SHAH ALAM: The High Court today ruled that three key prosecution witnesses in Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi's corruption case involving 40 counts of receiving bribes in connection with the Foreign Visa System (VLN) were unreliable and not credible.
Judge Datuk Mohd Yazid Mustafa, when reading out his more than two-hour judgment, named the witnesses as former directors of Ultra Kirana Sdn Bhd (UKSB, namely Harry Lee Vui Khiun, Wan Quoris Shah Wan Abdul Ghani and David Tan Siong Sun, who are the 15th, 16th and 17th prosecution witness (PW), respectively.
"I find that the three key witnesses called by the prosecution were not reliable and neither were they trustworthy or credible," he said.
Judge Mohd Yazid said the court found that the notations of 'Z' and 'ZH' that appeared in UKSB's ledger did not prove that Ahmad Zahid received the monies or gratification.
"I further find that even though there was a suggestion that the accused had received political donations amounting to RM200,000 on two occasions, there is no sufficient evidence of particulars before the court for me to come up with any amended charge," he added.
He said Harry Lee (PW15) and Wan Quoris Shah (PW16) also agreed that there was no independent evidence to support the contention that the monies were paid to Ahmad Zahid.
"Based on all the evidence adduced by the prosecution, I observe there is no closed-circuit television (CCTV) footage produced in court, the drivers (of the key witnesses), the guards and policemen (at Ahmad Zahid's house) were not called.
"Touch 'n Go transaction slips or phone call logs and messages with the accused were also not produced (as evidence)," he said.
Referring to Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor's solar case, judge Mohd Yazid said all the individuals involved in the process to deliver the money (RM5 million) to her were called as witnesses.
"However, in Ahmad Zahid's case, the witnesses involved or had knowledge of the source of funds, including Nicole (a businesswoman from Hong Kong) and two money changers were not called as witnesses to support the prosecution's case," he added.
Judge Mohd Yazid also said the three key witnesses testified that the monies were placed in a brown envelope on each occasion of delivery, but the prosecution did not produce any sample envelope as evidence.
"No evidence was led to show the size of the envelope used. I simply cannot imagine what envelope, in what size, could fit in the SG$600,000 in cash which is equivalent to about RM1.6 million at the material time.
"Surprisingly, David Tan (PW17), the creator of the ledger, admitted during cross-examination that the second delivery of RM3 million was by way of a luggage was an afterthought.
"This admission of an afterthought by PW17 is more than sufficient for me to find that he has zero credibility," he added.
To further support his finding, the judge said David Tan testified that he would record the payments on the same day or the next day, but most of the 'remark' columns in the ledger were left blank.
"PW15 also agreed that the blank 'remark' columns do not show that the monies were paid to the accused. The blank 'remark' columns give rise to a possible inference as suggested by the defence that the monies could have been distributed among the three of them (PW15, PW16 and PW17) as they maintained a luxurious lifestyle," the judge said.
He said each of them owned one unit of property at Pavilion, with PW16 also owning a bungalow house in Putrajaya, one semi-detached house in Cyberjaya, two Range Rovers, expensive motorcycles and pay tax amounting to millions of ringgit.
"Without strong evidential support, I simply cannot consciously make a finding that the monies were in fact received by the accused as suggested by the prosecution based on transactions recorded in the ledger as there was no record that the monies were in fact received by the accused in the 'remark' columns," said the judge.
Judge Mohd Yazid said from the testimony of the three key witnesses, it was Harry Lee (PW15) who controlled and decide on the funds and made payments to various parties.
"Further, these monies were not reported to the tax authorities, never reported to the external and internal auditors of UKSB and these monies were are not reflected in audited accounts of UKSB.
"I find that there is sufficient evidence to show that criminal offences have been committed. Based on ledger (UKSB), the monies received from Sept 2004 until Aug 2018 was about RM238,356,966," he said.
Judge Mohd Yazid said the court found that the prosecution failed to make out a prima facie case on all the charges when they failed to prove the foremost important element against Ahmad Zahid, which is the receipt of the corrupt monies.
"Based on the foregoing reasons and analysis of the evidence and the law, I hereby acquit and discharge the accused from all charges without calling for his defence as the prosecution has failed to made out a prima facie case," he added.
However, on the issue of political donation, the judge said the defence failed to lead evidence to suggest that the political donation of RM200,000 was spent for political purposes.
On the issue of unfair trial and selective prosecution raised by the defence, he said the matters did not arise at all in the case.
"I myself certainly have refrained from day one to be swayed or influenced by any comments made outside of this courtroom. It was my solemn duty to uphold justice without favour and fear or prejudice," he added.
He expressed his appreciation to both parties for their professionalism in conducting the trial, enabling the proceedings to run smoothly without any vexatious and frivolous interlocutory applications.
After the judge finished reading out the more than 100-page judgement, Ahmad Zahid, clad in white baju Melayu and black pants shouted 'Allahu Akbar', followed by applause by family members and supporters.
Ahmad Zahid had pleaded not guilty to 33 charges of receiving bribes amounting to SG$13.56 million from Ultra Kirana Sdn Bhd for himself as Home Minister to extend the contract of the company as the operator of a one-stop centre (OSC) service in China and the VLN system, as well as to maintain its contract with the Home Ministry to supply the VLN integrated system.
On the other seven charges, he was alleged to have obtained for himself cash of SG$1,150,000; RM3.125 million; 15,000 Swiss Franc; and US$15,000 from the same company, which he knew had a connection with his official functions.
He was charged with committing all the offences at Seri Satria, Precinct 16, Putrajaya and Country Heights, Kajang, between Oct 2014 and March 2018.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Fri Sep 23 2022
Ahmad Zahid Hamidi arriving at the Shah Alam High Court earlier to hear the verdict on 40 corruption charges related to the Foreign Visa System (VLN). - Astro AWANI/Shahir Omar
Malaysia, Uzbekistan akan ubah jawatankuasa bersama dalam perdagangan kepada suruhanjaya bersama
Malaysia dan Uzbekistan telah bersetuju untuk mengaktifkan Jawatankuasa Bersama Perdagangan Antara Kerajaan dan mengubah jawatankuasa itu menjadi Suruhanjaya Bersama Antara Kerajaan.
13 negara gesa sekatan terhadap Israel daripada serang Rafah
Antara negara yang menandatangani surat berkenaan ialah Australia, yang mana menteri-menteri luar negara terbabit turut meminta gencatan senjata yang mampan.
Sekolah di bandar Bitung ditutup
Sekolah-sekolah ditutup di Bandar Bitung selepas abu dan hujan dari gunung berapi Ruang mencurah di Sulawesi Utara Indonesia.
Brazil dipilih sebagai tuan rumah Piala Dunia Wanita FIFA 2027
Brazil akan menjadi tuan rumah Piala Dunia Wanita Persekutuan Bola Sepak Antarabangsa (FIFA) 2027 selepas undian di Kongres FIFA ke-74 pada Jumaat.
40 senator Thailand mohon pemecatan Srettha
Ketika rombakan Kabinet bulan lalu, senator itu membantah pelantikan bekas peguam, Pichit Cuenban, sebagai Menteri di pejabat Srettha.
Lelaki bakar rumah ibadat ditembak mati
Polis menembak mati seorang lelaki bersenjata yang membakar rumah ibadat di Rouen Perancis.
Bayaran dam dan korban melalui THiJARI diteruskan
Lembaga Tabung Haji (TH) meneruskan perkhidmatan bayaran dam dan korban melalui aplikasi THiJARI untuk musim haji tahun ini seperti tahun-tahun sebelumnya, bagi memudahkan bakal jemaah haji negara untuk melunaskan tanggungjawab masing-masing.
Singapura kutuk, nasihat warganya di Malaysia berhati-hati
Singapura mengutuk sekeras-kerasnya serangan ke atas Balai Polis Ulu Tiram di Johor pada Jumaat, yang mengakibatkan kematian dua anggota polis dan mencederakan seorang lagi.
Pengajaran kepada kita, akibat fahaman radikal
Insiden yang menimpa dua anggota polis di Ulu Tiram patut dijadikan sebagai pengajaran akibat bila berfahaman radikal.
KJ beri gambaran tak cepat kembali ke dunia politik, jika mampu bertahan
Khairy Jamaluddin berkongsi pengalaman dalam program Ayuh Johor, termasuk melibatkan kejayaan ketika menggalas tugas sebagai menteri sehingga kekalahannya dalam Pilihan Raya Umum Ke-15, yang lalu.
Hari Guru: Tablet percuma untuk murid dan guru - Zahid
Ahmad Zahid berkata bajet pada tahun hadapan akan ditambah untuk pembelian perkakasan bagi melaksanakan kaedah pembelajaran melalui sistem digital.
Kerajaan cuba pastikan satu peranti untuk satu pelajar - Zahid Hamidi
Kerajaan akan cuba memastikan setiap pelajar dan murid dibekalkan dengan sebuah peranti bagi memudahkan kaedah pembelajaran secara digital, kata Ahmad Zahid.
Tiada lagi panjat pokok, kerajaan akan pastikan liputan internet cukup - Ahmad Zahid
Kerajaan akan memastikan kawasan berkepadatan rendah, desa dan pedalaman disediakan liputan Internet yang secukupnya untuk memudahkan pelajar mengikuti pembelajaran secara dalam talian.
Jemaah Menteri Malaysia rakam ucapan tahniah kepada Lawrence Wong
Ucapan itu antara intipati mesyuarat Kabinet dipengerusikan Timbalan Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi, di Putrajaya pada Rabu.
Pelaksanaan program TVET kekal dikendali 12 kementerian - Ahmad Zahid
Program TVET yang dilaksanakan dengan kerjasama 12 kementerian dan agensi kerajaan perlu dikekalkan.
UMNO kian kukuh, keahlian terus bertambah - Ahmad Zahid
Presiden UMNO Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi berkata parti pimpinannya itu kian kukuh, di sebalik pelbagai tohmahan dilontarkan pihak tertentu.
'UMNO tak akan tenggelam dalam lipatan sejarah' - Zahid
Presiden UMNO, Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi bersumpah dan tekad untuk memastikan parti itu tidak akan tenggelam dalam lipatan sejarah.
Kenyataan media UMNO yang tular di media sosial, palsu - UMNO
Kenyataan tular mendakwa UMNO kini lebih bersifat terbuka dalam pendekatan dan sanggup mengurangkan penekanan eksklusif terhadap keutamaan kaum Melayu, adalah palsu.
Kejayaan calon PH bukti semangat kekitaan yang erat dalam Kerajaan Perpaduan - Ahmad Zahid
"DAP banyak bantu calon BN dalam PRK sebelum ini, tidak salah jika UMNO membalas budi yang telah ditabur oleh mereka."
RM1.06 bilion bangunkan projek infrastruktur di Sabah tahun ini - Ahmad Zahid
Kerajaan memperuntukkan sebanyak RM1.06 bilion bagi membangunkan 224 projek infrastruktur di Sabah pada tahun ini.