PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal today struck out a lawsuit filed by a lawyer questioning the legality of the royal pardon granted to Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim for his sodomy conviction.
In striking out the lawsuit by Mohd Khairul Azam Abdul Aziz, the court allowed the appeals by Anwar and the Pardons Board against a High Court's dismissal of their applications to strike out the lawsuit.
A three-member bench of the Court of appeal, comprising Datuk Has Zanah Mehat, Datuk Indera Mohd Sofian Abd Razak and Datuk Lee Heng Cheong, in allowing the appeals by Anwar and the Pardons Board, held that the claims made by Mohd Khairul Azam against the appellants were obviously unsustainable as he did not disclose any reasonable cause of action against them.
In the court's decision, Justice Has Zanah who led the bench, said Mohd Khairul had no right to question the clemency or the advice given by the Pardons Board to the Yang-di Pertuan Agong in respect to the granting of the pardon.
"We find the process of clemency and granting of pardon by the Yang-di Pertuan Agong to the appellant (Anwar) does not in any manner or way attack the respondent's (Mohd Khairul) personal or legal or any right or interest," she said.
She said a decision made in pursuant to the exercise of royal pardon prerogative cannot be varied or confirmed by the court and hence it is not justiciable.
The power of pardon is preserved under Article 42 of the Federal Constitution, she said, adding that the power was not limited on just the sentence but also on the conviction.
She said the court found that the High Court judge had erred in not following the established list of court authorities decided by the Apex Court.
The court also find that the Pardons Board was lawfully and properly constituted under the Federal Constitution, she added.
On Sept 21 last year, the High Court dismissed both Anwar and the Pardons Board's applications to strike out the lawsuit, after finding that Mohd Khairul Azam had locus standi to initiate the legal suit as he is a member of the public and a qualified person as lawyer.
Anwar filed the striking-out application on grounds that Mohd Khairul Azam had no locus standi to file the originating summons and that it was frivolous, an embarrassment and abuse of the court process.
Mohd Khairul Azam, who filed the originating summons on Feb 26 last year and named the Pardons Board and Anwar as respondents, claimed that several unconstitutional actions had been taken to ensure that Anwar received a pardon which released him from prison following the 14th General Election in 2018.
He claimed that the pardon granted to Anwar by the Yang di-Pertuan Agong was in contravention of Articles 42 (4) and (5) of the Federal Constitution in view of the fact that pardons granted by the Agong should be based on the advice of the Pardons Board which he (Mohd Khairul Azam) argued had not yet been formally formed following the General Election on May 9, 2018, and the formation of the new government.
Anwar had been sentenced to five years' jail for sodomising his aide, Mohd Saiful Bukhari Azlan, and the conviction and sentence were affirmed by the Federal Court on Feb 10, 2015.
In the proceedings conducted online today, the court heard submissions from Anwar's counsel Datuk Seri Gopal Sri Ram, senior federal counsel Suzana Atan, who appeared for the Pardons Board, and lawyer Mohamed Haniff Khatri Abdullah, representing Mohd Khairul.
Suzana argued that Mohd Khairul should have established how the Pardons Board's decision had affected him and the reason he gave in his statement of claim did not fulfil the legal principles established by a recent Federal Court decision.
Meanwhile, Mohamed Haniff Khatri submitted that there can only be pardon on the sentence and not on the conviction, adding that those issues had never been decided in any court and that the suit should go for trial.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Tue Sep 21 2021
The Court of Appeal today struck out a lawsuit filed by a lawyer questioning the legality of the royal pardon granted to Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim for his sodomy conviction. - BERNAMA
Genting Malaysia nafi terbabit perbincangan
Selepas Berjaya Corporation Bhd dan Kerajaan Negeri Johor, kini Genting Malaysia Bhd pula menafikan sebarang penglibatan dalam perbincangan mengenai pengoperasian kasino di Forest City, Johor.
Berita tempatan pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Berikut adalah berita yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang Sabtu, 27 April 2024.
Lima cedera dalam tembakan di luar kelab malam di Washington
Lima cedera dalam insiden tembakan di luar sebuah kelab malam di Washington, Amerika Syarikat pada lewat Jumaat.
Potensi dilanda tsunami, pihak berkuasa tingkatkan amaran
Pihak berkuasa Indonesia tingkatkan lagi amaran Gunung Ruang di Sulawesi dengan mengeluarkan amaran tsunami susulan berlakunya sekali lagi letusan gunung ruang di wilayah Sulawesi utara pada Rabu.
Houthi tembak Kapal Tangki Minyak Andromeda Star di Laut Merah
Kumpulan Houthi terus melancarkan serangan ke atas kapal komersial di Laut Merah dan terbaharu serangan peluru berpandu mengenai kapal tangki minyak Andromeda Star.
Ratusan rumah, bangunan rosak dibadai puting beliung
Ratusan rumah, bangunan dan ladang ternakan di Omaha, Nebraska rosak akibat kejadian Puting beliung yang membadai kawasan itu pada petang Jumaat.
Hamas sudah terima maklum balas Israel mengenai cadangan gencatan senjata
Rundingan sebelum ini pada November lepas menyaksikan pembebasan 81 rakyat Israel dan 24 warga asing dengan pertukaran 240 warga Palestin termasuk 71 wanita dan 169 kanak-kanak.
95 kanak-kanak mangsa diselamatkan di India
Seramai 95 kanak-kanak berumur empat hingga 12 tahun diselamatkan di Uttar Pradesh di utara India, dipercayai mangsa pemerdagangan manusia dari negeri jiran, Bihar.
Pesara tentera diminta kemaskini data di JHEV
Jelas Adly setakat ini lebih 213 ribu veteran berdaftar dengan jabatan tersebut, berbanding sekitar 300,000 yang telah bersara dalam perkhidmatan.
10 Berita Pilihan - (27 April 2024)
Antara pelbagai berita dalam dan luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
Nahas helikopter Lumut: Presiden Turkiye ucap takziah kepada keluarga anggota, Malaysia - Anwar
Presiden Turkiye Recep Tayyip Erdogan mengutuskan ucapan takziah kepada keluarga 10 wira negara yang terkorban dalam nahas helikopter TLDM di Lumut, Perak.
Pihak dikaitkan dalam laporan berkaitan lesen kasino perlu ambil tindakan - PM Anwar
Laporan yang memetik satu sumber itu berkata perbincangan mengenai pemberian lesen itu masih di peringkat awal.
Tiada kasino akan beroperasi di Johor - Onn Hafiz
Onn Hafiz berkata khabar angin yang tular itu berunsur sabotaj dan berniat jahat untuk mencemar imej Forest City dan Johor secara keseluruhannya.
MOT, Khazanah, MAG perlu perkukuh tadbir urus MAB - PM Anwar
Jelas Anwar lagi, pengurusan syarikat penerbangan yang baik juga akan memberi manfaat kepada kakitangan melalui gaji yang setimpal dengan perkhidmatan mereka.
Kontroversi UM: Sarjana ‘berkualiti rendah’ tak patut dijemput - PM Anwar
Anwar menyindir ahli akademik AS yang terbabit dalam kontroversi pro-Israel sebagai sarjana berkualiti rendah dan tidak mempunyai pencapaian luar biasa atau istimewa.
Terdapat keperluan tambah bilangan wanita isi jawatan KSU, KP - PM Anwar
Anwar berkata jumlah pimpinan wanita sedia ada tidak mencerminkan jumlah keseluruhan 42 peratus golongan itu yang terlibat sebagai pembuat keputusan dalam perkhidmatan awam ketika ini.
PM nafi kerajaan beri lesen kasino di Forest City
Perdana Menteri menafikan laporan yang mendakwa kerajaan akan mengeluarkan lesen untuk pengoperasian kasino di Forest City, Johor.
SSPA terbaik pernah diperkenalkan kerajaan - PM Anwar
Beliau berkata, usaha tersebut diharap dapat menjadi motivasi buat penjawat awam untuk meningkatkan produktiviti, dan memberikan perkhidmatan terbaik kepada rakyat.
Sultan Selangor adakan pertemuan dengan PM Anwar di Seri Perdana
Sultan Selangor Sultan Sharafuddin Idris Shah berkenan berangkat ke kediaman rasmi Perdana Menteri di Kompleks Seri Perdana, Putrajaya.
Agong berkenan meriahkan Majlis Sulaman Kasih Aidilfitri Kementerian Perpaduan
Yang di-Pertuan Agong Sultan Ibrahim hari ini berkenan memeriahkan Majlis Sulaman Kasih Aidifitri Kementerian Perpaduan Negara.