CONNECTED devices designed to monitor and therefore improve one's sleep are becoming increasingly popular around the world, but do they really bring benefits to the user? A team of American researchers has looked into the subject, revealing that trackers marketed on a large scale are far from equal in terms of efficiency.
While it's easy to know whether one has had a good night's sleep or a night full of waking, it is more complicated to accurately evaluate the time spent sleeping, or even in the waking-up process, and even more complicated to analyze with certainty how restful this sleep has been. For a few years now, small connected personal devices have been available to carry out this task while you let yourself be lulled to dreamland. But few independent studies have so far evaluated the effectiveness of these trackers, which are more and more numerous on the market.
Neuroscientists from West Virginia University have been working on the subject - Apple Watch, Fitbit, Oura. In total, the researchers evaluated eight commercial sleep trackers. They observed five healthy adults -- two men aged 26 and 41 and three women aged 22, 23, and 27 -- who wore these trackers for 98 nights.
At the conclusion of the study, published in Nature and Science of Sleep, the verdict was in: Fitbit and Oura obtained the best results, in terms of measuring total sleep time, total wake time, and sleep efficiency. All other connected devices either overestimated or underestimated at least one of the sleep measures studied. The researchers note that none of the eight were able to quantify the different sleep stages with effective accuracy.
However, the neuroscientists remain very cautious about these results; each device may be appropriate for the needs of a particular individual. "The biggest takeaway is that not all consumer devices are created equal, and for the end user to take care in selecting the technology to suit their application based on the data. Some devices are currently performing well for total sleep time and sleep efficiency, but the community at large seems to still struggle with sleep staging (deep, REM, light). This is not surprising, since typically brain waves are needed to properly measure this," explains Joshua Hagen, who led the research.
The researchers seem convinced of the importance of such data, despite these results, as they allow an objectivity that one's own feelings will never provide. The main author explains, for example, that you can wake up groggy if you wake up in a deep sleep phase, which could lead you to think that your sleep has not been restorative.
The onus is now on users to find the device that will be the most accurate according to their own needs, and then turn to a product whose design, price, approach and user-friendliness will suit what they are looking for when it comes to optimal daily use.
ETX Studio
Sun Feb 21 2021
Does your sleep tracker accurately provide you with all the information you need? ETXStudiopic
Bintang 'Spider-Man' Tom Holland zahir hasrat kahwini aktres Zendaya
Bintang Spider-Man itu dikatakan sudah berbincang dengan Zendaya untuk berkahwin.
Raja Charles III kembali jalani tugas awam selepas rawatan kanser
Raja Britain, Raja Charles III kembali menjalankan tugas awam selepas kesan positif rawatan kansernya.
LHDN pergiat ‘buru’ syarikat, individu culas bayar cukai
Ujar beliau, LHDN sentiasa memantau data-data sedia ada untuk tindakan sewajarnya.
Program Jelajah Siswa antara pengisian Hawana 2024
Sambutan Hari Wartawan Nasional (Hawana) 2024 pada Mei ini buat julung kalinya akan menyaksikan penglibatan pelajar jurusan komunikasi menerusi Program Jelajah Siswa.
[KEMAS KINI] SPRM ambil keterangan, MB Perlis tegaskan tidak direman
Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) mengesahkan mengambil keterangan Maenteri Besar Perlis kira-kira jam 10 pagi tadi.
Bekas isteri Safee Sali fail tuntutan balas nusyuz
Sebutan semula kes bagi menjawab tuntutan itu oleh plantif ditetapkan pada 11 Jun depan.
Polis selamat mangsa pemerdagangan orang dipaksa bekerja di kelab malam
Polis berjaya menyelamatkan empat wanita warga Filipina yang dipercayai menjadi mangsa pemerdagangan orang.
Pengasas maahad tahfiz didakwa di mahkamah kes liwat pelajar
Tertuduh didakwa meliwat tiga pelajar berusia antara 12 hingga 15 tahun manakala dua daripada mereka merupakan mangsa yang sama.
Pelajar UCLA dakwa universiti lepas tangan
Sebagai pelajar di antara puluhan kampus yang membantah serangan di Gaza, Isabelle Friedman yang memimpin akhbar bebas pelajar UCLA berbicara mengenai cabaran kehidupan harian pelajar dan memberikan liputan berita yang seimbang ketika protes terus meningkat.
Beg sandang dicuri dalam tandas, wanita sarat mengandung trauma kejar peragut
Suspek lelaki berusia 22 tahun yang mempunyai empat rekod lampau berkaitan jenayah dan dadah itu direman selama tiga hari bermula 30 April hingga 2 Mei 2024.