PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal today reserved its decision on Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's appeal against the High Court's refusal to grant him leave to challenge former Prime Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin's action in advising the Yang di-Pertuan Agong (YDPA) to suspend Parliament during the emergency period.
A three-member panel chaired by Datuk Has Zanah Mehat deferred the judgment on the appeal by the Opposition Leader after hearing submissions from Anwar's lawyers Ramkarpal Singh and Sangeet Kaur Deo and senior federal counsel S. Narkunavathy, who acted for the Attorney-General's Chambers, in the proceedings conducted virtually through the Zoom application.
"We think that as the submissions are very substantive, we may not be able to decide today on the appeal. The substantive issue was also raised in the other two appeals from Hassan Abdul Karim (Pasir Gudang MP) and Datuk Seri Salahuddin Ayub (Pulai MP) where we were supposed to give our decision on the Sept 30.
"But looking at this (Anwar) appeal, I think we need to consider it together with the two other appeals because the background facts are more or less the same. It also involved the issue of the Emergency Ordinance and the advice of the YDPA. So, we will decide the appeal on the same date," said Justice Has Zanah, who sat with Justices Datuk Vazeer Alam Mydin Meera and Datuk Ahmad Zaidi Ibrahim.
The court then fixed tomorrow for online case management to set a date for a decision on all three appeals.
On April 22 this year, the Kuala Lumpur High Court dismissed Anwar's application to obtain leave to commence a judicial review to challenge Muhyiddin's advice to Yang di-Pertuan Agong Al-Sultan Abdullah Ri'ayatuddin Al-Mustafa Billah Shah to suspend Parliament sittings during the state of emergency.
Then High Court judge Datuk Seri Mariana Yahya (now Court of Appeal judge) had dismissed Anwar's application on the grounds that the court had no jurisdiction to hear the judicial review based on Articles 150 (6) and 150 (8) of the Federal Constitution.
Justice Mariana ruled that the advice of the Cabinet and Muhyiddin to Al-Sultan Abdullah to promulgate the Emergency Ordinance was not amenable to judicial review.
Anwar, who is also Port Dickson Member of Parliament, filed the application seeking leave to initiate a judicial review on Jan 25 this year, naming Muhyiddin and the government as respondents in his application.
Anwar sought, among others, a court declaration that the decision by the Cabinet, led by Muhyiddin, to advise Al-Sultan Abdullah to promulgate Section 14 of the Emergency (Essential Powers) Ordinance 2021, which had resulted in the suspension of Parliament, is unconstitutional, unlawful, has no effect and is ultra vires.
Earlier, Ramkarpal submitted that the previous Perikatan Nasional-led government could rely on the existing Movement Control Order (MCO) to combat the COVID-19 pandemic.
"MCO and the Prevention and Control of Infectious Disease Act 1988 are enough to control the pandemic instead of advising the YDPA to proclaim an emergency.
"The decision made by Muhyiddin and his Cabinet to advise the YDPA was unreasonable and irrational," the lawyer said.
Narkunavathy countered that looking at the Hansard on the tabling of the Bill for the amendment of Article 150 (6) and (8) of the Federal Constitution dated April 9, 1981, it was clear that the intention of Parliament was to exclude judicial review of the decision in proclaiming emergency and the Ordinance made under the emergency law.
"The reasons forwarded by the deputy prime minister when tabling the Bill was to avoid important information from being heard in court in a situation where no effective and immediate action is taken. Such information if revealed would likely turn the country into chaos and could result in destruction of property and loss of lives of the innocent.
"Based on Hansard, the intentions of the legislation were clear. The insertion of Article 150 (6) and (8) was meant to shut the doors of the court from any challenge of the law made during the emergency and the proclamation of emergency by YDPA," she said.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Tue Sep 28 2021
The Court of Appeal today reserved its decision on Anwar Ibrahim's appeal against the High Court's refusal to grant him leave to challenge Muhyiddin's action in advising the YDPA to suspend Parliament during the emergency period. - BERNAMA
Polis rampas dadah lebih RM2.3 juta, lelaki tempatan ditahan
Polis Johor merampas dadah bernilai lebih RM2.3 juta dalam dua serbuan berasingan di sekitar kawasan Johor Bahru Selatan pada Rabu lalu.
Jalani tempoh perkenalan singkat, warga emas 78 tahun teruja bertemu jodoh semula
"Kami diperkenalkan oleh kawan anak. Pertemuan pertama kami, dia pandang saya dia dah berkenan."
Waspada ejen nikah Siam
Konsulat Malaysia di Songkhla, Ahmad Fahmi Ahmad Sarkawi menasihat rakyat Malaysia yang ingin berkahwin di Selatan Thailand supaya waspada dalam pemilihan ejen.
Twincity Marathon rai golongan OKU
Perbezaan fizikal tidak melunturkan semangat golongan orang kurang upaya (OKU) untuk menyertai acara larian Twincity Marathon sejauh lima kilometer (km) di Cyberjaya hari ini.
Bersatu serah notis kepada enam ahli Parlimen selepas PRK Kuala Kubu Bharu - Hamzah
Bersatu akan mengeluarkan notis berhubung status kedudukan enam ahli Parlimennya yang menyokong Perdana Menteri selepas PRK Kuala Kubu Bharu.
Kemarau: Beting pasir seluas padang bola timbul di Sungai Kelantan
Beting pasir tersebut mula kelihatan sejak pertengahan Ramadan lepas dan saiznya semakin besar dari sehari ke sehari.
Dhobi Ghat Pulau Pinang: Daerah dobi terakhir di Malaysia
Terletak di antara Jalan Air Hitam dan Jalan York, Dhobi Ghat di Pulau Pinang itu telah wujud sejak awal 1800-an.
KBS sasar 8,880 individu sertai KLAS Renang tahun ini
Kementerian Belia dan Sukan (KBS) menyasarkan sebanyak 8,880 individu menyertai Program Kemahiran Latihan Asas Sukan Renang (KLAS Renang) di seluruh negara tahun ini.
Penyu PD pulang bertelur, orang ramai jangan buat kacau ganggu
Selepas menemui 159 telur penyu karah di Pantai Tanjung Gemok Port Dickson, pada Jumaat, kini sebanyak 117 telur penyu agar pula ditemui pada Sabtu.
Che'gubard direman dua hari
Che'gubard atau nama sebenarnya Badrul Hisham Shaharin ditahan reman dua hari bagi membantu siasatan berkaitan hantaran mengenai pengoperasian kasino di Forest City.
Nahas helikopter Lumut: Presiden Turkiye ucap takziah kepada keluarga anggota, Malaysia - Anwar
Presiden Turkiye Recep Tayyip Erdogan mengutuskan ucapan takziah kepada keluarga 10 wira negara yang terkorban dalam nahas helikopter TLDM di Lumut, Perak.
Pihak dikaitkan dalam laporan berkaitan lesen kasino perlu ambil tindakan - PM Anwar
Laporan yang memetik satu sumber itu berkata perbincangan mengenai pemberian lesen itu masih di peringkat awal.
Tiada kasino akan beroperasi di Johor - Onn Hafiz
Onn Hafiz berkata khabar angin yang tular itu berunsur sabotaj dan berniat jahat untuk mencemar imej Forest City dan Johor secara keseluruhannya.
MOT, Khazanah, MAG perlu perkukuh tadbir urus MAB - PM Anwar
Jelas Anwar lagi, pengurusan syarikat penerbangan yang baik juga akan memberi manfaat kepada kakitangan melalui gaji yang setimpal dengan perkhidmatan mereka.
Kontroversi UM: Sarjana ‘berkualiti rendah’ tak patut dijemput - PM Anwar
Anwar menyindir ahli akademik AS yang terbabit dalam kontroversi pro-Israel sebagai sarjana berkualiti rendah dan tidak mempunyai pencapaian luar biasa atau istimewa.
Terdapat keperluan tambah bilangan wanita isi jawatan KSU, KP - PM Anwar
Anwar berkata jumlah pimpinan wanita sedia ada tidak mencerminkan jumlah keseluruhan 42 peratus golongan itu yang terlibat sebagai pembuat keputusan dalam perkhidmatan awam ketika ini.
PM nafi kerajaan beri lesen kasino di Forest City
Perdana Menteri menafikan laporan yang mendakwa kerajaan akan mengeluarkan lesen untuk pengoperasian kasino di Forest City, Johor.
SSPA terbaik pernah diperkenalkan kerajaan - PM Anwar
Beliau berkata, usaha tersebut diharap dapat menjadi motivasi buat penjawat awam untuk meningkatkan produktiviti, dan memberikan perkhidmatan terbaik kepada rakyat.
Sultan Selangor adakan pertemuan dengan PM Anwar di Seri Perdana
Sultan Selangor Sultan Sharafuddin Idris Shah berkenan berangkat ke kediaman rasmi Perdana Menteri di Kompleks Seri Perdana, Putrajaya.
Agong berkenan meriahkan Majlis Sulaman Kasih Aidilfitri Kementerian Perpaduan
Yang di-Pertuan Agong Sultan Ibrahim hari ini berkenan memeriahkan Majlis Sulaman Kasih Aidifitri Kementerian Perpaduan Negara.