What do you call a multimillion-dollar, for-profit company that's run in large part by unpaid or underpaid grunt laborers? A century ago, you might've dubbed it robber-barony or sharecropping — if not, you know, outright slavery.
In 2015, though, we call it the social Web: a glorious dystopia where everybody works for likes — as in, "for free" — while a handful of tech tycoons profit.
Never has this been clearer than in the past month, as Reddit — a private company that recently accepted $50 million in venture funding — quelled an uprising among the volunteers who actually run the site: its moderators.
But insomuch as Reddit relies on digital work to run its business, it is not alone. In fact, that's basically the elevator pitch of every major Internet institution, from Twitter, Facebook and YouTube to Wikipedia. Even when these sites don't openly rely on "consumers" to create the content that keeps venture capital, ad revenue or donations pouring in, they're mining them for other sorts of resources that can be monetized: personal data, structured and aggregate data, clicks.
"Digital labor is like a meeting with free pizza and soda," quips the new media scholar Trebor Scholz, "but the Stasi is listening in."
That may seem like a dramatic analogy — the Stasi were, after all, a Cold War-era secret police — but it goes pretty far toward explaining exactly how blurred the lines have become between things we used to consider distinct: things like pizza parties and espionage. Or playing and working.
Uploading a selfie to Facebook, for instance, seems like something we do for fun. But Facebook, the very company that convinced us that online "sharing" was a natural facet of the human condition, uses that selfie to target ads and boost its profits. The same goes for leaving comments on websites, where — through a complicated system of display ads and site metrics and tracking cookies — "user" opinions just lead to more money for corporations.
There's an old Internet truism that warns, "If you're not paying, you're the product," which is almost accurate; it should really warn that, if you're not paying, you are the product or you're making it.
Justin Anthony Knapp doesn't necessarily mind that: With nearly 1.5 million contributions, the 33-year-old Wikipedian is more active on the site than literally anyone else — including members of the nonprofit Wikimedia Foundation's paid staff.
Every day, Knapp drives his 15-year-old car from Indianapolis' poorest neighborhood, where he lives, over to a restaurant on the city's West Side; he delivers pizzas to pay his bills, in between piecemeal work at a grocery store and a crisis hotline.
Every night, Knapp logs onto Wikipedia, where he's averaged 385 daily edits over the past decade. He thinks he spends a comfortable 20-plus hours a week working on the site now, but he's had a fair share of 16- or 18-hour days. Arguably, his work plays a large role in the $51 million in donations that Wikipedia scored last year — and also in the staggering $16.5 billion in revenue that Google reported in 2014. (Through its Knowledge Graph, which displays basic factual data and short answers to questions in search, Google leans heavily on Wikipedia's unpaid editors.)
And yet, though Knapp makes no salary, he claims he's getting something a lot more valuable: entertainment. Knowledge. The chance to back his values and meet new people.
"I understand that some people want to be paid to do what they love," he said on the phone from Indianapolis, driving home from his (paid) job. "But when you put a number on the thing you love, it can't be priceless. If you don't put a number on it, you assign the value and the meaning to it, yourself — you don't negotiate that with the market."
Sociologists call this kind of value "affective currency," and it's what keeps many of the social Web's most prolific unpaid workers in the posting, moderating or editing game. Even when the time commitment becomes incredible — some would say insane — they argue they're "compensated" accordingly, whether in pleasure or new knowledge or what Scholz calls their "15 megabytes of fame."
"What's in it for me?" asked a Reddit moderator who goes by the name Soupy Hands and spends as many as 40 hours a week moderating more than 400 communities. "For one, there's the feeling of accomplishment that comes with having the power to make a community better."
For another? "I also enjoy the camaraderie."
Soupy Hands belongs to a network of mods — they run all the wildly popular "SFW" porn Reddits, like r/spaceporn, for space images, and r/foodporn, for food photography — and they oversee their 10 million subscribers pretty collaboratively.
Can something truly be called exploitative, or even labor, if the exploited parties enjoy it? That's a difficult question and one that theorists haven't conclusively answered yet.
And still, there's plenty to suggest that different sorts of labor arrangements would be really good for users and the sites they work on. When people aren't paid for their work, for instance, the only people who can contribute are the ones who (a) have money from other sources or (b) are overwhelmingly compelled by motivations like power, popularity or revenge. (The writer and tech theorist David Banks has implied this is one of the reasons that Reddit skews so heavily young and male.)
It also sets up a sort of precarious structural imbalance between a site's corporate management and its class of worker bees: In order to keep them, the site must keep paying out a stream of "affective currency." But if users stop getting good vibes from the site, or feel as though they've been treated badly, there's no reason for them to continue working. They can, as Redditors did over the July 4 weekend, declare themselves fed up and shut down the site entirely.
"The Reddit incident shows that volunteers who perform all the vital 'playbor' are less and less likely to take it much longer," Scholz said. "They want a slice of the pie or they might form their own platform."
No one knows what a slice of the pie would look like, or even if editors would take it — particularly on Reddit, where pay-for-play moderation schemes raise a host of suspicions. In a 2014 essay, the Wikipedian and archivist Dorothy Howard proffered one idea: a sort of "Partner Program," similar to YouTube's, that compensates super-editors and mods for the role they play in the site's function. Scholz, the new media scholar, has also advocated a movement called "platform cooperativism," wherein digital workers self-organize to demand compensation and worker-owned platforms, the same way the traditional labor movement did a century and a half ago.
Should these options fall through, of course, Internet history suggests a litigious alternative: In the late 1990s, AOL's chatroom moderators sued the company for back wages, claiming the "fun" "opt-in" volunteer work they did constituted an actual job.
Ten years later, AOL paid up: $15 million.
The Washington Post
Sat Jul 25 2015
A century ago, a company run by unpaid laborers are called slavery but today it is called social Web.
Serangan Balai Polis Ulu Tiram: Jenazah dua anggota dituntut keluarga
Jenazah Ahmad Azza dan Muhamad Syafiq dibawa ke Masjid Tunku Laksamana Abdul Jalil, IPK Johor untuk disembahyangkan dan diberi penghormatan terakhir.
[TERKINI] Sidang media KDN berhubung serangan balai polis
Ikuti sidang media Menteri Dalam Negeri, Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail, pasca serangan balai polis yang berlaku pada Jumaat.
Serangan Balai Polis Ulu Tiram: Penyerang tiada agenda besar, bertindak sendirian - Saifuddin
"Penyerang ini bertindak bersendirian atau kita sebut sebagai lone wolf. Driven by motivation yang dia faham, sebab dia tak bercampur dengan orang."
Maklumat awal mendapati pelaku bertindak secara bersendirian
Maklumat awal mendapati bahawa pelaku merupakan warganegara Malaysia berusia 21 tahun dan tidak mempunyai rekod lampau serta melakukan tindakan tersebut secara bersendirian.
#AWANInews
#AWANInews
Henti sebarang spekulasi, beri ruang polis jalankan siasatan
Menteri Dalam Negeri Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail menasihatkan orang awam supaya menghentikan sebarang spekulasi berhubung kes tembakan di Balai Polis Ulu Tiram, Johor Bahru.
#AWANInews
#AWANInews
Mayat lelaki ditemui di sempadan Mexico- AS, cetus ketakutan migran lain
Pejabat pendakwa raya di utara Mexico menyiasat kematian seorang migran di sebuah lokasi bersempadan dengan Amerika Syarikat (AS) pada Jumaat.
AWANI Ringkas: Sektor petrokimia dan penyelesaian tenaga hijau bersih
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Serangan Balai Polis Ulu Tiram: Tujuh individu dibawa ke mahkamah untuk reman
Tujuh individu yang dipercayai mempunyai kaitan dengan serangan di Balai Polis Ulu Tiram dibawa ke Mahkamah Majistret Johor Bahru hari ini.
AWANI Pagi: Pameran Palet Budaya: Interaksi seni & Gastronomi
Makanan dan seni visual mungkin kedengaran agak janggal untuk disatukan, tetapi itulah keunikan Pameran Palet Budaya: Interaksi Seni & Gastronomi.
Ikuti bingkisan disediakan penyampai AWANI Pagi, Azib Zikry dalam membedah karya-karya unik, khazanah seni negara.
Ikuti bingkisan disediakan penyampai AWANI Pagi, Azib Zikry dalam membedah karya-karya unik, khazanah seni negara.
AWANI Pagi: Berita tumpuan & menarik di astroawani.com [18 Mei 2024]
Fokus Awani Pagi bersama Nursyazwani Saiful Sham & Azib Zikry;
Dua anggota polis maut diserang lelaki bertopeng di Balai Polis Ulu Tiram
Polis siasat ancaman Jemaah Islamiyah dalam negara
Sekitar Kapas Marang Swimathon 2024
Dua anggota polis maut diserang lelaki bertopeng di Balai Polis Ulu Tiram
Polis siasat ancaman Jemaah Islamiyah dalam negara
Sekitar Kapas Marang Swimathon 2024
PM ucap Hari Guru, rakam jutaan penghargaan buat warga pendidik
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim hari ini mengucapkan Selamat Hari Guru kepada seluruh warga pendidik yang gigih membina bangsa.
Ahmad Zahid ucap tahniah atas pelantikan Lawrence Wong sebagai PM Singapura
Timbalan Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi menzahirkan ucapan tahniah atas pelantikan Lawrence Wong sebagai Perdana Menteri Singapura yang baharu.
Gelap mata untung lumayan, warga emas rugi RM412,500
Lelaki warga emas itu melakukan beberapa transaksi berjumlah RM412,500 kepada empat akaun berbeza baru-baru ini bagi menerima pulangan dan keuntungan berkenaan.
Anwar hulur bantuan kepada keluarga Pak Amjal aktivis awal reformasi
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim menghulurkan bantuan kepada isteri aktivis awal reformasi Jalaluddin Ab Manaf yang menghidap penyakit angin ahmar.
NRES rancang lestarikan industri plastik sekali guna elak pencemaran
Kementerian Sumber Asli dan Kelestarian Alam (NRES) merancang untuk melestarikan industri plastik sekali guna menerusi satu peralihan yang seimbang dalam bidang itu.
Anwar harap terminal baharu LTSIP jana lebih banyak peluang ekonomi di Kelantan
Anwar Ibrahim berharap terminal baharu Lapangan Terbang Sultan Ismail Petra (LTSIP) fasa satu, yang mula beroperasi semalam, mampu menjana lebih banyak peluang ekonomi di Kelantan.
Terima anugerah Reader's Digest buat kali kelima, Ahmad Zahid ucap tahniah kepada Kemas
Timbalan Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi mengucapkan tahniah kepada Jabatan Kemajuan Masyarakat (Kemas) yang meraih Anugerah Jenama Paling Dipercayai buat kali kelima bagi kategori Pu
AIM menang Anugerah Industri Kewangan Islam Global
AIM memenangi anugerah Islamic Finance News apabila dinobat IFN Best Islamic Microfinance Institution, serta menerima dua anugerah di bawah Global Good Governance Awards (3G).
Pulau Pinang akan bincang, teliti kenaikan gaji penjawat awam negeri - Chow
Kerajaan Pulau Pinang akan membincangkan mengenai kenaikan gaji penjawat awam di negeri itu pada Majlis Mesyuarat Kerajaan Negeri akan datang, menurut Ketua Menteri Chow Kon Yeow.
Jambatan Bailey di Jalan Kuantan-Segamat dibuka semula hari ini
Jambatan Bailey di Seksyen 102 Jalan Kuantan-Segamat yang ditutup sebelum ini untuk kerja-kerja pembaikan dibuka semula bermula 4 petang tadi.