KUALA LUMPUR: Certain quarters have been calling for the establishment of a National Operations Council (NOC) – on the basis that the government of the day has ostensibly “failed” in curbing the outbreak and transmission of Covid-19 with the surging cases and increased deaths.
They rest their argument on the historical precedent of 1969 when the nation was tragically embroiled in inter-ethnic clashes that resulted in bloodshed and mayhem. Upon the Proclamation of Emergency under Article 150 of the Federal Constitution, the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong proceeded to delegate and vest executive authority with a “Director of Operations” and who’s assisted by an NOC.
It’s argued that Article 40 of the Federal Constitution whereby the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong “shall act in accordance with the advice of the Cabinet or of a Minister acting under the general authority of the Cabinet …” doesn’t apply under the Emergency.
Historically speaking, proponents of NOC point to the so-called “fact” that the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong made the appointment without waiting for Parliament to convene – fresh from the general election.
They then deduce from this (temporal sequence) the logical conclusion that the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong, therefore, has ultimate authority and power during times of Emergency whilst recognising that this doesn’t apply under ordinary situations. Thus, proponents of NOC concede that Article 40 is to be read according to its natural and literal meaning but with the proviso that it’s only limited to ordinary (i.e., non-Emergency) situations.
What they failed to mention is that as a constitutional monarch, the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong has to act according to and within the ambit of the Federal Constitution as the supreme law of the land, as per Article 4.
To be sure, in agreement with proponents of NOC, being a constitutional monarch doesn’t mean that the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong is constitutionally constrained from exercising any real power at all.
This is where the logic of the proponents of NOC is somewhat “amorphous”, for lack of a better term.
It’s true the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong can “refuse” (on a limited basis) the advice of the Prime Minister under certain circumstances such as on the proclamation of an emergency and dissolution of Parliament to make way for a general election.
However, such exercise of power doesn’t automatically or by default entail that the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong would be able to unilaterally willed to establish a National Operations Council (NOC), albeit to be sure, under the Emergency.
Firstly, to repeat a truism.
The authority and right of the Yang Di-Pertuan to declare and proclaim an Emergency comes under Article 150 of the Federal Constitution.
For example, Article 150(2A) reads: “The power conferred on the Yang di-Pertuan Agong by this Article shall include the power to issue different Proclamations on different grounds or in different circumstances, whether or not there is a Proclamation or Proclamations already issued by the Yang di-Pertuan Agong under Clause (1) and such Proclamation or Proclamations are in operation”.
If the “higher” power of the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong to proclaim an Emergency is derived not “internally” (absolute) but “externally” (relative), i.e., from the Federal Constitution itself, how could the logic of a “lesser” power (i.e., under the Emergency) to establish or form a NOC – apart from the advice of the Prime Minister or the Executive – be understood to apply in absolute terms?
Secondly, Article 40(1) reinforces this position.
If we were to read further, we find that “In the exercise of his functions under this Constitution or federal law the Yang di-Pertuan Agong shall act in accordance with the advice of the Cabinet or of a Minister acting under the general authority of the Cabinet” extends to “except as otherwise provided by this Constitution”.
Again, the monarchical role of the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong is strictly defined and circumscribed by the Federal Constitution. According to this Article, no where does the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong has the capability to act unilaterally.
Coming back to the historical facts.
The establishment of the NOC came after the Proclamation of Emergency. This is something that both proponents and opponents of NOC can agree.
But there’s more than meets the eye.
That’s to say, the same people who advised the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong to proclaim the Emergency were, of course, the same people who advised him to establish the NOC with the then Deputy Prime Minister Tun Abdul Razak Hussein as the Director of Operations.
The logic of the facts can’t be just swept away.
In other words, there’s a continuity here which the proponents of NOC wilfully ignore. And which is that the establishment of the NOC sits on the same basis as the proclamation of the Emergency, namely the advice of the Prime Minister (backed by the Cabinet).
Therefore, how can the 1969 scenario be used as the basis to advocate for establishment of an NOC which decision is independent and apart from the advice of the Prime Minister?
The wording of the Ordinance No. 1 (1969) makes it clear: “An Ordinance promulgated by the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong under Article 150(2) of the Federal Constitution”. It means that:
1. One can’t simply divorce the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong’s powers during ordinary, i.e., non-Emergency times from his powers during extraordinary i.e., Emergency times. The Federal Constitution doesn’t provide for such a distinction – for otherwise the Article concerned wouldn’t have been inserted in the first place. And Ordinance No. 1 (1969) wouldn’t have contained the said wording.
2. All ordinances under Article 150(2C) are made by the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong in accordance with the Federal Constitution – and, therefore by extension, based on the advice of the Prime Minister.
It’s to be noted that even where an Ordinance or provision therein could be inconsistent with any provision of the Federal Constitution, Article 150(6) provides for derogation or exemption. In other words, here the Federal Constitution specifically or explicitly constrains itself – to allow for any inconsistencies by an Ordinance or provision therein.
This is merely to highlight that any exercise of power by the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong has to be in accordance with the Federal Constitution. And any exception thereof must of and in itself be subject to the same Federal Constitution.
Article 150 is completely silent on the unilateral power of the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong or specifically on his majesty’s power to form a government (other than the government of the day), e.g., in the form of an NOC.
In summary, the argument put forward by proponents of NOC that under the Emergency, the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong is automatically or by default the ultimate authority (and by implication, irrespective of the Federal Constitution) can’t be sustained or doesn’t carry constitutional weight.
This is because the Federal Constitution is the supreme law of the land.
The exercise of power by the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong is correlated to the Federal Constitution.
And, finally, the Federal Constitution doesn’t recognise a situation where the powers of the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong can be differentiated between ordinary and extraordinary situations.
Jason Loh Seong Wei is Head of Social, Law & Human Rights at EMIR Research, an independent think tank focussed on strategic policy recommendations based on rigorous research.
** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
Jason Loh Seong Wei
Fri Jun 11 2021
A police officer stands guard outside National Palace in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia June 10, 2021. REUTERSpic
Hati-hati akaun fleksibel, guna sewaktu persaraan - Pakar
Pencarum seharusnya lebih berhati-hati dan merancangan kewangan dengan lebih baik susulan pengenalan akuan fleksibel Kwsp yang baharu.
Panel lima hakim Mahkamah Rayuan akan dengar permohonan Muhyiddin
Muhyiddin memohon bagi mendapatkan kebenaran menyemak keputusan panel sebelum ini yang mengembalikan semula empat pertuduhan salah guna kuasa membabitkan RM232.5 juta terhadapnya.
Dua maut kereta terbabas dan terbalik di Kuala Krai
Seorang lelaki dan wanita maut dalam kemalangan membabitkan sebuah kereta jenis Honda di Jalan Gua Musang-Kuala Krai dekat Kampung Pahi, pada Rabu.
MCMC kesan individu salah guna AI, sunting gambar aib - Fahmi
Langkah itu bertujuan membolehkan tindakan tegas diambil serta memastikan keselamatan pengguna dalam talian khususnya kanak-kanak, terjamin.
[TERKINI] Mahkamah: Suspek tembak KLIA dituduh cuba bunuh isteri
Lelaki yang melepaskan tembakan di Balai Ketibaan Terminal 1 Lapangan Terbang Antarabangsa Kuala Lumpur (KLIA) didakwa lagi hari ini di Mahkamah Sesyen di sini atas dua pertuduhan termasuk cuba membunuh isterinya.
[TERKINI] Reman terhadap anak seorang MB disambung sehari lagi
Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) memperoleh tempoh lanjutan tahanan reman terhadap anak Menteri Besar dan empat lagi suspek bagi membantu siasatan pemalsuan dokumen dalam membuat tuntutan palsu berjumlah RM600,000.
AWANI Ringkas: Akaun 3 KWSP diumum
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Barcelona: Xavi buat pusingan-U
Khabar angin bertiup bahawa pengurus Barcelona, Xavi, akan meneruskan peranannya pada musim depan selepas mengubah fikirannya.
Bank Indonesia naikkan kadar faedah kepada 6.25 peratus, dijangka terakhir bagi 2024
Kenaikan kadar faedah utama Bank Indonesia kepada 6.25 peratus pada Rabu, berkemungkinan besar menjadi yang pertama dan terakhir untuk bank itu bagi 2024.
Ketegasan Malaysia sekat kapal Israel berlabuh wajar dicontohi
Tindakan kerajaan Malaysia melarang syarikat perkapalan yang berpangkalan di Israel iaitu ZIM daripada berlabuh di mana-mana pelabuhan di negara itu, wajar dijadikan contoh.
Agong berkenan meriahkan Majlis Sulaman Kasih Aidilfitri Kementerian Perpaduan
Yang di-Pertuan Agong Sultan Ibrahim hari ini berkenan memeriahkan Majlis Sulaman Kasih Aidifitri Kementerian Perpaduan Negara.
Nahas helikopter Lumut: Agong zahir ucapan takziah, titah ATM jalankan siasatan terperinci
Sultan Ibrahim menzahirkan rasa sedih dan merakamkan ucapan takziah kepada keluarga 10 mangsa nahas helikopter Tentera Laut Diraja Malaysia (TLDM) yang terhempas di Pangkalan TLDM, Lumut, pagi tadi.
Titah Adendum: Sokongan Ahmad Zahid kepada Najib tulus, sejati - Megat Zulkarnain
Sokongan yang dizahirkan Timbalan Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi terhadap petisyen Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak berhubung Titah Adendum YDP Agong mengenai tahanan rumah, tulus dan sejati.
KKR beri jaminan projek kolam selam tempur siap Jun ini
Kementerian Kerja Raya (KKR) akan memastikan projek pembinaan kolam selam tempur di Kem Iskandar, Mersing, Johor yang mengalami kelewatan, siap sepenuhnya pada Jun ini.
Kes Najib cabar kewujudan Titah Adendum, dijalankan secara dalam kamar
Muhammad Shafee memaklumkan kepada mahkamah, supaya prosiding kes Najib itu dijalankan secara dalam kamar memandangkan terdapat isu sensitif.
Agong, Permaisuri ucap selamat menyambut Vaisakhi, Tahun Baharu Tamil
Yang di-Pertuan Agong bertitah toleransi dan sikap hormat-menghormati antara satu sama lain menjadi tunjang perpaduan negara selama ini.
Agong harap lebih banyak syarikat China melabur di Malaysia
Pertemuan bersama Seri Paduka Baginda itu membincangkan hubungan dua hala antara Malaysia dan China serta isu-isu semasa berkaitan kedua-dua negara.
Agong, Raja Permaisuri berkenan berangkat ke Rumah Terbuka Aidilfitri Istana Johor
Yang di-Pertuan Agong Sultan Ibrahim dan Raja Permaisuri Agong Raja Zarith Sofiah, berkenan berangkat ke Majlis Rumah Terbuka Aidilfitri Istana Johor di Istana Besar, di sini hari ini.
Agong, Raja Permaisuri berangkat ke Majlis Ramah Mesra Aidilfitri
Sultan Ibrahim dan Raja Zarith Sofiah hari ini berkenan berangkat ke Majlis Ramah Mesra Hari Raya Aidilfitri bersama Perdana Menteri, Jemaah Menteri.
Agong, Raja Permaisuri berkenan tunai solat sunat Aidilfitri di Surau Utama Istana Negara
Sultan Ibrahim dan Raja Zarith Sofiah berkenan berangkat menunaikan solat sunat Aidilfitri di Surau Utama Istana Negara.