Are eight billion humans too many for planet Earth? As we reach this milestone on November 15, most experts say the bigger problem is the overconsumption of resources by the wealthiest residents.
"Eight billion people, it is a momentous milestone for humanity," said United Nations Population Fund chief Natalia Kanem, hailing an increase in life expectancy and fewer maternal and child deaths.
"Yet, I realize this moment might not be celebrated by all. Some express concerns that our world is overpopulated. I am here to say clearly that the sheer number of human lives is not a cause for fear."
So, are there too many of us for Earth to sustain?
Many experts say that this is the wrong question. Instead of the fear of overpopulation, we should focus on the overconsumption of the planet's resources by the wealthiest among us.
"Too many for whom, too many for what? If you ask me, am I too many? I don't think so," Joel Cohen of Rockefeller University's Laboratory of Populations told AFP.
He said the question of how many people Earth can support has two sides: natural limits and human choices.
- 'Stupid and greedy' -
Our choices result in humans consuming far more biological resources, such as forests and land, than the planet can regenerate each year.
The overconsumption of fossil fuels, for example, leads to more carbon dioxide emissions, responsible for global warming.
We would need the biocapacity of 1.75 Earths to sustainably meet the needs of the current population, according to the Global Footprint Network and WWF NGOs.
The most recent UN climate report mentions population growth as one of the main drivers of an increase in greenhouse gases. However, it plays a smaller role than economic growth.
"We are stupid. We lacked foresight. We are greedy. We don't use the information we have. That's where the choices and the problems lie," said Cohen.
However, he rejects the idea that humans are a curse on the planet, saying people should be given better choices.
"Our impact on the planet is driven far more by our behavior than by our numbers," said Jennifer Sciubba, a researcher at the Wilson Center, a think tank.
"It's lazy and damaging to keep going back to overpopulation," she added, as this allows people in wealthy nations, who consume the most, to cast the blame for the planet's woes onto developing countries where population growth is highest.
"Really, it's us. It's me and you, the air conditioning I enjoy, the pool I have outside, and the meat I eat at night that causes so much more damage."
If everyone on the planet lived like a citizen of India, we would only need the capacity of 0.8 Earths a year, according to the Global Footprint Network and WWF. If we all consumed like a resident of the United States, we would need five Earths a year.
The United Nations estimates that our planet will be home to 9.7 billion people by 2050.
- Women's rights -
One of the trickiest questions that arise when discussing population is that of controlling fertility. Even those who believe we need to lower the Earth's population are adamant about protecting women's rights.
Robin Maynard, the executive director of the NGO Population Matters, says there needs to be a decrease in the population, but "only through positive, voluntary, rights-respecting means" and not "deplorable examples" of population control.
The NGO Project Drawdown lists education and family planning among the top 100 solutions to halt global warming.
"A smaller population with sustainable levels of consumption would reduce demands on energy, transportation, materials, food, and natural systems."
Vanessa Perez of the World Resources Institute agrees that "every person that is born on the planet puts additional stress on the planet."
"It is a very thorny issue," she said, adding that we should reject "this idea that the elite capture this narrative and say we need to cap population growth in the South."
She believes the most interesting debate is not about the number of people but "distribution and equity."
Cohen points out that even if we currently produce enough food for 8 billion people, there are still 800 million people who are "chronically undernourished."
"The concept of 'too many' avoids the much more difficult problem, which is: are we using what we know to make the human beings we have as healthy, productive, happy, peaceful, and prosperous as we could?"
ETX Studio
Wed Nov 09 2022
One of the trickiest questions that arise when discussing population is that of controlling fertility. - ETX Studio
Polis geledah pejabat pemimpin Parlimen Eropah di Brussels
Pihak berkuasa Jerman melakukan penggeledahan di pejabat seorang ahli Parlimen Eropah di Brussels pada Selasa.
Cermin kereta Safiq Rahim pecah diketuk dengan tukul besi
Bekas pemain kebangsaan, Safiq Rahim, turut ditimpa malang apabila cermin kereta dipecahkan menggunakan tukul besi berdekatan pusat latihan Johor Darul Ta'zim (JDT).
Balu Navalny gesa rakyat Rusia tidak putus asa
Balu kepada pemimpin pembangkang Rusia Alexei Navalny, Yulia Navalnaya menggesa rakyat negara itu supaya tidak berputus asa memerangi rejim selepas pelantikan Vladimir Putin.
Perhimpunan Agung PBB mengundi Jumaat ini
Ia secara berkesan akan bertindak sebagai tinjauan global mengenai berapa banyak sokongan rakyat Palestin terhadap bidaan mereka, yang telah diveto dalam Majlis Keselamatan PBB bulan lalu oleh Amerika Syarikat.
Serangan di Rafah satu kesilapan, malapetaka kemanusiaan - PBB
Setiausaha Agung PBB Antonio Guterres pada Selasa memberi amaran kepada Israel bahawa serangan ke atas Rafah akan menjadi kesilapan strategik, bencana politik dan kemanusian.
Kehadiran Agong ke Parlimen kukuhkan lagi hubungan dua hala
Di bawah pemerintahan Yang Di-Pertuan Agong, Sultan Ibrahim selaku Sultan Negeri Johor, hubungan negeri itu dengan Singapura semakin kukuh.
Ia dapat dilihat dari segi ekonomi dan hubungan antara rakyat.
Ia dapat dilihat dari segi ekonomi dan hubungan antara rakyat.
Vladimir Putin angkat sumpah sebagai Presiden bagi penggal kelima
Majlis angkat sumpah itu diadakan di Kremlin dengan diboikot Amerika Syarikat dan beberapa negara barat lain susulan perang antara Rusia-Ukraine.
Cuaca panas undang stres kalangan jemaah wanita
Dalam keadaan cuaca panas melampau dan untuk tempoh yang lama, ia boleh mengundang kepada stres atau tekanan sehingga berupaya menjejaskan kesihatan mental jemaah wanita yang menerima tawaran sebagai tetamu Allah di musim haji.
Mesyuarat JKKTN setuju perkukuh kawal selia BBP
Mesyuarat Jawatankuasa Khas Kabinet Tatakelola Nasional (JKKTN) yang bersidang hari ini bersetuju dengan cadangan memperkukuh kawal selia Badan Berkanun Persekutuan (BBP) melalui penggubalan akta.
Usaha bersepadu penting untuk mengekang jenayah
Usaha bersepadu di kalangan agensi-agensi dari pelbagai bidang adalah penting untuk mengekalkan kerangka keselamatan global, kata Menteri Dalam Negeri Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail.
Beliau menyatakan bahawa akses internet dan kemajuan teknologi telah membawa ancaman baru dan mengubah landskap keselamatan, oleh itu perlunya pendekatan yang bersatu padu untuk menangani mereka.
Beliau menyatakan bahawa akses internet dan kemajuan teknologi telah membawa ancaman baru dan mengubah landskap keselamatan, oleh itu perlunya pendekatan yang bersatu padu untuk menangani mereka.