TAIPEI: For nearly 70 years an imagined line running down the Taiwan Strait between Taiwan and China has helped keep the peace but the so-called median line is looking increasingly meaningless as China's modernised navy asserts its strength.
China has never officially recognised the line that a U.S. general devised in 1954 at the height of Cold War hostility between Communist China and U.S.-backed Taiwan although the People's Liberation Army largely respected it.
Now Taiwan is bracing for warships from China's much larger navy routinely pushing over the line as part of the steps an angry Beijing has taken to protest against a visit to Taipei three weeks ago by U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi.
"They want to increase pressure on us with the end goal of us giving up the median line," said one Taiwanese official familiar with security planning in the region.
"They want to make that a fact," said the official, who declined to be identified given the sensitivity of the issue.
Some Taiwanese officials say it would be "impossible" for the island to abandon the concept of a buffer that the line represents.
Foreign Minister Joseph Wu told a news conference this month a change in the status quo could not be tolerated.
"We need to join our hands with likeminded partners to make sure that the median line is still there, to safeguard peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait," Wu said.
Other officials and security analysts warn that it would be difficult for the island to defend the line without raising the risk of dangerous escalation.
PROJECTING POWER
Taiwan would have to react militarily if Chinese forces entered its 12 nautical miles of territorial waters, the Taiwan official said, but apart from that, there was no immediate plan to give the military or coastguard more authority to respond.
President Tsai Ing-wen has repeatedly said Taiwan will neither provoke nor escalate conflict.
It is questionable whether international support for Taiwan is sufficient to deter China from patrolling into Taiwan's side of one of the world's busiest shipping lanes, or if Taiwan's friends would help it maintain the line.
Ships of the U.S. and other Western navies sail through the strait to highlight what they maintain is its international status, not to strictly enforce the imaginary line that has no legal standing.
The Taiwan Strait is some 180 km (110 miles) wide and at its narrowest, the median line is about 40 km (25 miles) from Taiwan's waters.
An established Chinese naval presence close to Taiwan's territorial waters would stretch Taiwan's military and make any Chinese blockade or invasion much easier, Taiwanese officials warn.
Ultimately, a redundant median line would also usher in further challenge to the long-standing U.S. dominance of China's near seas - the so-called first island chain - and help China to project its power into the Pacific.
The median line has no features marking it. For years, China tacitly acknowledged it but in 2020 a foreign ministry spokesman stated it "did not exist". That was echoed by its defence ministry and Taiwan Affairs Council.
In recent days, the two sides' frigates and destroyers have played cat-and-mouse, with Chinese ships attempting to manoeuvre around Taiwanese patrols to cross the line.
Chinese fighter jets have also crossed the line this month, albeit only going a short way over, something China's air force has only done rarely in the past.
China's defence ministry did not respond to requests for comment.
'POLITICAL ARTEFACT'
Chieh Chung, a security analyst from the National Policy Foundation think tank in Taipei, said the "overthrowing" of the median line consensus had increased the risk of accidental conflict.
Chieh said the codes of engagement for Taiwan's coastguard and military should be reviewed to give them more authority and legal protection in reacting to increasingly complex challenges from Chinese forces.
Within weeks, U.S. warships are expected to sail through the Taiwan Strait, underscoring what they see as its status as an international waterway, to the inevitable annoyance of China, which claims sovereignty and other rights over the strait.
But the U.S. ships are not expected to challenge Chinese vessels on either side of the median line.
Three U.S. officials, speaking on the condition of anonymity, said that Chinese crossings of the median line had little tactical importance.
"It's an imaginary line that's symbolic and it's about poking Taiwan in the eye a bit," one of the officials told Reuters.
The United States saw little need to uphold the status of the line or push back against China's moves across it, they said.
Christopher Twomey, a scholar at the U.S. Naval Postgraduate School in California, said he believed the U.S. Navy viewed the line as a "political artefact" rather than a legal one.
Speaking in a private capacity, Twomey said the dangers should not be overstated and the recognition and use of the strait as an international waterway would continue. He described Chinese activities as "political statements".
"Mere Chinese presence on either side of arbitrary lines within that area is not likely to lead to any operational response," Twomey said.
Reuters
Fri Aug 26 2022
A Taiwan Coast Guard ship travels past the coast of China, in the waters off Nangan island of Matsu archipelago in Taiwan. - REUTERS
AWANI Ringkas: Perketat kawalan premis kerajaan, tumpuan awam
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Penyasaran subsidi tidak harus bebankan rakyat terbanyak - PM
Kerajaan tidak mampu memberi subsidi kepada golongan mahakaya dan warga asing kerana hasil usaha penyasaran subsidi diesel, jumlah penjimatan dijangka (secara kasar) sekitar RM4 bilion setahun.
Kerajaan setuju laksana penyasaran subsidi ke atas bahan api - PM
Penyasaran subsidi akan mula dilaksanakan ke atas bahan api
diesel dan sebagai permulaan, penyasaran subsidi diesel hanya akan melibatkan pengguna di Semenanjung Malaysia.
diesel dan sebagai permulaan, penyasaran subsidi diesel hanya akan melibatkan pengguna di Semenanjung Malaysia.
Jangan perkenalkan dasar yang bebankan rakyat miskin - PM
Kekangan hasil dan perbelanjaan tidak berhemat menyebabkan kerajaan menanggung bebanan hutang. Timbunan hutang hanya membazirkan wang rakyat kerana banyak dihabiskan untuk bayar faedah hutang.
[TERKINI] Perutusan Negara oleh Perdana Menteri
Ikuti Perutusan Negara Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Polis panggil Mohamed Azmin bantu siasatan berhubung pendedahan maklumat
Ketua Polis Selangor Datuk Hussein Omar Khan berkata rakaman keterangan itu, bagi membantu siasatan di bawah Seksyen 203A Kanun Keseksaan iaitu pendedahan maklumat.
Hentikan amalan sakau wang rakyat, kayakan diri dan kelompok kecil - PM Anwar
Kerajaan Perpaduan mewarisi negara dalam keadaan sukar, termasuk hutang negara yang tinggi dan kenyataan itu seolah-olah cuba dipadamkan sesetengah pihak.
Lapan cap jari ditemukan di lokasi Faisal Halim disimbah asid - KPN
Bagaimanapun, hasil analisis mendapati lima daripadanya tidak cukup sifat.
Kerajaan setuju laksana penyasaran subsidi bahan api diesel - PM Anwar
Dengan penyasaran subsidi diesel tersebut, jumlah penjimatan kepada kerajaan adalah dijangka sekitar RM4 bilion setahun.
Rasuah adalah barah utama yang melemah ekonomi negara, menjatuhkan moral rakyat - PM
Kelemahan tatakelola dan amalan rasuah sudah sistemik, dari peringkat atas, peringkat penengah hingga ke peringkat bawahan.
Gempa bumi dengan magnitud 5.8 gegarkan timur Taiwan
Gempa bumi dengan magnitud 5.8 melanda pesisir pantai Daerah Hualien di timur Taiwan pada pukul 3.45 petang Jumaat.
Syed Saddiq mohon pelepasan sementara pasport untuk ke Singapura dan Taiwan
Ahli Parlimen Muar Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman telah memfailkan permohonan bagi pelepasan sementara pasportnya untuk membolehkan beliau ke Singapura dan Taiwan.
Piala Thomas: Taiwan lakar kejutan singkir Denmark untuk mara ke separuh akhir
Kejayaan sensasi itu menyaksikan Taiwan berdepan Indonesia dan Malaysia menentang China di pentas separuh akhir pada jam 5 petang hari ini.
Piala Uber: Malaysia tewas kepada Taiwan
Malaysia memulakan kempen Kumpulan B Piala Uber 2024 mereka dengan langkah kiri apabila tewas 1-4 kepada Taiwan, di sini hari ini.
Gempa bumi sederhana dikesan di Taiwan
Gempa bumi dengan kedalaman 10 kilometer (km) itu berlaku pada jarak 71 km tenggara dari Taichung, Taiwan.
Kejohanan Olahraga Tiger Klasik: Azeem rekod masa terpantas 2024
Muhammad Azeem merekodkan prestasi terbaiknya musim ini apabila merakamkan 10.31 saat dalam acara 100m Kejohanan Olahraga Tiger Klasik, di Taiwan.
Gempa bumi di Taiwan diunjur beri kesan minimum kepada industri semikonduktor Malaysia
Antara bangunan di Hualien yang runtuh akibat gempa bumi yang melanda timur Taiwan. FOTO CNA / AFP
'Tanah Besar China, Taiwan sedarah sedaging' - Presiden Xi
Tanah Besar China dan Taiwan sedarah sedaging dan hubungan antara kedua-dua pantai Selat Taiwan harus ditangani dengan menjaga kepentingan keseluruhan dan memacu pembangunan untuk jangka masa panjang.
Dua warga Singapura hilang selepas gempa bumi di Taiwan - Laporan
Pejabat Perdagangan Singapura di Taipei berhubung rapat dengan pihak berkuasa tempatan mengenai perkara itu.
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Antara pelbagai berita luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.