHDN peroleh penghakiman terus kes tunggakan cukai Muhammad Shafee
Mahkamah Tinggi membenarkan permohonan LHDN untuk memasukkan penghakiman terus terhadap peguam Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah berkaitan kes tunggakan cukai.
Pendakwaan tarik balik rayuan, keputusan lepas dan bebas Shafee kekal
Penarikan balik rayuan itu bermakna pembebasan Muhammad Shafee dalam keempat-empat kes itu kekal.
Tunggakan cukai pendapatan RM9.41 juta: Shafee, LHDN akan selesai kes
Muhammad Shafee dan LHDN memberitahu Mahkamah Tinggi bahawa, kes tuntutan tunggakan cukai pendapatan, berada dalam proses penyelesaian.
Najib tidak bekerjasama selepas didakwa - Pegawai penyiasat 1MDB
Datuk Seri Najib Razak dikatakan tidak memberi kerjasama ketika disoal siasat berhubung penyelewengan dana 1MDB.