A U.S. federal appeals court on Thursday unanimously upheld a temporary suspension of President Donald Trump's order that restricted travel from seven Muslim-majority countries.
The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruling came in a challenge to Trump's order filed by the states of Washington and Minnesota. The U.S. Supreme Court will likely determine the case's final outcome.
The White House said it had no immediate comment.
Trump's Jan. 27 executive order barred entry for citizens from Iran, Iraq, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, Syria and Yemen for 90 days and imposed a 120-day halt on all refugees, except refugees from Syria who are barred indefinitely.
U.S. District Judge James Robart suspended Trump's order last Friday.
The ruling from the 9th Circuit, which follows a hearing on the case on Tuesday, does not resolve the lawsuit, but relates instead to whether Trump's order should be suspended while litigation proceeds.
Two members of three-judge panel that ruled were appointed by former Democratic Presidents Jimmy Carter and Barack Obama, and one was appointed by former President George W. Bush.
Either side could decide to appeal directly to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Trump had said the order was vital for national safety and criticized Robart, the Seattle judge, for suspending it.
Critics have called Trump's ban discriminatory against Muslims and have questioned its value as a security measure. National security veterans, major U.S. technology companies and law enforcement officials from more than a dozen states backed a legal effort against the ban.
Ultimately the courts will have to address questions about the extent of the president's power on matters of immigration and national security. Traditionally, judges have been extremely cautious about stepping on the executive branch’s authority in such matters, legal experts say, though some note that the implementation of this order presents unique issues.
INTENSE SCRUTINY
The appeals court panel subjected Trump's order to intense scrutiny during Tuesday's oral argument.
During the oral argument, the judges asked a government lawyer whether the Trump administration's national security argument was backed by evidence that people from the seven countries posed a danger.
Judge Richard Clifton posed equally tough questions for an attorney representing Minnesota and Washington. Clifton asked if Robart's suspension of Trump's policy was "overbroad." Clifton is an appointee of former President George W. Bush, a Republican like Trump.
August Flentje, representing the Trump administration as special counsel for the U.S. Justice Department, told the panel on Tuesday that "Congress has expressly authorized the president to suspend entry of categories of aliens" for national security reasons.
"That’s what the president did here," he said.
When the 9th Circuit asked Flentje what evidence the executive order had used to connect the seven countries affected by the order with terrorism in the United States, Flentje said the "proceedings have been moving very fast," without giving specific examples.
He said both Congress and the previous administration of Democrat Barack Obama had determined that those seven countries posed the greatest risk of terrorism and had in the past put stricter visa requirements on them.
Noah Purcell, solicitor general for the state of Washington, began his argument urging the court to serve "as a check on executive abuses."
Curbing entry to the United States as a national security measure was a central premise of Trump's 2016 presidential campaign, originally proposed as a temporary ban on all Muslims. He has voiced frustration at the legal challenge to his order.
"I actually can't believe that we're having to fight to protect the security, in a court system, to protect the security of our nation," he said at an event with sheriffs on Tuesday.
U.S. presidents have in the past claimed sweeping powers to fight terrorism, but individuals, states and civil rights groups challenging the ban said his administration had offered no evidence it answered a threat.
Reuters
Thu Feb 09 2017
U.S. President Donald Trump delivers remarks at the National Prayer Breakfast in Washington, U.S., February 2, 2017. REUTERS / File
Berita tempatan pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Berikut adalah berita yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang Ahad, 28 April 2024.
Mesyuarat Khas WEF: Dunia perlukan persaingan sihat dalam transisi ke Orde Baharu - Menteri Luar Arab Saudi
Menteri Luar Negeri Arab Saudi, Putera Faisal bin Farhan Al Saud berkata dunia memerlukan persaingan sihat dalam transisi daripada Orde Dunia Lama kepada Orde Baharu. Jelasnya, persaingan ini akan memberi manfaat dalam bentuk kos pengeluaran lebih rendah, perkembangan inovasi dan pelaburan lebih baik. #MesyuaratKhasWEF #WEF
Mesyuarat Khas WEF: Dunia saling tidak percaya akibat kebergantungan dipersenjatakan - Naib Presiden Suruhanjaya Eropah
Naib Presiden Suruhanjaya Eropah, Josep Borrell Fontelles berkata fenomena hilang kepercayaan yang melanda komuniti antarabangsa ketika ini adalah akibat kebergantungan yang dipersenjatakan oleh beberapa pihak. Jelasnya, situasi ini boleh membawa kepada pengasingan negara-negara tertentu dari pentas global, seterusnya menghambat pelaksanaan agenda antarabangsa. #MesyuaratKhasWEF #WEF
Mesyuarat Khas WEF: Negara-negara selatan global hilang percaya akibat ‘leteran’ negara maju - Menteri Luar Sri Lanka
Menteri Luar Negeri Sri Lanka, Mohamed Uvais Mohamed Ali Sabry berkata negara-negara selatan global hilang percaya kepada inisiatif antarabangsa akibat campur tangan berlebihan dalam proses membuat keputusan di peringkat domestik oleh negara-negara utara global. Jelasnya, negara-negara maju perlu berhenti memaksakan penyelesaian kepada semua masalah yang timbul keatas negara-negara membangun. #MesyuaratKhasWEF #WEF
Mesyuarat Khas WEF: Hubungan China-AS kelam - Pakar
Pengasas dan Pengerusi Wusawa Advisory Inc., Qian Liu berkata hubungan China dan Amerika Syarikat tidak akan bertambah baik untuk tahun-tahun mendatang. Jelasnya, kedua-dua negara menggunakan momokkan imej negara pesaing dalam usaha menangani isu-isu domestik, yang secara tidak langsung merugikan dunia. #MesyuaratKhasWEF #WEF
Mesyuarat Khas WEF: China akan atasi AS, sedang belajar menggunakan kuasanya keatas dunia - Pakar
Pengasas dan Pengerusi Wusawa Advisory Inc., Qian Liu berkata China dilandasan yang betul untuk mengatasi Amerika Syarikat sebagai ekonomi terbesar dunia dalam masa beberapa tahun. Jelasnya, meskipun pertumbuhan ekonomi China perlahan, namun saiz pertumbuhan itu secara relatifnya lebih besar daripada keseluruhan ekonomi Arab Saudi dan Switzerland. #MesyuaratKhasWEF #WEF
Bangladesh buka semula sekolah walaupun cuaca masih panas
Pelajar kembali ke sekolah di seluruh Bangladesh walaupun negara itu dilanda gelombang panas berlarutan yang mendorong pembelajaran secara bersemuka ditangguhkan, hujung minggu lalu.
Filipina tangguh kelas secara bersemuka kerana cuaca panas
Filipina menangguhkan kelas bersemuka di semua sekolah kerajaan selama dua hari, susulan cuaca panas melampau dan mogok oleh pemandu jeepney atau bas mini di seluruh negara.
Puting beliung landa bandar Guangzhou
Puting beliung melanda bandar Guangzhou di selatan China dan mengorbankan lima nyawa dan 33 lagi cedera.
Menurut laporan CCTV, puting beliuang itu melanda daerah Baiyun di Guangzhou pada petang Sabtu.
Menurut laporan CCTV, puting beliuang itu melanda daerah Baiyun di Guangzhou pada petang Sabtu.
Tak dapat jadi TPM, Menteri Luar Thailand letak jawatan
Menteri Luar Thailand, Parnpree Bahiddha-Nukara meletak jawatan secara mengejut hari ini, selepas tidak dinamakan sebagai timbalan perdana menteri dalam rombakan Kabinet.