What’s worse for big business in Hong Kong -- street protests, or the tear gas fired to disperse the protests? That's the uncomfortable question now confronting Hong Kong's button-down business community, which has co-existed relatively peacefully with the city’s Communist overlords since the handover to Chinese rule in 1997.
For 30 years, nobody -- other than perhaps China’s growing middle-class -- has benefited more from China’s economic rise than Hong Kong. Uniquely positioned both geographically and politically as a bridge between the mainland and the developed world, Hong Kong’s leaders and businesspeople have learned the value of not rocking the boat and -- when necessary -- throwing in with those who promise continued good times.
Few groups appreciate stability quite as much as the Big Four audit firms (Deloitte, PwC, Ernst & Young and KPMG), all of whom covet the business of the state-owned Chinese companies that have long favored Hong Kong’s equity markets for public listings. The multinationals proved as much on June 27, when they jointly published a letter calling upon Occupy Central -- the pro-democracy movement partly behind the current protests in central Hong Kong -- to stand down. The warning was specific, prescient and written in language intended to appeal to Hong Kong’s commercially-minded citizens:
If Occupy Central happens, commercial institutions such as banks, exchanges and the stock market will inevitably be affected. We are worried that multinational corporations and investors will consider relocating their headquarters from Hong Kong or even withdrawing their businesses.
Two days after Hong Kong students began an unofficial occupation of central Hong Kong, the first part of the warning has come true. Markets are down, while banks and other business are closed. In the unlikely event that the protests are allowed to continue for several more days, the damage to the local economy could become substantial.
But would that be enough to convince multinational companies, investors, and audit firms to leave Hong Kong? Needless to say, it’s the rare multinational that hasn’t operated in a challenging political environment. For now, protests are an inconvenience, but they’re surely not enough to force a major Western company -- or a Chinese state-owned company -- to seek a new headquarters, especially in age when most employees can probably operate from home indefinitely. Hong Kong’s political and financial advantages are too great to be overshadowed by barricaded subway stops and college students blocking downtown arteries.
But the same cannot be said of a city that responds to peaceful student protests with tear gas. No doubt, plenty of Hong Kong businesspeople would like nothing more than to see the students cleared from central Hong Kong immediately, no matter the means. But there are also plenty of moderate Hong Kong bankers, accountants, and lawyers who are horrified to see that the authorities' first instinct was to respond with violence. Indeed, not only does Hong Kong’s handling of the protests reflect an authoritarian state of mind that seems out of place in what has traditionally been one of Asia’s most tolerant cities. It also suggests a government that lacks the competence to do what other world cities do regularly: peacefully manage a student protest.
If Hong Kong’s business community hopes to preserve what’s unique about their city, it can no longer remain silent about how the local and Chinese governments have chosen to manage dissent there. Rather, they need to be just as vocal about the negative consequences of assaulting unarmed students as they have been about threats to shut down the central business district. It’s time for them to reaffirm how a world-class business city should behave under duress. The Chinese government won’t appreciate the warning, but it’s guaranteed to listen.
- By Adam Minter
Bloomberg
Tue Sep 30 2014
Its time for Hong Kong businesses to reaffirm how a world-class business city should behave under duress.
Malaysia, Kazakhstan sepakat perkukuh hubungan, teroka kerjasama baharu
Malaysia dan Kazakhstan sepakat untuk terus memperkukuhkan hubungan yang terjalin sejak 16 Mac 1992, serta meneroka peluang kerjasama baharu.
Pecah amanah: JSJK dedah dua kes baharu oleh firma guaman, pelanggan rugi RM8 juta
JSJK mendedahkan dua kes terbaharu membabitkan jenayah pecah amanah oleh firma guaman melibatkan kerugian wang pelanggan berjumlah RM8 juta.
Bersatu hantar surat kepada semua Ahli Parlimen, ADUN
Parti Pribumi Bersatu Malaysia sudah menghantar surat arahan bertulis majlis pimpinan tertinggi parti kepada semua Ahli Parlimen dan Ahli Dewan Undangan Negeri parti itu.
Setiausaha Agung Bersatu, Datuk Seri Hamzah Zainudin berkata, surat itu mengandungi lima perkara utama bagi mengingatkan ahli parti tentang tanggungjawab mereka di bawah perlembagaan Bersatu.
Enam ahli Bersatu yang berpaling tadah dengan menyatakan sokongan kepada kerajaan Perpaduan diberi tempoh 14 hari untuk mengakui menerima dan mengesahkan pematuhan semua arahan yang dilampirkan bersama surat khusus yang dihantar kepada mereka.
Setiausaha Agung Bersatu, Datuk Seri Hamzah Zainudin berkata, surat itu mengandungi lima perkara utama bagi mengingatkan ahli parti tentang tanggungjawab mereka di bawah perlembagaan Bersatu.
Enam ahli Bersatu yang berpaling tadah dengan menyatakan sokongan kepada kerajaan Perpaduan diberi tempoh 14 hari untuk mengakui menerima dan mengesahkan pematuhan semua arahan yang dilampirkan bersama surat khusus yang dihantar kepada mereka.
Baling bom petrol di pusat hiburan: dua lagi lelaki didakwa
Peguam M.V. Yoges yang mewakili kedua-dua tertuduh memohon jaminan rendah atas alasan Muhammad Hasan mempunyai tanggungan enam orang anak serta isteri yang menghidap asma serta ibu mentua yang sakit tua
[TERKINI] Tujuh individu termasuk ahli keluarga direman pada Sabtu
Tujuh individu yang ditahan berhubung insiden serangan di Balai Polis Ulu Tiram, Johor Bahru akan dibawa ke Mahkamah Majistret pada Sabtu bagi mendapatkan perintah reman.
TPM Fadillah ketuai delegasi Malaysia ke Forum Air Dunia di Bali
Timbalan Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Fadillah Yusof akan mengetuai delegasi Malaysia ke Forum Air Dunia kali ke-10 di Bali dari 18 hingga 21 Mei atas jemputan Presiden Indonesia, Joko Widodo.
Kazakhstan beri peluang syarikat Malaysia teroka bidang baharu
Kazakhstan bersetuju memberi peluang kepada syarikat Malaysia untuk meneroka pelbagai bidang di negara Asia Tengah itu termasuk perlombongan dan tenaga boleh baharu.
Baling bom petrol di pusat hiburan: Dua lagi lelaki didakwa
Dua lelaki mengaku tidak bersalah atas pertuduhan melakukan khianat dengan membaling bom petrol di sebuah pusat hiburan di ibu kota.
12 terbunuh dipanah petir di Bengal Barat, India
Sekurang-kurangnya 12 orang terbunuh dan beberapa lagi mangsa cedera pada Khamis akibat dipanah petir di Bengal Barat, di timur India.
MyCEB lebar luas rangkaian dengan para pemain acara perniagaan di IMEX Frankfurt
Penyertaan tahun ini tepat pada masanya ketika MyCEB, agensi di bawah MOTAC, menggembleng usaha mempromosikan Tahun Melawat Malaysia 2026.
Piala Thomas: 'Kemenangan ke atas Hong Kong lonjak keyakinan' - Jun Hao
Kem perseorangan negara Piala Thomas 2024 berjaya membuktikan kemampuan mereka, sekurang-kurangnya selepas mengetepikan pemain Hong Kong dalam aksi pembukaan Kumpulan D hari ini.
Piala Thomas: Leong Jun Hao lakar kebangkitan, pastikan kemenangan Malaysia!
Leong Jun Hao melakar kebangkitan memastikan Malaysia memperoleh kemenangan ke atas wakil Hong Kong, Angus Ng Ka Long.
Thomas Cup: Zii Jia ketepikan 'kegoyahan' kem perseorangan lelaki negara
Lee Zii Jia tidak mahu terlalu memikirkan situasi kem perseorangan negara yang kurang mantap menjelang aksi pembukaan Kumpulan D saingan Piala Thomas 2024 berdepan Hong Kong, esok.
'Malaysia ada kelebihan di Piala Thomas'
Pemain profesional negara Cheam June Wei menyifatkan pasukan negara mempunyai kelebihan tersendiri pada pertarungan pusingan pertama bertemu Hong Kong pada kejohanan Piala Thomas 2024.
Hong Kong tagih sentuhan pakar untuk Piala Thomas
Hong Kong, yang mempunyai bekas pemain antarabangsa Wong Choong Hann dan Choong Tan Fook dalam set kejurulatihan mereka, hanya membuat penampilan keenam mereka di pusingan akhir.
KPKT akan perkenal model perumahan awam baharu - Nga
Kementerian Perumahan dan Kerajaan Tempatan sedang merangka model baharu perumahan awam yang dinamakan Program Residensi Rakyat (PRR).
Aksi Argentina di China batal angkara Messi
Messi berdepan dengan kritikan selepas dia hanya berada di bangku simpanan semasa perlawanan persahabatan yang menampilkan Inter Miami di Hong Kong.
Piala Asia: Kemenangan pertama bawa Palestin ke pusingan kalah mati
Penyerang Oday Dabbagh muncul pemain paling menonjol apabila menjaringkan dua gol.
Witchcraft terus penguasaan di RLIR 2024
Witchcraft mempamerkan corak pelayaran konsisten untuk berada di kedudukan pertama dengan lima mata penalti.
Dua penalti bantu UAE atasi Hong Kong 3-1
Naib juara edisi 1996 itu mendahului 1-0 pada separuh masa pertama menerusi sepakan penalti yang disempurnakan Sultan Adill Alamiri.