TikTok is one of the top five social media platforms in the world this year.
In Southeast Asia last year, 198 million people, about 29% of the region’s population, used TikTok. It is not an exaggeration to say the platform has become one of, if not the souk of ideas and opinions for the people in the region.
Like other interested scholars, my research team was also intrigued to look into TikTok. Specifically, we wanted to look at how information, including political misinformation and disinformation, flows on the platform. The distinction between the two forms of false information is that disinformation is intentionally, maliciously misleading.
During our eight months’ research, we found tracking political misinformation and disinformation on TikTok quite challenging. This was despite the fact the platform launched a fact-checking program in 2020 in partnership with independent fact-checking organisations that would “help review and assess the accuracy of content” on the platform.
Under this program, TikTok surfaces potential misinformation to its partners. It may include videos flagged by TikTok users for misinformation, or those related to COVID-19 or other topics “about which the spread of misleading information is common”.
However, we still find difficulties tracking misinformation and disinformation on the platform, such as fact-checking audiovisual content and identifying foreign languages and terms.
It is difficult to fact-check audiovisual content on TikTok.
To effectively track mis/disinformation, all content should be watched carefully and understood based on local context. To ensure the correct assessment, this required long hours of human observation and video analysis (observing language, nonverbal cues, terms, images, text and captions).
This is why fact-checkers globally rely on public participation to report misleading content, aside from having the human fact-checkers focusing on verifying mainly viral content.
AI technology can help verify some of these posts. However, fact-checking audiovisual content still relies heavily on human assessment for accuracy.
To date, audiovisual content is arguably one of the most challenging formats to fact-check across the world. Other social media platforms face the same challenge.
In our research, we found much of the content monitored contained no verifiable claims. This meant it could not be objectively corroborated, or debunked and tagged as misinformation.
To determine which videos or comments contained inaccurate claims, we developed a misinformation framework based on the criteria for determining verifiable statements used by VERA Files in the Philippines and Tirto.id in Indonesia. Both organisations are signatories of Poynter’s International Fact-Checking Network.
We also considered the 10-point list of red flags and tips in identifying misinformation provided by Colleen Sinclair, an associate professor of clinical psychology at the Mississippi State University.
Using this misinformation framework, we found the majority of the videos and corresponding comments monitored carried mere subjective statements (opinion, calls to action, speculation) or were difficult to verify due to a lack of feasibility.
Examples included comments on Indonesia’s controversial new Labour Law known as the Omnibus Law, debates on the inappropriateness of rape jokes in schools which initiated #MakeSchoolASaferPlace movement in Malaysia, arguments surrounding poor government policies in Malaysia amid COVID-19 which started another online campaign #kerajaangagal, and the Philippines Anti-Terrorism Law.
These comments were deemed not verifiable, since they were emotionally driven and based on users’ opinions of the issues. Therefore, they could not be tagged as containing or possibly containing mis/disinformation.
These findings could be different if content creators and video commentators integrated statements of fact or “feasible claims” that we could cross-check with credible and authoritative sources.
Some fact-checkers and researchers have previously noted that diverse languages and dialects in the region have made fact-checking difficult for local agencies.
In this study, we likewise found that slang makes it harder to track political mis/disinformation on TikTok even when we analyse content uploaded in our mother tongue.
Factors like generational gaps and lack of awareness of trendy slang and jargon used by content creators and users should not be underestimated in fact-checking content on the platform. Undoubtedly, this will also be an issue for AI-driven fact-checking mechanisms.
During our research, we realised that tracking misinformation on the platform can be a bit more challenging for the research team and common people.
Unless you are a data scientist with the ability to code Python API to collect data, scraping data on TikTok would require manual labour.
For this project, our team opted for the latter, considering most of our members were not equipped with data science skills. We tracked misinformation on the platform by manually mapping out relevant hashtags through TikTok’s search function.
A downside we observed in using this strategy is that it can be time-consuming due to the search function’s limitations.
For one, TikTok’s Discover tab allows users to sort the results according only to relevance and/or total number of likes. They can’t sort results by the total number of views, shares and/or comments.
It also allows one to filter results by date of upload, but only for the last six months. This makes searching for older data, as in our case, difficult.
As such, we had to manually sift through the entries to find relevant videos with the most views or highest number of engagements uploaded within our chosen monitoring period.
This made the process quite overwhelming, especially for the hashtags that yielded thousands (or more) of TikTok videos.
TikTok should be thinking of improving its platform to allow users to filter and sort through videos in search results. Specifically, they should be able to sort by number of views and/or engagements and customised date of upload. Interested individuals and fact-checkers would then be able to track political mis/disinformation more efficiently.
This would help TikTok become less polluted with false information as more people would have the means to monitor mis/disinformation efficiently. That could complement existing efforts by TikTok’s own fact-checking team.
Reuters
Tue Dec 21 2021
In Southeast Asia last year, 198 million people, about 29 per cent of the region's population, used TikTok. - REUTERS
Bersatu ambil tindakan susulan terhadap enam ahli Parlimen - Muhyiddin
Bersatu sedang melaksanakan tindakan susulan terhadap enam ahli Parlimennya yang menyokong Perdana Menteri selepas meminda Perlembagaan parti bulan lalu.
'Made in Malaysia' - Apple punyai 19 kilang pembekal di negara ini
Malaysia merupakan salah satu negara yang mempunyai beberapa kilang pembekal yang menawarkan komponen kepada Apple.
SPRM lancar bilik gerakan PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu
SPRM melancarkan bilik gerakan, bagi membolehkan orang ramai menyalurkan maklumat serta aduan berkaitan perbuatan rasuah dan salah guna kuasa.
WEF anjur mesyuarat khas di Arab Saudi ketika suhu geopolitik Asia Barat memanas
WEF keluar dari kelazimannya dengan menganjurkan mesyuarat khas dua hari, 28-29 April 2024 di Riyadh, Arab Saudi.
Kerajaan rangka hala tuju beri lebih banyak perlindungan kepada kanak-kanak
Kerajaan akan merangka hala tuju bagi memberikan lebih banyak perlindungan dari segi undang-undang kepada kanak-kanak di negara ini.
Tiada tepung di pasaran tempatan mengandungi benzoil peroksida melebihi kadar dibenarkan - KKM
Tiada mana-mana jenama tepung di pasaran tempatan mengandungi benzoil peroksida melebihi paras yang dibenarkan di bawah undang-undang.
Freedom Flotilla to Gaza: Semua delegasi diminta pulang, FFC akan maklumkan tarikh baharu misi
Menurut Jawatankuasa Pemandu FFC, Ann Wright, pihaknya akan memaklumkan perkembangan terbaharu kepada semua delegasi terlibat sekiranya tarikh akhir pelayaran ditetapkan.
Bytedance enggan jual TikTok di Amerika Syarikat
BYTEDANCE kini mengatakan mereka tidak akan menjual perniagaan TikTok di Amerika Syarikat (AS).
Malaysia komited tingkat hubungan dua hala bersama Libya
Malaysia terus komited mempertingkatkan hubungan dua hala yang berterusan bersama Libya demi manfaat bersama dalam pelbagai sektor.
Cegah jenayah: Kerjasama komuniti kekang jenayah secara holistik
Jelasnya, program seumpama ini diharap dapat memberikan pendedahan tentang pencegahan jenayah dan menzahirkan aspirasi PDRM untuk penglibatan aktif warga komuniti dalam memerangi aktiviti jenayah.
Bytedance enggan jual TikTok di Amerika Syarikat
BYTEDANCE kini mengatakan mereka tidak akan menjual perniagaan TikTok di Amerika Syarikat (AS).
5.9 bilion tontonan di TikTok Malaysia direkodkan sepanjang Ramadan, awal Raya
Tiktok Shop dilihat berkembang menjadi tumpuan ramai pengguna untuk membeli barangan, kerana ia turut digayakan dan didemonstrasikan.
TikTok akan saman AS jika dipaksa jual atau dihalang akses
Bytedance dijangka akan melihat kepada pelbagai perkara termasuk melawan di mahkamah sebelum membuat keputusan untuk menjual atau sebagainya.
TikTok akan halang akaun kerap langgar terma daripada saranan For You
Sistem halangan kandungan ini akan berkuat kuasa 17 Mei depan.
Pesohor media sosial cari suami kaya
Karolina turut membawakan kod bar bagi mereka yang berminat mengenanya dengan lebih dekat supaya dapat menghubunginya secara peribadi.
TikTok uji pempengaruh maya dikuasakan AI untuk jana kandungan, pengiklanan
Melalui ciri ini, pempengaruh maya yang dibangunkan dan ditawarkan kepada pengiklan boleh menghasilkan kandungan serta melakukan jualan melalui platform TikTok.
Lagu viral sampai luar negara, De Fam kongsi cerita di sebalik single Alamak Raya Lagi!
De Fam mengakui tidak menjangkakan single terbaharu mereka itu tular sehingga ke luar negara dan menjadi trend terkenal di aplikasi TikTok.
TikTok, META perlu tingkatkan usaha pantau kandungan memudaratkan
Penyedia platform dalam talian Tiktok dan META digesa meningkatkan usaha pemantauan, susulan peningkatan kandungan dalam talian yang memudaratkan.
Pemilikan akaun media sosial beri kesan terhadap perkembangan minda kanak-kanak
Pemilikan akaun media sosial oleh kanak-kanak di bawah usia 13 tahun akan mendedahkan mereka kepada kerencaman dan kecelaruan maklumat sekali gus memberi kesan terhadap perkembangan minda.
TikTok kini bayar pencipta kandungan berdasarkan nilai carian
TikTok telah memperkenalkan Creator Rewards Program yang memberi ganjaran dalam bentuk bayaran tunai kepada pencipta kandungan dengan nilai carian yang tertinggi.