KUALA LUMPUR: As the cobweb of China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) extends its reach across continents, fostering economic ties and promising infrastructure development and prosperity, nations worldwide are diligently assessing their individual stakes in this groundbreaking blueprint.
Positioned at the crossroads of East and West, Malaysia finds itself at a critical juncture, poised to make decisions that will decisively shape its future.
The undeniable allure of the BRI is evident: this initiative has made its economic mark in 140 countries and international organizations, with China's foreign direct investment in these nations surpassing a staggering USD 1.016 trillion earlier this year.
Surely, Malaysia wants a slice of the pie. Nonetheless, it is imperative to delve beneath the surface of the ostensible economic shine and critically evaluate the underlying factors at play.
Malaysia's geopolitical trump card lies within the Malacca Strait, which has historically served as the lifeblood of global commerce.
Consider this: one-quarter of the world's traded goods traverse this narrow channel, generating a mind-boggling annual value of USD 5.3 trillion.
It is certainly no exaggeration to regard Malaysia's geographic position as a cornerstone of global trade.
However, with Thailand's land bridge project, supported by the BRI, offering a shorter route that bypasses the Malacca Strait, Malaysia stands at the precipice of potentially witnessing a significant diversion of this vital traffic.
Meanwhile, the South China Sea dispute represents a more contentious turn of events. Despite the Permanent Court of Arbitration's invalidation of China's nine-dash line in 2016—an assertion that claims a significant portion of the South China Sea—territorial tensions have seen little respite. Malaysia, bolstered by the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), maintains legitimate territorial claims that intersect with China's assertions.
A peaceful resolution based on laws is indisputably in the best interest of the ASEAN community, but the overwhelming influence of the BRI may further complicate this already delicate situation.
Debt will always remain as a looming concern, particularly due to the potential risks associated with the BRI's perceived "debt traps," a notion that resonates with participating countries.
Sri Lanka's Hambantota port scenario, often cited as an example, has engendered a tangible apprehension that nations might unwittingly trade their sovereign assets in exchange for unsustainable debt burdens.
Malaysia itself bears a national debt that hovers at 60.4% of its GDP, a figure that necessarily demands caution when embarking upon large-scale economic endeavors, no matter how imperative it is.
However, it is not all doom and gloom. Bilateral trade between Malaysia and China soared to an impressive RM 203.6 billion in 2022.
The BRI's involvement holds the potential to further amplify this already remarkable figure. Nonetheless, the emphasis must undoubtedly be on quality rather than quantity. Is it sufficient to merely boast staggering trade numbers, or should the focus also encompass the creation of local job opportunities and the nurturing of domestic industries?
One must bear in mind that the propensity of the initiative to favor Chinese contractors, with 89% of BRI projects employing them according to the Peterson Institute for International Economics, may not necessarily bode well for Malaysia's local economic landscape.
Furthermore, the environmental repercussions should not be disregarded. Malaysia's priceless biodiversity-rich regions, such as Borneo, may find themselves under the radar for potential infrastructure projects, bringing with them the looming risk of ecological imbalances.
If not addressed immediately, the Southeast Asian region confronts environmental costs that could potentially escalate to a staggering $2 trillion by 2100.
While Malaysia's participation in the BRI is laden with immense economic opportunities, it is inextricably intertwined with a complex web of geopolitical, environmental, and legal challenges. As the nation charts its course forward, striking an optimal balance between economic aspirations and long-term sovereignty stands as a paramount objective.
The responsibility lies with Putrajaya to ensure that while the modern incarnation of the Silk Road promises prosperity, it does not come at the expense of the nation's core values and fundamental strengths.
* Ahmad Zaim Ahmad Tawfek was an assistant to Federal ministers in formulating economic, youth and foreign policies for Malaysia.
** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
AWANI Columnist
Mon Oct 30 2023
This handout photo taken and released by the Philippine Navy on May 12, 2015. Photo for illustration purposes. File pic by AFP
Tumpuan Selasa - 30 April 2024
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan di Astro AWANI.
SC, IsDB jalin bersama majukan pasaran modal Islam dan kewangan sosial
SC hari ini memeterai MoU dengan IsDB, sekali gus membuka ruang kerjasama lebih erat dalam ICM dan meluaskan jangkauan teknologi kewangan (fintech) dan kewangan sosial Islam, terutama wakaf.
Hamidin sedia terima kritikan, terbuka dicabar
Presiden Persatuan Bolasepak Malaysia (FAM) Datuk Hamidin Mohd Amin tidak terkecil hati dan sedia menerima kritikan mana-mana pihak termasuk bekas Timbalan Presiden FAM Khairy Jamaluddin.
Bekas penjawat awam ditahan kes tipu tanah rizab Melayu
Penipuan itu menyebabkan pemecahan lot Tanah Rizab Melayu melibatkan kawasan seluas kira-kira 649.2 hektar.
Perintah bela diri Bung Moktar, isteri bercanggah dengan keterangan di mahkamah
Dua saksi penting pendakwaan telah dengan jelas menyatakan bahawa tiada unsur suapan wujud dalam kes itu.
Kerajaan komited pastikan pelaburan LTAT hasilkan pulangan konsisten - Mohamed Khaled
Kerajaan komited untuk memastikan pelaburan yang dibuat oleh Lembaga Tabung Angkatan Tentera (LTAT) dalam syarikat domestik dan antarabangsa menghasilkan pulangan yang konsisten dan kukuh.
Kes demam denggi meningkat pada ME16, empat kematian dilaporkan
Kes demam denggi dilaporkan meningkat kepada 2,321 kes pada Minggu Epidemiologi ke-16 (ME16) iaitu bagi tempoh 14 April hingga 20 April lepas.
KFC tutup sementara sejumlah cawangan, pindah pekerja tempat lain
QSR Brands bagaimanapun tidak mendedahkan jumlah cawangan KFC Malaysia yang telah ditutup buat sementara waktu dan bilangan pekerja yang terjejas.
Nor Farah Ain tidak percaya bergelar juara dunia
Atlet boling pada negara Nor Farah Ain Abdullah masih tidak percaya sudah bergelar juara dunia pada penampilan sulungnya di Kejohanan Boling Padang Dalam Dewan Dunia 2024 di Guernsey, Channel Islands
Program Jana Wibawa dilaksana selepas dapat persetujuan Jemaah Menteri - Saksi
Mahkamah Sesyen di sini hari ini diberitahu bahawa cadangan mengenai Jana Wibawa telah dibawa ke mesyuarat untuk pertimbangan sebelum Jemaah Menteri memutuskan supaya program itu diteruskan pada 2020.
Piala Thomas: Malaysia tempah slot ke suku akhir
Malaysia berjaya menempah slot ke suku akhir selepas menewaskan Algeria dengan kemenangan 5-0 dalam saingan Piala Thomas di Chengdu, China sebentar tadi.
Boling padang: Daripada jaguh kampung, Farah Ain kini bergelar jaguh dunia!
Farah Ain berjaya menempatkan dirinya di puncak dunia dengan menggondol pingat emas perseorangan wanita di Kejohanan Boling Padang Dalam Dewan Dunia, Guernsey.
Piala Uber: Malaysia tewas kepada Taiwan
Malaysia memulakan kempen Kumpulan B Piala Uber 2024 mereka dengan langkah kiri apabila tewas 1-4 kepada Taiwan, di sini hari ini.
Jabatan Pengajian Antarabangsa dan Strategik UM mohon maaf kepada seluruh rakyat Malaysia
Dalam satu kenyataan pada Sabtu, jabatan itu menegaskan pihaknya kesal dan memandang serius terhadap perkara itu.
Piala Thomas: 'Kemenangan ke atas Hong Kong lonjak keyakinan' - Jun Hao
Kem perseorangan negara Piala Thomas 2024 berjaya membuktikan kemampuan mereka, sekurang-kurangnya selepas mengetepikan pemain Hong Kong dalam aksi pembukaan Kumpulan D hari ini.
Thomas Cup: Permulaan cemerlang buat Malaysia
Malaysia bermula cemerlang pada perlawanan pembukaan Piala Thomas 2024, dengan menewaskan Hong Kong 5-0 hari ini.
'Made in Malaysia' - Apple punyai 19 kilang pembekal di negara ini
Malaysia merupakan salah satu negara yang mempunyai beberapa kilang pembekal yang menawarkan komponen kepada Apple.
Freedom Flotilla to Gaza: 'Berhadapan tekanan Israel, FCC tiada istilah putus asa'
Pemeriksaan kapal penumpang, Akdeniz (Mediterranean) yang terlibat dalam misi Break The Siege Freedom Flotilla to Gaza dilaporkan sedang berjalan.
Malaysia, Jepun perkukuh kerjasama strategik dalam sektor binaan - Nanta
Kerajaan Malaysia dan Jepun memperkukuhkan kerjasama strategik dalam sektor teknologi dan digitalisasi pembinaan, infrastruktur jalan, pengurusan bencana dan cerun.
Malaysia, Jepun perkukuh kerjasama dalam sektor pembinaan
Kedua-dua negara juga berhasrat memperkukuhkan kerjasama mengenai perkongsian maklumat dalam pengurusan dan penyelenggaraan lebuh raya, cerun serta pertukaran tenaga kepakaran dan teknikal.