Verizon Communications Inc said on Thursday it has a "reasonable basis" to believe Yahoo Inc's massive data breach of email accounts represents a material impact that could allow Verizon to withdraw from its $4.83 billion deal to buy the technology company.
Verizon's general counsel Craig Silliman told reporters at a roundtable in Washington the data breach could trigger a clause in the deal that would allow the U.S. wireless company not to complete it.
"I think we have a reasonable basis to believe right now that the impact is material and we're looking to Yahoo to demonstrate to us the full impact. If they believe that it's not then they'll need to show us that," he said, declining to comment on whether talks are under way to renegotiate the purchase price.
Asked for comment, a Yahoo spokesman said: "We are confident in Yahoo’s value and we continue to work towards integration with Verizon."
The deal has a clause that says Verizon can withdraw if a new event "reasonably can be expected to have a material adverse effect on the business, assets, properties, results of operation or financial condition of the business.”
Silliman said the U.S. Federal Trade Commission has approved Verizon's planned acquisition of Yahoo, but it still needs approval from the European Commission and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission is reviewing the proxy.
Verizon has had preliminary briefings from Yahoo but it still needs "significant information" from the company before it makes a final decision on the materiality of the hacking of at least 500 million email accounts, Silliman said.
He said Verizon is "absolutely evaluating (the breach) and will make determinations about whether and how to move forward with the deal based on our evaluation of the materiality."
Yahoo shares ended 1.75 percent lower at $41.62, while Verizon was largely unchanged, closing at $50.29, down 0.02 percent.
Yahoo in September disclosed that it had fallen victim to a data breach in 2014 that compromised users’ names, email addresses, telephone numbers, dates of birth and encrypted passwords.
The company has said the cyber attack was carried out by a “state-sponsored” actor, but some private security experts have challenged that assertion.
Several Democratic senators have pressed Yahoo to reveal more information about the hack and why it took so long to discover.
The internet firm said it learned of the breach this summer while investigating claims of a separate intrusion, but it has not provided a specific timeline of events.
Some analysts suggested Verizon may be trying to get a better price.
Roger Entner, an analyst at Recon Analytics, said "Verizon is rightfully upset about Yahoo not properly disclosing the breach."
He said Yahoo would most likely have to consider renegotiating the price with Verizon, if it came to that.
"I don't think it has much of a choice. Who else would want to buy them?" Entner said.
Experts said bidders who try to extract themselves from mergers using the material adverse clause face an uphill battle. No U.S. company has ever invoked the clause successfully in court to get out of a deal.
In 2013, Cooper Tire & Rubber company got cold feet about a $2.5 billion sale to Apollo Tyres and argued in the Delaware Court of Chancery that Apollo had seen a material adverse change related to union issues at a subsidiary of the company. The court rejected Cooper Tire’s claims and the deal fell apart.
A Delaware court ruled in 2001 that poultry producer Tyson Foods Inc could not terminate its merger with beef producer IBP Inc over accounting irregularities. The court said the shortfall was not due to a long-term problem.
Reuters
Fri Oct 14 2016
Yahoo spokesman says: "We are confident in Yahoos value and we continue to work towards integration with Verizon." - EPA/MICHAEL NELSON/File
Niaga AWANI: Meneliti dinamika ekosistem pekerjaan di era teknologi
Teknologi pesat ketika ini memerlukan sektor buruh di negara ini beradaptasi, dan tidak menjadikannya sebagai halangan dalam meningkatkan produktiviti.
AWANI Ringkas: Sultan Nazrin dilantik Pengerusi MKI untuk 2 tahun
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Agong, Raja Permaisuri zahir penghargaan kepada warga pekerja
Seri Paduka Baginda berdua bertitah warga pekerja adalah pemacu pertumbuhan Malaysia ke tahap yang lebih baik.
Niaga AWANI: Sejauh mana reformasi dasar diperlukan untuk tangani cabaran TVET?
Graduan dalam aliran Pendidikan Teknikal dan Latihan Vokasional (TVET) kini, mempunyai potensi besar menjadi tenaga mahir negara dalam pelbagai bidang. Apakah langkah yang boleh diambil untuk memastikan kurikulum bidang TVET dapat memenuhi keperluan industri semasa serta dapat mempersiapkan graduan bagi menghadapi pelbagai cabaran dalam pasaran pekerjaan?
Niaga AWANI: Pekerja Kesuma Bangsa: Lonjakkan kesejahteraan pekerja, produktiviti organisasi
Bagaimana untuk memahami hubungan antara kesejahteraan pekerja dan produktiviti organisasi, terutamanya dalam konteks Malaysia?
Boleh guna kad debit, kredit di semua kaunter khidmat pelanggan - Rapid Rail
Kaedah pembayaran baharu ini bertujuan untuk memberi kemudahan dan meningkatkan kecekapan proses pembelian untuk pengguna Rapid KL.
Bekas pemain yakin Arne Slot pilihan tepat buat Liverpool
Feyenoord dan Liverpool dilaporkan minggu lalu mencapai persetujuan pada dasarnya untuk Slot mengambil alih daripada Jurgen Klopp musim depan.
Blinken akan terus desak Netanyahu
Blinken berkata masih banyak lagi yang perlu dilakukan bagi memastikan bantuan sampai kepada orang ramai secara berterusan.
Trak bawa tahanan, mayat ke Gaza bertindak sekat bantuan
Trak yang membawa kedua-dua mayat dan tahanan ke Gaza melalui persimpangan utama Kerem Shalom kerap menahan penghantaran bantuan.
IsDB simpul mesyuarat 4 hari, dengan 85 perjanjian pembiayaan US$8 bln
Perjanjian tersebut berkaitan dengan operasi serta projek dalam pelbagai sektor, kata Presiden IsDB Dr Muhammad Al-Jasser.