PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal in a 2-1 majority decision today ruled that the children born overseas to Malaysian mothers who are married to foreign spouses are not entitled by operation of law to be Malaysian citizens.
The three-member bench chaired by Justice Datuk Kamaludin Md Said made the ruling after allowing the appeal by the government, Home Ministry and National Registration Department (NRD) director-general (appellants).
The majority decision was agreed to by Justice Kamaluddin and Justice Datuk Azizah Nawawi, while Justice Datuk S. Nantha Balan dissented.
In reversing the High Court ruling, Justice Kamaludin said the word 'father' in Section 1(b) and 1(c) of the Second Schedule, Part II of the Federal Constitution meant the biological father and cannot be extended to include the mother or parents.
Whereas, the High Court in its decision to allow children born overseas to Malaysian mothers married to foreigners to automatic be entitled to citizenship by the operation of law under Article 14(1)(b) of the Federal Constitution had held that the word 'father' in Section 1 (b) must be read to include the mother.
Justice Kamaludin however said the word 'father' in Article 14(1)(b) and its related provisions in the Second Schedule is clear and unambiguous and cannot be construed to include 'mother'.
"Only the Parliament can rewrite the Constitution, not the court, to amend the Constitution. The court cannot in its own whim and fancy change the Constitution.
"Thus, the government's appeal is allowed with no order as to cost while the High Court decision is set aside," he said.
Meanwhile, Justice Nantha, who gave the dissenting judgment, opined that there was a plain and apparent conflict between Article 8(2) and Article 14(1)(b) and its related provisions of the Federal Constitution which implies that the bloodline of the mother is inferior to the bloodline of the father.
"This is an indignity to Malaysian mothers and discriminatory to Malaysian mothers who marry foreigners. The court's theory of constitutional interpretation is to prevent citizenship absurdity that results in discrimination, thus the (Federal Constitution) is to be read harmoniously to prevent discrimination on Malaysian mothers," he said.
In its majority decision, the panel also made it clear that the status quo should be maintained for the overseas-born children of the six Malaysian mothers who had obtained the Malaysian citizenship papers, pending disposal of their appeal to the Apex Court.
As for other Malaysian mothers who are not part of the lawsuit and who had also applied for their overseas-born children to be given citizenship documents by the NRD, the panel said their applications should be frozen and should not be rejected.
"Whatever granted, leave it, don't disturb it. Whatever is pending, leave it in suspended animation pending disposal of appeal. Whatever is pending should not be rejected, just freeze it. You get what I mean?" Justice Nantha asked.
To this, senior federal counsel Liew Horng Bin representing the three appellants replied: "Yes, completely understand."
Last September, High Court Judge Datuk Akhtar Tahir made an order that all the relevant authorities must issue relevant documents, like identity cards, to these children in recognition of this effect.
In their suit, among other things, the mothers want a court order for all relevant government agencies, including the NRD, Immigration Department and Malaysian embassies, to issue documents relating to citizenship (including passports and identity cards) to children born abroad to Malaysian mothers with foreign spouses.
Lawyer Datuk Gurdial Singh Nijar appeared for the six mothers and Family Frontiers.
During today's proceedings, the same panel, in a 2-1 majority decision, dismissed an appeal by a 24-year-old woman, Mahisha Sulaiha Abdul Majeed, against High Court's decision on Aug 19, 2020, that rejected her suit which she filed to seek a declaration that she is entitled to be a Malaysian citizen.
It was reported that Mahisha Sulaiha was born to a Malaysian mother and an Indian national father in India.
Meanwhile, Family Frontiers president Suriani Kempe said that they will appeal against the decision at the Federal Court, and continue to hold faith in the justice system.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Fri Aug 05 2022
The Court of Appeal in a 2-1 majority decision today ruled that the children born overseas to Malaysian mothers who are married to foreign spouses are not entitled by operation of law to be Malaysian citizens. - BERNAMA
Polis tingkat kawalan keselamatan pemain TFC
Polis Terengganu meningkatkan kawalan keselamatan terhadap pemain Terengganu FC (TFC) susulan insiden serangan yang menimpa dua pemain bola sepak tempatan pada Khamis dan semalam.
Bursa Malaysia melonjak ke paras tertinggi dalam tempoh 52 minggu
Bursa Malaysia meneruskan kenaikan minggu lepas untuk ditutup tinggi bagi hari ketiga dagangan berturut-turut hari ini dengan indeks utama mencecah paras tertinggi dalam tempoh 52 minggu.
AWANI 7:45 [06/05/2024] – Tiada kaitan 'bookie' | perlu setimpal pengiktirafan | Rela berhenti daripada lama di pejabat
- Kes Akhyar, Faisal Halim tiada kaitan bookie, polis minta jangan reka cerita.
- Penjawat awam tiada integriti tak berhak dapat layanan sama.
- 80% pekerja Malaysia pilih masuk pejabat hanya tiga hari seminggu.
- Hail Amir meninggal dunia kerana komplikasi paru-paru.
- Penjawat awam tiada integriti tak berhak dapat layanan sama.
- 80% pekerja Malaysia pilih masuk pejabat hanya tiga hari seminggu.
- Hail Amir meninggal dunia kerana komplikasi paru-paru.
Geran RM149.1 juta telah diberikan kepada PKS galakkan adaptasi teknologi baharu - Menteri MITI
Menteri Pelaburan, Perdagangan dan Industri, Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Abdul Aziz berkata Kementerian Pelaburan, Perdagangan dan Industri (MITI) telah memberikan geran berjumlah RM149.1 juta kepada Perusahaan Kecil dan Sederhana (PKS) untuk tujuan adaptasi teknologi industri baharu. Jelasnya, ini sekaligus menafikan dakwaan yang menyatakan pihak Kementerian hanya memberi tumpuan kepada syarikat korporat besar dan mengabaikan PKS.
81 peratus kes dilaporkan kepada IMFC selesai, percepat realisasi pelaburan - Menteri MITI
Menteri Pelaburan, Perdagangan dan Industri, Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Abdul Aziz berkata 81 peratus daripada 464 kes yang dilaporkan kepada Pusat Memudah Cara Pelaburan Malaysia (IMFC) telah diselesaikan dan berjaya mempercepat proses realisasi pelaburan-pelaburan yang diumumkan. Jelasnya, angka ini sangat membanggakan bagi sebuah agensi yang baru ditubuhkan sejak Januari lalu.
Malaysia sasar 22.6 peratus KDNK disumbangkan ekonomi digital menjelang 2025 - Menteri MITI
Menteri Pelaburan, Perdagangan dan Industri, Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Abdul Aziz berkata Kementerian Pelaburan, Perdagangan dan Industri (MITI) meletakkan sasaran untuk mengembangkan ekonomi digital kepada 22.6 peratus daripada Keluaran Dalam Negara Kasar (KDNK) Malaysia menjelang 2025. Jelasnya, ini merupakan sebahagian daripada strategi kementerian untuk memperkasakan sektor ekonomi selain daripada elektrik dan elektronik (E&E).
Pastikan sistem penilaian prestasi adil, tidak digunakan Ketua Jabatan untuk balas dendam - Pakar
Kongres Kesatuan Pekerja-pekerja Dalam Perkhidmatan Awam (CUEPACS), Aminuddin Awang berkata Kerajaan perlu memastikan sistem penilaian prestasi yang sedang dan akan digunakan adalah adil dalam menilai sumbangan penjawat awam. Jelasnya, tidak wajar sistem yang membolehkan mana-mana Ketua Jabatan memangsakan pekerja bawahan dikuatkuasakan tanpa penyesuaian yang perlu.
JPA perlu beri fleksibiliti kepada jabatan, agensi nilai prestasi penjawat awam sesuai gaji diberikan - Pakar
Ketua Pegawai Eksekutif MTalent Training & Consultancy, Datuk Dr. Musa Ali berkata Jabatan Perkhidmatan Awam (JPA) perlu memberi fleksibiliti kepada jabatan-jabatan dan agensi-agensi Kerajaan di semua peringkat untuk menilai prestasi penjawat awam. Jelasnya, ini bagi memastikan penilaian tersebut mencerminkan sumbangan penjawat awam sesuai dengan pelaburan dan gaji yang diperuntukan untuk badan-badan yang berbeza berkenaan.
GRS selesa kerjasama dengan PH Sabah
Gabungan Rakyat Sabah (GRS) akan memperkukuhkan lagi kerjasama sedia ada dengan Pakatan Harapan (PH) Sabah terutama dalam usaha memajukan negeri ini dan menyatupadukan rakyat.
PM ucap takziah kepada keluarga Hail Amir
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim menzahirkan ucapan takziah kepada keluarga penyanyi dan pelakon veteran Datuk Hail Amir yang meninggal dunia di Hospital Kuala Lumpur hari ini.