KUALA LUMPUR: The prosecution in Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor's money laundering and tax evasion trial contended that her second bid to recuse Justice Mohamed Zaini Mazlan from presiding over the case is an abuse of court process.
Former Federal Court judge Datuk Seri Gopal Sri Ram, who is the lead prosecutor in the case, said as Justice Mohamed Zaini had dismissed a similar application (to have him removed as the trial judge) previously, it was only a repeated attempt to achieve what had already failed last year.
"Messrs Geethan Ram submitted for the earlier recusal application and presently the same relief is filed by a different firm, which means next time we will be seeing the same application by another firm.
"It is an abuse of the court process because Your Lordship had already handed down the ruling on the same application in December last year. This application is a non-starter," said Sri Ram.
This is the second time the wife of former prime minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak has filed the application after Judge Mohamed Zaini, who is also the same judge in Rosmah's solar hybrid case trial, had rejected Rosmah's application last Dec 14 to recuse him from hearing the trial.
In delivering his judgment on that date, Justice Mohamed Zaini said he took great care to ensure that Rosmah would not be prejudiced in the money laundering case when references were made to the statements in the solar case because a judge was required to consider separately and independently the evidence against the accused.
"Any findings that I make in the solar case remains there. It is after all my solemn duty or of any judge, to ensure that the accused or any accused for that matter, is tried fairly as enshrined under Article 5 of the Federal Constitution," he said.
Rosmah's counsel Datuk Firoz Hussein Ahmad Jamaluddin responded to the prosecution's argument by insisting that the current application could not be said to have abused the court process as it stood on different grounds (risk of bias).
He said that Justice Mohamed Zaini's role in several criminal cases connected to Rosmah's family including Najib might cause the judge to not be able to carry his judicial function without having pre-judged the issues, therefore posing a real danger of bias to his client.
"It is pertinent to acknowledge and accept that 'human frailty' is an important factor to be considered even when it comes to those who are trained to be independent and fair-minded, because a judge is a human after all," he added.
Firoz also said that Justice Mohamed Zaini's involvement in multiple cases involving Rosmah might expose her to miscarriage of justice and as a result, might diminish public confidence in the judiciary and the administration of justice.
Justice Mohamed Zaini then fixed March 21 for the decision.
Rosmah, 70, is facing 12 money laundering charges involving RM7,097,750 and five counts of failure to declare her income to the Inland Revenue Board (LHDN).
The offences were allegedly committed at Affin Bank Berhad, Bangunan Getah Asli branch, Jalan Ampang, here, between Dec 4, 2013 and June 8, 2017, and at LHDN at Kompleks Bangunan Kerajaan, Jalan Tuanku Abdul Halim, here, between May 1, 2014 and May 1, 2018.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Wed Mar 02 2022
Rosmah, 70, is facing 12 money laundering charges involving RM7,097,750 and five counts of failure to declare her income to the Inland Revenue Board (LHDN). - Astro AWANI/Shahir Omar
Jalan rosak di Johor berbaki 979 daripada 2,642 lokasi dikenal pasti
Sebanyak 1,075 kawasan jalan rosak telah dibaiki tahun lepas dan 588 lokasi lagi akan dibuat sepanjang tahun ini.
Imigresen Kelantan dakwa 15 pendatang di Mahkamah Sesyen Khas
Kesemua pendatang yang berusia antara 19 hingga 48 tahun itu ditangkap dalam Op Kutip sekitar Kota Bharu dan Bachok pada 3 Mei.
Semakan lengkap industri pertengahan kewangan sedang dijalankan - BNM
Kajian semula yang lebih menyeluruh terhadap industri pengantara kewangan sedang dijalankan, kata Penolong Gabenor Bank Negara Malaysia.
Piala FA 2024: Laluan mudah buat juara bertahan JDT
Melalui undian, JDT dilihat meraih lawan mudah dengan mengetuai 12 lagi pasukan Liga Super serta tiga pasukan daripada Liga A1 Semi Pro.
Dua wanita cedera, kereta terbalik dalam longkang di Lebuhraya WCE
Empat mangsa dalam kereta itu merupakan dua wanita dewasa, seorang lelaki dewasa dan seorang kanak-kanak perempuan.
Menteri China, Liu Jianchao bertemu pegawai kanan PKR diketuai Nurul Izzah
Malaysia sangat mementingkan hubungan dengan China dan pencapaian luar biasa China dalam pembangunan ekonomi dan sosial amat mengagumkan.
Polis minta bantuan kesan Safiea Dania, hilang lepas naik e-hailing
Kali terakhir ditemui adalah pada 24 April jam 6.35 petang, ketika dia menggunakan perkhidmatan e-hailing untuk ke tempat kerja.
AirAsia dipilih rakan penerbangan rasmi Sidang Kemuncak Malaysia-China 2024
Sidang kemuncak itu adalah peluang strategik untuk meningkatkan hubungan perdagangan, pelaburan dan kebudayaan Malaysia.
SC pelawa permohonan untuk Program Kepimpinan investED 2024
Suruhanjaya Sekuriti Malaysia mempelawa permohonan untuk kohort kedua Program Kepimpinan investED, sebuah program siswazah pasaran modal.
Pusat Latihan TFC dipasang CCTV
Hishamuddin berkata langkah itu diambil selepas perbincangan lanjut dengan pihak polis yang masih giat memburu suspek samun berkenaan.
Ucapan Azmin bersifat jahat dan memfitnah beliau dan abangnya - Saksi
Ahli perniagaan, Deepak Jaikishan, berkata kenyataan Mohamed Azmin dalam ceramah politiknya pada 11 Mac 2023, adalah bersifat jahat yang memfitnahnya dan nama abangnya.
Projek solar: Mahkamah dengar rayuan Rosmah pada 23 dan 24 Okt
Dalam pengurusan hari ini, Rosmah diwakili Akberdin dan Datuk Jagjit Singh manakala Timbalan Pendakwa Raya K. Mangai hadir mewakili pihak pendakwaan.
Mahkamah Persekutuan tolak permohonan Rosmah
Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor gagal mendapat kebenaran untuk merayu terhadap keputusan Mahkamah Rayuan berhubung usahanya mencabar kesahihan pelantikan mendiang Datuk Gopal Sri Ram sebagai ketua pendakwa.
Kes saman syarikat barangan kemas, permohonan Rosmah didengar 29 Mei
Permohonan Rosmah untuk memasukkan kerajaan dan polis sebagai pihak ketiga dalam kes saman syarikat barangan kemas Lebanon, terhadapnya akan didengar pada 29 Mei.
Perkembangan status representasi Rosmah 1 Mac ini
Ia berkaitan 12 pertuduhan pengubahan wang haram berjumlah RM7,097,750 dan lima kesalahan gagal isytihar pendapatan kepada LHDN.
Rayuan Rosmah cabar pelantikan mendiang Sri Ram Mac depan
Sebutan kes Rosmah di Mahkamah Rayuan yang dijadualkan pada Isnin dijadualkan semula pada 8 Februari depan.
Anak bongsu Najib, Norashman selamat nikah
Anak bongsu bekas Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Najib Abdul Razak dan Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor, Norashman selamat bernikah dengan gadis pilihannya, Nikola Mulyadi.
Rosmah kemuka representasi baharu gugur 17 pertuduhan
Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor telah mengemukakan representasi baharu kepada Jabatan Peguam Negara (AGC) untuk menggugurkan 12 pertuduhan.
Hilang barang kemas, syarikat Lubnan gagal peroleh penghakiman terus terhadap Rosmah
Mahkamah Tinggi menolak permohonan syarikat barang kemas Global Royalty Trading SAL yang berpangkalan di Lubnan untuk mendapatkan penghakiman terus terhadap Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor.
Rosmah dakwa pertuduhan pengubahan wang haram bertindih, tidak dapat perbicaraan adil
Rosmah berkata pertuduhan berkenaan bertindan antara satu sama lain dan ia sebenarnya merujuk kepada kesalahan yang sama.