PUTRAJAYA: Clerk Sam Ke Ting's conviction for reckless driving that killed eight teen cyclists cannot stand as the charge framed against her was defective, the Court of Appeal was told today.
Her lawyer, Datuk Hisyam Teh Poh Teik, submitted that there was duplicity of the charge as the public prosecutor had included two distinct offences in the charge, namely reckless driving and driving in a dangerous manner.
"This is erroneous. Only one offence is allowed in law to be framed in the charge," he added.
Hisyam was submitted in Sam's appeal against a High Court's decision which convicted her of reckless driving and sentenced her to six years in jail and a fine.
The counsel argued that his client had been prejudiced as there was "a failure of justice" because she had been convicted of a charge not recognised in law.
"The High Court judge convicted Sam for "reckless or dangerous driving. The appellant (Sam) did not get what the law says she should get," he said before a three-member bench comprising Justices Datuk Hadhariah Syed Ismail, Datuk Hashim Hamzah and Datuk Azman Abdullah.
Sam, 27, was initially acquitted and discharged without being called to enter her defence by the Johor Bahru Magistrate's Court on Nov 18, 2019, on a charge of reckless driving that caused the death of the teenagers who were riding on modified bicycles, commonly known as basikal lajak.
The eight teenagers killed in the incident were Mohamad Azrie Danish Zulkefli, 14; Muhamad Shahrul Izzwan Azzuraimie, 14; Muhammad Firdauz Danish Mohd Azhar, 16; Fauzan Halmijan, 13; Mohamad Azhar Amir, 16; Muhammad Harith Iskandar Abdullah, 14; Muhammad Shahrul Nizam Marudin, 14 and Haizad Kasrin, 16.
She was charged with committing the offence at Jalan Lingkaran Dalam, Johor Bahru, Johor at 3.20 am on Feb 18, 2017. Sam) was 22 years old at the time of the incident.
On Feb 18, 2021, High Court judge Shahnaz Sulaiman allowed the prosecution's appeal and remitted the case back to the Magistrate's Court for Sam to enter her defence on the reckless driving charge.
On Oct 10, 2021, the Magistrate's Court discharged and acquitted Sam at the end of the defence case. The prosecution appealed to the High Court.
On April 13 last year, High Court judge Datuk Abu Bakar Katar allowed the prosecution's appeal and convicted Sam of reckless driving. Sam was sentenced to six years in jail and RM6,000 fine.
The woman then appealed to the Court of Appeal and on April 18 last year, the appellate court allowed her application to stay the execution of the jail sentence and fine and released her on bail of RM10,000 with one surety pending the hearing of her appeal.
In today's appeal hearing, Hisyam also argued that in the magistrate's court, the prosecution's case was that of reckless driving, but when the case went up before the first High Court judge, the prosecution's stand changed to dangerous driving.
Meanwhile, another of Sam's counsel, Harvinderjit Singh submitted that what happened on that day was an "emergency situation", saying that the situation was created by the victims and not Sam.
The victims were riding on modified bicycles at 3 am illegally, he said, adding that the finding of prima facie against Sam by the first High Court was wrong.
The court fixed April 11 to resume hearing after deputy public prosecutor Tengku Amir Zaki Tengku Abdul Rahman said he would take two hours to submit.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Fri Mar 31 2023
Sam Ke Ting's conviction for reckless driving that killed eight teen cyclists cannot stand as the charge framed against her was defective, the Court of Appeal was told today. - BERNAMA/Filepic
Segmen penerbangan Capital A catat 90 peratus faktor muatan, 15.4 juta penumpang pada suku pertama 2024
AAG mencatatkan prestasi yang bertambah baik dengan merekodkan faktor muatan sebanyak 90 peratus pada suku pertama 2024, mencerminkan peningkatan satu peratus tahun ke tahun.
Pegawai, anggota bomba di lima negeri ada masalah kesihatan
Ujian Kemahiran Taktikal Kebombaan diduduki seramai 12,608 anggota dan pegawai dan hanya 9,313 sahaja yang lulus.
Kerajaan komited lahirkan lebih ramai teknousahawan
Anugerah Teknousahawan TVET@KKDW diperkenalkan bagi memberi pengiktirafan serta penghargaan kepada institusi, pengajar, pelajar, graduan dan alumni yang telah menunjukkan kecemerlangan dalam bidang keusahawanan TVET.
Kedah bakal bangunkan LRT di Langkawi
Kedah merancang membina sistem tren Transit Aliran Ringan (LRT) menggunakan teknologi levitasi magnet di Langkawi
Kes pedofilia MRSM Tumpat diklasifikasikan fitnah, tiada bukti kukuh
Kes pedofilia terhadap seorang guru Maktab Rendah Sains Mara di Tumpat diklasifikasikan sebagai fitnah selepas siasatan tidak menemui bukti kukuh berhubung kes itu, kata Ketua Polis Kelantan Datuk Muhamad Zaki Harun.
Kerajaan berusaha tangani inflasi, tingkat kuasa beli rakyat
Menurut Datuk Armizan Mohd Ali, kerajaan tidak berdiam diri dalam menangani masalah inflasi termasuk melalui pelaksanaan pelbagai bentuk intervensi seperti kawalan harga.
Keutamaan negara Asia Barat untuk penuhi hasrat rakyat Palestin
Sekiranya Palestin diberikan negara dan kebebasan, mana-mana pihak tidak perlu lagi campur tangan dan tidak ada lagi konflik di Timur Tengah.
WEF gemakan wawasan, keterbukaan Malaysia dalam tiga hasrat
Mesyuarat Khas Forum Ekonomi Dunia (WEF) menjadi platform untuk Malaysia menggemakan keterbukaan jalinan kerjasama untuk melonjakkan ekonomi negara.
Hari ketiga lawatan Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim di Riyadh Arab Saudi membawa wawasan Malaysia memperkasa hubungan bilateral antara negara, selain perbincangan mengenai pelaburan dan usaha memperkasa jalinan kerjasama sedia ada.
Hari ketiga lawatan Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim di Riyadh Arab Saudi membawa wawasan Malaysia memperkasa hubungan bilateral antara negara, selain perbincangan mengenai pelaburan dan usaha memperkasa jalinan kerjasama sedia ada.
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Antara pelbagai berita luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
Berita tempatan pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Berikut adalah berita yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang Isnin, 29 April 2024.
Tragedi basikal lajak: 'Setiap detik dihantui insiden itu, saya mohon maaf' - Sam Ke Ting
Ke Ting berkata peristiwa tersebut sentiasa bermain di fikirannya malah sering tertanya-tanya mengenai kehidupan serta masa depan keluarga remaja yang terkorban akibat kemalangan itu.
Sam Ke Ting bebas tuduhan sebabkan kematian 8 remaja basikal lajak
Pada 13 April tahun lalu, Mahkamah Tinggi Johor Bahru memerintahkan kerani itu dikenakan hukuman berkenaan atas kesalahan dilakukannya pada 2017.
Kes basikal lajak: Mahkamah Rayuan diberitahu pertuduhan terhadap Sam tidak sah
Mahkamah Rayuan diberitahu bahawa sabitan Sam Ke Ting bagi kesalahan memandu secara melulu sehingga mengorbankan lapan remaja penunggang basikal tidak boleh bertahan.
Hisyam Teh ketuai pasukan peguam Sam Ke Ting dalam rayuan kes 'basikal lajak'
Hisyam Teh akan mengetuai pasukan peguam dalam rayuan Sam terhadap sabitan dan hukuman bagi kesalahan memandu melulu sehingga menyebabkab kematian remaja menunggang basikal lajak.
Kes basikal lajak: Rayuan kerani akan didengar 31 Mac tahun depan
Mahkamah Rayuan menetapkan 31 Mac tahun depan bagi mendengar rayuan Sam Ke Ting terhadap sabitan kesalahan kerana memandu secara melulu sehingga menyebabkan kematian lapan remaja.
Kes basikal lajak: Pengurusan kes bagi rayuan kerani ditetapkan 13 Okt
Tarikh baharu itu ditetapkan selepas pengurusan kes di hadapan Timbalan Pendaftar Mahkamah Rayuan Norkamilah Aziz hari ini.
Basikal lajak: Pengurusan kes selanjutnya rayuan kerani pada 28 Jun
Mahkamah Rayuan menetapkan 28 Jun bagi pengurusan kes selanjutnya dalam rayuan Sam Ke Ting terhadap sabitan dan hukuman penjaranya.
Kes basikal lajak: Sri Ram ketuai rayuan kerani
Pengurusan kes bagi rayuan Sam ditetapkan di hadapan Timbalan Pendaftar Mohd Khairi Haron pada 11 Mei.
Kes basikal lajak: Sam Ke Ting percaya kebebasan perlu dibayar dengan harga mahal
Kerani wanita, Sam Ke Ting memohon agar orang ramai tidak mempertikaikan sistem undang-undang dan kehakiman negara.
Kes basikal lajak: Sam Ke Ting dibebaskan dengan jaminan
Panel tiga hakim Mahkamah Rayuan sebulat suara membenarkan permohonan Sam untuk mengemukakan rayuan di Mahkamah Rayuan.