Although COVID-19 presents itself as global health crisis on the surface, the pandemic appears to have been capitalised for a new type of warfare behind the scenes. In addition to commercial gains, COVID-19 vaccines have been wielded as a tool for geopolitical reconfigurations by global superpowers.
While the world blames the more protectionist, or for a lack of a better word, the so-called “greedy” countries contributing to world vaccine shortages, nations that appear to be more “outward” in their initial approach also have to observed with a keen eye for ulterior motives. As the saying goes, there’s no such thing as a free lunch.
Experts in international studies and political science Simon Frankel Pratt and Jamie Levin pointed in a Foreign Policy article that although many of China’s global vaccine dissemination were provided at no cost (which could imply the appearance of altruistic motives), it “seems intended to rapidly undercut and abort deals that states have made with Pfizer through earlier shipments and, potentially, bribery of local officials”. No doubt these are strong speculations that needs to backed up by evidence.
In any case, the capitalisation of a country’s desperate circumstances in the battle of the powerful global North for influence on the global South can be best observed in Brazil, which is one of the most hard-hit countries in the world by deadly COVID-19 waves. The Bureau of Investigative Journalism revealed that Pfizer has been accused of “bullying” the government of Brazil in vaccine-related negotiations.
On March 4, Reuters reported that Brazil’s then-Minister of Health Eduardo Pazuello alluded that the agreement with Pfizer was nearing completion, which Reuters mentioned as “effectively overcoming a dispute over liability clauses”. In the midst of the spat between Brazil’s government and the US multinational pharmaceutical giant, China was able to gain significant foothold in Brazil.
By mid-March, vaccine coercion may have been used to power through the global battle for 5G infrastructure, whereby The New York Times revealed that China has set a precondition of allowing Huawei access to Brazil’s 5G market for the supply of its vaccines. A well-placed chess piece by China given that Brazil was initially in the same boat with Trump in its denouncement of Huawei as China’s “trojan horse” of global surveillance.
Russia also wanted to supply its vaccines to Brazil, but the US may have influenced Brazil to reject Russian vaccines, as pointed by Brasilwire in an article on March 14.
The Brazil-centric portal cited what was claimed to be contents from page 48 of the US Department of Health and Human Services Annual Report 2020, which implicitly stated “Examples include using OGA’s Health Attaché office to persuade Brazil to reject the Russian COVID-19 vaccines” in a paragraph under the heading “Combatting malign influences in the Americas”.
The Twitter account for Sputnik-V (one of Russia’s vaccines) picked up on this the next day (March 15) and posted what appears to be a screenshot of said page.
Obviously, the battle must have raged on behind the scenes and by the end of April, Reuters reported that Anvisa (Brazil’s health regulator) rejected the importation of Sputnik-V vaccines, claiming “serious defects” of potentially replication-competent adenoviruses. The Russian Direct Investment Fund (RDIF) obviously dismissed this as false and stated that this may have been politically motivated. The developers of Sputnik-V have since then announced legal actions on Anvisa for defamation.
The World Health Organisation (WHO) is currently conducting site inspections of Sputnik V manufacturing facilities to ensure safety and quality standards are met. WHO’s findings and stance should carry more weight than Anvisa.
Interestingly, Reuters also reported on May 14 that Pazuello was replaced in April largely due to criticism of vaccination delays, and that Pazuello had failed to take Pfizer’s offers last year due to his stance on relying on locally-produced British and Chinese vaccines, according to two sources in Brazil’s government.
Though the influence of foreign lobby in Brazil’s political and administrative landscape remains a speculation, it’s clear that the US and China are winners in what appears to be a vaccine tactical warfare to exert influence in the most powerful south-American nation.
While Russia may have been rejected in Brazil, its vaccine diplomacy has succeeded elsewhere.
Although the official story regarding the release of an Israeli citizen detained in Syria was that it happened through the exchange of two Syrians detained by Israelis, The New York Times revealed in February that it was actually a secret agreement for Israel to fund for Sputnik-V vaccines in Syria in exchange for Russia’s brokerage of the deal for the Israeli citizen’s release.
Sources claimed that Russia has been engaging in vaccine diplomacy in Latin America, Middle East, Eastern and Central European countries.
India also found a way to exhibit vaccine diplomacy capabilities against neighbouring China. The New York Times reported indications of China’s vaccine coercion with Paraguay, whereby vaccine supply was allegedly tied to Paraguay’s reconsideration of its relationship with Taiwan. This was unsuccessful as China’s competitor India stepped in (under the request of Taiwan) to supply vaccines to Paraguay, as reported in Foreign Policy.
The US, which has initially focused on its domestic vaccination efforts, have recently announced plans for the donation of an initial seven million doses of COVID-19 vaccines to Asian nations, including Malaysia. This was reported as a part of its planned 80 million vaccine doses donation worldwide by the end of June.
This could indicate Biden administration’s move to show global solidarity and/or an effort to balance the global chess pieces played in advanced by China and Russia.
While we have learned that free lunches are hard to come by, some nations may take US’s move at face value and interpret it as an attempt for the US turn a new leaf under the new administration. Regardless of motives, it’s a win for the US because at the end of the day many nations need vaccines and will welcome it with open arms.
We would expect China to make competing exemplary moves, but instead, China appears to be making intrusion into Malaysia’s airspace, and most recently, encroaching Malaysia’s waters off Miri. Though it may be unrelated to vaccine diplomacy, it is still unwise for China to disregard its neighbour’s sovereignty if it seeks to reconfigure its geopolitical influence. Or does China consider its neighbouring countries in South East Asia to be under its sphere of influence by default?
With such events happening around the word, there is fear that vaccine passports could be misused to further geopolitical interests and agendas through selective empowerment.
For example, the European Union (EU) travel pass which only accepts vaccines approved by the European Medicines Agency (EMA) currently discriminate (as of June 9) millions of potential travellers vaccinated with China’s Sinopharm and Sinovac vaccines, Russia’s Sputnik-V, and other vaccines not in EMA’s approved list.
Despite the notion of “the best vaccine is the fastest one you can get”, Malaysians, and people in other countries are now presented with a discriminatory factor irrelevant to public health.
From the commercial perspective, being a first-mover to secure a large chunk of the vaccination market kills two birds with one stone because of the likelihood for continuous need of the same vaccine type. Securing the market now blocks future market competition as well. Brand reliance in place of brand loyalty.
That said, vaccine producers and their parent nations that have overplayed their cards through the wrongful capitalisation of vaccines, should know that the emerging findings on the potential to mix different types of vaccines (or switch vaccines), emergence of potential drugs for COVID-19 treatments, the increasingly loud call for temporary intellectual property waivers and other factors may change this power-dynamic in the future.
The dust will settle and governments remember when and if their arms were twisted to give way to geopolitical concessions.
The “joker” card could be the findings of on-going investigations on COVID-19 virus origins. Outcomes of such investigations (and the severe implications it would have should it point to a certain country or organisation being responsible) would not only risk undoing the geopolitical reconfigurations, but may also regress its image and influence globally.
Ameen Kamal is the Head of Science & Technology at EMIR Research, an independent think tank focused on strategic policy recommendations based on rigorous research.
** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
Ameen Kamal
Wed Jun 09 2021
In addition to commercial gains, COVID-19 vaccines have been wielded as a tool for geopolitical reconfigurations by global superpowers. REUTERSpic
Berita tempatan pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Berikut adalah berita yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang Jumaat, 26 April 2024.
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Antara pelbagai berita luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
Imigresen Perak gempur 9 premis, tahan 38 pendatang tanpa izin
Jabatan Imigresen Malaysia (JIM) Perak menahan 38 warga asing dalam serbuan ke atas sembilan premis perniagaan di sekitar daerah Kinta dan Batang Padang semalam.
Jangan kecam, politikkan penganjuran Jejak Harmoni - Aaron
Kementerian Perpaduan Negara (KPN) berharap penganjuran program Jejak Harmoni yang menyantuni pemimpin agama dan penganut di rumah-rumah ibadat di negara ini tidak dikecam atau dipolitikkan.
Agenda pemantapan tatakelola, integriti jadi asas utama SPRM
SPRM akan memastikan agenda pemantapan tatakelola serta penginstitusian integriti menjadi asas utama selain siasatan kes jenayah rasuah yang menjadi tugas agensi itu.
Bursa Malaysia ditutup tinggi susulan sentimen positif pasaran serantau
Pada 5 petang, FTSE Bursa Malaysia KLCI (FBM KLCI) meningkat 5.91 mata kepada 1,575.16 daripada paras penutup 1,569.25 pada Khamis.
Pasukan sorak Malaysia raih tempat ketiga di Florida
Pasukan sorak Team Malaysia Youth All Girls meraih tempat ketiga divisyen Youth All-Girl Median di International Cheer Union World Junior Cheerleading Championship.
Freedom Flotilla to Gaza: Sekumpulan pakar PBB gesa laluan selamat bagi misi penghantaran bantuan
Sekumpulan pakar dari Pertubuhan Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu (PBB) menggesa agar laluan selamat bagi misi Break The Siege Freedom Flotilla to Gaza pada Jumaat.
Sabah FC berdepan tunggakan sebulan gaji pemain - Pengarah
Sabah FC kini hanya berdepan tunggakan gaji pemain untuk satu bulan setelah usaha dilakukan secara tuntas untuk menyelesaikan masalah pembayaran tunggakan sejak tahun lepas.
Tumpuan Jumaat - 26 April 2024
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan di Astro AWANI.
Kelaparan akut jejaskan 281.6 juta orang tahun lepas - PBB
Tahap bahaya kelaparan akut menjejaskan 281.6 juta orang tahun lepas, tahun kelima berturut-turut bahawa ketakjaminan makanan semakin memburuk.
Hamilton optimis kedudukan lebih baik di GP China
Lewis Hamilton melihat potensi kedudukan yang lebih baik dalam saingan Grand Prix yang kembali ke China buat pertama kali dalam tempoh lima tahun, hujung minggu ini.
'Selfish!' - Fasha Sandha sedih raya di Perlis tak jadi gara-gara dijangkiti COVID-19
Fasha berkata dia mula melakukan pemeriksaan COVID-19 selepas berasa tidak sihat badan dan mengalami bersin tidak henti sejak Raya pertama.
Kes COVID-19 catat penurunan ketara pada ME 14/2024 - KKM
Jumlah kes COVID-19 menurun 97.1 peratus kepada 493 kes pada Minggu Epidemiologi ke-14 (ME 14/2024) iaitu bagi tempoh 31 Mac hingga 6 April lepas berbanding 17,256 kes pada ME 1/2024.
China jadikan pengalaman pencegahan COVID-19 untuk hadapi pandemik masa depan
China akan menjadikan pengalaman dalam pencegahan dan kawalan COVID-19 untuk membuat persediaan yang lebih proaktif untuk menghadapi pandemik masa depan seperti "Penyakit X".
Negara berdepan ketirisan subsidi diesel serius - Amir Hamzah
Negara kini sedang berdepan isu ketirisan subsidi diesel yang serius dan wujud kemungkinan terdapat pihak yang tidak layak masih menikmati subsidi itu, kata Menteri Kewangan II Datuk Seri Amir Hamzah.
Kematian akibat kemalangan jalan raya lebih tinggi daripada COVID-19 - Anthony Loke
PDRM akan mengeluarkan data mengenai kemalangan jalan raya pada setiap hari, bukan setahun sekali seperti diamalkan sebelum ini.
Ismail Sabri ziarah lapan beradik yatim piatu akibat COVID-19
Ismail Sabri tiba kira-kira jam 2 petang di kediaman lapan beradik itu di Taman Adenium, Bukit Beruntung pada Selasa.
Teori konspirasi 'Penyakit X'
Ahli teori konspirasi AS sekali lagi membuat 'keuntungan' selepas PBB memberi amaran tentang wabak lebih berbahaya iaitu 'Penyakit X'.
Reformasi dasar, kukuhkan perlindungan, produktiviti pekerja tidak formal
Reformasi dasar perlu dilakukan dalam usaha meningkatkan perlindungan dan produktiviti pekerja tidak formal di Malaysia.