PUTRAJAYA: A seven-member Federal Court panel today dismissed a review application by Malaysiakini to overturn a Federal Court's decision which found the online news portal guilty for contempt over comments by its readers.
The panel led by Justice Puan Sri Zaleha Yusof held that the arguments raised in today's review proceedings by counsel Datuk Malik Imtiaz Sarwar, representing Malaysiakini operator Mkini Dotcom Sdn Bhd, had been raised and considered by the Federal Court panel hearing the contempt application.
She said the court were not persuaded by the submissions raised by the counsel on issues pertaining to allegation of breach of the rules of natural justice.
Even, if assuming for a moment that the court agree with the argument by Malaysiakini's counsel, the court is constrained by lack of jurisdiction to entertain the complaints as it is a review application and not an appeal, she added.
Justice Zaleha said since the matter is a public interest case, the court would not make any order on costs.
The other judges presiding were Datuk Zabariah Mohd Yusof, Datuk Seri Hasnah Mohammed Hashim, Datuk Mary Lim Thiam Suan, Datuk Harmindar Singh Dhaliwal, Datuk Rhodzariah Bujang and Datuk Mohamad Zabidin Mohd Diah.
On Feb 19 last year, in a 6-1 majority decision, a Federal Court seven-member bench led by Court of Appeal President Tan Sri Rohana Yusuf, found Mkini Dotcom guilty of contempt of court for facilitating in the publication of five readers' comments and fined the company RM500,000. Mkini Dotcom paid the fine.
The Federal Court, on June 17, 2020 had allowed Attorney-General's ex-parte application to obtain leave to commence committal proceedings against Mkini Dotcom and its editor-in-chief Steven Gan over readers' comments on an article published by Malaysiakini on June 9, 2020, entitled "CJ orders all courts to be fully operational from July 1" which was deemed offensive.
The court, however, found Gan not guilty of contempt of court.
In the review application filed only by Mkini Dotcom, the company sought to set aside the earlier Federal Court's decision and a re-hearing of the contempt proceedings.
In today's proceeding conducted online, Malik Imtiaz argued that Malaysiakini had been prejudiced as the majority judgment of the Federal Court dealt on certain issues which was beyond the Attorney-General's argument.
He said Malaysiakini would not have been found guilty for contempt of court if the case was based only on the Attorney-General's case as the later had conceded on some points that favoured the portal.
Malik Imtiaz said the Federal Court panel, in arriving at the majority decision, had occasioned serious breaches of the rules of natural justice, resulting in a miscarriage of justice.
He also said Malaysiakini was not asked or given the chance to clarify during the contempt hearing on issues that formed the foundation of the majority judgment.
Senior federal counsel Suzana Atan representing the Attorney-General, however, submitted that the review application was without merit as the Federal Court panel hearing the contempt proceedings had made findings of facts and on law based on evidence that was adduced in the court.
She said the review application is an attempt to re-submit arguments that had already been submitted in the contempt proceedings.
The other lawyers representing Mkini Dotcom were Surendra Ananth and Khoo Suk Chyi, while federal counsel Saravanan Kuppusamy also represented the Attorney-General.
Lawyers who held a watching brief were Datuk Joy Wilson Appukuttan for the Bar Council and New Sin Yew for the International Federation of Journalists (IFJ) and National Union of Journalists Malaysia (NUJM).
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Tue Mar 29 2022
A seven-member Federal Court panel today dismissed a review application by Malaysiakini to overturn a Federal Court's decision which found the online news portal guilty for contempt over comments by its readers. - malaysiakini
Tumpuan Selasa –21 Mei 2024
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan di Astro AWANI.
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Antara pelbagai berita luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
KP Kementerian Luar Singapura dijatuhkan hukuman penjara, salah guna beg diplomatik
Oh menghadapi dua pertuduhan menipu kerana menyalahgunakan perkhidmatan beg diplomatik.
10 Berita Pilihan - (20 Mei 2024)
Antara pelbagai berita dalam dan luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
Cuba ceroboh masuk Istana Negara, dua individu dipenjara dua bulan
Pertuduhan dibuat mengikut Seksyen 447/451 Kanun Keseksaan dan dibaca bersama Seksyen 34 kanun sama.
Kerajaan Malaysia bekerjasama dengan rakan antarabangsa untuk bawa keluar pasukan perubatan MERCY
Kerajaan Malaysia sedang bekerjasama dengan rakan antarabangsa untuk membawa keluar sebuah pasukan perubatan Malaysia yang terperangkap di Rafah, Gaza, menurut Kementerian Luar (Wisma Putra).
PM Anwar ulangi gesaannya untuk AS hentikan keganasan Israel di Gaza
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim mengulangi gesaannya supaya Amerika Syarikat (AS) melakukan apa sahaja yang diperlukan untuk menghentikan keganasan Israel di Gaza.
10 individu ditahan dalam enam serbuan khas aktiviti penyeludupan
Polis menahan 10 individu termasuk seorang wanita dalam enam serbuan menerusi operasi khas Biro Jenayah Hidupan Liar/Perisikan Siasatan Khas.
65 murid keracunan makanan di Sungai Petani
Seramai 65 murid Sekolah Kebangsaan Bandar Puteri Jaya dipercayai mengalami keracunan makanan selepas makan di kantin sekolah pagi tadi.
Pengadu terima panggilan pertama Ebit Lew jam 3.40 pagi - Saksi
Seorang wanita hari ini memberitahu Mahkamah Majistret bahawa dia menerima panggilan telefon pertama daripada Ebit Irawan Ibrahim Lew atau Ebit Lew pada jam 3.40 pagi, 4 Mac 2021.
Federal court fixed Dec 8 to hear Najib's application to intervene in Azilah's review
Deputy public prosecutor Muhammad Azmi Mashud appeared for the prosecution while lawyer J. Kuldeep Kumar appeared for Azilah.
[EKSKLUSIF] Apandi Ali umum letak jawatan, tak rela jadi 'kuda tunggangan' dalam UMNO
Mohamed Apandi letak jawatan sebagai Pengerusi Lembaga Displin kerana kecewa prosiding dengan Hishammuddin Hussein dibatalkan pucuk pimpinan.