PUTRAJAYA: The Federal Court today was told that the action by Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak and his son Datuk Mohd Nazifuddin to appeal against the summary judgments obtained by IRB to recover more than RM1.7 billion in tax arrears, was to evade paying the tax.
Head of Revenue Solicitor Dr Hazlina Hussain, who was representing the Inland Revenue Board (IRB) said generally the taxation scheme of every tax administration in the world demands that taxpayers pay the tax due and payable regardless of any appeal.
"If this appeal is allowed by the court, public interest shall be prejudiced as a whole and this appeal is filed by the appellants to evade the tax that is due and payable in the first place," she said during the hearing of Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak and his son Datuk Mohd Nazifuddin's appeals against the summary judgments entered against them before a panel of five judges led by Court of Appeal President Tan Sri Abang Iskandar Abang Hashim.
The other judges are Chief Judge of Malaya Datuk Mohamad Zabidin Mohd Diah and Federal Court judges Tan Sri Nallini Pathmanathan, Datuk Mary Lim Thiam Suan and Datuk Abu Bakar Jais.
She said, the scheme of taxation that a taxpayer must pay first does not prejudice or discriminate against the taxpayer as any taxpayer aggrieved by the Director-General of Inland Revenue's (DGIR) assessment can appeal to the Special Commissioners of Income Tax (SCIT), which is set up by an Act of Parliament, the Income Tax Act (ITA) 1967.
"The taxpayers must pay the amount due first and payable regardless of any appeal. The rationale behind this principle is to treat taxpayers equally, vis a vis, between compliant and non-compliant taxpayers, and most importantly, to protect the Government's coffers," she added.
Counsel Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah representing Najib and Mohd Nazifuddin submitted that it was clear the respondent is seeking to bankrupt the appellants even before the SCIT can hear the merits of the defence to the additional tax assessments raised against his clients.
"If the respondent succeeds in bankrupting the appellants even before the SCIT can proceed or conclude, this would mean that the respondent's entire argument of the SCIT being the "proper forum" is academic," he said adding that this case was not one that is suitable for summary judgment as there is a reason why it should proceed to trial.
The lawyer said this court is cloaked with the jurisdiction to hear and determine the constitutional challenge arising from Section 106(3) of ITA which stated that in relation to IRB civil action to recover taxes, the court shall not entertain any plea that the amount of tax sought to be recovered is excessive, incorrectly assessed, under appeal or incorrectly increased.
At this point, Justice Nallini interjected, saying that such provisions are essential to Malaysia's ability to collect taxes as part of the government's efforts to redistribute wealth among the people.
The judge said the country still needs to collect tax and the government's ability to collect taxes may be jeopardised if every taxpayer is allowed to present their statement of defence during the tax suit.
"If every taxpayer can come to court and have a full trial (against the IRB's tax suits and with no summary judgment allowed) on the amount assessed, the country would come to a standstill. The B40 would be wiped out as there would be no money (in the government's coffers)," Justice Nallini said.
After parties submitted, the court reserved judgment on the appeals.
The former prime minister and his son are appealing against the High Courts' decision to allow IRB's application to enter summary judgments over the income tax arrears.
A summary judgment is obtained when the court decides on a case, through written submissions, without a full trial and calling witnesses.
Two separate High Courts had allowed the IRB's applications to enter summary judgments to recover tax arrears of RM1.69 billion from Najib and RM37.6 million from Mohd Nazifuddin respectively, for the period between 2011 and 2017.
Both Najib and Mohd Nazifuddin lost their appeals in the Court of Appeal in September 2021 to set aside the summary judgments. On May 10, last year, the Federal Court granted them leave to pursue their appeals to the Federal Court.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Wed Jun 14 2023
Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak and his son Datuk Mohd Nazifuddin are appealing against the High Courts' decision to allow IRB's application to enter summary judgments over the income tax arrears. - Facebook/Nazif Najib
Pemain ragbi meninggal dunia selepas perlawanan pasukan pilihan MB Kedah
Seorang bekas pemain Sukma Kedah meninggal dunia selepas menyertai perlawanan pertunjukkan pasukan pilihan Menteri Besar Kedah pada Ahad.
OCC: Masih banyak usaha perlu dibuat dalam isu hak kanak-kanak
Masih banyak yang perlu dilakukan kerana Malaysia masih ketinggalan berbanding negara lain dalam menangani isu penderaan dan masalah sosial melibatkan kanak-kanak.
iPad Pro mungkin dijana dengan cip Apple M4 terbaharu, fokus ciri AI
Cip Apple M4 dijangka memfokuskan kepada keupayaan enjin neural yang disertakan bersama dengannya membolehkan ia menawarkan ciri AI yang lebih baik.
Lebih 840,000 permohonan untuk London Marathon 2025 pecah rekod dunia
Jumlah permohonan untuk menyertai larian TCS London Marathon tahun depan telah memecahkan rekod dunia.
WEF: Anwar jumpa 50 pemimpin industri & perniagaan, yakin pelabur bernilai tinggi pilih Malaysia
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim menzahirkan keyakinan lebih banyak pelabur bernilai tinggi akan memilih Malaysia sebagai destinasi pelaburan mengikut jejak langkah syarikat-syarikat gergasi seperti Tesla, AWS, Infineon dan Nvidia.
AWANI Ringkas: Ikut jejak syarikat gergasi lain
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Bursa Malaysia dibuka tinggi seiring prestasi Wall Street
Bursa Malaysia dibuka rendah pada Isnin, mengambil petunjuk pasaran serantau dan kenaikan di Wall Street pada hari Jumaat.
Kementerian Perpaduan kaji keperluan pelan tindakan pendidikan & penghargaan Rukun Negara
Kementerian Perpaduan Negara melalui Jabatan Perpaduan dan Integrasi Nasional akan mengkaji keperluan untuk melancarkan Pelan Tindakan Pendidikan & Penghargaan Rukun Negara sejajar dengan Dasar Perpaduan Negara 2021-2030.
Akta pekerjaan bagi lindungi pekerja OKU/Autistik diperlukan
Beatrice yang juga merupakan individu autistik berkata, bagi mengadakan akta atau menggubal dasar berkaitan, kerajaan perlu libatkan lebih banyak golongan autistik sebagai pemegang taruh utama.
Mesyuarat FOMC: The Fed dijangka kekalkan kadar faedah Mei 2024
Ketua Ekonomi Bank Muamalat Malaysia Bhd, Dr Mohd Afzanizam Abdul Rashid berkata, ia selepas unjuran awal beberapa pakar ekonomi melihat The Fed masih belum cukup yakin dengan usaha menurunkan kadar inflasi di negara itu.
Polis Jerman rampas 4 kereta Bugatti Veyron edisi terhad yang dikaitkan dengan 1MDB
Kenderaan berkenaan dikatakan sebahagian daripada siri "Legenda" khas Bugatti Veyron, dengan hanya 18 daripada supercar tersebut dibina dalam enam spesifikasi.
Rumah Najib boleh jadi penjara - Peguam
Rumah bekas Perdana Menteri itu boleh dijadikan sebagai penjara dan tempat tahanan untuk beliau seperti yang termaktub dalam undang-undang.
Kes 1MDB: Najib percaya Blackstone dikawal Arab Saudi, Raja Abdullah - Saksi
Saksi memberitahu Najib percaya bahawa syarikat Blackstone Asia Real Estate Partners dikawal oleh kerajaan Arab Saudi dan Raja Arab Saudi.
1MDB: Prosiding Najib julung kali dibuat pada Sabtu
Perbicaraan pertama dibuat pada hujung minggu ini berlangsung tepat jam 8.30 pagi, selepas bekas Perdana Menteri itu dibawa pihak berkuasa dengan menaiki kenderaan dari Jabatan Penjara.
'Kementerian Kewangan tiada rekod surat kelulusan Najib bagi 1MDB ambil alih Tanjong Energy, Genting Sanyen' - Saksi
Dalam siasatan SPRM, Kementerian Kewangan mengesahkan tidak mempunyai rekod ke atas kedua-dua surat tersebut.
Najib diberi peluang jelaskan mengenai dokumen 1MDB ketika disoal siasat - Pegawai SPRM
Mahkamah Tinggi diberitahu bahawa Najib diberi peluang untuk menjelaskan secara terperinci mengenai dokumen berkaitan 1MDB, ketika disoal siasat.
Najib tak pernah arah pengurusan 1MDB pindah AS$1.03 bilion kepada syarikat Jho Low - Saksi
Mahkamah Tinggi diberitahu bahawa Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak tidak pernah mengarahkan mana-mana individu daripada pengurusan 1MDB untuk memindahkan AS$1.03 bilion kepada syarikat Jho low.
1MDB: SPRM ke Riyadh untuk sahkan surat derma RM2.6 bilion - Saksi
Penguasa Kanan SPRM Nur Aida Arifin berkata pihaknya telah pergi ke Istana Riyadh pada 2015 bagi mengadakan pertemuan dengan dua putera Arab Saudi.
1MDB: Najib tak dedah mengenai pertemuan dengan Raja Arab Saudi ketika siasatan - Saksi
Najib tidak memaklumkan kepada SPRM mengenai pertemuan delegasi Malaysia bersama Raja Arab Saudi, Almarhum Raja Abdullah Abdul Aziz Al-Saud.
1MDB: Muhammad Shafee ditegur hakim kerana bersikap 'keterlaluan'
Ketua peguam bela yang mewakili Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak ditegur apabila dilihat menyerang kredibiliti pengawai penyiasat Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) ketika perbicaraan.