The High Court here will deliver a decision next month over an appeal by the Attorney-General’s Chambers against 21 people acquitted of the charge of taking part in an ‘illegal assembly’ five years ago.
Judge Choong Siew Khim on Friday fixed June 5 as the date to deliver her ruling, saying that she needed some time to go through the evidence before deciding on the matter.
Choong had earlier heard submissions by the appellant and the respondents, which included several Opposition representatives as well as a Catholic priest.
Deputy public prosecutor Lailawati Ali on Friday morning played a video recording recorded by the police of the November 9, 2008, gathering in the courtroom, identifying those who appeared at the ‘Bersih anniversary vigil’.
Lailawati argued that the court should take into account the ‘new’ evidence and overturn the decision made by the Sessions court in acquitting the group.
The crux of the matter, said Lailawati, was whether the gathering, which started off in Amcorp mall and ended near the Petaling Jaya City Council (MBPJ) building, was planned or not.
Lailawati added that both assemblies were “continuous”, one and the same, and therefore is considered organised. However, the lawyers acting for the respondents argued that the gathering was “spontaneous”.
“Even the prosecution witnesses support that the gathering was one that was spontaneous,” said Gobind Singh Deo, acting for the four DAP representatives in the case, submitting that even the police witnesses did not know that there would be a second gathering at MBPJ.
Gobind also argued that there were several discrepancies in the prosecution’s case -- including the length of time police allowed before the dispersal order was given; and the timing of the video being different from that of the charge.
However, deputy public prosecutor How May Ling argued that any discrepancies were immaterial to the case.
“The charge is still valid. The video merely corroborates what was said previously by witnesses. The order of dispersal, whether 15 or 30 minutes, had lapsed anyway,” she said.
On September 18, 2012, a Sessions Court acquitted all 21 charged with taking part in an illegal assembly under the now-repealed Section 27 of the Police Act 1967.
Sessions Court judge Hayatul Akmal ruled that the prosecution had failed to prove a prima facie against the 21 who accused of refusing to comply with a police order to disperse in front of the Petaling Jaya City Council (MBPJ) building on November 9, 2008 between 9pm and 10.10pm.
Those charged included Catholic priest Rev Father Paulino Miranda, Petaling Jaya Utara MP Tony Pua, Selangor DAP state assemblymen Ronnie Liu and Lau Weng San, and Petaling Jaya city councillor Tiew Way Keng. They also included activists aged between 25 and 62.
The current Public Assembly Act 2012 have now greatly relaxed the laws on gatherings, allowing assemblies without the need of a police permit.
Astro Awani
Fri Apr 11 2014
Tony Pua, among the 21 respondents in the case
AWANI Ringkas: Polis sahkan Chegu Bard direman dua hari
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
AWANI 7:45 [28/04/2024] – Malaysia tumpu pelaburan baharu | Pertumbuhan saksama dan inklusif | Kajian pertubuhan buruh antarabangsa | Tabung Haji teruskan bantuan
Laporan berita padat dan ringkas #AWANI745 bersama Dzulfitri Yusof
Tumpuan #AWANI745 malam ini:
- Malaysia hadapi cabaran baharu dari negara maju, bidang teknologi, tegas PM
- Ekonomi dunia kian tidak seimbang, Tengku Zafrul di pentas forum desak negara maju lebih adil dan saksama
- 70 peratus pekerja dunia terdedah kepada penyakit akibat perubahan iklim
- Tabung Haji tanggung kos lebih RM350 juta tahun ini
Tumpuan #AWANI745 malam ini:
- Malaysia hadapi cabaran baharu dari negara maju, bidang teknologi, tegas PM
- Ekonomi dunia kian tidak seimbang, Tengku Zafrul di pentas forum desak negara maju lebih adil dan saksama
- 70 peratus pekerja dunia terdedah kepada penyakit akibat perubahan iklim
- Tabung Haji tanggung kos lebih RM350 juta tahun ini
Liek Hou rangkul dua lagi emas di Sepanyol
Jaguh badminton para negara Cheah Liek Hou terus cemerlang apabila menggondol dua pingat emas pada Kejohanan Badminton Para Sepanyol Antarabangsa II 2024 pada Sabtu.
Rakyat Malaysia di Jordan jadi duta produk PMKS negara - Ewon
Datuk Ewon Benedick menyarankan rakyat Malaysia yang menetap di Jordan supaya memainkan peranan sebagai "duta" untuk mempromosikan produk PMKS dan koperasi negara.
Fokus Minggu Depan: Solidariti Gaza Merentasi Bangsa dan Agama
Break The Siege: Fokus Minggu Depan membincangkan topik Solidariti Gaza Merentasi Bangsa dan Agama susulan penangguhan misi penghantaran bantuan ke Gaza anjuran Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC).
Lelaki rugi lebih RM13,000 terperdaya tawaran kerja dalam talian
Seorang lelaki berputih mata apabila wangnya berjumlah RM13,460 lesap setelah menjadi mangsa penipuan tawaran kerja.
Misi ditangguh, delegasi Malaysia berlepas pulang
Delegasi Malaysia dalam misi Break The Siege Freedom Flotilla To Gaza akan berlepas pulang malam ini.
Keputusan dicapai selepas Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC) tidak dapat meneruskan misi selepas Republik Guinea-Bissau menarik balik kebenaran menggunakan bendera untuk dua kapal yang digunakan.
Laporan lanjut bersama Syaff Shukri di Istanbul.
Keputusan dicapai selepas Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC) tidak dapat meneruskan misi selepas Republik Guinea-Bissau menarik balik kebenaran menggunakan bendera untuk dua kapal yang digunakan.
Laporan lanjut bersama Syaff Shukri di Istanbul.
Ustaz Wan sanggup bina tempat main boling DIY di sekolah kampung
Ustaz Wan mempunyai minat yang sangat tinggi terhadap sukan boling dan berhasrat untuk turut mengasah bakat anak muridnya.
Karnival Malaysia di New Delhi tarik 2,000 pengunjung
Pengunjung diraikan dengan persembahan kebudayaan, makanan, demonstrasi masakan, mencanting batik dan peluang merasai buah-buahan tropika Malaysia.
Anak-anak mula terima kenyataan ibu sudah tiada - Suami Nurfarahimi
"Sebagai ayah, saya menasihati mereka untuk menerima apa yang telah ditentukan Allah SWT."