CANBERRA: The architect of Australian media reforms being watched around the world claimed victory on Wednesday, even as critics said concessions to the laws forcing Big Tech to pay for news content have given Facebook and Google a get-out clause.
The Australian government made late changes to the laws after Facebook last week blocked news content in Australia, escalating a dispute over the proposed legislation and catching international attention.
The amended legislation is expected to pass the Senate this week, despite opposition from some minor opposition parties and independent politicians who argue it disadvantages smaller news companies.
Rod Sims, the chairman of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC), told Reuters the bargaining power imbalance he was tasked with correcting had been addressed.
"The changes the government's done are things that either don't matter much or are just to clarify things that, at least in Facebook's mind, were unclear," said Sims, who led the drafting of the legislation.
"Whatever they say, they need news. It keeps people on their platform longer - they make more money."
With Australia's reforms serving as a model for other nations to adopt, Facebook was also keen to claim a win.
Facebook Vice President of Global News Partnerships Campbell Brown stressed the company had retained the ability to decide if news appeared on its platform and could sidestep the forced negotiation for content payment under the original legislation.
In a key amendment to the legislation, Treasurer Josh Frydenberg was given the discretion to decide that either Facebook or Google need not be subject to the code, if they make a "significant contribution to the sustainability of the Australian news industry."
The original legislation had required Facebook and Alphabet Inc's Google to submit to arbitration if they could not reach a commercial deal with Australian news companies for their content, effectively allowing the government to set a price.
Facebook, which contends news accounts for just 4% of traffic on its site in Australia, said it would restore news on Australian pages in the coming days.
"This isn't a must-carry regime," said Sims. "We never said we're forcing Facebook to keep showing news."
SMALL MEDIA, BIG CONCERNS
While the Senate is expected to pass the legislation, with the main opposition Labor Party supporting the ruling Liberal Party, some politicians and media companies have expressed concern about the amendments.
"This changes the bill significantly," independent senator Rex Patrick, who plans to vote against the amended bill, told Reuters.
"The big players could successfully negotiate with Facebook or Google. The minister then doesn't designate them, and all the little players miss out."
Lee O'Connor, owner and editor of regional newspaper The Coonamble Times, agreed the amendments favoured big media groups.
"It's the vagueness of the language that's the main concern, and the minister's discretion is part of that," O'Connor said.
Frydenberg has said he will give Facebook and Google time to strike deals with Australian media companies before deciding whether to enforce his new powers.
CONTENT DEALS
The code was designed by the government and competition regulator to address a power imbalance between the social media giants and publishers when negotiating payment for news content displayed on the tech firms' sites.
After first threatening to withdraw its search engine from Australia, Google has instead struck a series of deals with several publishers, including a global news deal with News Corp.
Television broadcaster and newspaper publisher Seven West Media on Tuesday said it had signed a letter of intent to reach a content supply deal with Facebook within 60 days.
Rival Nine Entertainment Co also revealed on Wednesday it was in negotiations with Facebook.
"At this stage, we're still obviously proceeding with negotiations," Nine chief executive Hugh Marks told analysts at a company briefing on Wednesday. "It is really positive for our business and positive particularly for the publishing business."
Reuters
Wed Feb 24 2021
Google and Facebook logos and Australian flag are displayed in this illustration taken, February 18, 2021. REUTERS pic
Polis panggil Mohamed Azmin bantu siasatan berhubung pendedahan maklumat
Ketua Polis Selangor Datuk Hussein Omar Khan berkata rakaman keterangan itu, bagi membantu siasatan di bawah Seksyen 203A Kanun Keseksaan iaitu pendedahan maklumat.
Lapan cap jari ditemukan di lokasi Faisal Halim disimbah asid - KPN
Bagaimanapun, hasil analisis mendapati lima daripadanya tidak cukup sifat.
Kerajaan setuju laksana penyasaran subsidi bahan api diesel - PM Anwar
Dengan penyasaran subsidi diesel tersebut, jumlah penjimatan kepada kerajaan adalah dijangka sekitar RM4 bilion setahun.
Rasuah adalah barah utama yang melemah ekonomi negara, menjatuhkan moral rakyat - PM
Kelemahan tatakelola dan amalan rasuah sudah sistemik, dari peringkat atas, peringkat penengah hingga ke peringkat bawahan.
Azizulhasni ketepi saingan Ridwan, juarai acara pecut di Nilai
Jaguh berbasikal trek negara, Datuk Mohd Azizulhasni Awang tidak berdepan masalah menjuarai acara pecut lelaki elit pada Kejohanan Berbasikal Trek Kebangsaan 2024.
Kawalan keselamatan di bangunan kerajaan, tempat tumpuan awam, kemudahan penting pada tahap tertinggi - PDRM
Datuk Seri Azmi Abu Kassim berkata, pihak polis memandang serius insiden baru-baru ini yang menimbulkan kegusaran masyarakat awam.
Melaka terima dua artifak dipercayai peninggalan Hang Tuah
Artifak berkenaan diterima daripada Tun Muhammad Amin Tun Ahmad iaitu waris ke-11 Hang Tuah yang berasal dari Kepulauan Bintan, Riau di Indonesia.
AWANI Ringkas: Suntikan HPV 719,236 pelajar perempuan
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
AWANI 7:45 [21/05/2024] – Penyelidikan FICO | Bayi berusia 11 bulan | Bakal dibentangkan di Parlimen | 57,991 unit pada April 2024
#AWANI745 malam ini bersama Irfan Faruqi;
1. 32 peratus rakyat Malaysia paling bimbang ditipu urusan pembayaran
2. Suami isteri naik motosikal bersama anak sakit, dapat bantuan PM
3. Pas yakin RUU 355 dapat majoriti mudah
4. Jualan kenderaan baharu melonjak 21 peratus
1. 32 peratus rakyat Malaysia paling bimbang ditipu urusan pembayaran
2. Suami isteri naik motosikal bersama anak sakit, dapat bantuan PM
3. Pas yakin RUU 355 dapat majoriti mudah
4. Jualan kenderaan baharu melonjak 21 peratus
Ziyad rangkul emas kejohanan dunia di Jepun
Muhammad Ziyad Zolkefli menjuarai acara lontar peluru lelaki F20 di (kecacatan intelektual) Kejohanan Olahraga Para Dunia 2024 di Jepun.
Kunjungan ke tiga negara di benua Asia Tengah jana potensi pelaburan, perdagangan lebih RM2.1 bilion - PM Anwar
Kunjungan ke Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan dan Uzbekistan berjaya menjana potensi pelaburan dan perdagangan sekurang-kurangnya berjumlah lebih RM2.1 bilion.
Hargai peranan pasukan keselamatan negara - Raja Permaisuri Agong
Raja Permaisuri Agong, Raja Zarith Sofiah bertitah bahawa rakyat perlu menghargai peranan pasukan keselamatan dengan lebih berterima kasih.
PM ucap Hari Guru, rakam jutaan penghargaan buat warga pendidik
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim hari ini mengucapkan Selamat Hari Guru kepada seluruh warga pendidik yang gigih membina bangsa.
Ahmad Zahid ucap tahniah atas pelantikan Lawrence Wong sebagai PM Singapura
Timbalan Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi menzahirkan ucapan tahniah atas pelantikan Lawrence Wong sebagai Perdana Menteri Singapura yang baharu.
Gelap mata untung lumayan, warga emas rugi RM412,500
Lelaki warga emas itu melakukan beberapa transaksi berjumlah RM412,500 kepada empat akaun berbeza baru-baru ini bagi menerima pulangan dan keuntungan berkenaan.
Anwar hulur bantuan kepada keluarga Pak Amjal aktivis awal reformasi
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim menghulurkan bantuan kepada isteri aktivis awal reformasi Jalaluddin Ab Manaf yang menghidap penyakit angin ahmar.
NRES rancang lestarikan industri plastik sekali guna elak pencemaran
Kementerian Sumber Asli dan Kelestarian Alam (NRES) merancang untuk melestarikan industri plastik sekali guna menerusi satu peralihan yang seimbang dalam bidang itu.
Anwar harap terminal baharu LTSIP jana lebih banyak peluang ekonomi di Kelantan
Anwar Ibrahim berharap terminal baharu Lapangan Terbang Sultan Ismail Petra (LTSIP) fasa satu, yang mula beroperasi semalam, mampu menjana lebih banyak peluang ekonomi di Kelantan.
Terima anugerah Reader's Digest buat kali kelima, Ahmad Zahid ucap tahniah kepada Kemas
Timbalan Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi mengucapkan tahniah kepada Jabatan Kemajuan Masyarakat (Kemas) yang meraih Anugerah Jenama Paling Dipercayai buat kali kelima bagi kategori Pu
AIM menang Anugerah Industri Kewangan Islam Global
AIM memenangi anugerah Islamic Finance News apabila dinobat IFN Best Islamic Microfinance Institution, serta menerima dua anugerah di bawah Global Good Governance Awards (3G).