Rolling Stone has reached a confidential settlement with Nicole Eramo, a former University of Virginia associate dean who had sued the magazine alleging that it defamed her in a 2014 story about an alleged gang rape on campus, according to lawyers for both parties.
The settlement brings an end to a lawsuit that had roiled the U-Va. community with a case study in the practice and ethics of journalism.
"We are delighted that this dispute is now behind us, as it allows Nicole to move on and focus on doing what she does best, which is supporting victims of sexual assault," said Libby Locke, a lawyer for Eramo, in a statement Tuesday.
Rolling Stone called the settlement an "amicable resolution."
The magazine's November 2014 story, "A Rape on Campus," recounted the shocking story of a young woman's gang rape at a U-Va. fraternity house - a story that was discredited after serious flaws were revealed.
An investigation by The Washington Post showed that aspects of the account were not true. For example, no one in Phi Kappa Psi, the fraternity in question, matched the name or description that the young woman - known as Jackie - gave for the person who allegedly was the ringleader in her 2012 assault.
A person whom Jackie had described to friends at the time as her assailant was complete fiction, according to Eramo's attorneys, and The Post found that a photo she shared of her alleged attacker was actually of someone she knew from high school, who attended a different university out of state.
The magazine soon acknowledged that it had lost faith in its main source for the story and - after a police investigation and a report by the Columbia University School of Journalism found that aspects of the account were false - ultimately retracted the article.
In a trial that began in October 2016, Eramo's lawyers argued that the article's author, Sabrina Rubin Erdely, had arrived on campus determined to write a story about a university's callousness to the problem of sexual assault. She did not let facts get in the way of the story, they argued, and she wrongly turned Eramo into the face of institutional indifference.
Eramo testified that she faced threats, lost professional credibility and lost her ability to work as an advocate for sexual-assault prevention.
Tom Clare, one of the attorneys representing Eramo, said during his closing statement that his client had become "collateral damage in a quest for sensational journalism."
Jackie's tale "had all the elements of a perfect story," Clare said. "And when something appears too perfect, it usually is."
Scott Sexton, an attorney for Rolling Stone, told the jurors in his closing statement that the magazine "acknowledges huge errors in not being more dogged. . . . It's the worst thing to ever happen to Rolling Stone."
The article cost Erdely her job at the magazine and her reputation as a journalist, Sexton said. In court documents, Erdely said she was "shattered" to discover that she had repeated falsehoods in her story.
"This experience has been devastating to me, both professionally and personally. Never in my 20-plus years as a reporter have I had a story or a source fall apart on me after publication. After feeling so sure about the Article, and believing so strongly that it would help spur change on college campuses, losing faith in the credibility of one of my major sources post-publication took me entirely by surprise. I was stunned and shaken by the experience, and remain so to this day."
In November, a federal jury sided with Eramo, awarding her $3 million in damages - $1 million from Rolling Stone and $2 million from Erdely.
Rolling Stone filed a motion to vacate that judgment, the first step toward an appeal, but then agreed to settle the case before a judge could rule.
The Washington Post
Wed Apr 12 2017
Rolling Stone called the settlement an "amicable resolution."
UAE hantar 100 tan bantuan kemanusiaan ke Brazil
Emiriah Arab Bersatu (UAE) pada Sabtu telah menghantar pesawat bantuan pertama yang membawa 100 tan makanan, perubatan dan bantuan kemanusiaan untuk membantu mangsa banjir dan hujan lebat yang melanda Brazil baru-baru ini.
Sekurang-kurangnya 400 maut susulan hujan lebat, banjir di Afghanistan
Hujan lebat dan banjir di Afghanistan telah menyebabkan sekurang-kurangnya 400 kematian.
Gunung Ibu meletus, tujuh kampung dipindahkan
Letusan gunung berapi di pulau terpencil Indonesia, Halmahera semalam yang memuntahkan awan abu kelabu ke langit memaksa penduduk tujuh kampung dipindahkan.
[TERKINI] Lelaki ceroboh, serang anggota di Balai Polis Dato' Keramat ditahan
Polis menahan seorang lelaki yang dipercayai menyerang anggota polis di Balai Polis Dato' Keramat, George Town pada Ahad.
Serang balai polis: Henti kaitkan dengan kumpulan ekstremis, JI
Semua pihak perlu berhenti menyebar spekulasi liar mengaitkan insiden serangan di Balai Polis Ulu Tiram di sini dengan kumpulan ekstremis termasuk Jemaah Islamiyah (JI).
Beri lebih peruntukan kepada Selangor
Sany meminta agar kerajaan persekutuan memberikan lebih peruntukan kepada negeri Selangor, khususnya daerah-daerah yang sedang pesat membangun.
Percepat proses, kerja naik taraf jalan persekutuan
Kerja naik taraf yang sedang berjalan di Jalan Persekutuan dari Persimpangan Jalan Dato’ Alias ke Persimpangan Batu 9, Cheras perlu mempunyai kesinambungan bagi memastikan keselesaan berterusan dan mengurangkan kesesakan trafik khususnya pada waktu puncak.
Kerjasama Malaysia-Uzbekistan tawar potensi amat besar
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim berkata, Malaysia, sejak satu setengah tahun lepas dilihat sebagai hab semikonduktor mikrocip di rantau Asia Tenggara menerusi banyak pelaburan daripada syarikat asing utama.
[TERKINI] Anggota MALBATT 850-11 meninggal dunia di Lubnan
Seorang Pegawai Tidak Tauliah Kanan (PTTK) dari Malaysian Battalion 850-11 (MALBATT 850-11) bagi Misi United Nations Interim Force In Lebanon (UNIFIL), Sarjan Faridah Abd Rahman telah disahkan meninggal dunia di Lubnan pada 18 Mei 2024 (Sabtu) jam 2.25 pagi waktu Lubnan atau jam 7.25 pagi
waktu Malaysia.
waktu Malaysia.
Johor tidak sepatutnya dibelenggu miskin tegar - Onn Hafiz
Kerajaan Johor menegaskan negeri ini sepatutnya tidak mempunyai rakyat yang dibelenggu kemiskinan tegar.
Remaja 16 tahun dirogol bergilir-gilir 30 lelaki di bilik hotel
Menurut polis tempatan, mangsa yang pada ketika itu berada dalam keadaan mabuk kemudiannya ke Hotel Red Sea di mana dia ingin menggunakan bilik air.