Health Minister Datuk Seri Dr S. Subramaniam is either ignorant or lying to claim that healthcare costs will not be impacted by the implementation of the Goods and Services Tax (GST), the DAP said today.
DAP publicity chief Tony Pua (pic) commented on reports quoting Subramaniam saying healthcare costs would not be impacted when the GST is implemented in 2015.
On Tuesday, Subramaniam had said healthcare was generally GST-exempt and that the ministry would be carrying out an in-depth study on the GST structure before issuing a detailed list of services and health products which are exempted from the GST for public consumption.
Subramaniam had also urged all quarters to "not make speculation on this to avoid confusing the people."
Rebutting the minister, Pua said: "It is Subramaniam who should stop making misleading remarks 'to avoid confusing the people' and not otherwise. The Health Minister and many other Barisan Nasional leaders are obviously either ignorant about what is meant by GST-exempt, or choose not to be truthful about it."
Pua said, the government's GST website (http://gst.customs.gov.my) has explained "GST-exempt supplies" very clearly. In his explanation, a GST-exempt product or service only meant that no GST will be imposed by the provider to the consumer.
"However, provider of these products and services such as hospitals will still be required to pay GST for all products and services it purchases from its suppliers."
He cited an example of a hospital purchasing a drug from a medical supplier for RM50, and then sell it to patients at RM55 for a 10 percent profit margin.
"After the implementation of the GST, the hospital will have to pay the medical supplier RM50 plus six percent GST, amounting to RM3. The cost to the hospital would increase to RM53.
"If the hospital was to maintain the price of the drug to the consumer, then the hospital will only be making a profit of RM2 or a 3.8 percent profit margin," Pua said.
He said Subramaniam "must be day-dreaming to believe that Malaysian hospitals will be so magnanimous to absorb all the GST-induced increase in cost and continue to provide its products and services to the public at existing prices, and suffering a severe squeeze in profitability."
Continuing with the example, the Petaling Jaya Utara MP said assuming that the hospitals were 'extremely kind' and decided to only pass on the increase in cost in absolute terms to the patient, then the price of the drug sold would increase from the previous RM55 to RM58.
Pua said the RM3 increase is the amount of GST paid by the hospital to the Government, hence the hospital is only reclaiming its actual increase in cost.
"At RM58, that will already result in a 5.5 percent increase in healthcare cost to the consumer."
Pua said, this was just a conservative estimate and in the end the final prices might be even higher with markup by the hospital or medical businesses.
Given the example, Pua said "it is a practical impossibility" for the Government to control post-GST prices of goods and services in hospitals.
"Based on the explanations given by the Finance Ministry on 'GST Exempt Supplies', it is clear that our BN ministers either have an incompetent understanding on the impact of GST or they chose to be untruthful about its negative price impact."
Pua also said Pakatan Rakyat will continue to oppose the implementation of the GST based on the fact that the BN government has not been able to plug billions of ringgit in leakages, stop corruption and end cronyism in its administration.
Astro Awani
Wed Nov 06 2013
Kesan sampingan vaksin: KKM akan dapatkan penjelasan AstraZeneca
Kementerian Kesihatan (KKM) akan mendapatkan penjelasan daripada firma farmaseutikal AstraZeneca berhubung kesan sampingan vaksin COVID-19 seperti yang dilaporkan media antarabangsa baru-baru ini.
FIFA lulus penggunaan VAR di Liga Malaysia - FAM
Penggunaan teknologi Video Bantuan Pengadil (VAR) dalam saingan Liga Malaysia (Liga-M) bermula musim 2024/2025 sudah mendapat pengiktirafan dan kelulusan Persekutuan Bolasepak Antarabangsa (FIFA).
Niaga AWANI: AirAsia Cambodia mula penerbangan domestik pertama
AirAsia menghubungkan Kemboja dengan laluan antarabangsa dari hab Kuala Lumpur dan Bangkok dengan 63 penerbangan setiap minggu.
Niaga AWANI: Bukti Malaysia diiktiraf sebagai hab pilihan Asia Tenggara
Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Abdul Aziz, berkata ini menunjukkan keyakinan Microsoft terhadap Asia Tenggara dan kedudukan strategik Malaysia sebagai pintu masuk untuk pertumbuhan.
Niaga AWANI: Perkhidmatan Skypark Link akan diaktifkan kembali - Anthony Loke
Beliau menjelaskan terminal itu diharap dapat menarik lebih ramai penumpang ke lapangan terbang kerana ia merupakan antara kawasan paling sesak di Lembah Klang.
Niaga AWANI: Pengambilalihan Affin Bank, Sarawak tunggu lampu hijau BNM
Proses pengambil alihan majoriti pegangan saham dalam Affin Bank oleh Kerajaan Sarawak berada di peringkat akhir untuk dimuktamadkan.
Niaga AWANI: Trafik udara berkembang 16.1 peratus pada suku pertama 2024
Trafik penumpang udara domestik serta antarabangsa masing-masing menyumbang 47.5 peratus dan 52.5 peratus daripada jumlah trafik penumpang udara suku tahunan.
ADUN Sungai Bakap semakin stabil - Isteri
Keadaan Ahli Dewan Undangan Negeri (ADUN) Sungai Bakap Nor Zamri Latiff yang sedang menerima rawatan di Unit Rawatan Rapi (ICU) Hospital Seberang Jaya (HSJ), di sini kini semakin stabil.
Mahkamah Tinggi tolak permohonan Tengku Zafrul fail afidavit
Mahkamah Tinggi Kuala Lumpur menolak permohonan Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Tengku Abdul Aziz, untuk kebenaran memfailkan afidavit bagi memperbetulkan fakta didakwa tidak tepat dalam afidavit Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi.
PM yakin kenaikan gaji lulus bergaya di Parlimen
Perdana Menteri turut membidas pihak terbabit sebagai 'haprak' dan tidak boleh diterima kerana mengkritik usaha kerajaan untuk menaikkan gaji penjawat awam selepas 12 tahun ia tidak dilaksanakan.
PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu: Pang Sock Tao diumum calon Kerajaan Perpaduan
Pang Sock Tao diumumkan sebagai calon yang akan mewakili Kerajaan Perpaduan pada Pilihan Raya Kecil (PRK) Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Kuala Kubu Baharu.
'Hormati hak MCA tidak kempen kecuali calon dari BN' - Pemuda MCA
Pemuda MCA tidak akan menghalang mana-mana parti yang mahu membantu DAP untuk berkempen dalam Pilihan Raya Kecil (PRK) Kuala Kubu Baharu (KKB), Mei ini.
PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu: DAP sokong penuh siapa sahaja calon Kerajaan Perpaduan - Nga
DAP akan memberi sokongan penuh kepada siapa sahaja calon yang mewakili Kerajaan Perpaduan bagi PRK DUN Kuala Kubu Baharu pada 11 Mei ini.
DAP hormati keputusan mahkamah libat isu tahanan rumah Najib
DAP akan menghormati keputusan mahkamah berhubung permohonan bekas Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Najib Razak untuk menghabiskan baki hukuman penjara enam tahun sebagai tahanan di rumah.
PH bermesyuarat esok muktamadkan calon PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu
Kepimpinan tertinggi Pakatan Harapan (PH) akan bermesyuarat esok untuk memuktamadkan pemilihan calon yang mewakili gabungan itu pada PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu, Selangor, 11 Mei ini.
PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu: Wanita DAP punyai beberapa calon layak untuk diketengahkan
Wanita DAP mempunyai beberapa nama untuk diketengahkan sebagai calon mewakili Pakatan Harapan (PH), pada PRK Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Kuala Kubu Baharu, Selangor, 11 Mei ini.
DAP belum bincang PRK, tumpu pengebumian Lee - Teo
DAP mahu tumpu urusan pengebumian mendiang Lee Kee Hiong sebagai penghormatan kepada penyandang kerusi DUN berkenaan.
DAP tubuh jawatankuasa urus pengebumian mendiang ADUN Kuala Kubu Baharu
DAP Selangor akan menubuhkan satu jawatankuasa khusus bagi menguruskan pengebumian Ahli Dewan Undangan Negeri (ADUN) Kuala Kubu Baharu Lee Kee Hiong yang meninggal dunia hari ini.
DAP sokong keberanian PM jadi suara antarabangsa dalam isu Palestin - Loke
Setiausaha Agung DAP, Anthony Loke berkata, ini kerana kekejaman di Gaza hanya dapat ditamatkan melalui penyelesaian antarabangsa.
UMNO-DAP: Pemimpin perlu tunjuk teladan, hindari kenyataan sensitif - Penganalisis
Pemimpin dalam parti komponen yang membentuk Kerajaan Perpaduan perlu menunjukkan teladan yang baik kepada akar umbi demi mengekalkan kestabilan yang wujud.