NEW YORK: The U.S. judge named to review documents seized by the FBI last month at Donald Trump's Florida home pressed Trump's lawyers on Tuesday to say whether they plan to assert that the records had been declassified by the former president, as he has claimed.
Judge Raymond Dearie - serving as an independent arbiter, or special master, to vet the more than 11,000 seized documents and potentially recommend keeping some away from federal investigators - asked Trump's lawyers why he should not consider records marked classified as genuinely classified.
"If the government gives me prima facie evidence (a legal term meaning a fact presumed to be true unless disproved) that this is classified, and you decide not to advance a claim of declassification ... as far as I'm concerned that's the end of it," Dearie told Trump's lawyers in his first public hearing on the matter.
Dearie, a senior federal judge in Brooklyn who Trump's lawyers recommended to serve as special master, did not issue a ruling.
Roughly 100 of the documents seized in the court-approved Aug. 8 search at Trump's home in the Mar-a-Lago resort in Palm Beach had classified markings. Trump's attorney James Trusty told Dearie it is too early to say Trump had used his powers while still president to declassify the documents - a stance that Dearie suggested weakened the claim.
"You can't have your cake and eat it," the judge said.
The Justice Department is conducting a criminal investigation of Trump for retaining government records, some marked as highly classified including top secret, at Mar-a-Lago after leaving office in January 2021. Trump has denied wrongdoing and has said without providing evidence that the investigation is a partisan attack.
Trump has said in social media posts that he declassified the records, but his lawyers have skirted the issue in court.
The three statutes underpinning the search warrant used by the FBI at Mar-a-Lago make it a crime to mishandle government records, regardless of their classification status.
Dearie is tasked with recommending to Florida-based U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon, who is presiding over the fight over access to the seized documents, which records may be protected by attorney-client confidentiality or an assertion of executive privilege, a legal doctrine under which a president can keep certain documents or information secret.
Trump's lawyers argued that now is not the time to present specific information regarding declassification and, in a letter filed ahead of the hearing, said it would force them to disclose a defense to any subsequent indictment - an acknowledgement that the investigation could lead to criminal charges.
Cannon's order appointing Dearie as special master asked him to conclude his review by the end of November and to prioritize documents marked as classified. The process set out by Cannon called for a Trump lawyer to review the documents, a task for which members of his legal team may lack the necessary U.S. government security clearance.
Trusty asked Dearie to urge prosecutors to let more members of Trump's team get proper clearance. Dearie said only those who truly need to see classified material should be granted access.
Julie Edelstein, a prosecutor, told the hearing some of the documents are so sensitive that even some members of the Justice Department team have not been allowed to see them.
The Justice Department on Friday appealed to the Atlanta-based 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals the portion of Cannon's ruling allowing the special master to vet the records marked as classified and the judge's restricting FBI access to them.
Trump's legal team on Tuesday opposed the government's request and calling the Justice Department's investigation "unprecedented and misguided."
The department opened its investigation after the National Archives, the U.S. agency responsible for preserving government records, tried to get missing government property returned by Trump and received 15 boxes with classified documents mixed in.
Reuters
Wed Sep 21 2022
Donald Trump's attorneys (front row) Christopher Kise, Lindsey Halligan and Evan Corcoran listen in front of lawyers for the justice department Jay Bratt, Juan Antonio Gonzalez and Julie Edelstein at a courtroom in NY, US, Sept 20, 2022. - REUTERS
AWANI Ringkas: Ucaptama PM di Forum Nikkei ke-29
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Susulan serangan Ulu Tiram: Polis Perak tingkatkan kawalan di 16 IPD, 107 balai polis
Polis Perak turut menambah anggota yang bertugas pada sebelah malam di setiap IPD dan balai polis sebagai langkah memperketat keselamatan.
CCTV dipercayai rakaman insiden serangan asid terhadap Faisal Halim tular
Tular satu rakaman kamera CCTV di platfrom X yang memperlihatkan insiden dipercayai serangan asid terhadap bintang Selangor FC, Faisal Halim.
Spotify kemas kini rupa huruf dengan rekaan tersendiri
Ia dibangunkan dengan kerjasama Dinamo Typefaces yang merupakan studio reka bentuk berpangkalan di Berlin.
[TERKINI] Bekas Setiausaha politik Hamzah Zainuddin didakwa terima rasuah RM350,000
Bekas Setiausaha Politik kepada Ketua Pembangkang, Datuk Seri Hamzah Zainudin, mengaku tidak bersalah di Mahkamah Sesyen Kuala Lumpur pada Khamis, atas dua pertuduhan menerima suapan RM350,000 berhubung tender perkhidmatan penyelenggaraan dan pembekalan alat ganti peralatan, empat tahun lalu.
Nikkei Forum: Posisi Malaysia di pentas global
Profesor di Pusat Pengajian Antarabangsa, UUM, Prof. Dr. Muhammad Fuad Othman mengulas lanjut berkenaan impak ucaptama Perdana Menteri di Forum Nikkei dari sudut geopolitik dan multilateral seiring kepengerusian ASEAN 2025 oleh Malaysia.
Representasi Papagomo gugur pertuduhan ditolak, perbicaraan bermula 11 Julai
Representasi dikemukakan Papagomo untuk menggugurkan pertuduhan menyebut kata-kata menghasut yang mengaitkan kerajaan pro kepada Israel ditolak Jabatan Peguam Negara.
Malaysia sedia memimpin ASEAN ke arah kestabilan dan kemakmuran
Malaysia menegaskan komitmennya untuk mengukuhkan kepimpinan dan kerjasama serantau dalam menghadapi cabaran global yang semakin meningkat.
Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim berkata perdagangan, pelaburan dan teknologi kini sering digunakan sebagai senjata dalam persaingan antara kuasa dunia, sekali gus menjejaskan negara-negara membangun.
Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim berkata perdagangan, pelaburan dan teknologi kini sering digunakan sebagai senjata dalam persaingan antara kuasa dunia, sekali gus menjejaskan negara-negara membangun.
Arab Saudi tangguh pemberian visa umrah sebagai persediaan musim haji 1445H
Pemberian visa umrah melalui aplikasi telefon pintar "Nusuk" ditangguhkan mulai Khamis, 23 Mei (15 Zulkaedah) hingga 21 Jun (15 Zulhijjah).
Perbuatan mengkafirkan orang bawa kemusnahan dahsyat - Saifuddin
"Amalan yang membawa kepada kepercayaan 'iman kita sendiri saja yang sempurna, orang lain rosak imannya, orang lain kafir' tak boleh dibenarkan' ", kata Menteri Dalam Negeri, Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail. #AWANInews
Pilihan raya AS: Biden, Trump setuju dengan dua Debat Presiden
Joe Biden dan Donald Trump setuju mengadakan dua Debat Presiden pada Jun dan September ini sebagai sebahagian daripada kempen pilihan raya.
Hakim tangguh perbicaraan dokumen sulit Trump
Perbicaraan berkemungkinan tidak akan bermula sebelum pilihan raya presiden AS pada November.
Biden rancang untuk berdebat dengan Trump
Sebelum ini, Biden tidak komited untuk berdebat dengan lawannya, Trump.
Lelaki bertindak bakar diri di luar mahkamah New York
Max Azzarello yang berasal dari St. Augustine, Florida, dilaporkan telah diselamatkan dan berada dalam keadaan kritikal.
7 juri dipilih dalam bicara kes wang sogok yang dihadapi Trump
Tujuh juri dipilih dalam perbicaraan kes wang sogok Donald Trump di New York, perbicaraan jenayah pertama terhadap bekas presiden Amerika Syarikat.
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Antara pelbagai berita luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
Perbicaraan skandal Donald Trump - bintang porno bermula
Donald Trump menjadi bekas Presiden Amerika Syarikat pertama yang menghadapi perbicaraan kes jenayah.
Bicara kes bayaran tutup mulut yang dihadapi Trump bermula dengan pemilihan juri
Donald Trump akan menjadi bekas presiden pertama dalam sejarah Amerika Syarikat (AS) yang dibicarakan atas tuduhan jenayah.
Trump gagal tangguh, perbicaraan tetap berlangsung 15 April ini
Ini merupakan kali pertama bekas Presiden AS dibicarakan melibatkan bayaran menutup mulut kepada seorang bintang filem lucah.
Biden menang pemilihan peringkat awal di Dakota Utara
Dalam pemilihan peringkat awal di Dakota Utara, terdapat 13 perwakilan ditawarkan dan kebanyakan pengundian dilakukan melalui undi pos.