Calls to boycott United Airlines are growing as outrage over the company's violent "re-accommodation" of an elderly doctor enters its second day.
While the incident has tapped into a deep vein of customer frustration with the practices of United and other airlines, many passengers promising a boycott may find flying without United to be harder than they're expecting -- and in some areas, nearly impossible.
Thanks in part to a rash of airline mergers and consolidations in recent years, major airports are increasingly becoming one or two-carrier affairs. Today, United commands over 50 percent of the market share in some places where it served fewer than five percent of air travelers ten years ago.
United could be the cheapest option serving a major air route. Or, it could be the only option. And that makes a boycott complicated.
United tops 50 percent market share in Houston and Newark. At other major hubs, including Dulles, San Francisco, Denver and O'Hare, anywhere from 28 to 43 percent of passengers are flying United flights.
The airline's 2010 merger with Continental has allowed it to greatly increase its market share in certain regions. For instance, at Houston and Newark United's share of passenger traffic exploded from less than 5 percent in 2006 to over 50 percent last year. That's primarily due to United's takeover of Continental's business.
The Department of Justice recently put the kibosh on United's plans to expand even further at Newark. According to the DOJ's complaint, "the enhancement of United's dominant position would subject air-travel passengers at Newark - who already pay some of the highest fares in the nation - to higher fares and fewer choices."
Still, consolidation is a fact of life, meaning that many American airports are dominated by just one or two carriers. All this concentration means that boycotting an airline is a potentially expensive proposition, particularly if your home airport is one of that airline's major hubs.
If I wanted to boycott say, McDonald's, for instance, I could simply take my business to Burger King instead. The two products cost the same and, let's be honest, more or less taste the same too -- switching from one to the other does little to disrupt my pocketbook or my daily routine.
But competing airline flights between the same airports can differ radically in terms of price --and not much else. Aggregators like Google and Expedia have made the ticket price the primary factor distinguishing between competing airline services. At the price points most consumers are willing to pay, the flight experience is essentially identical across the major air carriers: cramped quarters, headaches and delays, a litany of TSA indignities before you board.
If I want to fly nonstop between Dulles and San Francisco (two United hubs), for instance, my options this weekend include a United flight for $632, and a Virgin America flight that costs $115 more. Virgin may offer better service -- but is it $115 better?
I could be outraged enough by recent United controversies that I'll spring for the pricier Virgin America flight. But in all likelihood I'll opt for the cheaper United flight, pocket the extra hundred bucks and hope for the best.
For an airline boycott to work, in other words, customers would have to be really mad -- mad enough to actually make a financial sacrifice. Judging by the ongoing reaction to the latest United incident, they very well might be.
WHERE IT"S HARDEST TO BOYCOTT UNITED
Here are the major airports where United accounts for more than 10 percent of total passenger traffic:
Houston--51.54 percent
Newark--50.49 percent
Washington Dulles--43.25 percent
San Francisco--37.96 percent
Chicago O'Hare--30.87 percent
Denver---28.72 percent
Los Angeles--14.88 percent
Boston--12.28 percent
San Diego--11.95 percent
Orlando--10.26 percent
Portland--10.15 percent
Source: Department of Transportation
The Washington Post
Wed Apr 12 2017
United could be the cheapest option serving a major air route.
Thailand: Enam muka baharu sertai Kabinet Srettha
Perdana Menteri Thailand Srettha Thavisin melantik enam menteri kabinet baharu.
Anwar bertemu PM Jordan, tekan kepentingan sokong pengiktirafan negara Palestin di PBB
Pada pertemuan itu, Perdana Menteri turut menekankan kepentingan memastikan Israel dipertanggungjawabkan terhadap kekejamannya di Palestin.
Lebih ramai atlet dijangka layak ke Paris 2024
Kontinjen Malaysia ke Sukan Olimpik Paris 2024 terus diperkuat dengan empat lagi atlet berjaya mengesahkan slot ke temasya terbesar dunia itu minggu ini, menjadikan sejumlah 10 atlet layak setakat ini
AWANI Ringkas: Polis sahkan Chegu Bard direman dua hari
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Pegawai kastam maut dalam kemalangan babit tiga kenderaan
Seorang pegawai kastam maut dalam kemalangan membabitkan tiga kenderaan di Kilometer 18.2 Lebuh Raya Utara Selatan arah Utara, semalam.
AWANI 7:45 [28/04/2024] – Malaysia tumpu pelaburan baharu | Pertumbuhan saksama dan inklusif | Kajian pertubuhan buruh antarabangsa | Tabung Haji teruskan bantuan
Laporan berita padat dan ringkas #AWANI745 bersama Dzulfitri Yusof
Tumpuan #AWANI745 malam ini:
- Malaysia hadapi cabaran baharu dari negara maju, bidang teknologi, tegas PM
- Ekonomi dunia kian tidak seimbang, Tengku Zafrul di pentas forum desak negara maju lebih adil dan saksama
- 70 peratus pekerja dunia terdedah kepada penyakit akibat perubahan iklim
- Tabung Haji tanggung kos lebih RM350 juta tahun ini
Tumpuan #AWANI745 malam ini:
- Malaysia hadapi cabaran baharu dari negara maju, bidang teknologi, tegas PM
- Ekonomi dunia kian tidak seimbang, Tengku Zafrul di pentas forum desak negara maju lebih adil dan saksama
- 70 peratus pekerja dunia terdedah kepada penyakit akibat perubahan iklim
- Tabung Haji tanggung kos lebih RM350 juta tahun ini
Liek Hou rangkul dua lagi emas di Sepanyol
Jaguh badminton para negara Cheah Liek Hou terus cemerlang apabila menggondol dua pingat emas pada Kejohanan Badminton Para Sepanyol Antarabangsa II 2024 pada Sabtu.
Negara maju harus tundukkan 'ego' dan bekerjasama dengan ASEAN - Penganalisis
Menurut Faisal, ini kerana negara membangun di ASEAN sedang mencorak ekonomi ke arah lebih mampan yang perlu dimanfaatkan negara maju
Rakyat Malaysia di Jordan jadi duta produk PMKS negara - Ewon
Datuk Ewon Benedick menyarankan rakyat Malaysia yang menetap di Jordan supaya memainkan peranan sebagai "duta" untuk mempromosikan produk PMKS dan koperasi negara.
Fokus Minggu Depan: Solidariti Gaza Merentasi Bangsa dan Agama
Break The Siege: Fokus Minggu Depan membincangkan topik Solidariti Gaza Merentasi Bangsa dan Agama susulan penangguhan misi penghantaran bantuan ke Gaza anjuran Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC).