PARIS - France was supposed to be next.
Following the seismic shocks of the Brexit referendum and the victory of Donald Trump, commentators worldwide fixed their sights on the French presidential election as the next potential populist upheaval. But it never happened. Emmanuel Macron, the centrist, pro-European Union candidate, demolished Marine Le Pen, the far-right ultranationalist, in a landslide victory.
"Everyone told us it would be impossible," Macron declared Sunday of his victory, to a crowd that erupted in cheers. "But they did not know France."
Why did right-wing populism fall flat on its face in France, a country that would seem such a fertile breeding ground?
The country, after all, has had double-digit unemployment for years. It has been rocked by terrorist attacks - perpetrated mostly by Islamist militants. In the aftermath of that violence, there has been a strong anti-immigrant backlash.
But compared with Britain and the United States, analysts say, there were two important factors that helped explain why the center held in France: the country's history and a lower level of inequality.
French voters were clearly ready to back a political outsider. But for many, the National Front - Le Pen's party - did not represent change in the same way that Trump did in the United States. Co-founded in 1972 by Le Pen's father, the convicted Holocaust denier Jean-Marie Le Pen, the party has existed on the margins of public life for decades. Its identity is well known.
"The rejection of Le Pen was a basic rejection of the extreme right and its racist, anti-Muslim sentiment," said Vivien Schmidt, an expert in French and European politics at Boston University. "In a country that's already experienced the extreme right in power before, you can put the rejection of Le Pen in a direct line with the rejection of Vichy."
The Vichy government assumed power after France fell to Nazi Germany in 1940. Although Vichy is infamous in France for having complied with German demands to deport tens of thousands of Jews to death camps, the regime also passed a slew of anti-Jewish regulations on its own.
Although the younger Le Pen sought to change the National Front's reputation for anti-Semitism and racism, her efforts were undermined by revelations in French media that several of its high-ranking members had committed variations of Holocaust denial. In a poll conducted before the election, 58 percent of voters said that the National Front presented a "threat to democracy."
At Macron's victory party outside Paris's Louvre Museum, many described their primary emotion as relief, rather than excitement.
Simon Moos, 18, a high school student, braved the unseasonable chill to catch a glimpse of Macron at the rally, even though he had not supported the candidate in the first round of the election.
"I'm relieved, honestly," he said. "Really relieved. France will remain France. I'd cut my throat before Le Pen was president."
In terms of economics, analysts said, the populist platform was likely less appealing in a country where a strong, centralized state has maintained a variety of social benefits.
Despite a recently widened gap between rich and poor, France still trails the ratios of Britain and the United States, according to statistics from the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.
In the 1980s, Ronald Reagan in the United States and Margaret Thatcher in Britain, both conservatives, began implementing reforms intended to stimulate economic growth, including deregulation, privatization, free trade, fiscal austerity and cuts in government spending. Some of these ideas were ultimately incorporated in the platforms of their more liberal successors.
France adopted some of those "neoliberal" reforms in the 1980s. But it never relinquished its statist economy and especially its extensive system of welfare protections in the same way, said Daniel Stedman-Jones, a historian and the author of an acclaimed study of neoliberalism.
"It may be no surprise that we see this populist backlash against globalization and immigration in the U.K. and the U.S., because these were the countries where Thatcher and Reagan introduced the most radical neoliberal policies," said Schmidt. "You had them in France to some degree, but never to the same extent."
Although Marine Le Pen was a staunch defender of France's famous welfare state, she did not benefit from a swelling tide of protest votes. Le Pen received roughly 34 percent of the ballots cast, but a larger percentage of voters abstained or turned in blank ballots.
"People may be feeling insecure and left behind, but the situation is not nearly as bad" as in other countries, Schmidt said.
There is also the reality that the National Front did not have a monopoly on the populist market, others said, pointing to the astonishing rise of Jean-Luc Mélenchon, a far leftist who advocated withdrawing from NATO. He did not make it past the first round.
"In France, we have two populisms - one of the extreme right, but another of the extreme left. To understand this, you have to understand the history of France," said Michel Wieviroka, a sociologist. "This is essentially the legacy of the old Communist Party. Britain never had that same history, and neither did the U.S."
Perhaps the most visceral challenge to France's political establishment in recent years has been terrorism. More than 230 people have died here in terrorist attacks in the last two years, many committed by men from immigrant backgrounds who held French or other EU passports.
Despite the rise in popularity of Le Pen's anti-immigrant platform in the aftermath of these attacks, most French voters seem to have rejected her appeals to sharply reduce immigration, at least for the moment.
Antoine Leiris, a French journalist, lost his wife, Hélène, in the Islamic State attack on the Bataclan concert hall in Paris in November 2015. In a best-selling book, Leiris addressed the extremists who murdered his wife: "You will not have my hate," he wrote.
The same message, he said in an interview, emerged from the 2017 election.
"Despite these horrible attacks, the French chose intelligence and wisdom," he said.
The Washington Post
Tue May 09 2017
Emmanuel Macron arrives on stage with his wife Brigitte Trogneux to deliver a speech after early results in the first round of 2017 French presidential election, France, April 23, 2017. REUTERS/Philippe Wojazer
PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu: Tiada aduan sogokan, salah guna jentera kerajaan - SPR
Suruhanjaya Pilihan Raya (SPR) setakat ini belum lagi menerima aduan rasmi mengenai wujud sogokan kepada pengundi dan salah guna jentera kerajaan dalam kempen Pilihan Raya Kecil (PRK) DUN KKB.
Pengumuman pelaburan Google di Malaysia dalam masa terdekat - Tengku Zafrul
Kementerian Pelaburan, Perdagangan dan Industri (MITI) mengesahkan satu pengumuman berkenaan pelaburan Google di Malaysia akan dilakukan dalam masa terdekat.
Aksi Sumbangsih JDT, Selangor FC kekal Jumaat ini
Perlawanan Sumbangsih musim 2024/2025 bagi merebut Piala Sultan Haji Ahmad Shah antara JDT dan Selangor FC kekal Jumaat ini.
Kes serangan Akhyar, Faisal tiada kaitan - Polis
Polis berkata, tidak ada hubung kait antara kes samun Akhyar dan Faisal Halim yang disimbah asid.
Kes simbah asid: Tindakan melampau, tidak beradab jangan dibiarkan berulang
Tindakan melampau dan tidak beradab pihak yang terlibat menyimbah asid ke pemain bola sepak kebangsaan, Faisal Halim sepatutnya jangan dibiarkan berulang lagi.
Keadaan Faisal kritikal, tangan kiri sukar bergerak
KEADAAN pemain sayap kebangsaan, Faisal Halim dilaporkan berada dalam keadaan kritikal susulan kesan asid yang disimbah kepadanya dalam kejadian di sebuah pusat beli belah di Petaling Jaya.
Perlawanan Piala Sumbangsih kekal berlangsung
Perlawanan Sumbangsih musim 2024/2025 bagi merebut Piala Sultan Haji Ahmad Shah antara juara bertahan Liga Super, Johor Darul Ta’zim (JDT) dan Selangor FC di Stadium Sultan Ibrahim, Iskandar Puteri di Johor akan kekal berlangsung Jumaat ini.
Isu tanah kubur Selat Klang: Waris, ahli keluarga mohon tangguh lagi
Waris dan ahli keluarga mendakwa tiada kata sepakat dicapai pada perjumpaan tertutup bagi membincangkan isu pengalihan tanah kubur di Selat Klang pada Ahad lalu.
[TERKINI] Seorang lagi suspek kes simbah asid Faisal Halim ditahan
Seorang lagi individu ditahan dipercayai mempunyai kaitan melibatkan kes simbah asid terhadap pemain bola sepak kebangsaan, Faisal Halim di sebuah pasar raya dekat Kota Damansara, Ahad lalu.
Pantau Belanjawan: Strategi Pembanterasan Rasuah Nasional (NACS)
Theresa May umum letak jawatan PM Britain
May akan kekal sebagai Perdana Menteri sementara menantikan penggantinya dipilih dalam proses dua tahap yang menyaksikan dua calon akhir berhadapan undian 125,000 anggota Parti Konservatif.