An Australian judge will be investigated for his "appalling" comments on incest, in which he reportedly said sex between siblings was gaining social acceptance just like homosexuality, authorities said Friday.
New South Wales state Attorney-General Brad Hazzard said he was "extremely concerned" about District Court judge Garry Neilson's alleged comments in a case where a man was accused of repeatedly raping his younger sister, which were reported in the Sydney Morning Herald.
"In my view the community would be rightly appalled at his reported comments," Hazzard said in a statement.
"Incest is completely reprehensible, unacceptable, disgusting and criminal."
Neilson was quoted as saying communities might no longer see sex between siblings as "unnatural" or "taboo", likening a change in mindsets to how homosexuality was now socially accepted despite being criminalised in the past.
"A jury might find nothing untoward in the advance of a brother towards his sister once she had sexually matured, had sexual relationships with other men and was now 'available', not having (a) sexual partner," Neilson reportedly said.
Hazzard said he had referred Neilson to the Judicial Commission of New South Wales, which investigates complaints. He also requested the District Court suspend the judge from criminal trials until the probe was completed.
In his case comments, Neilson reportedly added that the "only reason" incest remained a crime was due to the risk of genetic abnormalities in children born through such a relationship.
"But even that falls away to an extent (because) there is such ease of contraception and ready access to abortion," he said.
The 58-year-old man accused in the case earlier pleaded guilty to sexually assaulting his sister when she was 10 to 11 years old in the 1970s, but not guilty to separate charges when she was 18, the Herald said.
The NSW prosecutor has reportedly requested that the ongoing case be transferred to another judge due to what she said was Neilson's "misogynistic" attitude towards the alleged victim.
In a separate case reported in Sydney's Daily Telegraph, Neilson was said to have given an incestuous rapist a lighter sentence in 2011 because he did not ejaculate inside his teenage niece.
The appeal judges reviewing that case last year criticised the stance, saying "it is difficult to see how that was a matter which could have been considered to reduce the objective seriousness of this offence in any real way".
Cathy Kezelman, president of support group Adults Surviving Child Abuse, said Neilson's alleged comments were "beyond belief" and such cases seriously damaged children.
"There are still a lot of myths, still a lot of entrenched, very damaging beliefs and that's why we need to speak out about it... so we're not hearing these outrageous statements," she told Fairfax radio.
AFP
Fri Jul 11 2014
Neilson was quoted as saying communities might no longer see sex between siblings as "unnatural" or "taboo", likening a change in mindsets to how homosexuality was now socially accepted despite being criminalised in the past.
Perhilitan Kelantan tangkap gajah liar ganggu penduduk di Tanah Merah
Jabatan Perlindungan Hidupan Liar dan Taman Negara (Perhilitan) Kelantan menangkap seekor gajah liar di Kampung Tal Tujuh, Jerangau, semalam.
Pemuda dipenjara lapan bulan, denda 1,500 kerana curi beg sandang wanita sarat hamil
Seorang pekerja sebuah syarikat penapis air yang mencuri beg sandang seorang wanita sarat mengandung sembilan bulan dihukum penjara selama lapan bulan oleh Mahkamah Majistret di sini hari ini.
AWANI 7:45 [03/05/2024] – 15 lokasi skrin besar | Malaysia di kedudukan 107 | Nasihat Mufti Perak
Laporan berita padat dan ringkas #AWANI745 bersama Syaff Shukri
Tumpuan #AWANI745 malam ini:
- Misi 'pecahkan Tembok Besar China' dan mara ke final Piala Thomas
- Indeks kebebasan media Malaysia merudum
- Tersasar daripada landasan keadilan Islam, mufti nasihat henti boikot KK Mart
- Cedera di kepala, kaki dan tangan, polis buru dua individu samun Akhyar Rasid
Saksikan #AWANI745 di saluran 501 Astro AWANI, Astro AWANI apps dan astroawani.com/live-tv
Tumpuan #AWANI745 malam ini:
- Misi 'pecahkan Tembok Besar China' dan mara ke final Piala Thomas
- Indeks kebebasan media Malaysia merudum
- Tersasar daripada landasan keadilan Islam, mufti nasihat henti boikot KK Mart
- Cedera di kepala, kaki dan tangan, polis buru dua individu samun Akhyar Rasid
Saksikan #AWANI745 di saluran 501 Astro AWANI, Astro AWANI apps dan astroawani.com/live-tv
AWANI Tonight: Malaysia drops 34 spots to 107th place in World Press Freedom Index
Malaysia placed 107th in the World Press Freedom Index, dropping 34 places from 73rd last year with a score of 52.07 points.
AWANI Tonight: Turkiye halts all trade with Israel
Turkiye will suspend all trade with Israel over its offensive in Gaza until it allows an uninterrupted and sufficient flow of aid into the Strip to address the humanitarian crisis there.
PM tidak pernah pinggir masyarakat India malah salur pelbagai bantuan - Ramanan
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim tidak pernah meminggirkan masyarakat India di negara ini malah beliau telah meningkatkan lagi peruntukan kepada mereka.
Tiga pegawai polis berpangkat ACP, DSP, Inspektor disyaki terlibat pemerasan ditahan
Tiga pegawai kanan polis berpangkat Asisten Komisoner, Deputi Superitendan dan Inspektor yang disyaki terlibat dalam kes pemerasan berjumlah RM1.25 juta ditahan pada Jumaat.
AWANI Ringkas: MKT UMNO beri komitmen sokong calon PH
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Pasaran getah ditutup bercampur-campur untuk hari kedua berturut-turut
Pasaran getah Kuala Lumpur ditutup bercampur-campur untuk hari kedua berturut-turut pada Jumaat berikutan pasaran Jepun dan China yang ditutup sempena cuti umum.
Ringgit ditutup lebih positif, terus mengukuh berbanding dolar AS
Pada 6 petang, ringgit mencecah paras 4.7370/7400 berbanding dolar AS daripada 4.7535/7555 pada Khamis.