THE South China Sea remains a contentious region, with several countries vying for sovereignty over its resource-rich waters. China's incursions into these disputed territories have caused alarm for the affected nations.

In this context, it is crucial to examine the divergent stances of Malaysia's key political leaders, Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim, and Defence Minister Muhammad Hassan.

This article aims to analyse their media responses, compare their positions, and explore the implications for Malaysia's foreign policy and regional stability, while scrutinizing Anwar's approach and suggesting potential measures.

Anwar Ibrahim: Diplomacy or Appeasement?

Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim has adopted a pragmatic stance, emphasizing diplomacy and cooperation with China. In response to recent incursions by Chinese vessels near a Petronas oil rig in Sarawak, Anwar expressed concern while maintaining a measured tone. He emphasized the importance of a peaceful resolution through dialogue and engagement.

However, it can be said that Anwar's approach may border on appeasement, potentially emboldening China to further expand its military presence in the disputed waters. While the economic significance of China as a trading partner and investor is undeniable, prioritizing economic interests over national security and territorial sovereignty could have long-term consequences for Malaysia's regional standing and autonomy.

Muhammad Hassan: A More Assertive Stance

Defence Minister Muhammad Hassan has taken a more robust approach. In his response to the Petronas oil rig incident, he condemned China's actions and called for an immediate withdrawal of its vessels from Malaysia's Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ). Hassan expresses scepticism towards China's intentions in the region, arguing that its growing military presence threatens regional security.

His position emphasizes the importance of protecting Malaysia's territorial rights and sovereignty. While he acknowledges the need for diplomacy with China, he also advocates for increased defence spending and military modernization to prepare for potential conflicts in the region. Furthermore,  he supports strengthening ties with the United States and other regional partners to counterbalance China's influence.

Suggested Response and Measures

Given the potential risks associated with Anwar's approach, Malaysia may need to consider adopting a more balanced strategy that reconciles economic interests with national security concerns. The following measures could be pursued:

1. Strengthen multilateral diplomacy: Malaysia should actively engage with regional organizations, such as ASEAN and the East Asia Summit, to promote dialogue and cooperation on the South China Sea issue. Building consensus with other affected countries can help establish a unified regional stance, making it more difficult for China to dismiss or undermine the concerns of individual nations.

2. Enhance maritime surveillance capabilities: Investing in modern surveillance technologies can help Malaysia monitor and respond more effectively to potential incursions in its territorial waters. This would enable Malaysia to gather evidence of violations and strengthen its position in diplomatic negotiations.

3. Diversify economic partnerships: While maintaining its relationship with China, Malaysia should work on diversifying its trade and investment partnerships to reduce overdependence on a single economic partner. This would provide Malaysia with greater flexibility in addressing security challenges in the South China Sea without jeopardizing its economic well-being.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while the pragmatic approach of Malaysia's Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim has its merits, the potential risks of prioritizing economic interests over national security and territorial sovereignty cannot be ignored.

Adopting a more balanced strategy that reconciles diplomacy with security concerns is essential for navigating the complexities of the South China Sea dispute and ensuring a peaceful and prosperous future for Malaysia and the region.

By pursuing measures such as strengthening multilateral diplomacy, enhancing maritime surveillance capabilities, and diversifying economic partnerships, Malaysia can better protect its interests and contribute to regional stability.


* Rahman Hussin interests is in public affairs, politics and stakeholder managements. He runs his own firm that serves a wide range of clients focusing on strategy and government affairs.

** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.