The Federal Court decision to ban the usage of the word 'Allah' has left many issues unanswered, said lawyers representing the Catholic Church.
Lead counsel for the Catholic Church, Datuk Cyrus Das said that despite apex court having for the first time a seven-judges panel presiding over a 4-3 ruling, the court had failed to clarify important issues in the case such as the scope of the ban.
"I'm afraid the confusion continues as an opportunity has been lost in testing the scope of the judgement in court of appeal.
"As one of the dissenting judges (the chief justice of Sabah and Sarawak) pointed out correctly, Court of Appeal seems to suggest that it is a decision not just confined to The Herald but it is a ban generally, which means it cannot be used by Non-Muslims whether in West or East Malaysia," he told reporters.
Cyrus also pointed out that another issue that ought to have been clarified but was not was the scope of Article 3 of the Constitution, which declares Islam as religion of federation but also encompasses a guarantee that it would not affect other religions to be practiced in peace and harmony.
"That was missed out," he said.
The third issue that the Federal Court had not considered was whether the correct 'test' was applied on a minister's decision, said Cyrus.
"The problem that we had was in Court of Appeal was that they created a new test which was a fusion test which was subjectively and objective. Whereas the trend of case law has always been that the minister's decision should be open to review on an objective manner."
Astro Awani
Mon Jun 23 2014
The Federal Court decision leaves many to be desired - Astro AWANI
Pesawah dituduh buat kenyataan menghasut di WhatsApp
Seorang pesawah mengaku tidak bersalah di Mahkamah Sesyen di sini terhadap tuduhan membuat kenyataan menghasut di menerusi aplikasi WhatsApp pada Selasa.
9 tentera terbunuh nahas helikopter di Colombia
Helikopter itu terputus hubungan dengan pangkalan pada tengah hari dan kemudian didapati terhempas berhampiran daerah Santa Rosa.
Venue Piala Thomas, Uber di Chengdu dilanda 'demam' panda
Yang paling mencuri perhatian ialah magnet peti sejuk yang menampilkan Yu Rong Rong bermain badminton.
Houthi Yaman serang dua kapal pemusnah AS
Houthi berjaya menyasarkan serangan terhadap dua kapal pemusnah AS dan kapal CYCLADES di Laut Merah serta MSC Orion di Lautan Hindi pada awal Selasa.
Ringgit rendah berbanding dolar AS pada awal dagangan
Pada 9 pagi, ringgit merosot kepada 4.7665/7710 berbanding mata wang Amerika Syarikat (AS) daripada 4.7650/7700 semalam.
Bakal jemaah haji OKU syukur dipilih jadi tetamu Allah
Abdul Samad MM Abdul Aziz, 53, yang merupakan Orang Kurang Upaya (OKU) Penglihatan bersyukur dan teruja apabila dipilih seorang daripada 31,600 jemaah haji dari Malaysia tahun ini.
Pendakwa raya ICC temu bual kakitangan hospital di Gaza
Pendakwa raya dari Mahkamah Jenayah Antarabangsa (ICC) telah menemu bual kakitangan dari dua hospital terbesar di Gaza.
Israel bimbang ICC keluar waran tangkap berkait perang Gaza
Israel menyuarakan kebimbangan bahawa Mahkamah Jenayah Antarabangsa (ICC) bersiap sedia untuk mengeluarkan waran tangkap bagi pegawainya atas tuduhan berkaitan dengan pengendalian perang terhadap Hamas.
Liputan Haji: Bakal fokus kepada cabaran dan kebajikan jemaah wanita
Bagi petugas media mewakili Astro AWANI, untuk tahun ini, musim 1445 hijrah, yang terpilih ialah Editor dan Penerbit Astro AWANI, Dr Azlinariah Abdullah dan Azlinda Salim bersama 12 yang lain daripada agensi media.
Che'gubard mengaku tidak bersalah pertuduhan Akta Hasutan 1948
Dia didakwa membuat penerbitan menghasut di akaun Facebook atas nama Che'GuBard di Mutiara Villa, Bukit Bintang, Kuala Lumpur pada jam 6.30 petang 26 April lalu.
Biarawati disimpan sebagai hamba seks oleh paderi
Pope Francis mengaku buat pertama kali bahawa wujudnya skandal biarawati didera secara seksual oleh para pendeta di Gereja Katolik.