PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal today dismissed the appeals by 32 individuals including former Felda chairman Tan Sri Shahrir Abdul Samad and Pontian MP Datuk Seri Ahmad Maslan to challenge the compound notices issued by the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) over charges of receiving funds linked to the 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB).
A three-member bench led by Justice Datuk Suraya Othman dismissed their appeals on grounds there was no merit in the appeals.
The 32 individuals had appealed against the decisions of the High Court in denying them leave to commence judicial review against the MACC's decision in issuing them the compound notice.
Justice Suraya, in a unanimous decision, said the appellants in challenging the offer to a compound made by the MACC, was in effect, challenging the discretion of the Public Prosecutor to consent and to authorise the issuance of the compound offer and thus directly challenging the Public Prosecutor's authority under Article 145(3) of the Federal Constitution and Section 376 of the Criminal Procedure Code.
"The issuance of the offer to the compound was made under Section 92(1) of the Anti-Money Laundering, Anti-Terrorism Financing and Proceeds of Unlawful Activities Act (AMLATFPUAA) and under that section, before an offer for a compound can be made, the consent of the Public Prosecutor must be obtained.
"The appellants, after receipt of the offer to compound, can decide either to accept the compound offer or to reject it. If the appellants accepted the compound offer under Section 92(4) of the AMLATFPUAA, no prosecution can be initiated against them by the Public Prosecutor.
"If they rejected the offer, then under Section 92(3) of the AMLATFPUAA, the Public Prosecutor may institute prosecution which will result in charges being presented against them in the criminal court," justice Suraya said at the virtual proceedings today.
The other two judges were Datuk Darryl Goon Siew Chye and Datuk Seri Mariana Yahya.
Justice Suraya further said it was trite that the power of the Public Prosecutor to charge any person can be exercised by him at any time.
"In our present appeals, no charges have been preferred against all the appellants. At this juncture, we are of the view that it is premature on the part of the appellants to challenge the power of the Public Prosecutor in the exercise of his discretion to authorise the respondents (MACC and the MACC chief commissioner) to issue the offer to compound the offence under AMLATFPUAA.
"Based on the above reasons, the appeals are hereby dismisses with no order as to costs and the decision of the High Court, dated Feb 26, 2020 is affirmed," she said.
Lawyer Mohamed Shahrul Fazli Kamarulzaman, Mohamed Baharudeen Mohamed Ariff and Mohd Shahril Madisa represented the appellants, while senior federal counsel Ahmad Hanir Hambaly acted on behalf of the MACC.
On Feb 26, 2020, the High Court dismissed an application by 32 individuals to obtain leave for judicial review after the Attorney-General Chambers raised a preliminary objection on the basis that the applications were devoid of any prima facie, arguable case, were frivolous, vexatious and an abuse of court process.
Shahrir and Ahmad, as well as the 30 other individuals, filed the judicial review applications separately in November and December 2019.
In the applications, all of them sought to declare the decision and action of the two respondents in compounding them via the Offer to Compound Offence, dated Oct 7, 2019, as ultra vires, invalid, canceled and could not be enforced.
The applicants also sought to cancel the decision and action of the second respondent in compounding them apart from applying for an order to prevent MACC from enforcing the compound or continue their prosecution against them.
They also sought a declaration that the statement of the first respondent (MACC chief commissioner) during a media conference on the decision to issue compound notice against three of the applicants was to recover 1MDB funds said to be belonging to the people as premature, wrongly conceived and abuse of the civil service.
On Oct 7, 2019, then then MACC chief commissioner, Latheefa Koya, in a media conference, said MACC had issued compound notices to 80 individuals and entities for receiving RM420 million believed to be from 1MDB.
Latheefa said nine individuals and 71 entities, comprising 23 companies, 43 political organisations and five foundations received cheques involving the personal account of former prime minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Fri Oct 15 2021
The Court of Appeal today dismissed the appeals by 32 individuals including Shahrir Abdul Samad and Ahmad Maslan to challenge the compound notices issued by the MACC over charges of receiving funds linked to the 1MDB. - BERNAMA filepic
Kelantan: 70 peratus kemalangan maut babit penunggang, pembonceng motosikal
70 peratus kes kemalangan maut yang dicatat berlaku dari 1 hingga 26 April di Kelantan, membabitkan penunggang dan pembonceng motosikal.
[TERKINI] WEF | Pembangunan dunia yang tidak seimbang, Apa Solusi?
Mesyuarat Khas Forum Ekonomi Dunia (WEF) di Arab Saudi merungkai masalah ekonomi dan ketidakseimbangan pembangunan yang sedang melanda dunia. Menteri MITI, Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Abdul Aziz dan Menteri Kewangan Arab Saudi, Mohammed Al-Jadaan berada sepentas merungkai masalah dunia yang memberi impak kepada semua negara.
PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu: Calon PH, PN bertembung ketika kempen
Dua calon yang bersaing bagi PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu hari ini bertembung buat kali pertama sejak hari penamaan calon semalam.
AWANI Ringkas: 1MDB - Polis Jerman rampas 4 kereta Bugatti Veyron edisi terhad
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Gempa bumi Indonesia, Tasikmalaya paling terjejas
Sekurang-kurangnya empat orang cedera dan 27 keluarga lagi terkesan selepas satu gempa bumi dengan magnitud 6.2 melanda Daerah Garut di Jawa Barat pada pukul 11.29 pagi waktu tempatan, Ahad.
Air penstabil dan pemangkin pembangunan negara - Fadillah Yusof
Air merupakan komponen penting yang bertindak sebagai penstabil dan pemangkin untuk pembangunan negara yang mampan.
Pelaburan RM2.4 bilion dibawa masuk ke Terengganu - MB
Sebanyak RM2.4 bilion nilai pelaburan yang berpotensi sedang dibawa masuk ke Terengganu setakat bulan April ini.
PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu: Kelayakan akademik bukan isu calon PN - Pas
Kempen PN sempena PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu tidak akan terjejas berikutan isu yang mengaitkan kelayakan akademik calonnya, Khairul Azhari Saut.
Peniaga nasi kukus raih jualan RM14,000 sebulan
Inisiatif Pendapatan Rakyat (IPR) mampu merubah graf pendapatan bulanan peserta apabila meningkatkan hasil jualan.
Piala Uber: Malaysia tewas kepada Taiwan
Malaysia memulakan kempen Kumpulan B Piala Uber 2024 mereka dengan langkah kiri apabila tewas 1-4 kepada Taiwan, di sini hari ini.