Although a policy consensus has emerged since the Covid-19 outbreak over the need for more government spending to come out of what are unprecedented times on a firmer footing, some are still jittery over what they perceive to be a dearth of viable sources of funding.
Whilst it’s acknowledged, on the one hand, that the fiscal deficit needs to increase in order to accommodate greater direct injection by the government, on the other hand, there are still worries about the debt level which has breached the 60% self-imposed ceiling to reach 60.7% of the gross domestic product (GDP) – which translates into RM874.27 billion – by end of September. This is expected to go up to 61% in 2021 according to The Edge Markets. In the same vein, the country’s deficit is expected to be at least 6% as already anticipated, which it has to be noted and stressed is nothing out of ordinary, historically speaking.
According to the Ministry of Finance’s (MOF) Fiscal Policy Review 2021, Malaysian Government Securities (MGS) and Malaysian Government Investment Issues (MGIIs) or government bond issuance that is our national debt denominated in the ringgit mainly made up 96.7% of the country’s borrowings. And it has to be highlighted that government borrowing constitutes only 26.5% of the source of Budget 2021 – with 40.9% coming from direct tax and the rest, i.e. 19.4% derived from non-tax revenue.
It’s hereby submitted, however, that arguably the real concern should be our debt-servicing ratio. In 2019, our interest payments alone accounted for about 13% of revenue and the figure is set to rise together with a rising deficit – which represents a form of (deliberate) leakage.
According to the International Monetary Fund (IMF), Singapore has a much higher debt to GDP ratio than us, i.e. at a staggering 130%.
It has to be highlighted that Singapore Government Securities (SGS) and Special SGS have never been issued for fiscal policy but exclusively for monetary policy purposes and to develop and cater to the needs of the financial market in providing risk-free (i.e. government-backed) benchmark (for risky assets) and investments.
Singapore’s sources of funding are mainly taxation (direct and Goods & Services Tax/GST) and since 2016 increasingly also by “net investment contribution returns” (NIRC). NIRC are investment proceeds made by the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) or in effect the central bank together with sovereign wealth fund Temasek Holdings and Government Investment Corporation (GIC). Lastly, a drawdown of past reserves also plays a critical role, particularly at this time of the Covid-19 crisis.
The point, however, is that the level of national debt is not necessarily the chief indicator of the government’s ability to repay.
There have been calls by some for our government to emulate Indonesia in doing debt monetisation which primarily means directly borrowing from the central bank by way of the Treasury issuing debt or public bonds to the central bank.
In the Malaysian context of Bank Negara, this would, however, represent a step too far and out of bounds. It would also directly blur the distinction between fiscal and monetary policy roles which would be unpalatable to the technocratic sensibilities of Bank Negara.
In addition to debt issuance and taxation, perhaps the following modest policy proposals – which aren’t exhaustive – could be considered in the future in view of the impact of Covid-19:
1. Tapping into an overdraft
This requires amending Section 71 of the Bank Negara Act (2009) to shift from provision of temporary financing to a permanent overdraft facility – mimicking the UK’s Ways and Means (W&M) facility in relation to the Treasury’s account with the Bank of England – and limited to a specified level. However, overdraft extension shall be temporary with no deadline for repayment. Repayment to Bank Negara (for national accounting purposes) could involve issuance of perpetual or 50-year or even 100-year bonds to institutional investors.
In terms of spending, 30% could be channelled to our Covid-19 Fund to be used for our front-liners, personal protective equipment (PPEs), vaccine procurement and distribution purposes, among others.
2. Borrowing from government-linked banks
Instead of going through the bond market, the government should be leveraging on its (indirect) ownership of government-linked banks (Maybank, CIMB, and RHB) by borrowing directly at favourable rates in this time which could be used to fund development/capital expenditure (devex/capex). At nearly 20% which far exceeds the 8% minimum capital adequacy ratio of risk-weighted assets imposed by Basel 3, our banks have more than enough liquidity buffer.
At the same time, quantitative easing (QE), i.e. purchase of government bonds in the secondary market, could be pursued by Bank Negara on a limited and temporary basis targeted at keeping government debt burden in the form of interest rates low.
It was reported by The Edge Markets (Oct 5, 2020) that Bank Negara’s holdings of Malaysian Government Securities (MGS) increased to RM10.9 billion as at end-August this year, which translates into merely 2.5% of the outstanding RM431.7 billion.
The current 10% policy limit of secondary purchases of MGS by Bank Negara should be increased drastically to 60% (reflecting the current self-imposed debt ceiling) on a one-off basis and fully taken up with the purpose of flattening across the yield curve of the bond market so as to result in lower coupon or interest rates as much as possible. It’ll be on a one-off basis before reverting back to a lower figure of 30%.
The MGS deposited with Bank Negara – as the government’s de jure (i.e. legally-appointed or statutory) banker – could also earn interest. Proceeds from the interest rate would be returned to the government to be absorbed by the Consolidated Fund or Covid-19 Fund.
By way of analogy, in 2012 it was reported that the UK Treasury received £35 billion from Bank of England as it surrendered interest earned on QE assets, i.e. gilts or government bonds, bought in the secondary markets as off-loaded by institutional investors. It has to be stressed that this is strictly just on a temporary basis.
In conclusion, the government is well-poised to be in a position to pull out all the stops to ensure that we successfully come out of the Covid-19 crisis on a sustained basis.
Jason Loh Seong Wei is Head of Social, Law & Human Rights at EMIR Research, an independent think tank focussed on strategic policy recommendations based on rigorous research.
** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
Jason Loh Seong Wei
Tue Nov 17 2020
There have been calls by some for our government to emulate Indonesia in doing debt monetisation which primarily means directly borrowing from the central bank by way of the Treasury issuing debt or public bonds to the central bank. AWANIpic
Penunjuk perasaan pro-Palestin di Paris kepung universiti
Penunjuk perasaan pro-Palestin mengepung bangunan dan kawasan hadpaan Universiti Sciences Po yang berprestij di Paris pada Jumaat.
Piala Thomas: Zii Jia pamer magis tarik perhatian ramai di Chengdu
Zii Jia merekodkan kemenangan ke atas Lee Cheuk Yiu dalam aksi yang mengambil masa 45 minit menghadirkan saat-saat terbaik dalam saingan pembukaan ini.
Youth All Girls raih gangsa di Amerika Syarikat
Pasukan sorak Malaysia Youth All Girls raih gangsa di The 2024 International Cheer Union World Cheerleading Championships (ICU JWCC) di Florida, Amerika Syarikat pada Khamis.
Perkembangan proses penamaan calon PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu
Pilihan Raya Kecil (PRK) Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Kuala Kubu Baharu (KKB) membuka tirai hari ini dengan bermulanya proses penamaan calon pagi tadi di Dewan Serbaguna Dan Kompleks Sukan Daerah Hulu Selangor.
Firdaus Azil ada perincian untuk dikongsikan jam ini.
Firdaus Azil ada perincian untuk dikongsikan jam ini.
Malaysia-China bincang perkukuhkan kerjasama sektor pendidikan
Malaysia dan China membincangkan inisiatif strategik bagi memperluas serta memperkukuh jalinan kerjasama sektor pendidikan tinggi antara Kuala Lumpur-Beijing sempena sambutan ulang tahun ke-50 hubungan diplomatik Malaysia-China.
Perdana Menteri ke Riyadh sempena mesyuarat khas Forum Ekonomi Sedunia
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim akan mengadakan lawatan kerja ke Riyadh, Arab Saudi sempena mesyuarat khas forum sedunia World Economic Forum (WEF) bermula 27 hingga 29 April ini.
Kerajaan Persekutuan kaji cadangan wujud hospital di Pengerang - Azalina
Hospital tersebut akan memudahkan penduduk mendapatkan rawatan memandangkan Pengerang semakin pesat membangun.
AWANI Ringkas: Reformasi gaji di Malaysia
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Piala Thomas: Lee Zii Jia beri mata pertama buat Malaysia!
Kemenangan straight set benarkan Malaysia raih mata pertama dalam aksi peringkat kumpulan saingan Piala Thomas berdepan Hong Kong.
AWANI Pagi: Filem Oppa semai mesej PDRM banteras jenayah scam
Ikuti diskusi bersama Pengarah Jabatan Siasatan Jenayah Komersial (JSJK) Bukit Aman, Datuk Seri Ramli Mohamed Yoosuf akan berkongsi mesej disemai PDRM dalam membanteras jenayah scam yang berleluasa ketika ini.
Harga petrol, diesel kekal bagi tempoh 11 hingga 17 April
Harga runcit bagi petrol RON97 dan RON95 serta diesel masing-masing kekal pada RM3.47, RM2.05 dan RM2.15 seliter bagi tempoh 11 hingga 17 April ini.
MOF komited laksana dasar fiskal progresif kurangkan kemiskinan, ketaksamaan
Sumbangan dasar fiskal terhadap inisiatif mengurangkan kemiskinan dan merapatkan jurang pendapatan adalah minimum dari segi KDNK.
PM akui wujud keresahan kenaikan harga barang, MOF sedia tampung kesan kenaikan
MOF sedia menampung dan memberi bantuan tambahan bagi mengimbangkan kesan kenaikan harga barangan kepada rakyat.
Harga petrol, diesel kekal dari 31 Ogos hingga 6 September
RON97 akan kekal pada RM3.37 seliter, RON95 (RM2.05 seliter) dan diesel (RM2.15 seliter)
Firma AS minat teroka kemasukan operasi perniagaan baharu ke Malaysia
Steven Sim berkata AMCHAM menekankan kepentingan kesinambungan kawal selia untuk membantu memudahkan menjalankan perniagaan.
Kerajaan laksana semula Program Pengakuan Sukarela mulai 6 Jun - MOF
Beri peluang kepada orang ramai secara sukarela bayar cukai yang bertanggungan tanpa penalti atau pada kadar sifar peratus.
MOF serah kepada Bank Negara cari remedi kukuhkan ringgit
Timbalan Menteri Kewangan I, Datuk Seri Ahmad Maslan berkata, beliau yakin Bank Negara mempunyai penyelesaian sekiranya AS belum membuat keputusan terhadap permintaan tersebut.
Muhyiddin dakwa tetap akan diheret ke mahkamah atas arahan pihak tertinggi pentadbiran negara
Muhyiddin mendakwa SPRM tidak menemui sebarang bukti terhadap segala pertuduhan yang dikaitkan dengan beliau
Cukuplah mercu tanda sedia ada, saya tak berhajat buat satu lagi - Anwar
Tumpuan sebaliknya diberikan kepada aspek kemampanan pembangunan sesebuah bandar terutama di ibu kota Kuala Lumpur.
Kebakaran di Kementerian Kewangan: Tiada kecederaan, kerugian - MoF
Kementerian Kewangan mengesahkan berlaku kebakaran melibatkan bilik sampah di kompleks kementerian itu di sini pada Selasa.