Facebook Inc's oversight board on Wednesday upheld the company's suspension of former U.S. President Donald Trump but said the company was wrong to make the suspension indefinite and gave it six months to determine a "proportionate response."
Trump called the decision and his banning across tech platforms "a total disgrace" and said the companies would "pay a political price."
The much-awaited board verdict has been watched for signals on how the world's largest social media company will treat rule-breaking political leaders in the future, a key area of controversy for online platforms.
The board, created by Facebook to rule on a small slice of its content decisions, said the company was right to ban Trump following the Jan. 6 storming of the U.S. Capitol by Trump supporters.
Facebook indefinitely blocked Trump's access to his Facebook and Instagram accounts over concerns of further violent unrest following the Jan. 6 riot. It enacted the suspension after removing two of Trump's posts during the Capitol riot, including a video in which he said supporters should go home but reiterated his false claim of widespread voter fraud, saying "I know your pain. I know you’re hurt. We had an election that was stolen from us."
But the board said Facebook should not have imposed an indeterminate suspension without clear standards and said the company should determine a response consistent with rules applied to other users. It said Facebook could determine that Trump's account could be restored, suspended temporarily or permanently banned.
"Indefinite penalties of this sort do not pass the international or American smell test for clarity, consistency, and transparency," said former federal Judge Michael McConnell, co-chair of the Oversight Board, during a press conference after publishing its decision on Wednesday.
In an interview with Reuters, board co-chair and former Danish Prime Minister Helle Thorning-Schmidt said public figures should not be allowed to incite violence or create harm though their posts, but that Facebook "can't just invent new sanctions as they go along."
In its decision, the board said Facebook refused to answer some of the 46 questions it posed, including those on how its news feed affected the visibility of Trump's posts, and whether the company planned to look into how its technology amplified content as it had done in the events leading to the Capitol siege.
The board said Facebook's existing policies, such as deciding when material is too newsworthy to remove, need to be more clearly communicated to users. It also called on Facebook to develop a policy that governs how it handles novel situations where its existing rules would be insufficient to prevent imminent harm. See takeaways from the board's decision.
Facebook's business has thrived during the controversy and its main source of revenue, advertising, has boomed as COVID-19 pandemic restrictions begin to ease in the United States, but lawmakers across the political spectrum have raised concerns about the power of Facebook and other social media, many calling for new regulations and some calling for breakups of big tech.
Trump called the move "an embarrassment to our Country," and added that "Free Speech has been taken away from the President of the United States because the Radical Left Lunatics are afraid of the truth, but the truth will come out anyway, bigger and stronger than ever before."
At a Financial Times conference after the verdict, Nick Clegg, Facebook's vice president of global affairs and communication, said the company would hope to resolve the matter "considerably faster" than six months.
Tech platforms have grappled in recent years with how to police world leaders and politicians that violate their guidelines. Facebook has come under fire both from those who think it should abandon its hands-off approach to political speech and those, including Republican lawmakers and some free-expression advocates who saw the Trump ban as a disturbing act of censorship.
Facebook was one of a slew of social media sites that barred the former president, including Twitter Inc, which banned him permanently, a move welcomed by some civil rights groups and social media researchers. Political leaders from German Chancellor Angela Merkel to U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders expressed concern that private companies could silence elected officials on their sites.
At the time of the suspension, Facebook Chief Executive Mark Zuckerberg said "the risks of allowing the president to continue to use our service during this period are simply too great." The company later referred the case to its recently established board, which includes academics, lawyers and rights activists.
The binding verdict means Trump will not for now be able to return to Facebook's platforms, where he had a combined 59 million followers across Facebook and Instagram. His campaign spent about $160 million on Facebook ads in 2020, according to Democratic digital firm Bully Pulpit Interactive's campaign tracker.
On Tuesday, Trump launched a web page to share messages that readers can then re-post to their Facebook or Twitter accounts. A senior adviser has said Trump also plans to launch his own social media platform.
Wednesday's decision marks a milestone for the oversight board, which Facebook financed with $130 million. The body has been hailed as a novel experiment by some researchers but criticized by those who have been skeptical about its independence or view it as a PR stunt to deflect attention from the company's more systemic problems.
"This verdict is a desperate attempt to have it both ways, upholding the 'ban' of Donald Trump without actually banning him, while punting any real decisions back to Facebook," said a group of academics, experts and Facebook critics known as the "Real Facebook Oversight Board."
Reuters
Thu May 06 2021
Facebook indefinitely blocked Trump's access to his Facebook and Instagram accounts over concerns of further violent unrest following the Jan. 6 riot. REUTERSpic
Bersih pantau perjalanan PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu
Gabungan Pilihan Raya Bersih dan Adil (Bersih) akan memantau perjalanan Pilihan Raya Kecil (PRK) Kuala Kubu Baharu yang akan berlangsung pada 11 Mei depan.
AWANI Ringkas: Banjir kilat di Kota Tinggi, 1 PPS dibuka
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
PM Anwar umum peruntukan RM250,000 kepada persatuan di Parlimen Tambun
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim mengumumkan peruntukan sebanyak RM250,000 kepada persatuan-persatuan di kawasan Parlimen Tambun hari ini.
Bersih anjur kongres 25 Mei ini, rangka perancangan menuju PRU16
Gabungan Pilihan Raya Bersih dan Adil (Bersih) akan menganjurkan Kongres Bersih sebagai medan mengumpulkan pertubuhan masyarakat sivil, mahasiswa dan rakyat.
Sultan Ibrahim berkenan hadir Majlis Rumah Terbuka Aidilfitri Ketua Menteri Melaka
Yang di-Pertuan Agong berkenan berangkat menghadiri Majlis Rumah Terbuka Aidilfitri Ketua Menteri Melaka Datuk Seri Ab Rauf Yusoh.
Indeks Kebebasan Media: Fahmi minta Wan Saiful insaf
Fahmi membidas kenyataan Wan Saiful yang menyalahkan beliau atas kemerosotan kedudukan Malaysia dalam Indeks Kebebasan Media bagi tahun ini.
Himpunan 100K Bela Palestin: Tun M, Abdul Hadi antara ribuan berhimpun di kedutaan AS
Ribuan membanjiri kawasan berhampiran bangunan Kedutaan Amerika Syarikat di ibu negara bagi menyertai Himpunan 100k Bela Palestin.
DSA NATSEC Asia 2024 bermula Isnin, pamer teknologi, aset pertahanan tercanggih dunia
Pameran Perkhidmatan Pertahanan Asia (DSA) dan Pameran Keselamatan Kebangsaan (NATSEC) Asia 2024 akan membuka tirai Isnin depan.
PM Anwar saksi penyerahan Kem Sultan Nazrin Shah 69 Komando
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim hari ini menyaksikan penyerahan Kem Sultan Nazrin Shah 69 Komando di Ulu Kinta.
Kereta, rumah pemandu lori ditembak ketika nyenyak tidur
Seorang pemandu lori terkejut dan bingung selepas mendengar tembakan di pekarangan rumahnya ketika sedang tidur.
NRES rancang lestarikan industri plastik sekali guna elak pencemaran
Kementerian Sumber Asli dan Kelestarian Alam (NRES) merancang untuk melestarikan industri plastik sekali guna menerusi satu peralihan yang seimbang dalam bidang itu.
Anwar harap terminal baharu LTSIP jana lebih banyak peluang ekonomi di Kelantan
Anwar Ibrahim berharap terminal baharu Lapangan Terbang Sultan Ismail Petra (LTSIP) fasa satu, yang mula beroperasi semalam, mampu menjana lebih banyak peluang ekonomi di Kelantan.
Terima anugerah Reader's Digest buat kali kelima, Ahmad Zahid ucap tahniah kepada Kemas
Timbalan Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi mengucapkan tahniah kepada Jabatan Kemajuan Masyarakat (Kemas) yang meraih Anugerah Jenama Paling Dipercayai buat kali kelima bagi kategori Pu
AIM menang Anugerah Industri Kewangan Islam Global
AIM memenangi anugerah Islamic Finance News apabila dinobat IFN Best Islamic Microfinance Institution, serta menerima dua anugerah di bawah Global Good Governance Awards (3G).
Pulau Pinang akan bincang, teliti kenaikan gaji penjawat awam negeri - Chow
Kerajaan Pulau Pinang akan membincangkan mengenai kenaikan gaji penjawat awam di negeri itu pada Majlis Mesyuarat Kerajaan Negeri akan datang, menurut Ketua Menteri Chow Kon Yeow.
Jambatan Bailey di Jalan Kuantan-Segamat dibuka semula hari ini
Jambatan Bailey di Seksyen 102 Jalan Kuantan-Segamat yang ditutup sebelum ini untuk kerja-kerja pembaikan dibuka semula bermula 4 petang tadi.
Pengguna Facebook, Instagram luang 60% masa menonton video
Menurut Meta, kini pengguna meluangkan 60% daripada masa penggunaan di platform berkenaan dengan menonton video.
Semua pihak diminta siap siaga, segera salurkan bantuan mangsa banjir - Ab Rauf
Wakil rakyat dan agensi berkaitan termasuk pihak berkuasa tempatan diarahkan supaya siap siaga dan menyalurkan bantuan awal kepada semua mangsa yang terjejas akibat banjir terutama di Alor Gajah.
'Bila boss?' - Sian See tuntut janji Rafizi
Pempengaruh media sosial, Lim Sian See memberi peringatan kepada Menteri Ekonomi, Rafizi Ramli berhubung jemputan untuk muncul dalam program podcast 'berjudul, ang Bakar Menteri'.
Hina Raja Perlis, peniaga dihadap ke mahkamah
Seorang peniaga dihadapkan ke Mahkamah Sesyen, di sini hari ini atas kesalahan menghantar perkhidmatan komunikasi jelik mengenai Raja Perlis di laman Facebook pada Mac lalu.