The FBI intends to tell the White House this week that its understanding of how a third party hacked the iPhone of a shooter in San Bernardino, California, is so limited that there's no point in undertaking a government review of whether the tool should be shared with Apple, officials said.
The decision, said officials familiar with the discussion who spoke on the condition of anonymity, ends several weeks of internal debate by bureau lawyers and technical experts about the FBI's obligation to disclose the method.
Last month, the FBI paid more than $1 million for a tool to crack an iPhone used by one of the shooters in California. But the contract did not include rights to the software flaws that went into the tool, officials said.
READ: FBI paid more than $1 million to crack the San Bernardino iPhone
As a result, the bureau has a limited technical understanding of how the method worked, officials said.
On Tuesday, FBI Director James Comey acknowledged the internal debate.
"The threshold is: Are we aware of the vulnerability, or did we just buy a tool and don't have sufficient knowledge of the vulnerability that would implicate the process?" he said at a cyber conference at Georgetown University.
Comey was referring to a process, led by the White House, in which agencies such as the FBI, National Security Agency (NSA) and Homeland Security Department debate whether to disclose a computer software flaw discovered by the government to the software maker so the company can fix it.
Most flaws are disclosed, the White House has said. But some are kept secret so that the law enforcement or intelligence agency can use them in intelligence-gathering or criminal investigations.
The FBI's decision to not submit to a review of the method used in the San Bernardino case was first reported by the Wall Street Journal.
Some security experts said the bureau or the NSA could reverse-engineer the tool to gain information about the flaws. But the bureau was not likely to do so, several officials said.
"If what we have bought is a tool and we've said that we won't reverse-engineer the tool such that you can figure out what vulnerability is used to make the tool work, then even if we wanted to disclose something, there's nothing we can disclose," one senior administration official said.
The FBI recovered the iPhone of Syed Rizwan Farook, one of the shooters in the December terrorist attack in San Bernardino but could not access the data on it because it did not know Farook's passcode. In February, the Justice Department obtained a court order to force Apple to write software that would disable several phone security features so the FBI could try to crack the code.
Apple challenged the order, arguing that the court had no basis to issue it and that it would set a dangerous precedent. In late March, the FBI disclosed that a third-party had come forward with a tool to help it gain access to the phone and so it no longer needed the court order to force Apple's assistance.
Security and privacy advocates then began to push the bureau to disclose to Apple the flaws on which the tool was based so the tech giant could repair them.
Last month, professional hackers or vulnerabilities researchers brought flaws they had found to a company whose name the FBI has not disclosed.
Apple has said it will not press for the vulnerabilities to be disclosed.
"We're confident that the vulnerability the government alleges to have found will have a short shelf life," a lawyer for Apple told reporters earlier this month. "In our normal process . . . we'll continue to improve the phones and at some point this fix will get implemented."
The Washington Post
Wed Apr 27 2016
Last month, the FBI paid more than $1 million for a tool to crack an iPhone used by one of the shooters in California.
Stability AI dilapor dalam perbincangan jual syarikat
Mengikut laporan, Stability AI telah kerugian lebih $30 juta, dan mempunyai hutang hampir $100 juta dari segi bil untuk membayar pelayan dan sebagainya.
Kronologi anggota polis maut diserang lelaki bertopeng di Balai Polis Ulu Tiram
"Polis percaya kes tembakan di Balai Polis Ulu Tiram, Johor yang mengorbankan dua anggota pasukan keselamatan itu ada kaitan dengan kumpulan pengganas, Jemaah Islamiah (JI)," menurut Ketua Polis Negara, Tan Sri Razarudin Husain.
#AWANInews
#AWANInews
Ronaldo tiada hasrat untuk bersara, masih berminat teruskan karier
Pada usia 39 tahun, Ronaldo masih mempunyai motivasi yang tinggi untuk bersaing dengan "singa muda."
Meta uji paparan web untuk Threads dengan rekaan umpama Tweetdeck
Dengan langkah ini, pengguna boleh menyusun pelbagai lajur-lajur berbeza dan memantaunya dengan mudah melalui hanya satu paparan.
AFC sokong saranan gantung Israel
Presiden AFC suarakan sokongan terhadap usul Persatuan Bola Sepak Palestin agar Israel digantung daripada FIFA berikutan serangan tidak berpenghujung di Gaza.
Niaga SPOTLIGHT: Economic Impacts of Extreme Heat
[TERKINI] Sidang media IGP berhubung serangan di Balai Polis Ulu Tiram
Ikuti sidang media Ketua Polis Negara, Tan Sri Razarudin Husain berhubung kes serangan lelaki bertopeng di Balai Polis Ulu Tiram, Johor Bahru.
#AWANInews
#AWANInews
Bursa Malaysia dibuka tinggi
Pada 9.05 pagi, FTSE Bursa Malaysia KLCI (FBM KLCI) meningkat 2.38 mata kepada 1,613.49 daripada 1,611.11 semalam.
Tayar pecah punca nahas tiga lori di Lebuhraya PLUS
Pemandu yang maut dikenal pasti sebagai Hoo Yoon Wah, 61 tahun.
Filem berbahasa Dusun, 'Sinakagon' bakal ke pawagam 13 Jun ini
'Sinakagon' bukan sahaja mengangkat bahasa dan budaya kaum Dusun ke layar perak tetapi juga menawarkan jalan cerita yang menarik.
Pengguna iOS 17.5 dapati foto lama dipadam muncul kembali
Mereka terkejut melihat gambar yang telah bertahun dipadam, tiba-tiba muncul sebagai gambar yang baru dimuat naik ke iCloud.
iOS 17.5, Android 6 ke atas kini boleh banteras penyalahgunaan penjejak objek
Google telah memperkenalkan ciri ini sejak Julai tahun lepas, t i
Apple dilapor semakin hampir dalam kerjasama guna teknologi OpenAI pada iOS 18
Selain OpenAI, Apple turut berbincang bersama Google untuk penggunaan Gemini pada iOS 18, tetapi masih belum mencapai tahap perbincangan seperti OpenAI setakat ini.
Apple dijangka kemas kini Siri dengan keupayaan AI generatif
Siri baharu ini akan boleh berbual dengan lebih baik, dan mempunyai keupayaan menyambung pelbagai perbualan dan bukan sekadar menjawab soalan sahaja.
Apple mohon maaf selepas iklan iPad Pro guris perasaan
Apple memohon maaf kerana menghasilkan iklan itu kerana ia dilihat sebagai bersikap tidak sensitif terhadap artis.
Apple perkenal cip pemprosesan Apple M4
Apple M4 hadir dengan 4 teras CPU prestasi bersama 6 teras CPU efisien, selain 10 teras GPU untuk penawaran grafik yang baik melaluinya.
Apple sedang bangunkan cip kendiri untuk jalankan perisian AI
Cip AI kendiri ini akan digunakan di pusat data Apple dengan ini
Google bayar Apple hingga AS$20 bilion pada 2022, kekal enjin carian utama Safari
Google sedia bekerjasama dengan Apple untuk menjadi enjin carian utama dan pembayaran dilihat meningkat dari tahun ke tahun.
Apple dijangka tambah ciri AI pada Safari melalui iOS 18
Ciri kecerdasan buatan pada Safari kelak akan memudahkan beberapa proses pelayaran.
Apple Pencil baharu hadir dengan sistem haptik
Apabila digunakan pada skrin iPad, pengguna boleh merasakan tindak balas haptik seakan menggunakan pensel sebenar.