Johnny Depp has won his defamation suit against his ex-wife Amber Heard for her Washington Post op-ed article published in 2018, which stated she was a “public figure representing domestic abuse”.
The facts in every case are unique, and the jury is always in a better position to judge these facts than commentators relying on media reports.
Nevertheless in such a high profile case as this, the verdict has a ripple effect that can go beyond the facts. The unfortunate reality is the Depp Heard case is likely to reinforce the fear that women who come forward with claims of sexual and domestic abuse will encounter a system in which they are unlikely to be believed.
Reform is needed to better balance the protection of men’s individual reputations with the rights of women to speak about their experiences.
Depp was awarded more than US$10 million in damages after convincing the jury Heard was a malicious liar.
This is despite the fact a UK judge determined in 2020 that it was “substantially true” Depp had assaulted Heard repeatedly during their relationship.
After the verdict, Heard commented she was “heartbroken that the mountain of evidence still was not enough to stand up to the disproportionate power, influence, and sway” of her famous ex-husband.
Historically, the common law of defamation was built to protect public men in their professions and trades. It worked to both defend their reputations individually and shut down speech about them as a group.
Data from the United States in the late 20th century shows women comprise only 11% of plaintiffs bringing defamation suits.
As legal scholar Diane Borden has noted, the majority of libel plaintiffs are “men engaged in corporate or public life who boast relatively elite standing in their communities”.
Defamation trials – which run according to complex and idiosyncratic rules – are often lengthy and expensive, thus favouring those with the resources to instigate and pursue them.
Various defences exist, including arguing that the comments are factually true, or that they were made on occasions of “qualified privilege”, where a person has a duty to communicate information and the recipient has a corresponding interest in receiving it.
But in one way or another, disputes concerning allegations of sexual and domestic abuse usually come down to matters of credibility and believability that play on gendered stereotypes.
It becomes another version of “he said, she said”, and as we’ve seen from the social media response to Amber Heard, women making these types of allegations are often positioned as vengeful or malicious liars before their cases even reach the courts. This is despite the fact sexual assault and intimate partner violence are common, and false reporting is rare.
In fact, most victims don’t tell the police, their employer or others what happened to them due to fears of not being believed, facing professional consequences, or being subject to shaming and further abuse.
Heard has received thousands of death threats and suffered relentless mockery on social media.
The global #MeToo movement and recent Australian campaigns, such as those instigated by Grace Tame and Brittany Higgins, encourage survivors to speak out and push collectively for change.
But now, ruinous and humiliating defamation suits could further coerce and convince women to keeping their experiences quiet and private. Measures must be taken to better protect public speech on such matters.
One potential way forward is for defamation trials involving imputations of gendered abuse to incorporate expert evidence about the nature of sexual and domestic violence in our society.
For decades, feminist legal scholars fought for the inclusion of such evidence in criminal trials, especially those relating to matters of self-defence in domestic homicides and issues of consent in rape proceedings.
Expert sociological and psychological evidence can combat and discredit ingrained patriarchal assumptions and myths – comments and questions such as “what was she wearing?”; “why didn’t she fight back?”; “why didn’t she just leave him?”; “why was she nice to him afterwards?” or “why didn’t she tell people at the time?”
Otherwise, pervasive gender bias – often held by both men and women, judge and jury – can undermine the voices and accounts of women before they even set foot in court, before they even open their mouths.
Defamation trials have not traditionally included such expert evidence. But now that they have become a powerful forum for silencing speech about gendered harm, perhaps it’s time they did so.
READ ALSO - Amber Heard plans to appeal ruling that she defamed Johnny Depp
Reuters
Fri Jun 03 2022
Actors Amber Heard and Johnny Depp wait at the courtroom at the Fairfax County Circuit Courthouse in Fairfax, Virginia, US. - REUTERS/Filepic
Kertas Kabinet wujud sektor industri sukan dibentang dalam tempoh sebulan - Hannah
Kertas Kabinet berkenaan usaha mewujudkan sektor industri sukan dijangka dibentang kepada Jemaah Menteri dalam tempoh sebulan.
MoU PBS dan STAR elak pertembungan calon dalam PRN Sabah
Ketua Penerangan Parti Gagasan Rakyat Sabah (Gagasan Rakyat), Datuk NIzam Abu Bakar Titingan berkata MoU antara PBS dan STAR bagi mengelakkan kehilangan kerusi sepertimana yang berlaku dalam PRN16.
#AWANIBorneo
#AWANIBorneo
PRK KKB: GPS tidak akan terlibat kempen - Fadillah
Ketua Whip GPS yang juga Timbalan Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Fadillah Yusof mengesahkan gabuingan itu tidak akan terlibat dalam kempen PRk Kuala Kubu Bharu.
#AWANIBorneo
#AWANIBorneo
1,000 peluang pekerjaan bakal dinikmati penduduk Tongod
Sebuah kilang simen bernilai RM1.2 bilion akan dibina di Penangah, Tongod, Sabah sekali gus mewujudkan 1,000 peluang pekerjaan baharu.
#AWANIBorneo
#AWANIBorneo
Bahan keperluan utama industri kini ada di Sabah
Menteri Pembangunan Perindustrian dan Keusahawanan Sabah, Datuk Phoong Jin Zhe berkata, dengan pembukaan kilang simen itu, satu lagi bahan keperluan utama industri bakal diwujudkan di Sabah.
#AWANIBorneo
#AWANIBorneo
Peruntukan RM60 juta untuk bina semula SMK Sebuyau
Premier Sarawak, Tan Sri Abang Johari Tun Openg berkata, kerajaan negeri akan mengambil-alih projek berkenaan yang telah diluluskan dalam Rancangan Malaysia Ke-11 (RMK-11), namun tertangguh akibat kekangan peruntukan.
#AWANIBorneo
#AWANIBorneo
Kerajaan serius selesaikan isu industri minyak sawit - Johari
Kerajaan serius dalam usaha meleraikan isu membabitkan industri minyak sawit negara yang boleh memberi impak sekiranya tidak ditangani.
Gitar John Lennon dilelong RM3.81 juta
Sebuah gitar akustik yang lama hilang milik anggota The Beatles, John Lennon ditemui semula dan akan dipamerkan serta dilelong di New York City.
Pengusaha stesen minyak berdepan ugutan diminta buat laporan polis - Saifuddin
Pengusaha stesen minyak yang menjadi mangsa ugutan sindiket penyeludupan bahan api bersubsidi digesa membuat laporan polis.
Liga Parlimen Al-Quds: Malaysia kongsi pengalaman perjuang nasib rakyat Palestin - Syed Ibrahim
Delegasi negara berkongsikan pengalaman Malaysia sebagai usaha berterusan mempertahankan nasib Palestin dalam Persidangan Liga Parlimen Al-Quds di Istanbul, Turki pada Sabtu.
Amber Heard bayar saman, Johnny Depp derma semua pada rumah kebajikan
Heard dilaporkan media tempatan telah membayar sebanyak RM4.6 juta seperti yang diarahkan oleh mahkamah kepada Depp.
Amber Heard seronok duduk Sepanyol, sudah move on daripada Johnny Depp
Setelah melalui episod perceraian dan perseteruan di mahkamah yang tidak menyebelahinya, Amber Heard membawa diri berpindah ke Sepanyol.
Johnny Depp terima kontrak termahal dalam sejarah jenama Dior
Christian Dior dilaporkan telah memperbaharui kontrak luar biasa dengan pesohor hiburan penuh kontroversi, Johnny Depp.
Amber Heard setuju bayar AS$1 juta, selesai saman fitnah terhadap Johnny Depp
Heard bagaimanapun berkata keputusan itu "bukan tanda bersetuju", sebaliknya kerana dia "hilang kepercayaan terhadap sistem perundangan Amerika Syarikat".
Amber Heard gagal cubaan dapatkan perbicaraan baharu
Peguam Heard memfailkan permohonan mahkamah untuk membatalkan keputusan kes dan mengisytiharkan perbicaraan silap atas alasan juri berat sebelah.
Amber Heard didakwa semakin 'sengkek', dilihat beli-belah baju murah
Menerusi gambar-gambar yang dirakam orang awam, Amber dilihat sedang membelek beberapa pakaian yang dipamerkan di pusat beli-belah berkenaan.
Bukti rakaman 'Amber VS Johnny' didedahkan 25 Jun ini
Saksikan "Amber VS Johnny" pada 25 Jun ini, jam 9.55 malam di saluran Discovery Channel.
Peguam Johnny Depp jadi buruan Hollywood
Peguam Johnny Depp, Camille Vasquez dilaporkan menerima banyak tawaran dari Hollywood selepas berjaya mencuri perhatian semasa perbicaraan saman malu antara anak guamnya dan aktres Amber Heard.
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Antara pelbagai berita luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah antara yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
Tiada jalan kembali ke Hollywood untuk Amber Heard - Pakar perhubungan awam
Perbicaraan dramatik di mahkamah selama enam minggu itu menimbulkan pelbagai persoalan tentang kerjayanya dan situasi kewangannya, termasuk kemungkinan hilang pendapatan sehingga AS$50 juta.