AN injection commonly used to treat osteoarthritis in knees is hardly better than a placebo for relieving pain and increases the risk of harmful side effects, according to research.
Injections of hyaluronic acid have been prescribed since the 1970s, but despite previous research indicating the treatment is ineffective, its use has continued -- and even increased -- in some countries.
Knee osteoarthritis is a leading cause of disability among older people, the study said, citing 2020 research which found that more than 560 million people suffer from the condition worldwide.
It causes deterioration of the cartilage in knee joints, leading to pain and often difficulty walking.
Hyaluronic acid, a gel-like substance, has long been injected into the joint aiming to lubricate movement and decrease pain. The treatment is also known as viscosupplementation.
A meta-analysis published in the BMJ journal looked at 169 previous trials that compared the injections to a placebo -- or no treatment.
The researchers then whittled that down to 24 large placebo-controlled trials involving nearly 9,000 patients, in what is the largest review of the available data so far.
They found "strong conclusive evidence" that "viscosupplementation is associated with a clinically irrelevant reduction in pain intensity", the study said.
They also said the treatment is "associated with a higher incidence of serious adverse events", adding that it is "not only ineffective compared with a placebo but might also be seriously harmful".
- 'Don't need new trials' -
One of the study's authors, Bruno da Costa of the University of Toronto, and his team carried out a similar review of the available research in 2012 -- and found the same results.
"We don't need new trials," he told AFP, saying the latest results were conclusive.
He said that further research could be done into whether a sub-group of patients could benefit from the treatment -- but for the typical patient it should be considered at best as a last resort.
Since the team's 2012 research, several large-scale, industry-funded studies were carried out that found negative results about the treatment.
But those studies were never published, da Costa said.
"This is concerning, and perhaps mainly driven by commercial interests," he added.
Thursday's study suggested that more than 12,000 patients were unnecessarily subjected to the treatment between 2009 and 2021, given the compelling research already available at that point.
France's social security system stopped offering reimbursements for the treatment a few years ago, despite the opposition of specialists who prescribe the injections, companies that produce hyaluronic acid, and some patients' groups.
England's National Institute for Health and Care Excellence recommends against viscosupplementation.
In the United States, however, the treatment's use grew considerably from 2012 to 2018, the study said, with one in every seven patients with the condition receiving an injection. For many it was first treatment they were given.
The study also said that a quarter of the money that US Medicare spent on viscosupplementation in 2018 went towards treating infections in joints following an injection, one of the most common side effects.
ETX Studio
Sat Jul 09 2022
Knee osteoarthritis is a leading cause of disability among older people, the study said, citing 2020 research which found that more than 560 million people suffer from the condition worldwide. - ETX Studio
Guna visa pelancong untuk kerjakan haji, TH tidak akan bantu
Syed Saleh berkata, pihak berkuasa Arab Saudi memandang serius penyalahgunaan visa pelancong untuk tujuan mengerjakan haji.
Ibu bapa Zayn Rayyan ditahan
Suami isteri yang juga ibu dan bapa kepada kanak-kanak autisme, Zayn Rayyan Abdul Matiin, 6, yang meningggal dunia akibat dibunuh dalam kejadian di Damansara Damai Disember lalu diberkas pada Jumaat.
Ahmad Zahid bertemu Penasihat Negara China Wang Xiaohong
Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi pada Jumaat meneruskan misi bagi memperkukuhkan hubungan dua hala dengan mengadakan kunjungan hormat ke atas Penasihat Negara merangkap Menteri Keselamatan Awam China, Wang Xiaohong.
Allahyarham suami yang baik, anak yang taat - isteri
Isteri Mohd Zahir Ismail, jemaah haji Malaysia kedua yang meninggal dunia di Masjidilharam semasa mengerjakan umrah pada Rabu akan sentiasa mengenang suaminya itu sebagai seorang yang sangat suka bergurau selain ringan tulang membantunya sebagai isteri di rumah.
Bruno dan Benny berpeluang rasa pengalaman salji buatan
Sempena sambutan perayaan Gawai Petronas Sarawak melalui Program 50 Dreams telah menjadikan impian dua beradik Bidayuh Bruno dan Benny untuk merasakan pengalaman salji satu kenyataan.
Dunia perlu terus suarakan isu Palestin, jangan biar ia lenyap
Hak Palestin perlu terus disuarakan namun kesannya mungkin tidak nampak sekarang tapi suatu masa nanti akan tertegak juga keadilan buat rakyat Palestin.
Presiden Filipina kecam tindakan haram di Laut China Selatan
Presiden Filipina, Ferdinand Marcos Jr, kecam tindakan haram dan agresif di Laut China Selatan, semasa pembukaan Dialog Shangri-La di Singapura.
WFP: Penduduk Gaza tanggung akibat krisis politik
WFP dedahkan penduduk Gaza hidup dalam kesesakan melampaui krisis kesihatan, dengan risiko tinggi cirit-birit pada kanak-kanak dan kekurangan tandas yang wajar.
Kesemua ahli pasukan MERCY berjaya dibawa keluar dari Gaza
Kesemua ahli pasukan perubatan kecemasan Malaysia Mercy telah berjaya dibawa keluar dari Rafah, Gaza.
Wisma Putra dalam satu kenyataan pada Jumaat berkata, mereka dibawa keluar secara berkelompok bersama kakitangan antarabangsa lain pada hari yang berbeza.
Wisma Putra dalam satu kenyataan pada Jumaat berkata, mereka dibawa keluar secara berkelompok bersama kakitangan antarabangsa lain pada hari yang berbeza.
WHO desak Israel patuhi undang-undang antarabangsa untuk penghantaran bantuan
WHO menggesa Israel mematuhi undang-undang antarabangsa mengenai laluan selamat bantuan, berikutan amaran kebuluran kanak-kanak di Gaza akibat kekurangan makanan.