Uber drivers are entitled to class action status in litigation over whether they are independent contractors or employees, a key development in a case threatening Uber's business model and that of other hot startups dependent on similar service workers.
Three drivers sued Uber in a federal court in San Francisco, contending they are employees and entitled to reimbursement for expenses, including gas and vehicle maintenance. The drivers currently pay those costs themselves.
The results of Uber's legal battle could reshape the sharing economy, which is built around Internet companies that serve as marketplaces matching people who provide a service with others looking to pay for it.
In the ruling on Tuesday, U.S. District Judge Edward Chen in San Francisco said California drivers could sue as a group on the question of whether they are employees or contractors, and over their demand for payment of tips that were not passed on to them. Drivers' attorneys must submit more evidence to sue as a group for reimbursement of other expenses.
Chen also said Uber drivers who have worked for the service since May 2014 must specifically opt out of an arbitration agreement in order to sue the company.
Class action status generally gives plaintiffs more leverage to negotiate a settlement. In a statement, Uber said it will appeal, but that the arbitration portion of Chen's ruling means a "tiny fraction" of a potential 160,000 California drivers are eligible to be class members. Additionally, one of the three drivers who sued is no longer eligible to represent the class, Uber said.
Shannon Liss-Riordan, a lawyer who represents drivers in the case, said Uber's characterization of the size of the class is "not correct," and that "many thousands" will be part of the lawsuit.
"This decision is a major victory for Uber drivers," Liss-Riordan said.
Uber had argued that the drivers should not be allowed to sue as a group because they have little in common and relate to the company in different ways.
However, Chen wrote that there is an "inherent tension" in Uber's argument.
"On one hand, Uber argues that it has properly classified every single driver as an independent contractor," Chen wrote.
On the other, Chen wrote, Uber argues that individual drivers are so unique that the court, "unlike, apparently, Uber itself," cannot make its own determination.
Uber and other companies, including Lyft and Handy, say the contractor model allows for flexibility that many see as important to their success.
An ultimate finding that drivers are employees could raise Uber's costs beyond the lawsuit's scope and force it to pay Social Security, workers' compensation, and unemployment insurance.
In June, a California labour commissioner ruled that an Uber driver was an employee, not a contractor. Uber has appealed that decision.
The debate has spilled into U.S. presidential politics, with Democratic presidential contender Hillary Clinton in July saying on-demand companies raise "hard questions" about workplace protection and what a good job will look like in the future.
In arguing against class action status, Uber had submitted sworn statements from hundreds of drivers supporting the company. However, Chen rejected this evidence because the statements could have been the product of biased questions.
There is simply "no basis," Chen wrote, to support Uber's claim "that some innumerable legion of drivers prefer to remain independent contractors rather than become employees."
The case is Douglas O'Connor et al v. Uber Technologies Inc, U.S. District Court, Northern District of California, No. 13-3826.
Reuters
Wed Sep 02 2015
Three drivers sued Uber in a federal court in San Francisco, contending they are employees and entitled to reimbursement for expenses, including gas and vehicle maintenance.
2 maut, lebih 20 cedera dalam serangan pisau ke atas hospital di China
Sekurang-kurangnya dua orang terbunuh manakala 23 lagi cedera dalam serangan menggunakan pisau di sebuah hospital di wilayah barat daya Yunnan di China.
Malaysia rugi RM277 bilion dalam tempoh lima tahun akibat rasuah
Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) mendedahkan bahawa negara kerugian RM277 bilion akibat jenayah rasuah dalam tempoh lima tahun lepas.
Fitnah Sultanah Terengganu: Rewcastle-Brown diarah hadir prosiding rayuan
Mahkamah Tinggi mengarahkan Rewcastle-Brown, hadir ke mahkamah dalam pengurusan kes rayuannya.
Pemilik kedai perkakas rugi RM3.4 juta terpedaya skim simpanan tetap
Seorang warga emas yang juga pemilik kedai barangan perkakasan kerugian sebanyak RM3.4 juta selepas menjadi mangsa penipuan skim simpanan tetap.
[TERKINI] Speaker Dewan Negara Mutang Tagal masih dirawat di IJN
Pihak pejabat Yang Di-Pertua Dewan Negara memohon semua pihak agar tidak membuat spekulasi dan menyebarkan maklumat tidak sahih tentang status kesihatan Yang Dipertua Dewan Negara, Datuk Mutang Tagal.
Niaga AWANI: Forum Putrajaya 2024 buka ruang perkongsian maklumat bantu kurangkan jurang kepakaran
Forum Putrajaya 2024 buka ruang perkongsian kepakaran dan maklumat daripada negara lain bagi mengurangkan jurang kepakaran dalam menanggani cabaran isu keselamatan bukan tradisional.
#NiagaAWANI
#NiagaAWANI
AWANI Ringkas: Rasuah makin menjadi-jadi, negara rugi ratusan bilion
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu: SPRM teliti tindakan Kor Ming umum peruntukan dana
SPRM sedang meneliti tindakan Menteri Perumahan dan Kerajaan Tempatan Nga Kor Ming, yang mengumumkan peruntukan dana infrastruktur ke Kuala Kubu Bharu (KKB), baru-baru ini.
KBS pastikan Faisal Halim dapat rawatan percuma di ISN - Hannah
Hannah berkata pihaknya akan memastikan Faisal Halim mendapat sokongan dan rawatan yang diperlukan sepanjang tempoh pemulihan yang dijangka mengambil masa beberapa bulan.
Niaga AWANI: MITI galak syarikat tempatan jalin kerjasama pelaburan dengan Arab Saudi
Kementerian Pelaburan, Perdagangan dan Industri (MITI) menggalakkan syarikat tempatan untuk menjalinkan kerjasama pelaburan dengan syarikat dari Arab Saudi terutama dalam sektor perkhidmatan.
Menterinya Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Abdul Aziz berkata Arab Saudi mempelawa syarikat Malaysia untuk melabur di negara itu bagi membolehkan peningkatan perdagangan dan pelaburan dua hala.
#NiagaAWANI
Menterinya Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Abdul Aziz berkata Arab Saudi mempelawa syarikat Malaysia untuk melabur di negara itu bagi membolehkan peningkatan perdagangan dan pelaburan dua hala.
#NiagaAWANI