The 2016 Chinese New Year (CNY) advertisement by Petronas titled ‘Rubber Boy’ have touched the hearts of its viewers as it explores the story of a mother and son going through life’s hardships.
However, a filmmaker is now claiming that her idea was plagiarised by advertising agency Leo Burnett Malaysia, which produced the advertisement.
This was revealed by Da Huang Pictures filmmaker Tan Chui Mui, in a series of statements uploaded on Facebook.
She said the idea was based on the experience of a childhood friend, whose mother was a rubber tapper.
READ: 'Rubber Boy is my family's story', says Leo Burnett creative director
“My team from Da Huang Pictures had proposed a story to the agency, with casting, locations, reference films, and also a full script. The proposal was for the Petronas CNY advertisement in year 2015.
“That year, our story was not selected, and there were also no Petronas CNY advertisement in 2015.
“However, Leo Burnett went ahead and used our story for the Petronas CNY in 2016, which is really shocking. This is more than just stealing story,” she said, when contacted by Astro AWANI to elaborate on the situation.
She then explained that her scriptwriter John Cho We Jun and producer Beatrice Leong had a meeting with Leo Burnett in February.
“I was not present at that meeting as I was pregnant. There were no real talk, except they were told that we can't sue them under Malaysian Law.
“I was not too interested in legal action, unless it is for the better change of the creative industry,” she said.
She also mentioned about the tough pitching session in order to produce a story idea for presentation.
“Often we were taken for granted. We are supposed to work for free during the pitching stage,” she said.
Seeking recognition for original idea
Scriptwriter John Cho We Jun expressed his dissatisfaction at Leo Burnett for not recognising that the original idea for ‘Rubber Boy’ was from Chui Mui.
“The original story was entitled ‘Growing Up’, if I am not mistaken. We had a man in the present day reminiscing about his relationship with his mother, the rubber tapper.
“And though parts of it had been modified, and even if its theme has shifted slightly, it is predominantly the same film.
“I think it is only fair to seek recognition for our work,” he told Astro AWANI.
Leo Burnett’s response
Meanwhile, Leo Burnett Group Malaysia Chief Executive Officer Tan Kien Eng replied to Chui Mui’s Facebook status.
He said he would like to meet Chui Mui to understand the situation before any actions are taken.
“I don't endorse plagiarism. I contacted the team immediately after someone alerted me on your post and the writer from LB (Leo Burnett) has his side of the story.
“I would like to meet both of you at your convenience for me to fully understand both sides for me to take action,” he said on Facebook.
Syafique Shuib
Sat Jun 25 2016
Filmmaker Tan Chui Mui says the idea behind 'Rubber Boy' was from the experience of a childhood friend. -Photo: YouTube/Rubber Boy
PRK KKB: Bukan kali pertama BN berkempen untuk calon wakili Kerajaan Perpaduan - Zambry
BN dan PH pernah bersama dalam beberapa siri PRK sebelum ini termasuk Parlimen Pulai dan DUN Simpang Jeram di Johor dan terbaharu di DUN Kuala Kubu Baharu.
Kerajaan juga perlu tangani jurang pencen veteran tentera - RAFOC
Kenaikan gaji kakitangan awam adalah langkah positif, tetapi penting juga bagi kerajaan untuk menangani jurang pencen yang dihadapi veteran.
Kumpulan kedua petugas haji, 14 pengamal media berlepas ke Arab Saudi hari ini
Dua editor Astro AWANI, Azlinariah Abdullah dan Azlinda Md Salim antara pengamal media yang akan mengadakan liputan haji tahun ini.
Keterangkuman kewangan lonjakkan ekonomi digital, tanpa tunai
Pengarah Eksekutif Kiple, Norhizam Abdul Kadir dalam perbincangan dalam usaha menggalakkan pembangunan ekonomi, pengurangan kemiskinan, dan kesaksamaan sosial dengan menyediakan peluang kepada orang ramai untuk membina aset, menguruskan risiko, dan meningkatkan kesejahteraan kewangan, tanpa mengira tahap pendapatan, lokasi, jantina, umur, atau ciri-ciri lain.
Borussia Dortmund buat PSG terkedu
Penyerang itu mengawal bola dengan sempurna sebelum melakukan rembatan rendah melepasi penjaga gol Gianluigi Donnarumma pada minit ke-36.
AWANI Pagi: Perkhidmatan Awam: Gaji naik, produktiviti meningkat?
Susulan pengumuman Perdana Menteri atas kenaikan gaji penjawat awam.
Ramai yang tertanya-tanya adakah ini menjadi satu motivasi kepada produktiviti perkhidmatan yang semakin bertambah baik.
Ikuti diskusi AWANI Pagi bagi membincangkan topik ini.
Ramai yang tertanya-tanya adakah ini menjadi satu motivasi kepada produktiviti perkhidmatan yang semakin bertambah baik.
Ikuti diskusi AWANI Pagi bagi membincangkan topik ini.
Penjawat Awam: Gaji naik, pacu perkhidmatan berkualiti kepada rakyat
Pelarasan gaji penjawat awam itu akan membabitkan peruntukan mencecah lebih RM10 bilion berikutan jumlah kenaikan yang besar dan terbaik dalam sejarah negara. Bagaimana untuk memastikan kenaikan gaji penjawat awam memberi manfaat yang seimbang kepada pengurusan, penyampaian perkhidmatan kerajaan serta ekonomi negara?
ADUN Sungai Bakap stabil, masih di ICU
'YB Abang Zam' masih memerlukan rawatan dan rehat yang cukup serta tidak dibenarkan menerima pelawat buat masa ini.
AWANI Ringkas: Papagomo didakwa hari ini
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
EPL: Bruno Fernandes beri bayangan tinggalkan Manchester United
"Jika saya perlu berfikir untuk tidak terus berada di EPL maka ia tidak akan berlaku sehingga selepas saingan EURO nanti."